News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by senthil_rajasek on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:22PM (#35171682)
I found this article very shallow. It covers only spyware that are installed when a device is physically compromised.

I was hoping it would cover spy/malware that install remotely through many more infection vectors like clicking text messages. I guess NSO/Pegasus malware has this capability.

I barely use any apps and would gladly settle for a flip phone... I value privacy more than the ability to order food through my phone.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by TheRealDunkirk on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:51PM (#35172119)
> I value privacy more than the ability to order food through my phone.

I know you didn't mean it like this, but I find it funny that it reads like we've abandoned the idea of calling a restaurant and just talking to a person to order takeaway.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by walterbell on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:59PM (#35172230)
> talking to a person to order takeaway

Also supports small business by saving them double-digit app fees!

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by Jeremy1026 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:18PM (#35172471)
Not necessarily. The delivery apps set up proxy numbers to pass calls through, taking a lead fee. So you can't just search "sub shop near me" and call, as it might not be their actual phone number. Your best bet if you want to save the local place fees from the apps is walk in the first time, then call the number off the paper menu from then on.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by xeromal on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:56PM (#35173858)
If they have a website, that's usually a good number too
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by walterbell on Monday March 20, 2023 @06:48AM (#35229730)
PiTM (Parasite in The Middle)
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by scarface74 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:53PM (#35173016)
I know a couple of small restaurant owners. Even ones that don’t go through UberEats or GrubHub that use SaaS restaurant software that also come with a white labeled restaurant specific app that accepts Apple Pay (standard credit card fees - not 30%) and other payment methods. They actually prefer it.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by SoftTalker on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:58PM (#35173097)
Weird. The small places here (I'm thinking chinese take-out, for example) take cash only, order tickets are on paper, they don't deliver, and seem to be thriving. Have the Uber Eats and other tech middlemen started taking such a big slice of the profit that it's not worth it?

Having worked in a restaurant, if someone took 30% of my gross it certainly would have been all of my profit and then some.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by walterbell on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:11PM (#35173266)
NYC currently caps fees at 20%. Grubhub is lobbying for 30%.

https://www.restaurantbusinessonline.com/technology/nyc-coul...

> New York, like many cities, put a limit on third-party delivery fees during the pandemic to help restaurants that had come to depend heavily on the service. Last August, it became one of the few jurisdictions to make the emergency measure permanent ... Last year, it passed a first-of-its kind law that would force delivery providers to share more customer data with restaurants.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by scarface74 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @05:59PM (#35175318)
I just said the opposite. Restaurants apps do not pay 30% even when going through the App Store. It’s a physical good and even if they do except Apple Pay, they get charged standard credit card processing fees - $0.25 + 2-3% of the amount.

I said they do not use GrubHub. They have their own system run as SaaS. The company they use takes care of the POS system, merchant accounts, and a white labeled app just for their store.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by walterbell on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:19PM (#35175506)
Are customers willing to download a new app for each restaurant?

Does the SaaS/POS company let customers use one app and "install/subscribe" to each restaurant as needed?

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by scarface74 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:42PM (#35175718)
They also offer a white labeled website. Once you have a website, creating an “app” that’s just a web view that provides notifications for delivery and or when your table is ready is relatively easy. Of course it’s more about branding than anything else. They can also just send text messages
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by Schroedingersat on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:52PM (#35175806)
Middleman feudal tax garbage always seems great at first.

In an abusive relationship that part is called the honeymoon period. The goals, the mindset of the perpetrator, and the end results are the same.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by scarface74 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @07:15PM (#35175994)
What feudal tax? The SaaS system that provides servicing and support for the point of sales system, merchant accounts, online ordering, designs web pages, and optional apps, optional hardware for pagers when someone’s table is ready or a text messaging notification system?

Or are you referring to the app in the Apple Store that optionally supports Apple Pay (not in app purchasing) where the merchant is charged the standard credit card processing fee - $0.25 + 2-3% of the price?

Would it be better if the person running the restaurant had to do all that themselves?

I’ve seen a mom and pop pizza shop that had all of the technology of a papa Johns thanks to all of the SaaS offerings available

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by walterbell on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @07:28PM (#35176103)
Hopefully white label SaaS will grow their marketshare - any estimates on annual revenue for that sector?

