Restrict websites to a few domains on the devices they use. Youtube, wsj, etc...
If they want a new one just tell them to ask you.
It sucks and has problems, but its the only real straightforward and viable option I've seen work.
Source: have grandparents who were regularly getting scammed or close to being scammed on a weekly basis.
But what do we do when we get old? Will we be rational enough to disconnect ourselves? What if we don’t have any children that can help us make this decision?
With elderly loved ones, as with everything in life, a negotiation takes place.
https://www.truelinkfinancial.com/
https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/true-link (YC S13)
If you come across this comment and need advice in logistics for caring for loved ones, contact info in my profile.
That's a great idea. And it's easier than ever, now -- at least in my experience. For a while I still had to use bill pay or debit for some of my utilities, but now even those all take credit card. I do it for convenience and the rewards (and because the last time my wife used her debit card it got skimmed), but the result is the same -- 100% of my own spending is on my credit card now. This would work great for my own mother if she gets to a point where I doubt her ability to resist con artists.
1. If a service provider you use reaches out via email asking for money, its fake. Login to their online portal (it took a lot of coaxing to get them comfortable with this...)
2. If a service provider reaches out to you via SMS or Phone call, even if they know your account number or other sensitive data: Tell them you will call them back on the phone number listed on their website. If they insist, its fake.
3. If you aren't sure its fake, just ask me to look at it.
The simple rule of thumb that will keep people reasonably safe is: Do not trust anyone who E-mails or calls over the phone to be who they say they are. If they say they are from business XYZ, hang up the phone and call XYZ's main number and ask for them. While there are exceptions and scammers are getting craftier, incoming calls and E-mail is by far the major attack vector.
My stepfather always tries the factory reset button as if it's just a more hardcore reboot to "fix" the internet when the service is simply out.
If there's a private sector solution to the scam calls that can be charged heavily for, that's what we're most likely to get. The competent parts of government aren't concerned with this stuff. Congress has to make it a concern, but they mostly toil on behalf of corporate lobbyists. Lobbyists aren't hired to help society at the expense of who they represent.
Intelligent, informed voters and honest politicians would have solved this and many other problems already, but we're extremely far from that ideal, and I think still trending away.
I think real time alerts or daily summaries sent to trusted caretakers. Another layer is having the caretaker approve of the transactions. Can think of this as 2 factor authentication where they'd have to hack multiple phones or accounts for a successful scam.
For example, seeing multiple gift cards would be suspicious. Or if you know your parents never take out more than 100$ from the ATM.
Sometimes though they willingly scam themselves. My dad gave this real life scammer 30k in advance payment in return for future caregiving services. We told him she was scamming us and he didn't care. When she asked him for more money to buy a new car he finally realized she was truly scamming him.
It could be as common as sending a pin to YOUR phone or that they actually call the bank to authorize it.
Some join accounts also require approval from both parties to transfer large amounts of money.
Additionally you can open a secondary account for your elderly relatives for daily expenses, they fund this account from their main account.
Anything you do, do it at the banking level, do not rely on your elderly relatives to doge pretty sophisticated scams.
In my experience, trying to list and explain all of the ways that scams happen actually has the complete opposite effect — either it ends up as information overload and they don't remember it, or they become so fearful of doing wrong in specific situations that they almost certainly become more vulnerable to fear-based attacks as a result.
I tell her that if she ever has any doubt whatsoever that she’s to call me any time any where and I’ll help.
I also promised to cover any financial loss due to eg making a late payment because of my advice.
How do you protect your car from your teens crashing it? Don't give them the keys
I told my mother (who is 81) that the answer is always no. There is never an emergency, the answer is always no, she should hang up and then talk to me. Personally, if possible (we live 10 minutes apart) or at least on the phone. Any legitimate need for money can wait that long.
Fortunately, my mother has a somewhat technical background and her mind is 100% still there, so it hasn't ever been a real concern yet. She's skeptical by nature of what she sees online.
The ability to reason about money deteriorates with cognitive decline, in large part, I think, because it so abstract.
The solution is for them to not have direct access to control all their finances, but rather get monthly amounts via a trust. That way, downside is limited.
Unless the trustee is a scammer, or worse, one of several adult children who don't agree on how finances should be managed.
Secondly, it is typical to mitigate against a single trustee not acting in good faith by have an odd number of trustees.
So you are saying that if you trust the trustee, they can't be a scammer? I don't agree.
While I'm confident in the security of Chromebook in general, I'm worried by how readily she pulls out her credit card and types the number into obscure sites for purchasing wedding gifts, etsy items, etc. A few years ago she would click on Facebook ads and buy shit quality products for little reason, but I think she eventually learned not to do that.
At least it's a credit card and not a debit card. My dad manages the banking, and is a bit more sophisticated, but even he does things like install programs meant to protect him that actually expose him to more vulnerabilities. For example, there is some Symantec monstrosity installed on his computer that injects a green checkmark into Google search results next to each site it thinks is "trustworthy."
It's definitely frightening and mostly a numbers game whether they'll be the next victims of a scam.
A friend of the family recently had his email hacked. They sent targeted emails to all his contacts and setup a filter to hide the communication. His brother in law is a stoke victim with impaired cognition and only has access to $12k or so at a time. They were able to scam all of it from him over multiple transfers and he never picked up the phone to call the family friend. The family fiend is also his caretaker and limits his funds access for this exact reason.
The family friend is a retired old GE executive who will probably never run out of money no matter how many cars he buys due to pension funds. I wonder if he was targeted.