If you want to generalise like that you can even remove the US and swap it for "California" or even "the 100km surrounding mountain view"
As for your "tit for tat" explanation, it would hold a lot more water if the bans didn't target (almost?) exclusively the areas where China is pulling ahead.
But it seems like the people who want to "pause" or stop it span the spectrum from jealousy to inferiority to straight up lack of capability. If they'd got there first, they wouldn't be trying to shut it down.
All that said, it would be good to see some intelligent regulation, the development of which involves real businesses that have uses and not the usual suspects.
Regulation on facts and how AI can know the truth, and be ethical - we already have those rules for humans, we should just build these regulatory instruments as extensions of that or begin the work of discussing AI rights, and use all our hard work on those laws and save some time and heartache. Obviously it’s not sentient, but we are getting close to the point that it could happen at any moment.
we are getting close to the point that it could happen at any moment
No.As a huge Microsoft fan and Linux hater I totally agree. Europe can't do computing.
;-)
At this moment there is no "EU wants to ban AI" attempt. So OpenAI competitors, make sure to follow the laws and you will have a market in EU.
I don't know about Italy, but so far, I don't expect legislative action regarding ChatGPT in Germany. It would be an insanely unpopular decision and contribute nothing to SPD/FDP's voters. It doesn't add up, and the article is full of nothing.
The state of privacy in Germany can be summed up nicely by quoting the data privacy officer of Hamburg from a couple of weeks ago: "Principles for avoiding and minimizing the processing of personal information, which are enshrined in the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), among other things, "will be unable to be upheld."
Thus, you should follow Hanlon’s razor only if others don’t.
Any ecosystem where incompetence is assumed over malice creates material incentives for malice, because plausible deniability is fundamental to its environment. Therefore, malice is encouraged and becomes more likely, invalidating the theory.
As for your reply, I'm not actually sure what to make of it or how it relates to the previous comment, so I can't comment.
If they continue to enforce this without also making all liability-limitation clauses in software licenses invalid (and thus killing non-commercial software, including OSS), I would treat this as something very hypocritical.
For how long? A market is large because it has highly productive economies. If Europe can't hack computers, as you say, their growth potential will be curtailed.
European industry is alive and well, and it can buy the tools it needs from American companies. To the degree "Europe can't hack computers" is less of a ridiculous oversimplification, it's with pertinence to the consumer market.
European heavy industry expertise is deep [1]. It also undergirds a lot of America production; Rheinmetall, for instance, designs and builds the M1 Abrams’ gun. In light industry, ASML is the product of a distributed precision manufacturing culture.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_European_man...
> The EU has a higher GDP than the US (albeit they're very close).
In case anyone was curious, the IMF currently believes that the US's GDP is 50% higher than the EU's = 40% higher per capita.
https://www.imf.org/external/datamapper/profile/EU https://www.imf.org/external/datamapper/profile/USA
EU GDP per capita: $54K (PPP), $37K (nominal)
It's not even close.
Waymo is years ahead of anything coming out of Mercedes by the way.
>Mercedes has full Level 3 signed off in Nevada
I wonder why they're testing in Nevada and not the EU. Could it be that the EU stifles innovation with its strict laws?
Mercedes Level 3 cars expected to be priced at $50k, competitive with Tesla.
https://etsc.eu/europes-first-cars-with-level-3-automated-dr...
Actually US companies have an advantage as it's much easier for them to just ignore the laws / they have certain ways of getting around the laws that do not apply to EU companies.
What makes it worse: the GDPR itself is a great example of cultural differences: Americans are happy to eat bleached chicken and for all of their lives and personal data be there to make big companies lots of money. Europeans very much do not think like that. Which is good, different strokes for different folks.
Maybe delaying ChatGPT by a little opens up the market for an EU competitor, China style. I don't think that's very realistic because the EU doesn't move fast enough but who knows.
> But the EU has discovered that it can extract money by threatening to ban the foreign companies for reasons of privacy, data protection etc.
So your argument is that the EU, with trillions of dollars in GDP, decides to shoot itself in the foot by blocking one of the biggest inventions ever in order to "extract" a few millions of dollars here and there.
That's such a narrow minded view.
