August 2004:
Orange Juice Concentrate Futures $61
Google $85/share
Now:
Orange Juice Concentrate Futures $211
Google $576/share
211/61 ~= 3.45
85*4.27 ~= 293.25But even more than that, compare it to stock market indices. We're talking about how the market valued it, not about currency valuations. The whole argument about currency valuations is a silly sideshow.
In conclusion, if nobody understands the brilliance of your argument, it's probably stupid.
What they didn't understand (what I said they didn't understand) was that I tried to determine value of the USD, not compare price of the gold to price to the shares.
Almost everyone pulled out some stupid comparison, trying to be funny. The Ron Paul, Apple and Juice comments looked like they came here from reddit. Only few comments were actually valuable and tried to correct me in a non-condescending way.
Anyway, after some more reading around I came to conclusion that valuing USD by gold is indeed not the right idea. I was somehow convinced that gold is something stable. From what I found, the difference between 2004 and 2012 dollars is inly something above 25%.
Since 2009 gold has tripled in dollar value [1]. That does not mean that the dollar has lost a third of its value.
What your figures show:
--- August 2004: Gold $405 Google $85/share
Now: Gold $1735 Google $576/share --- Is this: Gold: 1735/405 ~= 4.28 GOOG: 576/85 =~ 6.77
GOOG/Gold: 6.77/4.3 = 1.57
Google have given their shareholders a value worth 57% more than gold.
If you instead had kept your $85 in your pocket since 2004, how many dollars would have today?
[1] http://goldprice.org/NewCharts/gold/images/gold_5_year_o_s_u...
August 2004:
AAPL $16
Google $85/share (thought it was $100/share, huh)
Now:
AAPL $447
Google $576/share
447/16 ~= 27.94
85*27.94 ~= 2374.90
So no, Google's shares are not worth 5 times more. Their value went down a massive amount in six years.
Comparing one asset (share of GOOG) vs. another, namely, gold is silly when you contrast to assigning currency value.
Last I checked, food hasn't become 4x more expensive, so things still revolve around currency (or currencies), not the value of gold.
According to the IMF Commodity Price Index, at least. http://www.imf.org/external/np/res/commod/index.aspx
http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/07/big-mac-in...
I know nothing of valuation, but by that logic the price of gold would never be worth more.. than.. the price of gold?
I thought you'd value the gain in the market currency, aka dollars. No?
Remember there are three functions of money
1) Unit of account 2) Medium of exchange 3) Store of value
Currency is not a good store of value - it can be printed at will. It does store value over a short time frame but if you were given a box from 1930 that inside held somones life savings from 1930 - would you wish it to be in USDs or gold? Hint: USDs is the wrong answer! Currency is an excellent medium of exchange. You can buy food at the supermarket with it. Just don't save your surplus wealth in it.
Gold is used as a store of value instead of orange juice concentrate since it has historical value, it is fungible, divisible and inert (ie: it won't spoil). Also you are not impinging on the economy by hoarding it as a store of value since it has relatively little utility otherwise.
If you think gold is not valuable because you cannot excahnge it for food, then ask yourself why the US Government banned its ownership in 1933 for citizens and why the Euro has it as its number one asset on its consolidated financial statement - above all currencies - including USD http://www.ecb.int/press/pr/wfs/2011/html/fs110706.en.html
August 2004:
Gold $405
Google $85/share (thought it was $100/share, huh)
Now:
Gold $1735
Google $576/share
1735/405 ~= 4.27
85*4.27 ~= 364
So no, Google's shares are not worth 5 times more. They value went up some 50% in six years, which is great but nothing scary.