Revenue for the major US delivery apps is currently in the billions, with feudal taxes.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by scarface74 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @07:50PM (#35176298)
The difference is that GrubHub has high fixed costs and high variable costs for drivers. A SaaS model has fixed costs for developers, sales, support etc. But marginal costs to add new customers is minimal.

Revenue may be in the billions. But they are all losing money. The smaller companies can easily be “lifestyle businesses” that hire in low cost of living areas and go after “enterprise devs” who are very happy to make $135k - $165K and don’t expect “equity”.

I spent most of my entire career as an “enterprise dev” working with SaaS companies in the bill payment space, field services, and health care.

I’m in $BigTech now working in the cloud consulting department working with a lot of the same types of companies.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by handedness on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:47PM (#35172908)
Many restaurant managers already have: I'm increasingly finding places won't allow phone orders, at least during peak hours.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by SoftTalker on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:56PM (#35173069)
So call the places that do. This is called free market competition.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by msm_ on Friday March 17, 2023 @12:12PM (#35199025)
But why? Ordering via app is more convenient, and the restaurants clearly don't mind fees.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:39PM (#35174399)
<< just talking to a person to order takeaway.

The sad thing is that even if you do that, the restaurants are now almost guaranteed to use your phone as unique identifier and use that data for, hopefully, their own purposes ( hopefully, because the lure of selling data might be too much ).

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by walterbell on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @07:30PM (#35176127)
It's good privacy practice to use cheap and disposable VOIP numbers for online/phone shopping, changed periodically.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by sizzle on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:57PM (#35172204)
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by Liquix on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:01PM (#35172261)
I was hoping it would raise the alarm regarding Google and Apple's overreaching, always-on data collection practices. 99% of people don't need to worry about an attacker gaining physical access to their unlocked device and installing an application. We as a society do need to worry about tech giants amassing enough data on us to gain an insurmountable AI-training-data advantage which makes them too useful as tools of the state to be regulated by said state.

The irony of pointing out how to spot a "spyware" app disguised as a WiFi icon when the dozen Big G apps pictured alongside are collecting the same data...

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by YeahNO on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:59PM (#35173112)
You would think the panic over TikTok spying would illuminate the problem with apps having carte-blanche access to your personal data 24/7. There is nothing that the TikTok app does that any other app cannot also do. It seems nobody wants to make that connection.

There should be real protections for consumers to prevent ANY application from slurping up this data, and I don't mean just a disclosure or system setting to hamstring the application into uselessness. I mean, there should be regulations preventing the collection of this data in the first place, with hefty fines and punitive damages.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by eternityforest on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:34PM (#35173558)
Most privacy advocates probably do plenty of things I would be perfectly happy to see made illegal, but we don't just ban them because we don't want a complete dictatorship of one segment of the population over everyone else, and because it seems the people realize it would cause problems for some people.

A lot of the tech I imagine you are referring to has been life changing for me, and if it cost normal SASS prices would not be affordable.

Regulations and disclosures are good, but a straight ban would (depending on how it was written) quite likely affect services that inherently require mass data collection, like Tile trackers, and might make other services have to do subscriptions and become unaffordable for many.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by nichohel on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:09PM (#35174040)
What do you mean by "Most privacy advocates probably do plenty of things I would be perfectly happy to see made illegal"? Can you give some examples of what you mean by things you want to see made illegal?
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by 867-5309 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:54PM (#35174578)
eating meat, burning coal, owning pets, paying taxes, cycling, sunbathing, crochet, wearing crocks with socks, shitposting..
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by hb0ss on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:01PM (#35175349)
Cycling… says the corn syrup addicted American
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by 867-5309 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @07:18PM (#35176021)
they probably would!
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:37PM (#35174377)
<< A lot of the tech I imagine you are referring to has been life changing for me, and if it cost normal SASS prices would not be affordable.

I think part of the issue is that it is too affordable. The whole free content, free email, free infrastructure got us into current mess to begin with and since advertising was the only place that paid, now it is a part of the landscape. But on that front, pendulum may be swinging the other way.

And privacy itself is one of those terms that can easily led into a very broad discussion unless it is not clearly defined from the outset.

<< we need to be careful to find suitable replacements before we ban things.

Nah, as a society we were very permissive for the past two decades at least. It is time for tech to grow up and join the rest of the mature industries.

