Because (potentially) stealing $6 million is still a very large crime in the absolute sense, even if it is smaller than other related crimes. Because it would be bad to alert white-collar criminals to the fact that they can escape prosecution by not being the largest participant in the criminal enterprise. Because $6 million is roughly 1000x larger (not a typo) than the typical bank robbery, which carries a 20-year sentence, and we don't advocate for non-prosecution of $500 bank robberies. Because it's only fair in a justice system that routinely imprisons people for stealing much smaller amounts.
As things stand today, she could be sentenced to 110 years for what she's already pled to; she's really got to make the prosecutors happy if she ever wants to live outside again.
Edit: One such article for illustrative purposes: https://www.popehat.com/2013/02/05/crime-whale-sushi-sentenc... . In this case, the news-headline number is "up to 77 years" and the plausible range Popehat calculates is 2-2.5 years.
She's pled to a set of felonies that each carry stiff penalties. A judge would apparently be within the law and federal guidelines to decide that an appropriate sentence is somewhere between the sentence for any one of the charges and below the sentence for running all the sentences consecutively. It's really easy to get sentencing guidelines to arrive at over 100 years for multiple felonies, if you stipulate consecutive sentences.
One notable exception to the typical kid-gloves treatment of financial crime syndicates was Bernie Madoff, who was sentenced to 150 years, the top of the sentencing guidelines.
The DoJ doesn't typically claim as far as I know that they will stop prosecution in other countries.
I wouldn't call ~20 years into the _future_ "already done". But definitely think long and hard about any agreements you sign in an adversarial situation.
TBH, the guys not even an American so I don't think he really has a right to stay in the country after his sentence is over.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Le_Roux#Trial_of_Le_Roux
Allow Caroline to testify in exchange for lenience. Share that... so that at some point in the future she can be extradited. All good now! As far as I can tell your criticism has no practical bearing on achieving these ends.
Or you might want to be confessing to a country you're a resident of so that you have actual standing to oppose being extradited.
Maybe there is some way she can avoid extradition from the US, I'm not sure, but I have a feeling such a greedy soul could be lured to some other country in promise of riches only to be escorted by men with badges for a nice cruise for a Caribbean vacation.
While SBF received much more, I wonder how much in total benefits everyone received. The penthouse, private jets, and vacations probably add up quick.
I was respond to:
> While SBF received much more, I wonder how much in total benefits everyone received. The penthouse, private jets, and vacations probably add up quick.
They don't add up quick. Not in any meaningful sense.
She fully deserves to go to jail for a long time, but probably won't since she was smart enough to get the early worm in terms of deals with the prosecution.
I'd argue that it's worse in corrupt organizations. Sometimes much worse.
Because when the feds go after her, she is strongly incentivized to flip, and cooperate in kicking the stool out from under SBF.
And because 6 million is big enough of a fraud that you can do a decade for it in Club Fed all on its own. If that were the only fraud that took place with FTX, she'd still deserve to be fully investigated and prosecuted for it.
Related to this is an interesting piece from Freakonomics[1] about drug gangs. They claim wealth inequality existing in corrupt organizations like drug gangs is a necessity.
[1] https://genius.com/Steven-levitt-the-freakonomics-of-mcdonal...
In the first Freakinomics book you learn that they once had found the accounting of a major drug cartel in NYC and the wage distribution from shoofer (?) on the street to the refiller, the dealer, the neighborhood lord, all the way to the top manager… was the same as at McDonald’s.
Feels like none of those laws helped, we’re stuck with a “natural distribution”.
Because it is still a crime and it would signal other criminals that they can be part of billion dollar scams, make 10s of millions and not be charged of fraud.
SBF running off with $2.2B really makes Caroline's $6m look quaint. I mean, why even go after her for (relative) pennies? The compensation gap between SBF and his underlings just goes to show you that wealth inequality exists even in corrupt organizations. Her charges will be far less, but it goes to show you that even in crime you're being stiffed unless you're at the absolute top of the food chain.