And ASML's golden goose, EUV tech, is an US invention licensed to ASML which can be revoked anytime if they sell EUV machines to China or any other US adversary, the restriction which is hurting ASML's bottom line as China is hungry for lithography machines and will pay top dollar for them.
ASML got to where it is precisely because of the US.
Longer story:
"The basics of EUV were invented in, and owned by, DOE labs (Sandia, Berkeley, and Lawrence) in the 1990s. The chip manufacturers wanted the labs' inventions commercialized, of course, so Intel took the lead on pushing that effort through a public/private partnership called a CRADA (Cooperative R&D Agreement) between the DOE labs and a consortium of private companies. They formed an entity called EUV-LLC to facilitate the CRADA.
Intel was eager to have Canon and Nikon participate in EUV-LLC, along with ASML and SVGL (the sole leading-edge American stepper supplier at the time and also a beneficiary of US taxpayer help). However, the DOE and the larger U.S. government weren't keen on handing U.S. taxpayer-funded research to foreign companies, so there was a lot of back and forth. I know only the sketchiest of details.
The DOE and Congress ended up rejecting Canon and Nikon's membership in EUV-LLC, denying them access to the underlying IP. But they allowed the (Dutch) ASML in. About 3 years later ASML was allowed to buy SVGL and, voilá, the only litho tool supplier that had a license to EUV IP, and the financial and technological backing of the EUV-LLC consortium, was Dutch."[1]
So no, we can't "do computers", that ship has sailed for us.
Not this again. Europe fails on producing unicorn that grow by exploiting people's addictions (Facebook), externalizing cost (Uber, AirBnB). However, Europe does fine in computing. The chips in you cell phone and computer are most likely made with an eUV machine from ASML, it probably has a bunch of NXP chips in it too. Europe has huge business software companies like SAP. Europe also has plenty of unicorns, like Klarna, Spotify, Revolut, Mollie, Just Eat/Takeaway etc. You may not know about all of them, because they operate primarily in Europe, like there are also plenty of US unicorns that barely have any footing in Europe.
Yes, the US is undoubtedly ahead in that regard as they are in most tech. Japan is also famous for its video game industry.
China is definitely one to be impressed with more than the EU in terms of emerging tech dominance [from a market that isn't a historical powerhouse in the way US and Japan are]. That doesn't mean the EU is "bad at computers" or that all tech companies are in the US, which is what I was responding to.
As an European I wouldn't gloat with Ubisoft.
The European Union is far behind, it's both pitiful and unproductive to suggest otherwise. The reason American's are surprised to hear certain companies like Ubisoft are from the EU is because it's that uncommon, no one gets surprised when a company is Japanese.
Europe is kind of blind spot for most Americans. They don't understand separate countries. They are surprised they can't pay in dollars and that the wall sockets are weird.
They don't know about European companies because they blindly assume that any western brand they heard of is American.
Absolute nonsense, what in the world led you to believing this? The average American has far more awareness of Europe than countries in South East Asia. That fact that Americans don't reciprocate the fanatical obsession Europeans tend to have with American current events & politics does not make them stupid like so many pretentious Europeans like to believe.
Other than Spotify, most unicorns in Europe are copies of businesses first successfully pioneered in the US. PayPal first did digital payments in the 20th century.
[0] https://ecommercedb.com/news/paypal-usage-around-90-in-europ...
[1] https://ecommercenews.eu/top-3-payment-methods-per-european-...
But I question the accuracy of these stats - I would expect to see SEPA wires and direct debit being significant everywhere, Multibanco and MBWay[0] in Portugal, TWINT in Switzerland, giropay in Germany, etc
Also, even if they are accurate, they rank Joe's homemade soap shop the same as a major retailer, and don't consider how many customers actually use each payment method.
I don’t actually know anyone who uses PayPal for anything but purchases outside the EU. Virtually all payments for online shopping here in The Netherlands are done using IDEAL (which is a system shared by all banks). When I lived in Germany, I did most online purchases through IBAN (you basically give your account number, do a 1 cent verification transaction and it is linked).
At any rate, IDEAL is so much better than dealing with all the PayPal crap or using credit cards. Select your bank, scan a QR code, confirm with Face ID and done.
I am far, far from a PayPal fan but the ability to seamlessly deal with merchants across the globe from you seems like a pretty good value add. And again, you didn't dispute why PayPal is so popular in Europe.