<< But at the moment, the FOSS community does not have true equivalents,

Sadly true. I am currently on Pine ( postmarketos ) since my main phone died. I absolutely love the idea and I keep trying to support it when I have a chance, but it is still not ready for prime time ( and I am not good enough to contribute in code ).

<< and the non-spy commercial solutions have many of the same issues and cost too much for low income people.

And this is why spying - ekh, totally voluntary data collection - should just be verbotten. We have seen where this road leads and it is not fun long term.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by eternityforest on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:10PM (#35175423)
Well, I sure don't ever want to losing half my day to forgetting things, being constantly lost, and losing my keys and wallet constantly.

As far as effects on me, getting rid of modern tech would already be getting close to the authoritarian nightmare they talk about, far more than basically any of the laws other people complain about.

If the effects are harmful enough to regulate, it's the same kind of conversation as cigarettes and gas engines and a million other things that we put varying levels of restrictions on but don't ban.

Going after spy tech with more force than we go after everything else just seems like government enforced luddism.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Thursday March 16, 2023 @03:07AM (#35179068)
<< Going after spy tech with more force than we go after everything else just seems like government enforced luddism.

You do have a point especially if I examine my thoughts on cigarettes, alcohol and so on to determine what makes spy tech more of a target in my life. I think the difference is that even without regulations and restrictions, I can escape both cigarettes, gas engines and so on if I so choose.

With spy tech, even if I take just about every step there is to take, even full blown luddism does not get me the world that was. These days, being a private person takes real money ( vide FB Zuckerberg buying property to ensure privacy on his real estate ).

You do have a point nonetheless, which brings me to this: what is an acceptable restriction on it to you?

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by eternityforest on Thursday March 16, 2023 @12:49PM (#35184587)
I'm not actually sure what the "maximum viable policy" would be for me. While privacy is a right, so is free speech and observation. Even something like "You can't spy whatsoever without consent" goes too far, because CCTV cameras are important, and legalizing secret recordings could deter many kinds of abuse.

One thing that definitely seems uncontroversial is protection for spaces that have an expectation of privacy. Obviously no democratic state has any business allowing AirBNB bathroom cameras, since basically nobody aside from criminals wants that to exist, and by extension any space that specifically claims to be private should have the same protection.

Requiring a "Facebook moderators may access these chat logs under some conditions" notice at the beginning of everything someone might otherwise think was private seems reasonable.

What I have more of an issue with is defining new spaces with that expectation.

The government should probably have stricter rules than everyone else on privacy, since they are the main group who both can and possibly might want to actually make use of data to harm an average person.

Digital search warrants and subpoenas have solved real problems, so I wouldn't want to get rid of those entirely, but there could be a central logging facility where you can get access to any data they have on you, get notified instantly (Or within a time limit that expires if you are arrested, if there's a need to temporarily seal it to prevent tipping off a murderer) of any new accesses, and appeal the decision that allowed them to access it, so they can't just rubber stamp give it to everyone without any transparency.

Encryption should be permanently made a right, along with anonymity networks like Tor, and Cryptocurrency in general(Although maybe not proof of work, and I sure wouldn't want to become an everyday thing we all have to deal with).

The big problem with spying is that it's just observing people and telling others what you saw, you can't fully eliminate spying without eliminating an important part of free speech.

In general, the GDPR seems to get things mostly right, but I still think the best solution is actually having private alternatives people actually would use by choice, and making sure those are legally protected.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by JohnFen on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @05:40PM (#35175110)
Most privacy advocates I know revolve around the concept of "informed consent". The idea isn't to ban technologies because they can be abused, it's to stop the abuse.

The guiding principle for when that line is crossed is whether or not the affected person was completely and accurately informed about what is going to happen, and that they have affirmatively given their consent for it to happen.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by eternityforest on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:15PM (#35175464)
The GDPR goes a little farther than that though, because it makes consent revokable even after the fact, and disallows consent as a requirement to access a service, and some privacy advocates seem to think that's still not enough.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by JohnFen on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:28PM (#35175600)
The ability to revoke consent is an essential part of consent, in my view.

> some privacy advocates seem to think that's still not enough.

I am one of them. I think the GDPR is inadequate in many ways, but it's certainly a huge improvement over the nothing that existed prior, and it's much better than anything we have here in the US.

