When we want to rein in inflation, I hear a thundering silence on the conjugate idea: preferentially paying poor people to save in order to take the highest velocity money out of circulation and obtain the greatest amount of inflation control per dollar.
Hmmmmm.
Capped personal savings instruments would be the next step (see: I-Bonds).
If you, say, give people $100 in a year if they keep $1000 on deposit for the whole year, you'd be paying them to save. Sure, the poorer people are going to go out and spend that $100 when it comes in. And if there's no new incentive to keep the $1000 in savings, they may likely spend that too. And you'd need to limit it to one offer per natural person, etc, or people with access to lots of money would endeavor to make many $1000 accounts to get the 2x market rate interest I made up.
Maybe $1000 is too much to ask poor people for, but you could scale it down. If you do it right, you get both the policy goal of reducing velocity of money, because you're getting people to save rather than spend some money, and you also get the typical policy goal of distributing money to the poor because even if everyone can get this $100, it's more impactful to the poorer.
Or you could do a savings account linked to a lottery. Every $1 in savings up to $X gets you a ticket, if the bank earns about the federal funds rate on the deposit, give half to the individual depositors, and pool the other half to share among the lottery winners. Might be more 'exciting' for some people and encourage more savings that way.
This is a good idea. Could it be implemented under current regulation as a neobank?
https://www.theleague.coop/solutions/savers-sweepstakes
And here's a hip app based version that isn't a bank, but keeps your funds at a bank:
Not sure about the terms or pay ratios on either of these, but I didn't come up with the idea, and I kind of find it distasteful, but it would seem to hit the right mix of meeting policy goals and attracting the desired clientele, so I restated it.
Many poor folks carry credit card balances at 15+% interest. Paying those off would be much more efficient for them that those CDs. Unfortunately if they manage to pay their credit cards they soon start racking them up again.
It's not that most people are maxing out credit cards on fur coats and caviar, they're paying for necessary and often unplanned expenses. They rack up credit card charges because as soon as they pay off one expense they get hit with another. This is especially true for people stuck with 15% interest rates.
This is the opposite of the mainstream economic consensus. The point of stimulus is to stimulate. Velocity makes fiscal stimulus more efficient. Even the Fed, in the depths of crises, pleads for fiscal stimulus because of its power and breadth relative to monetary methods.
But they've emailed to actively solicit me to move money from other banks into my eTrade savings.
Sounds like Bank of America (and Wells Fargo, etc.) are going to see cash moving out of their banks if they keep up the BS low-interest rates.
I've kept my current bank for various reasons but I'm much more aware of sweeping excess cash into my brokerage account.
[0] https://www.wealthfront.com/blog/why-is-wealthfront-cash-acc...
Pooling huge amounts of resources under the control of people who don't know how to manage it is pure waste, for no good reason. Giving them money on autopilot is even worse. And the whole idea of the federal reserve setting interest rates is bizarre, why is this market of all markets is the one where people want to try central planning? It is the perfect time to try a free market based approach. The US has been fighting the market on the price of money for decades and it is just putting them in a worse and worse spot.
Was the fall of the Soviet Union not enough to convince people that economic central planning is a mistake? What on earth will it take.
There is more to banking than deposit rates. Most Americans care about those other factors. If you care about rates, there are a plethora of options available to you.
Edit: linking article (I found it in a spreadsheet passed around Twitter at the time)
[0] https://seekingalpha.com/article/4586797-list-of-banks-paper...
I don’t think this explanation is plausible.
10-30 year bonds bought during 2020-2022 did not offer 5% yields. They were below 2.5% (30yr) and below 2% (10yr). Hence the “Zero” in ZIRP.
These banks cannot afford to pay close to the Fed overnight rate.
Not too long ago someone tried to charter a bank that just took deposits and placed them in the Fed overnight, but the charter wasn't approved because the bank wouldn't perform the economic role expected of a bank, which is to make loans that stimulate small business.
https://www.investopedia.com/best-high-yield-savings-account...
https://www.doctorofcredit.com/high-interest-savings-to-get/
CIT savings connect is 4.5% with no BS, and it is not obscure.
https://www.cit.com/cit-bank/bank/savings/savings-connect-ac...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Citizens_BancShares
Either way, they are FDIC insured, so as long as the website experience to transfer money in and out is good, it should not be a problem.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/hanktucker/2023/03/27/svbs-new-...