News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by 0xBABAD00C on Friday March 17, 2023 @03:19PM (#35201600)
Here's the analogy, per Sean Carroll [1]:

- There seems to be a special direction "down", where things fall by default, because we live in the vicinity of an influential object in space, called Earth

- There seems to be a special direction "forward in time", where things happen by default, because we live in the vicinity of an influential event in time, called Big Bang

If we had stuck to the local Earth context and geocentrism, the objectivity of the "down" direction would remain unquestioned. It's when we started modeling other things outside of Earth, it became clear there's no objective "down" direction, just a more general concept of Gravity.

Carroll's argument is that it's the Big Bang, an extremely low-entropy configuration of the universe, that gives rise to the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics and the resulting emergence of an arrow of time in the forward direction. It's purely a statistical phenomenon at larger scales, and attributable to being "next to an influential event", according to him.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZsmyTE3j9o

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by photochemsyn on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:16PM (#35202315)
It's difficult to see how such a hypothesis could be tested either experimentally or observationally. Sounds more like metaphysics?

Stars shine until they run out of fuel, and the age of a star - the status of its fuel, the buildup of fusion products - happens as time passes. Life on planets taps into the flow of sunlight from the star (and/or the flow of heat and chemical energy from the a hot planetary core) to generate complex structures in defiance of the regular direction of entropy (not violating conservation of energy, though). So... life reverses the arrow of time?

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by prerok on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:29PM (#35202471)
Well, of course not :) Entropy as direction of time just means that the chaos on the whole increases. So, to create an ordered structure, like a cell organism, the by-product is more chaos around it.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by ashirviskas on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:32PM (#35202534)
To add, life just speeds up the chaos by orders of magnitude, it's a perfect entropy catalyst.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by kergonath on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:40PM (#35203844)
I’d be shocked if that were the case, even only considering the Earth. The oceans and the atmosphere are full of entropy. So is the liquid outer core. And even if the mantle is not quite liquid, and even if the crust is mostly solid, these are huge in terms of volume and mass, much larger than the sliver of dirt we inhabit on top of them. So yeah, I really doubt we (collectively, all human beings) are changing the Earth’s entropy in any meaningful way.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by zone411 on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:47PM (#35203916)
Life reduces local entropy.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by lxgr on Friday March 17, 2023 @08:12PM (#35204607)
At the expense of increased global entropy, which I suppose is GPs point.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by zone411 on Friday March 17, 2023 @08:22PM (#35204669)
"there is 10 million times more entropy in that radiation [cosmic microwave radiation] than there is in all of the mass of the universe"

https://news.berkeley.edu/2016/09/20/new-book-links-flow-of-...

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by TeMPOraL on Friday March 17, 2023 @09:50PM (#35205261)
But then, this is just entropy from a one-off event long ago. Meanwhile, life is an entropy producing reaction with a strong exponential factor.

To butcher an insightful quote by (IIRC) Hamming, any positive slope will eventually make up for y-intercept of a constant function.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by zone411 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @12:00AM (#35205940)
It underlines the idea that the entropy-time connection is pretty shaky though.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by prerok on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:33PM (#35202544)
I think that the real question is whether the death of the universe by cool down will happen before the arrow of time is reversed. To me it seems more like it will just slow down and then finally stop.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by SirYandi on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:21PM (#35203657)
Or if there ever is a "big crunch" where all black holes crunch together to a critical mass, would there be another big bang and time then run backwards?
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by DubiousPusher on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:58PM (#35204014)
The hypothesis I have encountered is that time would reverse when the expansion of the universe peaked and started to collapse back in on itself. The next big bang would start another run of our universe. I'm guessing the randomness in quantum fluctuations would allow this next run to evolve somewhat differently from the one we are experiencing.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by K0balt on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:13PM (#35203589)
I think that one thing to keep in mind is that we are only capable of observing the passage of time along one vector because our perception relies upon entropic biological processes.

We cannot observe in any subset of possible universes where entropy is not present or is working backwards-Ergo those possibilities are wholly out of our direct perception.

