News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by jonny_eh on Friday March 17, 2023 @02:07PM (#35200659)
> It may seem eerie to our brains, which process events sequentially, but the history of science is also littered with examples of human biases leading to bad conclusions, such as the Earth-centric model of the solar system.

Slow down. Assuming that time moves in one direction is not comparable to geocentrism.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by whatshisface on Friday March 17, 2023 @02:15PM (#35200782)
It is because in both cases, you can work out that you'll never make an observation that really proves it one way or the other, but you might come up with some laws of physics that are more conveniently expressed in one way than another. They're both ultimately questions about your coordinate system, and in fact it is easier to invert time than it is to work out how everything's supposed to function in a rotating+sun-orbiting+precessing+... coordinate system.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by nanidin on Friday March 17, 2023 @02:46PM (#35201182)
If we reverse time and this implies running everything backwards in physics, do we include gravity in the set of things that are reversed? Then everything would fly off the face of the earth in reverse-time.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by theemathas on Friday March 17, 2023 @02:58PM (#35201369)
Reversing time on an attracting force still gives you an attractive force. Velocity is reversed, but acceleration isn't.

Imagine a ball being thrown up and then falling down, in a parabola. Reversing a video of that still gives you a video of a ball in a normal parabola trajectory.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by pixl97 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @08:04AM (#35208368)
The history of the universe channel on YouTube has an episode called 'what is time' that goes over symmetries like this. Lots of atomic/quantum scale interactions are time reversible like this, but not quote all, and that may be where time arrives from.

Well worth watching that episode as it does far better explaining than I do.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by whatshisface on Friday March 17, 2023 @02:56PM (#35201338)
Let's check.

F = ma

F = m dv/dt

u = -t dv/dt = -dv/du

- F = m dv/du

If you stop there it looks like you're right, but you also must change the definition of velocity to account for the new time.

v = dx/dt = -dx/du

+F = m dx/du

So the direction of gravity (the force F) stays the same when you flip time. I can explain that without the math by pointing out that if you took a video of a ball being thrown up and caught and played it in reverse, it would still depict a ball being thrown up and caught.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by nanidin on Friday March 17, 2023 @03:30PM (#35201731)
If we change the analogy of throwing a ball to firing a gun into the air - does the analogy still work? Since when we fire the gun up, the bullet will travel faster up than it will travel down due to terminal velocity in forward time. How is that phenomenon explained in reverse time?
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by whatshisface on Friday March 17, 2023 @03:31PM (#35201744)
Instead of predominately striking the bullet in a way that causes it to slow down, the molecules in the air will predominately strike it in a way that causes it to move faster, in what looks like an unbelievable (but still physically possible) run of good luck.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by kgwgk on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:55PM (#35203424)
In the way down -sky to gun - the molecules in the air will give it energy to accelerate more than gravity alone would. Before that - in the way up - air molecules will cause it to move upwards at constant speed until conveniently they stop doing so.

> unbelievable (but still physically possible)

Physically possible - but in the same sense that the second law is not a physical law.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by nanidin on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:10PM (#35203578)
So it seems like if we reverse time, we reverse entropy and that as time approaches 0, we would effectively be reversing the big bang and instead have the big collapse.

Another thought experiment that comes to mind is compressed gas in a cylinder. When we open the valve, the gas in the cylinder comes out. In reverse time, the gas would go back into the cannister and the valve would close after the gas went back in. Very low probability of that happening in forward time, though not not 0.

Though it seems weird, because why does the gas go into the cylinder? Because further into reverse-time, something sucked it all out (in forward-time, this machine is the compressor that put the gas in the cylider.) This hurts my brain!

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by nextaccountic on Friday March 17, 2023 @03:17PM (#35201586)
> I can explain that without the math by pointing out that if you took a video of a ball being thrown up and caught and played it in reverse, it would still depict a ball being thrown up and caught.

That's amazing, thanks. The portion where you caught the ball in forward time is equivalent to throwing the ball in reverse time.

I need to rewatch Tenet some day

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by novaRom on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:34PM (#35203221)
I watched it 4 times. Only then I started to understand what's happening. How great and unique this movie really is.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by mkl on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:31PM (#35203753)
I felt like I understood it the first time, but didn't think it was very good. Was that your initial reaction?
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by lupire on Friday March 17, 2023 @10:03PM (#35205334)
What is u?
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by whatshisface on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:06AM (#35206570)
A newline is missing there, u = -t. (Too late to edit it.)
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by entropicdrifter on Friday March 17, 2023 @02:52PM (#35201277)
Gravity is a universal constant. If you reverse time, you just reverse the order of cause and effect, not what the effect is.

Does that make more sense to you?

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by nanidin on Friday March 17, 2023 @03:27PM (#35201707)
If we reverse time, would gravitational waves flow backwards?
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by dekhn on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:30PM (#35202479)
yes. it's literally like playing a movie in reverse.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by nanidin on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:16PM (#35203011)
" it's literally like playing a movie in reverse" seems overly authoritative for something we haven't observed. I have seen Tenet, but it's a work of fiction.