But the things I think are inadequate about the GDPR still revolve around consent. I will admit that "consent" is a very broad term, though, and includes a whole lot of intricacies and nuances. It's a bit like "freedom" in that sense.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by eternityforest on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @08:23PM (#35176554)
I guess it depends on how you view personal data.

To me, it's just like any other data, licensing it to someone is no different than licensing the source code to something you wrote, if it's revokable the whole concept doesn't make sense, and you don't really own it so much as it's held in trust by the state.

But it seems like some people see it as something really personal and special that inherently shouldn't be treated like any other commercial asset, (Possibly because they've got more interesting lives than mine!) and there doesn't seem to be any compromise that doesn't make someone unhappy.

Revocability does make a lot of sense and I can think of a lot of very good use cases for that right, but also some ways it impairs P2P.

I think the only real solution is for private tech to achieve real parity with nonprivate tech, at least as much as is possible (Tech is almost never private compared to no tech at all, it can always be hacked), but I have no idea how that would be possible.

Technically it could happen, socially FOSS devs would rather work on minimalist stuff.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by specialist on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @09:55PM (#35177207)
What's your position on the right to privacy?
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by labster on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:34PM (#35177480)
The right to privacy is alienable, like the right to party; it must be fought for.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by specialist on Thursday March 16, 2023 @12:28PM (#35184238)
Like indentured servitude?
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by eternityforest on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:19PM (#35177738)
It's a basic human right, same as right to free speech. Encryption and anonymity technology should be strongly protected and respected, and I support most of what the GDPR is doing.

It's just completely banning the choice to use nonprivate services I have an issue with.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by Shish2k on Thursday March 16, 2023 @06:01AM (#35180017)
> To me, it's just like any other data, licensing it to someone is no different than licensing the source code to something you wrote, if it's revokable the whole concept doesn't make sense, and you don't really own it so much as it's held in trust by the state.

We live in a world where “buy this movie” on a streaming site gives you no kind of ownership, merely a temporary license to rent the data until the company decides they don’t want you to have it any more - treating personal data the same way doesn’t seem bad by comparison...

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by JohnFen on Thursday March 16, 2023 @11:12AM (#35182994)
> To me, it's just like any other data, licensing it to someone is no different than licensing the source code to something you wrote

I agree with this. It's your data, you're free to license it out in any way you choose.

> if it's revokable the whole concept doesn't make sense, and you don't really own it so much as it's held in trust by the state.

I don't understand this. How does your ability to revoke a license you've issued mean that it's held in trust by the state? Revocability underscores that you own the data and can control what happens to it in the future.

By the way, almost all licenses are revocable.

> But it seems like some people see it as something really personal and special that inherently shouldn't be treated like any other commercial asset,

And those people aren't wrong. They're exerting their rightful control over their data as they see fit. If I choose to license my data out, I am also exerting my rightful control over my data as I see fit. There is no contradiction here -- in both cases, it's about consent.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by fsflover on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:05PM (#35173180)
> I was hoping it would raise the alarm regarding Google and Apple's overreaching, always-on data collection practices

It seems this is the article you were expecting: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26639261.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by brutusurp on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @07:18PM (#35176023)
Oh, maybe I can give it a shot. I'll be sure to include Amazon as well.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @09:35PM (#35177082)
https://github.com/M66B/NetGuard

Works against the Big G apps. One can block every app and service by default, only letting selected ones connect to the internet. More importantly one can log every attmpted connection, observing the log in real-time, as well as saving lists of domain names or PCAP files.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by chaxor on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:50PM (#35172975)
Most spyware is installed by the user themselves. It's typically called "security software" from your company, or the VPN they provide (which also includes additional software that backdoors your entire device).
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by Antiks99 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @09:16PM (#35176955)
Most spyware is rolled into Windows, Android and Apple.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by fossuser on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:55PM (#35173056)
Apple has “Advanced Data Protection” that you can enable

This was built after the NSO group hacks to lock down the device to be resilient to nation state attacks.

It limits some of the attack vectors you’re taking about (with a tradeoff of also limiting some features).

Apple also enabled true e2ee in the cloud where only you retain the keys.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by irobeth on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:36PM (#35174373)
> Apple also enabled true e2ee in the cloud where only you retain the keys.

Is there a procedure to realistically verify that your communications are e2e and not e2mitm2e ?