That does not mean that causality cannot run in reverse, however, only that we cannot interact with those mechanisms in a way that would preclude our existence or observation.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by DubiousPusher on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:55PM (#35203984)
But could we observe the effects? Can there be particles which have mass and therefore exhibit gravitation but which are subject to reverse entropy? We would observe these for example as an unexplainable increase in gravitational pull on observable matter without an observable source of that gravitation and without a preceding cause.

Are photons themselves stratling this entropic boundary since they travel at the speed of light and within their own reference frame are not subject to the passage of time?

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by stametseater on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:24AM (#35208930)
Biology has nothing to do with it. We can't construct any manner of machine that measures time going in the other direction.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by postalrat on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:52AM (#35209134)
Maybe all that quantum nonsense we can't explain is due to some type of time travel we don't comprehend.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by lotsoweiners on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:18PM (#35211670)
If only we had Tony Stark to help build some sort of a “quantum GPS”.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Xelynega on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:02PM (#35213073)
Wouldn't questioning those pre-existing notions be the first step towards constructing such a machine? It sounds silly to dismiss the idea time could go backwards because we don't have any machines that work that way, since that typically how all ideas work before we implement them.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by tshaddox on Friday March 17, 2023 @07:03PM (#35204059)
> It's difficult to see how such a hypothesis could be tested either experimentally or observationally. Sounds more like metaphysics?

Sure, but some claims which cannot be tested experimentally or observationally are nonetheless important. For example, the claim “it’s important that scientific hypotheses be tested experimentally or observationally.”

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by lxgr on Friday March 17, 2023 @08:10PM (#35204589)
While I agree that not everything in science can be tested experimentally or observationally, arguably this one can:

Models created using both empirical experimentation and logical reasoning match reality much better than those based on "pure logics" (if that even is possible).

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by xwolfi on Friday March 17, 2023 @08:00PM (#35204526)
Alain Aspect tested it with his delayed choice quantum eraser, didnt he ? (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aspect%27s_experiment)

At least in France we take as fait accompli that causality is non trivial and that objects are non local at best: either you can consider objects as one despite immense distance between them, or you accept information passed between them in reverse time. Both are hard to swallow.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by kgwgk on Saturday March 18, 2023 @06:42AM (#35207902)
No, he didn’t. The “delayed choice quantum eraser” is something else - and it’s not about the flow of time either.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Rury on Friday March 17, 2023 @10:37PM (#35205508)
> Life on planets taps into the flow of sunlight from the star (and/or the flow of heat and chemical energy from the a hot planetary core) to generate complex structures in defiance of the regular direction of entropy

It doesn't defy the direction of entropy. Frankly, I'm not sure why you have that notion? Entropy is a measure of system's state of equilibrium. Moving energy from a concentrated source, and distributing it more equally (across life forms and other complex structures), is following the direction of entropy, as is it makes energy more equalized, in contrast to the former state where energy levels are unequal between highly concentrated areas (like stars), and areas without energy.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by coderenegade on Friday March 17, 2023 @11:39PM (#35205807)
Entropy only increases on average. You can decrease it locally, for example, making steel from iron ore. You generate heat, so you still get a net increase, but you could easily redefine your boundary to only include the local decrease in entropy (the steel from ore).
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Rury on Saturday March 18, 2023 @08:07PM (#35214531)
Yes, but like you said, that requires re-drawing your boundaries. It doesn't really defy the direction of entropy, it only appears that way from having changed scope.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by fdsafsd34 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @07:58PM (#35214469)
"Sounds more like metaphysics?"

The regular arrow of time from the human perspective, "leaks" changes into the future. The future is constantly being changed by the past.

You can measure those changes by many ways, the 2nd. law of thermodynamics is everywhere just to make sure you see this happening across everything.

So, probably there are other non-discovered underlying mechanisms in the reality that are already signaling changes from the future "leaking" into the past, changing the past right infront of us, without us noticing it.