Have we observed reflected gravitational waves? In reverse-time, where would they originate from if they presumably rippled out into space and didn't collide with anything in forward-time?

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by dekhn on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:14PM (#35203599)
.... they would "originate" from all the locations the gravity waves spread to and converge on the source.

Tenet has nothing to do with this- I'm just explaining it as it was covered in my many physics classes that covered the nature of the arrow of time (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrow_of_time) and how I interpret it in terms of what seems most likely/least unlikely.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by bigbacaloa on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:29PM (#35202475)
"gravity is a universal constant" contradicts Newtonian mechanics, special and general relativity.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by nanidin on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:18PM (#35203039)
In these "it's like taking a video of throwing a ball in the air and allowing it to land on the ground, then playing it playing it in reverse" examples, I can't help but think of Newton's first law. If an object at rest stays at rest, how does the ball leap from the ground? Where does the impulse come from? Reverse time seems too far fetched for me, or at least the simplified naïve version of it does.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by bnralt on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:55PM (#35203421)
It also seems a bit misleading, since in that scenario a ball is intentionally thrown so that it comes down the same way.

Let's consider something else - imagine an accretion disk of space dust slowly pulling itself together to form a planet. Play that in reverse, and you have the a planet slowly coming apart piece by piece. Imagine reversing the impact that created the moon. The moon comes apart piece by piece, creating an accretion disk around the earth, which then all moves and hits one area of the earth, and there several parts of it (and part of the earth itself) move together to form a separate planet, which then launches itself from the earths surface into space, flies around the sun a few times, and then slowly breaks apart piece by piece into another accretion disk.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by sidlls on Friday March 17, 2023 @02:49PM (#35201237)
It isn't because we have the observations we have. It might be mathematically easy to invert time, but empirically it's not so simple. Mathematical symmetries and expressions are nice, but then the actual physical consequences and requirements (e.g., material, time, energy inputs) sort of force one's hand.

Also, geocentrism is actually disproven by numerous observations, which in fact guided the mathematical formulation of our current physics.

One thing is (almost) certain: the laws of physics as we know them (i.e. the Standard Model and General Relativity) are incomplete ("wrong"). That doesn't mean any old model is equivalent or as useful as either, though.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by whatshisface on Friday March 17, 2023 @02:52PM (#35201284)
>Also, geocentrism is actually disproven by numerous observations, which in fact guided the mathematical formulation of our current physics.

The validity of a coordinate system with the earth stationary at the center is guaranteed by the general principle of relativity. To get the stars to circle around it you would add a radially increasing potential in classical mechanics, or some coordinate shenanigans in GR. These coordinate systems are used in aerospace engineering to get convenient expressions of L1 points, etc.

I know it sounds hard to believe, but if you're willing to bite the bullet that "the center of the universe" has no physical meaning, then earth can't be not the center of the universe any more than it can be.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by prerok on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:43PM (#35202650)
To be honest, I have no idea what you are talking about.

Certainly, there is merit in practical calculations when we are all this close to the ground where it all seems either flat or at least geo-centric.

But... the movements of the other planets in our solar system were really strange to model in geo-centric models. In short, each of the other planets should rotate around an imaginary axis to compensate for their changing positions in the sky.

Of course, all this is talk about in the context of our solar system. As for us being the center of the universe, well, the same argument holds for any other point in the universe. So, I think it's less likely than me winning the lottery in the next five minutes :)

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by felipeerias on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:30PM (#35203175)
In the XVII century, the alternative to heliocentrism was Tycho Brahe’s model: Earth at the centre, the Sun and Moon and the stars revolving around it, and the other planets revolving around the Sun. It was basically equivalent to the heliocentric model with a different coordinate system.

It’s important to understand that astronomers chose it because it really seemed to provide a better explanation given the knowledge and technology at the time.

Tycho Brahe himself noted that his model could be disproved by observing the stellar parallax effect as the Earth orbits the Sun (if the Earth does move, then the stars would look slightly different throughout the year). This is a real effect, but so small that it couldn’t be observed until the XIX century.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by matthewdgreen on Friday March 17, 2023 @07:11PM (#35204107)
There was even more to it. Cosmographers of the time were willing to consider the possibility that the stars were very far away, far enough to make parallax changes undetectable. The main stumbling point was that they assumed the stars would be similar in size to our sun, but based on naked-eye and telescopic measurements of the diameter of the “disk” of the stars (many taken by Brahe and Galileo themselves), any solution that explained the parallax effect would have resulted in enormous stars, and this they couldn’t accept. Eventually the measurements turned out to be an optical artifact.

I read an entire book on this subject, published by a Catholic press. There seems to be an active interest in the Catholic science establishment in rehabilitating some of Galileo’s critics.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by ben_w on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:33PM (#35203783)
> I know it sounds hard to believe, but if you're willing to bite the bullet that "the center of the universe" has no physical meaning, then earth can't be not the center of the universe any more than it can be.