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by walterbell on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @07:31PM (#35176140)
Canary content for your threat-modeled attacker, then monitor for the data being acted upon, e.g. traffic to non-public URL.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by chaxor on Thursday March 16, 2023 @06:27AM (#35180154)
All of it is a bit silly to trust companies with things like this when there are standard techniques which have stood the test of time and are *far* simpler - tar.zst.gpg or squash.gpg, luks-encrypted qemu images, etc. Things done locally are just inherently better, because it's far simpler tech, and you actually know what's happening rather than just blindly trusting some sketchy company.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by humanistbot on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:11PM (#35173273)
A university PR office puts out a press release that is shallow version of the actual paper? Why I never....
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by AtlasBarfed on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:24PM (#35173429)
Oh here, let me run it down real quick. You don't even need to be an expert.

Tracking cookies, browser fingerprinting, and ISP-level monitoring logs everything you do.

Various consumer database warehouses hoover up the data for resale/targetting by ad companies

Hint: once a business has it, at a minimum the FBI/CIA/Government has it. Likely, they've been hacked by China and Russia too.

In addition, the CIA/FBI run ISP-level and DC-level monitoring/hoovering.

Finally, there is no oversight. Either the FBI will cookie cutter whatever request they need after the fact to the rubber-stamp-anyway kangaroo oversight "Court", or they won't even bother. The CIA doesn't even need to care. The only limitation of widespread abuse is some sense of patriotism in the CIA/FBI, and of course that is pretty simple to frame/justify as needed.

The bottom line is that there is a 100% turnkey total information awareness infrastructure for any authoritarian regime that takes over the US government (see: Iraq war, false flag attacks, McCarthyism, etc). They know everyone you communicate with, your political views, your buying habits, and they will soon have AI software to maximize usitlization of the firehose for profiling, reeducation camps / gulags, and the like. The US government can deny you civil rights by declaring a US citizen an enemy combatant, and are more than willing to setup concentration camps for immigrants, and therefore "terrorists".

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by barrysteve on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:13PM (#35174098)
God's all-seeing presence is a preservative against sin and a means to make you watchful over all your ways and actions. - Thomas Gouge

It was always the intent to make sight of citizens completely transparent.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by BenFranklin100 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:20PM (#35174193)
Exactly three years ago I would have laughed at you, but three years of COVID has taught me that the powers that be in our society — which include journalists, academics and moderators of online forums — will happily help tear down essential liberties for perceived, small, and temporary safeties.

The abuses stemming from a lack of privacy have not been realized because of political convictions, but because of technical limitations. The advent of advanced AI models will remove many of these technical limitations and allow corporations and governments to quickly build detailed profiles of every citizen that touches the internet.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by AtlasBarfed on Thursday March 16, 2023 @11:59AM (#35183684)
It is interesting how this is something people only "wake up" to now on a generational basis. Obviously the government wants this to happen, each generations' specific communication modes are presented as "safe" but in reality each generations' social network apps du jour is a new opportunity for even better "total information awareness".

This has been apparent since "Carnivore" was revealed to not be a conspiracy theory, but an actual system in THE LATE NINETIES, and ECHELON since the 1960s. And since then I would roughly say computing power is 20-40x more powerful (5x the gigahertz, 8x the cores), and storage is probably 1000x more scalable (40GB/280$ vs 14TB/200$).

I have no idea how old you are, but three years ago, heck that is well past the point you should have been aware of this. Look:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A

That was revealed in 2006. Basically, the crux of it was that there were "secret rooms" like that in EVERY SINGLE telco. Well, except apparently Qwest, which blew my mind at the time because they were the worst regional telco of them all, so the fact they stood their ground was a total anomaly in their usual monopoly extraction sociopathy.

One big sign of this is Tiktok. Tiktok is an attempt by the Chinese to subvert the normal monopoly the FBI has with social networks, since the US/EU governments are working with US/EU companies for facebook, twitter, etc. But Tiktok is Chinese.

So Tiktok looks like just another social network to a typical social network junkie, but then you read all these headlines where congress and the EU wants to ban it, seemingly strangely up in arms over just another video social network, and .... that's because the Chinese are doing what the US/EU have done for 25+years. The US government has ITS toys, and doesn't want the Chinese to take them.

That should clue you in to how much the government likes have total information access to social networks that are US/EU based.