A probably omnipresent mechanism for observing the future changing the past, valid in the whole cone of light visible to us, is the probability law.

If you have 10 millions of possible events in a probability, one of them is the exact thing it will happen in the future, hence the information of what happens in the future is right here, existing in the past.

Yeah, you can say how would the nature could use this information without powerful processors predicting branches trillions of times per second on Earth right now?

Well, the brain is a pattern predictor, quite several parts of the brain are firmly attached to the physics of the universe, biochemically but what if the pattern prediction mechanisms in the brain are actually an adaptation of the evolution, just like wings to fly, but with those mechanisms the brain uses probability to "see" information from the future, and here in the "present", it changes the past (from the perspective of the future created originally from the past), if the brain "chooses now" to do something different that what originally created the future it "saw" by analizing patterns, essentially evaluating probabilities.

So the Probability Law would be a kind of Inverted 2nd. Law of Thermodynamics.

It would work perfectly as law of the universe: from the future to the past, the revered time of arrow, one single event created "a" future, but from the regular arrow of time, there would a range of probable future outcomes which you cannot precisely say it has "1" (100%) probability of ocurring, right to exact moment till the future becomes the present.

And it was right there all the time, something obvious infront of everybody in the world, like electricity (which was suspected by many across thousands of years, but just "discovered" recently).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_total_probability

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by psychphysic on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:30PM (#35202488)
I don't think Carroll can take credit for the idea of the arrow of time being emergent from a local entropy initial state.

Roger Penrose proposed that as far as I know, when Carroll was probably a high schooler.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by platz on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:45PM (#35202675)
who's taking "credit"
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by mellosouls on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:00PM (#35202847)
Roger Penrose proposed that as far as I know, when Carroll was probably a high schooler.

No. At least as early as Arthur Eddington when Penrose was a twinkle in his dad's eye.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by psychphysic on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:36AM (#35207601)
Thanks didn't know he'd made that argument although I knew he made the connection between entropy increasing and arrow of time.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by yeahwhatever10 on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:00PM (#35202851)
Explaining an idea is not equivalent to taking credit for it.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by psychphysic on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:03PM (#35202875)
> Carroll's argument

This assigns credit to Carroll.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Jcowell on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:09PM (#35202940)
It merely says that Carrol argued. The idea within the argument was no means assigned to her but used to make/support it.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by psychphysic on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:35AM (#35207593)
Sean Carroll is a man, and look up the possessive apostrophe while you're at it!
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by zone411 on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:49PM (#35203937)
This idea of time's relation to entropy is pretty iffy. I recommend this book https://news.berkeley.edu/2016/09/20/new-book-links-flow-of-....
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by klipt on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:22PM (#35203087)
Right, entropy can decrease, just with low probability, which you can calculate using the Fluctuation Theorem: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluctuation_theorem

Perhaps given infinite time, we will randomly get back to a low entropy state infinite times, but I don't know enough about the math to say for sure.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by ben_w on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:25PM (#35203695)
You can, but that inevitably leads to far more Boltzman brains than things like the universe, and that's disastrous because then you should expect to be a Boltzman brain yourself, but they're configured randomly so if you are a Boltzman brain you can't trust any belief you have about reality including the maths that says you should be a Boltzman brain.

It's basically a softer version of Russell's paradox but for cognition and reality.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by mjrpes on Saturday March 18, 2023 @04:12PM (#35212668)
Carroll did a great solo podcast about this last year: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B40PRvLtiec

Hard to summarize, but it's well worth anyone interested in this topic. There's a good bit where he ties the sleeping beauty thought experiment with Boltzmann Brains and consciousness; it blew my mind trying to understand the whole thing.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by kiicia on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:40AM (#35216105)
Infinite time is too much of a “get out from jail” card, because during infinite time anything and everything will happen by definition
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by Viliam1234 on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:31PM (#35223875)
I don't have a problem with "time" meaning "away from the local Big Bang". But that does not imply that future causes the past.

Just like noticing that "down" actually means "towards the center of the local planet" did not make water suddenly flow uphill.