I disagree.

The sentence «"the center of the universe" has no physical meaning» requires that Earth can't be at the center of the universe, because there isn't a center for it to be at.

You're still allowed any or many arbitrary zero-points, but that's only the center of a number line, nothing else.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by whatshisface on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:46PM (#35203903)
It's basically a semantic issue but I don't think the negation of an undefined proposition is true, I think it is undefined. (Thankfully the universe does not run in JavaScript, where !undefined is true.)
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by ben_w on Friday March 17, 2023 @07:02PM (#35204043)
That I agree with.

But, Earth.x = 42 (in some arbitrary coordinate space), if I understand correctly there isn't a sub-light coordinate space in this universe where Earth.x = undefined.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by whatshisface on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:28PM (#35211762)
Positions are defined, but they're different in every coordinate system, which makes "the center of the universe," by itself, undefined.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by ben_w on Saturday March 18, 2023 @04:38PM (#35212874)
That's not the reason why the centre of the universe is undefined.

By analogy, while spherical coordinates are arbitrary, latitude is defined. Arbitrary, but defined.

But the centre of the Earth has an undefined latitude, and a topological subspace consisting of just the surface of the Earth can't hand-wave past that by pointing out that's just a coordinate singularity that can be safely ignored — there isn't a center of the Earth anywhere in that subspace.

And the universe might be infinite, which has a different problem because you can't properly define a median of an infinite set[0], so no center exists.

[0] I think. Infinity is easy to get messed up with.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by rbanffy on Monday March 20, 2023 @05:30PM (#35239062)
> That's not the reason why the centre of the universe is undefined.

Be patient. It hasn't been evaluated just yet.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by jskulski on Friday March 17, 2023 @03:51PM (#35201971)
We may not be able to observed it, and maybe can’t. Just like time slowing down would be imperceptible to the person on the spaceship nearing light speed. It takes the mathematics

Or if I’m lucky enough to have the time to watch the moon move slowly, it feels natural to my senses to say it’s moving across the sky. The moon feels like it’s moving around me. But I can stretch my brain and imagine the reality.

Sometimes math arrives first. We have the new maths (or an problem in current math), and that points to some possibility. Because it’s not observable, ignoring our senses is a requirement to develop that in the model and measurements and experiments. Eventually we are able to observe it.

I’m not familiar with history of astronomy. Would it be the case where the observations that lead to heliocentric thought we nuanced and had to build on more obvious perceptions that things aren’t adding up? Was the wobble of Venus part of that?

And you’re right, old models are useful and remain relevant a lot! The model of time moving linearly will likely always be the most useful model for navigating our daily choices (if we have any at all!)

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by epgui on Friday March 17, 2023 @02:46PM (#35201181)
I disagree, I think the comparison is pretty reasonable.

Your entire experience of the world is defined and limited by the fact that your brain "only processes information in one direction of time" (for lack of better wording). Your personal experience does not necessarily map correctly to the real world. The same is true for both examples.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by brwck on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:03PM (#35202134)
It's not just a matter of our subjective experience of time, it's a matter of the laws of thermodynamics and entropy. Time moves in one direction is another way of saying entropy always increases. If time could move in the opposite direction, then entropy decreases which breaks our understanding of physics.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by VeninVidiaVicii on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:21PM (#35202359)
It's really interesting to think about how we struggle to express the idea of the future having a causal impact on the past. I reckon this is because our language and our understanding of time are limited.

Our brains like to process events in a linear sequence, from past to present to future, but this view of time might not fully capture how everything in the universe is interconnected. It's possible that our language just can't handle these complex concepts.

So, I don't think anything mentioned in this thread contradicts the idea that "time always moves in one direction" and "entropy always increases".

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by dasil003 on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:13PM (#35202982)
Right. "Time only moves in one direction" is not saying much more than "our consciousness experience time moving in one direction". The very idea that time "moves" is entirely related to our vantage point. If our perception were not bound to time, then the nature of cause and effect might look completely different.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Trasmatta on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:42PM (#35203308)
I don't think the idea that "the future can influence the past" is the same thing as saying that entropy decreases or that time can move in the opposite direction. I think these are different concerns
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by epgui on Friday March 17, 2023 @07:58PM (#35204512)
The "arrow of time" conception of entropy: 1) does not work locally and only works at large enough scales, and; 2) is essentially isomorphic to the concept of time.

So no, it's not at all incompatible with retro-causality. When you think about retro-causality, the idea that time "moves" is completely superfluous. Time is probably not even a real thing.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by coderenegade on Friday March 17, 2023 @08:04PM (#35204556)
The direction of causality should also be reversed from what I can tell. Instead of a bullet slowing down as it hits air molecules and pushes them out of the way, the air molecules push on the bullet because the bullet will be sucked into the barrel in the future.