A lot of this could be swallowed if the US exhibited healthy signs of a functioning democracy, instead it is another sign of an emerging postmodern totalitarian state. The last hope of this was our judicial branch, which has been so thoroughly compromised by 30 years of partisan nominations (read: pro-elite in all cases) and Iraq war case law that it will never go back.

I would stay quiet, but by the time I realized what was going on I had 10+ years of data on me. It doesn't matter anymore.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by tptacek on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:48PM (#35174503)
This is a standard university press-release style article about a paper accepted at PETS:

https://www.sysnet.ucsd.edu/~voelker/pubs/spyware-pets23.pdf

It's academic research, so this thread here expressing disappointment about the article is weird. We should probably just replace the press release with a link to the study itself.

From the abstract:

. In this work, we perform an in-depth technical analysis of 14 distinct leading mobile spyware apps targeting Android phones. We document the range of mechanisms used to monitor user activity of various kinds (e.g., photos, text messages, live microphone access) — primarily through the creative abuse of Android APIs. We also discover previously undocumented methods these apps use to hide from detection and to achieve persistence.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @05:10PM (#35174765)
Flip phones are available. SBF has been issued with one under his latest conditions of release.

Remember though, privacy comes at a cost. Thousands of parasitic "startups" that live off of VC, produce nothing for sale, have no profits and rely on surveillance to demonstrate speculative "value" might suffer or even "go out of business", "Big Tech" might not rake in billions per quarter for selling ad services, "jobs" might be lost. It could be catastrophic. The entire economy could crash. It could put a promised AI-driven utopian future at risk. All because of the desire to maintain privacy. This is not just another HN comment with a FUD or hype-based prediction with zero factual support. "We take privacy seriously." It's threat to what we do. As an "industry" it's vital that we maintain peoples' trust while we surveil them.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by teddyh on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:05PM (#35175376)
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by mjfl on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:31PM (#35175624)
It's because he was using sarcasm, which you failed to detect.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by teddyh on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:58PM (#35175856)
I probably failed because the quoted words were not actually quotes. I could understand a word like “value” being quoted sarcastically without a specific quote in mind, but the quoting of many other words and phrases were mystifying.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by marttt on Thursday March 16, 2023 @02:12AM (#35178739)
Try to replace OPs quotes with an appositive like so-called or so to say. "Big tech" = so-called Big Tech, "industry" = so-called industry etc. This way, the irony does make sense, especially when you read OPs earlier comments.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by teddyh on Thursday March 16, 2023 @02:40PM (#35186383)
Yes, I know how sarcasm quotes work. It just didn’t seem to fit all of them, like “go out of business”.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by marttt on Thursday March 16, 2023 @03:19PM (#35186930)
This seems like a sarcastic reference to "startup-speak": phrases that are somewhat overused by people from the startup industry. Corporate slang and a sign of belonging of sorts that might feel a little overblown for those outside the tech world.

I'm just a hobbyist geek, though, so I may heavily overinterpret things (and the OP) here. :)

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by salawat on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:06PM (#35175383)
> As an "industry" it's vital that we maintain peoples' trust while we surveil them.

Thanks. I puked a bit. Put a damn /s on that thing.

If it was not in jest, seek help. You aren't thinking properly.

Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by Antiks99 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @09:15PM (#35176945)
You really need a "/s" to detect sarcasm? What is it with people online these days? I hope this trend dies soon.
Re:What Happens When Your Phone Is Spying on You by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Thursday March 16, 2023 @03:36PM (#35187179)
"Business" is normally defined generally as sales and purchases made for profit.

What if a company has no profits.

What if a company's product or service is "free". Is that sales.

What if a company has sales, i.e., online advertising services, but in its communications with employees and the public it continually suggests its "business" is something else. Why would it do that.

In any event, there is a question IMO of whether a "tech" company is even "in business" if it can only ever pay its employees and other expenses with investment rounds. Is it possible to "go out of business" if the company was never "in business" (assuming we accept the usual definition of a business).

We already know how VC and "tech" companies would answer these questions. Anyone who questions what they are doing is always wrong. We know that. We have heard it before. But VC and "tech" companies do not have a history of being honest. There is a credibility issue.

This thread titled "What happens when your phone is spying on you" is about (free) "smartphone apps" that collect data about people below peoples' awareness, strategically avoiding the issue of consent. Why is this even happening. Did VC and "tech" companies have anything to do with it. No, of course not. Performing such hidden data collection is exactly what they consider a "business".