For local, in person, transactions my experience tells me the ratio of Debit vs Credit has to be in the order of 10 to 1.
Again, that’s just my experience living in Italy in not a huge city.
But Europe is definitely not homogeneous so other people will probably have a differente experience.
As for getting paid by people across Europe, in my 10+ years as a freelancer I never had to rely on anything different than SEPA direct transfer.
[1]: https://sifted.eu/articles/paypal-tops-european-downloads/
> In Europe, however, non-secure shopping was already happening online as early as the 1980s. Terminal-based services including Germany’s Bildschirmtext (launched in 1983), and Minitel in France (launched in 1982), offered various services including the ability to purchase air and train tickets.
https://www.kevin.eu/blog/history-of-online-payments/
Which would appear to be a whole decade before PayPal?
Not true, there's plenty of scummy dating apps for the German speaking market funded by Swiss and Bavarian VCs to exploit single lonely desperate men. European tech founders don't hold some holy moral high ground compared to the US ones.
>machine from ASML
Not this again, if I had a biscuit crumb for every time someone on HN mentioned ASML as an example of European tech dominance, I would have died from obesity several times over. The simple fact that ASML (and sometimes Spotify and scummy companies like Klarna) is the only name that comes to mind when discussion EU tech dominance, speaks volumes. (I'm European BTW)
Short story: the only reason ASML won and Canon and Nikon lost, is that US decided to license its domestic EUV tech From Sandia labs to ASML, and denied it to Canon and Nikon, purely because ASML acquired Silicon Valley Group Inc, US's leading lithography supplier at the time, giving ASML a strategic US presence versus their Japanese competitors.
Longer story:
"The basics of EUV were invented in, and owned by, DOE labs (Sandia, Berkeley, and Lawrence) in the 1990s. The chip manufacturers wanted the labs' inventions commercialized, of course, so Intel took the lead on pushing that effort through a public/private partnership called a CRADA (Cooperative R&D Agreement) between the DOE labs and a consortium of private companies. They formed an entity called EUV-LLC to facilitate the CRADA.
Intel was eager to have Canon and Nikon participate in EUV-LLC, along with ASML and SVGL (the sole leading-edge American stepper supplier at the time and also a beneficiary of US taxpayer help). However, the DOE and the larger U.S. government weren't keen on handing U.S. taxpayer-funded research to foreign companies, so there was a lot of back and forth. I know only the sketchiest of details.
The DOE and Congress ended up rejecting Canon and Nikon's membership in EUV-LLC, denying them access to the underlying IP. But they allowed the (Dutch) ASML in. About 3 years later ASML was allowed to buy SVGL and, voilá, the only litho tool supplier that had a license to EUV IP, and the financial and technological backing of the EUV-LLC consortium, was Dutch."[1]
>it probably has a bunch of NXP chips in it too
NXP make low margin chips. The margins US semi companies like Nvidia, Intel, AMD, Quallcomm make, dwarf NXP by orders of magnitude.
>Europe has huge business software companies like SAP
Companies? That's plural. But you only listed one. Which other large business SW companies do we have?
Where is EU's iPhone? Or Android? Or Windows? Or Intel? Or AWS? Or Office365? Or Google? Or ChatGPT? Or Xbox? Or Steam? Or Netflix? Or Nvidia? Or Micron? Or AMD?
Or why did Linus Torvalds, Bjarne Stroustrup, Guido van Rossum or Andrej Karpathy move to the US to make their impacts in the tech world instead of staying in their native European countries and doing it from here?
Europe is basically completely absent in terms of raising international champions in SW and HW products and services, especially in the consumer facing market. Our strength is making innovations and start-ups that end up swallowed by US money/entities and relocated across the Atlantic in some Delaware holding where they flourish on US soil.
US's handful of top tech companies outmatch the EU's entire tech sector combined, both in market cap and sheer numbers. It's not even a competition.
And using SAP as an example is, let's say on par with citing Exxon...
Europe suffers from a lack of initiative, vision and financing, much more than regulation. The Nokia fumble is just one of several examples.
On the other hand there is a lot of tech development in Europe "hidden" inside big "classical" companies. Has anyone heard of Cariad for example?
[1]: https://www.eu-startups.com/2011/04/9flats-and-wimdu-the-ger...