More on topic, I think our existing theories of reality tell us that the future probably affects the past, or at very least, is predetermined. If you know the solution to a differential equation, you know the state at any point in time. There's no going off the rails, so to speak. And if the system is constrained in any dimension (i.e. it's nonholonomic) then the state at any given moment relies on the full trajectory up to that point, as opposed to just the previous state. But you can flip that on its head and say that the future state determines the present trajectory. E.g. to turn a bicycle left, you have to first turn right.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by spixy on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:44AM (#35210021)
but what about reverse falling cartridge? Will spacetime around Earth change from "hole" to "hill"?
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by epgui on Sunday March 19, 2023 @01:39AM (#35216361)
That's not going to be necessary.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by coderenegade on Sunday March 19, 2023 @07:45PM (#35225085)
I think it's the same thing. The future energy state of the cartridge is that it's in the chamber, so it gets sucked up. It's problematic though, because the direction of gravity doesn't change.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by fdsafsd34 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:24PM (#35215022)
Just commented about interpreting the Probability Law as sort of "Inverted 2nd. Law of Thermodynamics".

I'll expand here how if the arrow of time actually doesn't exist, the future could change the past without breaking our - current - understanding of physics (tragiclly because we will probably have maybe hundred of years till we change our minds about what are the properties of the universe).

In a range or probabilities of one event, one of the probabilities will always be the one is going to actually happen. Closer to the event to occur the most certain you can be about which one of those, could be the one that will happen.

Here's the catch, you have to change your mind a bit, in our current understanding of physics, the information of the future event which has not happen yet, already exists here in the past for that event.

Now, if you know - and you know - the outcome of an event, you most certainly will be able to choose if you go along that path, or you choose to change the future event to something else. Whoalá, the future changed the past.

Brains of earth continously do this, every second of our entire lives, animal brains do this too, almost all life on Earth has some neurological, physiological, chemical predictive mechanism in place.

An example, you're about to walk across a street, you see a car coming, now your brain "predicts" you'll be hit by that car if you just keep walking, you stop walking to avoid certain death, done, the future changed the past. The information - really close to 100% of probability of death - extracted by the brain from the sheer reality of the universe, allowed you to survive.

And no current understanding of physics got harmed anywhere along the way of the future changing the past.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by 7thaccount on Friday March 17, 2023 @02:46PM (#35201194)
Yep. Someone else already pointed out the well known counterargument to symmetry below regarding thermodynamics. You typically don't see scrambled eggs become whole again. I think that's pretty hard evidence to overcome.

Granted, I'm not a physicist and I'm sure any physicist working on this totally understands that. Just wanted to point it out.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by kridsdale1 on Friday March 17, 2023 @02:56PM (#35201333)
Scrambled eggs can become whole again by being consumed by insects, who are then consumed by chickens, who then lay eggs.

The biological processes enabling that sequence can be said to have negative entropy.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by dekhn on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:33PM (#35202547)
Negative entropy (also called negentropy) isn't really a well-defined concept. Instead, better to say that biological processes harvest free energy to maintain order in the face of increasing entropy.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by resource0x on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:19PM (#35202339)
If the direction of time is reversed, the eggs become whole again, but your memory of them once being scrambled is reversed, too, so you don't notice anything unusual.

(It's like a rollback of database transaction, where not only the database state, but also the state of everything, including your brain, is getting rolled back)

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by fortyseven on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:47PM (#35202692)
That would suggest a kind of "super timeline" I'd imagine.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by 7thaccount on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:52PM (#35202751)
But is there any evidence of that? Or is it just a thought experiment? I need to read more of the article, but appreciate you giving me some food for thought.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by resource0x on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:30PM (#35203739)
It's a thought experiment, of course. There cannot be any evidence one way or the other, by definition. Any potential evidence is rolled back, too. But then, why are we so sure our current beliefs WRT the arrow ot time are true?

Though there's no hard evidence, but if you think, for example, about the efficiency of evolution - it would be much easier to explain if we assume that the unlimited number of iterations is performed. (This is not the only possible explanation, of course- but this one is overlooked IMO)

I would say that compared with the strange ideas like "multiverse", this one is rather benign :-)

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by beiller on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:11PM (#35202954)
If the future could affect the past, it suggest that then if time reversed, you would notice something unusual right? Kind of like suggesting there is a side effect in your function (consciousness). Kind of like how today, past events can influence the future like we act differently from learning from mistakes.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by MattPalmer1086 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @08:43AM (#35208630)
So the conscious experience of the person at each time would be exactly the same as our experience. They would feel as if they were moving forward in time.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by aeternum on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:00PM (#35203473)
The argument is that thermodynamics is simply a statistical phenomenon. Scrambled eggs are due to proteins denaturing (folding in a random way).

Scrambled eggs do actually unscramble spontaneously if you zoom in far enough. The issue is that the rate of scrambling is much higher than the rate of unscrambling so on the whole, you get scrambled eggs.

