News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by ben_w on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:33PM (#35203783)
> I know it sounds hard to believe, but if you're willing to bite the bullet that "the center of the universe" has no physical meaning, then earth can't be not the center of the universe any more than it can be.

I disagree.

The sentence «"the center of the universe" has no physical meaning» requires that Earth can't be at the center of the universe, because there isn't a center for it to be at.

You're still allowed any or many arbitrary zero-points, but that's only the center of a number line, nothing else.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by whatshisface on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:46PM (#35203903)
It's basically a semantic issue but I don't think the negation of an undefined proposition is true, I think it is undefined. (Thankfully the universe does not run in JavaScript, where !undefined is true.)
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by ben_w on Friday March 17, 2023 @07:02PM (#35204043)
That I agree with.

But, Earth.x = 42 (in some arbitrary coordinate space), if I understand correctly there isn't a sub-light coordinate space in this universe where Earth.x = undefined.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by whatshisface on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:28PM (#35211762)
Positions are defined, but they're different in every coordinate system, which makes "the center of the universe," by itself, undefined.
Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by ben_w on Saturday March 18, 2023 @04:38PM (#35212874)
That's not the reason why the centre of the universe is undefined.

By analogy, while spherical coordinates are arbitrary, latitude is defined. Arbitrary, but defined.

But the centre of the Earth has an undefined latitude, and a topological subspace consisting of just the surface of the Earth can't hand-wave past that by pointing out that's just a coordinate singularity that can be safely ignored — there isn't a center of the Earth anywhere in that subspace.

And the universe might be infinite, which has a different problem because you can't properly define a median of an infinite set[0], so no center exists.

[0] I think. Infinity is easy to get messed up with.

Re:A Growing Number of Scientists Are Convinced the Future I... by rbanffy on Monday March 20, 2023 @05:30PM (#35239062)
> That's not the reason why the centre of the universe is undefined.

Be patient. It hasn't been evaluated just yet.