[2]: https://techcrunch.com/2011/06/01/airbnb-buys-german-clone-a...
In car tech is moving to being built on top of Android.
Cloud computing-Amazon, Microsoft and Google.
Sure Europe has some smaller companies, but it’s behind in tech and the reasons are:
- regulations
- bankruptcy laws, where US bankruptcy code encourages risk taking which is needed in a fast moving industry like tech
We do care about privacy, worker's right, &c. and we do understand that allowing foreign, especially american, companies to break things isn't a net benefit for us.
Uber abusing their """contractors""" despite the fact that they clearly are employees and should therefore have the same rights as other employees
E-mobility companies using public infrastructure (paid by local taxes) while themselves tax evading their profit
Airbnb allowing people to transform their regular flats into full time 365/365 hotel rooms despite the housing crisis
Nobody in the world actually cares about privacy. All the GDPR stuff did was ruin every website on the internet, most people click accept all, few people click deny because they are paranoid, everyone still uses instagram, facebook, and iphones which constantly broadcast your information to Apple. e.t.c. But at least the politicians get to strut around pretending like they did something.
>worker's right
No, you guys care about worker equality. Workers right means that if I want to work extra to beat my colleagues for promotion, and forgo having a family, I should be able to. EU laws say, "No, you cannot do this because its unfair to all the people that want to have families and work less".
To be clear, worker equality is not a bad thing, since it does guarantee a lot of protection, but on the flip side, it doesn't allow for as much innovation.
EU could easily beat US if it allowed the same level of corporate freedom instead of trying to pass labor regulation laws, and focused resources of worker protection on things like unemployment insurance.
Then you clearly don't know what GDPR is and how different companies treat data in the US and in Europe.
> No, you guys care about worker equality
Ok, call it whatever you want, is it mathematically and objectively inferior to your superior American Standards Of Ethics And Morals ?
Just follow the damn law, it's really not that hard. Add a pop up, ask for consent, detail what the data is used for, don't collect what you don't need. It really isn't hard, if you american super-geniuses can't do that you should stop flexing your tech capabilities.
90% of what is in GDPR should be standard when handling data, if you can't comply with it you don't care about data privacy in the first place.
> EU could easily beat US
Beat it at what game ? You're exactly the stereotype I'm talking about, if all that matter is money then you're 100% right. But then again if we talk about social security, paid parental leave, paid vacation, work life balance, &c. it's a whole other story. Feel free to do whatever you want in your country but don't come to other continents and try to force it down out throats
> EU laws say, "No, you cannot do this because its unfair to all the people that want to have families and work less".
Which law are you referencing ?
> if all that matter is money then you're 100% right.
Money is the only thing that matters. Every EU benefit that you get costs money, its just paid for indirectly.
Thats what caring about privacy is. If you use an iPhone or Mac that sends all your data for Apple to use in their own ad servers, but claim that you are against companies tracking you, you are a hypocrite, plain and simple.
As for rights vs equality, no, its not word games. They are two very different things. Rights is the ability to do things without anyone getting in your way. Equality means that protections (and restrictions) are offered to everyone regardless of how much money they make
If EU wanted to privacy right, the solution would have been a technological one instead of a policy one. The whole GDPR thing was simply a show put on by politicians, nothing more.
It was the ePrivacy Directive that actually regulated cookie use.
Fines are laughably low.
Besides, the whole GDPR is in place to protect European citizens from abuse of a fundamental right, which is privacy, from commercial and not commercial actors. If you are willing to give out everything about you for the latest new iToy and not receive a cent, be my guest, nobody is going to stop you in America. But here, we have regulations in place to prevent the overselling and oversharing of customer's own data.
Besides, "Europe can't do computers", Linux is a Finnish creation, as an example. You are confusing factories that produce hardware with the software that runs on it.
2 3 & 4, Wüt? That's not how these bans work... So could you please elaborate further?
1. Europe can't do computers. This is bad for them, because foreign companies, who can do computers, make money in Europe and beat out the local competition.
2. But the EU has discovered that it can extract money by threatening to ban the foreign companies for reasons of privacy, data protection etc.
3. Since the EU is a valuable market, the companies accept the fines as a price of doing business.
4. Italy is getting in early by firing a shot across the bows of OpenAI, which is not yet a huge moneymaker, but may be in future.