The amazing thing is that all chemical processes are actually reversible given enough energy and finesse.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by seydor on Friday March 17, 2023 @02:48PM (#35201231)
Assuming that time "moves" kinda is
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by weknowbetter on Friday March 17, 2023 @02:55PM (#35201328)
Nothing actually moves according to Zeno's paradox.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Ygg2 on Friday March 17, 2023 @03:14PM (#35201552)
Zeno's paradox assumes space is infinitely divisible.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by kelseyfrog on Friday March 17, 2023 @03:45PM (#35201891)
they didn't understand limits
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Ygg2 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @12:57PM (#35210793)
You don't understand physics. Or logic.

Nature doesn't have to obey any particular set of axiom you adopt.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by kelseyfrog on Saturday March 18, 2023 @04:51PM (#35212975)
Can you make your point without a personal slight?
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by edgyquant on Friday March 17, 2023 @07:34PM (#35204319)
can you profe to me that the physical space between everything isn’t?
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Ygg2 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @12:41PM (#35210598)
Planck length.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by edgyquant on Monday March 20, 2023 @11:11AM (#35232657)
Yes I know what was meant and that’s my point. That is not a physical proof but a mathematical abstraction.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by stametseater on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:39AM (#35209058)
The real number line is infinitely divisible, but you can still move a point along it.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by macrolocal on Friday March 17, 2023 @03:13PM (#35201549)
It's comparable to GPT4 being shocked that we can read backwards!
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by 0xBABAD00C on Friday March 17, 2023 @03:19PM (#35201600)
Here's the analogy, per Sean Carroll [1]:

- There seems to be a special direction "down", where things fall by default, because we live in the vicinity of an influential object in space, called Earth

- There seems to be a special direction "forward in time", where things happen by default, because we live in the vicinity of an influential event in time, called Big Bang

If we had stuck to the local Earth context and geocentrism, the objectivity of the "down" direction would remain unquestioned. It's when we started modeling other things outside of Earth, it became clear there's no objective "down" direction, just a more general concept of Gravity.

Carroll's argument is that it's the Big Bang, an extremely low-entropy configuration of the universe, that gives rise to the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics and the resulting emergence of an arrow of time in the forward direction. It's purely a statistical phenomenon at larger scales, and attributable to being "next to an influential event", according to him.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZsmyTE3j9o

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by photochemsyn on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:16PM (#35202315)
It's difficult to see how such a hypothesis could be tested either experimentally or observationally. Sounds more like metaphysics?

Stars shine until they run out of fuel, and the age of a star - the status of its fuel, the buildup of fusion products - happens as time passes. Life on planets taps into the flow of sunlight from the star (and/or the flow of heat and chemical energy from the a hot planetary core) to generate complex structures in defiance of the regular direction of entropy (not violating conservation of energy, though). So... life reverses the arrow of time?

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by prerok on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:29PM (#35202471)
Well, of course not :) Entropy as direction of time just means that the chaos on the whole increases. So, to create an ordered structure, like a cell organism, the by-product is more chaos around it.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by ashirviskas on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:32PM (#35202534)
To add, life just speeds up the chaos by orders of magnitude, it's a perfect entropy catalyst.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by kergonath on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:40PM (#35203844)
I’d be shocked if that were the case, even only considering the Earth. The oceans and the atmosphere are full of entropy. So is the liquid outer core. And even if the mantle is not quite liquid, and even if the crust is mostly solid, these are huge in terms of volume and mass, much larger than the sliver of dirt we inhabit on top of them. So yeah, I really doubt we (collectively, all human beings) are changing the Earth’s entropy in any meaningful way.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by zone411 on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:47PM (#35203916)
Life reduces local entropy.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by lxgr on Friday March 17, 2023 @08:12PM (#35204607)
At the expense of increased global entropy, which I suppose is GPs point.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by zone411 on Friday March 17, 2023 @08:22PM (#35204669)
"there is 10 million times more entropy in that radiation [cosmic microwave radiation] than there is in all of the mass of the universe"

https://news.berkeley.edu/2016/09/20/new-book-links-flow-of-...

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by TeMPOraL on Friday March 17, 2023 @09:50PM (#35205261)
But then, this is just entropy from a one-off event long ago. Meanwhile, life is an entropy producing reaction with a strong exponential factor.

To butcher an insightful quote by (IIRC) Hamming, any positive slope will eventually make up for y-intercept of a constant function.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by zone411 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @12:00AM (#35205940)
It underlines the idea that the entropy-time connection is pretty shaky though.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by prerok on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:33PM (#35202544)
I think that the real question is whether the death of the universe by cool down will happen before the arrow of time is reversed. To me it seems more like it will just slow down and then finally stop.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by SirYandi on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:21PM (#35203657)
Or if there ever is a "big crunch" where all black holes crunch together to a critical mass, would there be another big bang and time then run backwards?
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by DubiousPusher on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:58PM (#35204014)
The hypothesis I have encountered is that time would reverse when the expansion of the universe peaked and started to collapse back in on itself. The next big bang would start another run of our universe. I'm guessing the randomness in quantum fluctuations would allow this next run to evolve somewhat differently from the one we are experiencing.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by K0balt on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:13PM (#35203589)
I think that one thing to keep in mind is that we are only capable of observing the passage of time along one vector because our perception relies upon entropic biological processes.

We cannot observe in any subset of possible universes where entropy is not present or is working backwards-Ergo those possibilities are wholly out of our direct perception.

That does not mean that causality cannot run in reverse, however, only that we cannot interact with those mechanisms in a way that would preclude our existence or observation.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by DubiousPusher on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:55PM (#35203984)
But could we observe the effects? Can there be particles which have mass and therefore exhibit gravitation but which are subject to reverse entropy? We would observe these for example as an unexplainable increase in gravitational pull on observable matter without an observable source of that gravitation and without a preceding cause.

Are photons themselves stratling this entropic boundary since they travel at the speed of light and within their own reference frame are not subject to the passage of time?

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by stametseater on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:24AM (#35208930)
Biology has nothing to do with it. We can't construct any manner of machine that measures time going in the other direction.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by postalrat on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:52AM (#35209134)
Maybe all that quantum nonsense we can't explain is due to some type of time travel we don't comprehend.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by lotsoweiners on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:18PM (#35211670)
If only we had Tony Stark to help build some sort of a “quantum GPS”.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Xelynega on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:02PM (#35213073)
Wouldn't questioning those pre-existing notions be the first step towards constructing such a machine? It sounds silly to dismiss the idea time could go backwards because we don't have any machines that work that way, since that typically how all ideas work before we implement them.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by tshaddox on Friday March 17, 2023 @07:03PM (#35204059)
> It's difficult to see how such a hypothesis could be tested either experimentally or observationally. Sounds more like metaphysics?

Sure, but some claims which cannot be tested experimentally or observationally are nonetheless important. For example, the claim “it’s important that scientific hypotheses be tested experimentally or observationally.”

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by lxgr on Friday March 17, 2023 @08:10PM (#35204589)
While I agree that not everything in science can be tested experimentally or observationally, arguably this one can:

Models created using both empirical experimentation and logical reasoning match reality much better than those based on "pure logics" (if that even is possible).

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by xwolfi on Friday March 17, 2023 @08:00PM (#35204526)
Alain Aspect tested it with his delayed choice quantum eraser, didnt he ? (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aspect%27s_experiment)

At least in France we take as fait accompli that causality is non trivial and that objects are non local at best: either you can consider objects as one despite immense distance between them, or you accept information passed between them in reverse time. Both are hard to swallow.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by kgwgk on Saturday March 18, 2023 @06:42AM (#35207902)
No, he didn’t. The “delayed choice quantum eraser” is something else - and it’s not about the flow of time either.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Rury on Friday March 17, 2023 @10:37PM (#35205508)
> Life on planets taps into the flow of sunlight from the star (and/or the flow of heat and chemical energy from the a hot planetary core) to generate complex structures in defiance of the regular direction of entropy

It doesn't defy the direction of entropy. Frankly, I'm not sure why you have that notion? Entropy is a measure of system's state of equilibrium. Moving energy from a concentrated source, and distributing it more equally (across life forms and other complex structures), is following the direction of entropy, as is it makes energy more equalized, in contrast to the former state where energy levels are unequal between highly concentrated areas (like stars), and areas without energy.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by coderenegade on Friday March 17, 2023 @11:39PM (#35205807)
Entropy only increases on average. You can decrease it locally, for example, making steel from iron ore. You generate heat, so you still get a net increase, but you could easily redefine your boundary to only include the local decrease in entropy (the steel from ore).
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Rury on Saturday March 18, 2023 @08:07PM (#35214531)
Yes, but like you said, that requires re-drawing your boundaries. It doesn't really defy the direction of entropy, it only appears that way from having changed scope.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by fdsafsd34 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @07:58PM (#35214469)
"Sounds more like metaphysics?"

The regular arrow of time from the human perspective, "leaks" changes into the future. The future is constantly being changed by the past.

You can measure those changes by many ways, the 2nd. law of thermodynamics is everywhere just to make sure you see this happening across everything.

So, probably there are other non-discovered underlying mechanisms in the reality that are already signaling changes from the future "leaking" into the past, changing the past right infront of us, without us noticing it.

A probably omnipresent mechanism for observing the future changing the past, valid in the whole cone of light visible to us, is the probability law.

If you have 10 millions of possible events in a probability, one of them is the exact thing it will happen in the future, hence the information of what happens in the future is right here, existing in the past.

Yeah, you can say how would the nature could use this information without powerful processors predicting branches trillions of times per second on Earth right now?

Well, the brain is a pattern predictor, quite several parts of the brain are firmly attached to the physics of the universe, biochemically but what if the pattern prediction mechanisms in the brain are actually an adaptation of the evolution, just like wings to fly, but with those mechanisms the brain uses probability to "see" information from the future, and here in the "present", it changes the past (from the perspective of the future created originally from the past), if the brain "chooses now" to do something different that what originally created the future it "saw" by analizing patterns, essentially evaluating probabilities.

So the Probability Law would be a kind of Inverted 2nd. Law of Thermodynamics.

It would work perfectly as law of the universe: from the future to the past, the revered time of arrow, one single event created "a" future, but from the regular arrow of time, there would a range of probable future outcomes which you cannot precisely say it has "1" (100%) probability of ocurring, right to exact moment till the future becomes the present.

And it was right there all the time, something obvious infront of everybody in the world, like electricity (which was suspected by many across thousands of years, but just "discovered" recently).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_total_probability

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by psychphysic on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:30PM (#35202488)
I don't think Carroll can take credit for the idea of the arrow of time being emergent from a local entropy initial state.

Roger Penrose proposed that as far as I know, when Carroll was probably a high schooler.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by platz on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:45PM (#35202675)
who's taking "credit"
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by mellosouls on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:00PM (#35202847)
Roger Penrose proposed that as far as I know, when Carroll was probably a high schooler.

No. At least as early as Arthur Eddington when Penrose was a twinkle in his dad's eye.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by psychphysic on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:36AM (#35207601)
Thanks didn't know he'd made that argument although I knew he made the connection between entropy increasing and arrow of time.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by yeahwhatever10 on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:00PM (#35202851)
Explaining an idea is not equivalent to taking credit for it.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by psychphysic on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:03PM (#35202875)
> Carroll's argument

This assigns credit to Carroll.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Jcowell on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:09PM (#35202940)
It merely says that Carrol argued. The idea within the argument was no means assigned to her but used to make/support it.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by psychphysic on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:35AM (#35207593)
Sean Carroll is a man, and look up the possessive apostrophe while you're at it!
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by zone411 on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:49PM (#35203937)
This idea of time's relation to entropy is pretty iffy. I recommend this book https://news.berkeley.edu/2016/09/20/new-book-links-flow-of-....
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by klipt on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:22PM (#35203087)
Right, entropy can decrease, just with low probability, which you can calculate using the Fluctuation Theorem: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluctuation_theorem

Perhaps given infinite time, we will randomly get back to a low entropy state infinite times, but I don't know enough about the math to say for sure.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by ben_w on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:25PM (#35203695)
You can, but that inevitably leads to far more Boltzman brains than things like the universe, and that's disastrous because then you should expect to be a Boltzman brain yourself, but they're configured randomly so if you are a Boltzman brain you can't trust any belief you have about reality including the maths that says you should be a Boltzman brain.

It's basically a softer version of Russell's paradox but for cognition and reality.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by mjrpes on Saturday March 18, 2023 @04:12PM (#35212668)
Carroll did a great solo podcast about this last year: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B40PRvLtiec

Hard to summarize, but it's well worth anyone interested in this topic. There's a good bit where he ties the sleeping beauty thought experiment with Boltzmann Brains and consciousness; it blew my mind trying to understand the whole thing.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by kiicia on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:40AM (#35216105)
Infinite time is too much of a “get out from jail” card, because during infinite time anything and everything will happen by definition
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Viliam1234 on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:31PM (#35223875)
I don't have a problem with "time" meaning "away from the local Big Bang". But that does not imply that future causes the past.

Just like noticing that "down" actually means "towards the center of the local planet" did not make water suddenly flow uphill.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by yyyk on Friday March 17, 2023 @03:49PM (#35201959)
The comparison is bad all around. Geocentrism actually had decent reasoning and was not a superstition. It's just we couldn't see the parallax with then-current instruments. As soon as instruments allowed, humanity changed rather quickly.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Notatheist on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:34PM (#35202561)
Time moving in one direction actually has decent reasoning and is not a superstition. It's just we can't detect time moving backwards with now-current instruments. As soon as instruments allow, humanity will change rather quickly.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by yyyk on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:47PM (#35202701)
The problem with the comparison is what it's used to imply. The popular understanding* is that scientists believed in religious dogma, and that led them to 'unscientific' geocentrism and believing that time has only one direction. It's a backhanded accusation of superstition, and that's unfair towards both current scientists and past scientists.

(On a personal note, I'm actually sympathetic to the article's retrocasual proposition. I suspect reality is non-local and TSVF etc. naturally tend towards non-locality.)

* This is Vice, of course they use the popular understanding and not something more sophisticated.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by stametseater on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:34AM (#35209028)
It seems to me that the popular understanding is influenced by grossly misleading 20th century anti-religious propaganda. The geocentric model is not something the Catholic Church plucked out of the bible; they got it from Ptolemy and other 'heathen' classical thinkers, whom the Catholic Church considered meritorious despite not being Christians. Sure, they then found some biblical citations to back themselves up in this, but the idea was never their own in the first place.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by TheSpiceIsLife on Friday March 17, 2023 @07:20PM (#35204185)
We've always been able to detect that some celestial objects appear to move backwards at times.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by bsder on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:17PM (#35202319)
> Slow down. Assuming that time moves in one direction is not comparable to geocentrism.

Why not?

The "arrow of time" almost always requires thermodynamic arguments. And that requires a concentration of "low entropy" to move toward "high entropy". Which, by definition, are "boundary conditions" and not a fundamental part of your physical rules.

If, for example, your universe is entropically uniform, is there an "arrow of time"? And, even if there were, could you detect it?

However, I would like to point out that it's not like we haven't had this kind of issue before. The Bohr-Einstein debates were a good example. Einstein favored a "fields" interpretation of quantum mechanics. Unfortunately, Einstein's interpretation predicted that atomic states wouldn't decay, and that was clearly, obviously wrong, and Bohr very much hammered on that.

Except that Einstein wasn't "clearly, obviously wrong." As you increasingly isolate excited atoms, their atomic states take longer and longer to decay. The problem was that the experiments of the day couldn't create these kinds of singular quantum state systems--they were stuck with systems that were contaminated with lots of thermodynamic interactions.

We may be seeing something similar here. We are just starting to be able to put together the experiments that can probe things like Bell's Inequality. As we isolate these systems, we may find that the systems were contaminated with statistical time and that we get different results when we can isolate them.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by kgwgk on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:59PM (#35202833)
> If, for example, your universe is entropically uniform, is there an "arrow of time"? And, even if there were, could you detect it?

What does that even mean ? If your universe is entropically uniform there is no “you”.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Barrin92 on Friday March 17, 2023 @07:02PM (#35204051)
>If, for example, your universe is entropically uniform, is there an "arrow of time"?

Nope, and there's a really great 'physics slam' about this, sadly only in German but auto-translate seems fine. https://youtu.be/z64PJwXy--8?t=519

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by yportne on Friday March 17, 2023 @07:46PM (#35204441)
> If, for example, your universe is entropically uniform, is there an "arrow of time"? No. For a system at thermodynamics equilibrium entropy is constant, neither increasing nor decreasing. So there is no arrow of time, no sense in which one direction is "the future" and the other "the past".
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by archontes on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:09PM (#35234859)
If a universe were entropically uniform, wouldn't the arrow of time definitely be negative? Wouldn't any random evolution result in a lessening of entropy by definition?
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by febusravenga on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @12:12AM (#35256753)
> If, for example, your universe is entropically uniform, is there an "arrow of time"? And, even if there were, could you detect it?

Would we have fluctuations in that state? In which directions they would... Progress?

Isn't what you describe an anomaly like black hole or division by zero, where we cannot understand what actually happens because normal laws break because they are unsolvable with current models?

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by CuriouslyC on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:02PM (#35202868)
Geocentrism seemed reasonable until it didn't.

If time is a true dimension rather than just something we model as a dimension, it's not unreasonable to think that outcomes in the present could be influenced by constraints that exist in the future - if the "universe" function must be valid according to some constraints at all points in the time dimension, "past" states that lead to invalid future states will never occur.

The idea of invalid universe states is of course purely fun conjecture, but this same concept also maps to probable vs improbable universe states as well. If a future state is improbable (in the sense of a Bayesian prior according to some underlying distribution of energy in the universe) that might cause the universe to evolve in a way that seems improbable at the moment by moment level, but is actually the most probable sequence of events when integrated over the entire duration of the universe.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by bmacho on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:24PM (#35203686)
> Geocentrism seemed reasonable until it didn't.

Literally nobody "assumes" that "time moves one direction" (which is not even a statement). There are models, where t is a real number, which models are sadly very very good models, but they are not perfect. Noone believes that Newtonian mechanics, QM or GR are true. QM fails to correctly predict the movement of the planets, and GR fails at the two-split experiment.

But then there are literally thousands of physicists that try to come up with different models.

How is this even remotely similar to geocentrism?

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by willis936 on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:03PM (#35202878)
Time could move backwards if we lived in a time symmetric universe. We don't. Maybe if you flipped the charge and handedness of the entire universe you could also reverse time, but that's yet to be tested.

https://youtu.be/L2idut9tkeQ

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by lxgr on Friday March 17, 2023 @08:04PM (#35204552)
How so?

The idea doesn't seem so different from matter being the default (vs. antimatter), relative speeds much closer to zero than to the speed of light being what's commonly observable etc.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by fdsafsd34 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:54PM (#35215192)
I think the actual assumption is that we are currently seeing just one direction of the arrow of time, but if there is no arrow of time, maybe we are already seeing the future and not realizing it is the future.

I commented further in this line of though in another comments, about a probable (ironically), "Inverted 2nd. Law of Thermodynamics" of sorts, which it would be basically just the Law of Probability, interpreted from the point of view of not having an actual arrow of time and the fact that we have - all the time, again ironically - the information of what happens in the future (the one probability in the range which ends being the right one, actually ocurring).

Yeah, I know it would be another Law, and the universe would upside down once again for us the poor meatbags, but we were already in this position several times, discovering the electricity, quantum mechanics, relativiy, you name it.