News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by abeppu on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @09:15PM (#35162332)
... but aren't job postings a poor measure of actual hiring? Once you reach the point of not being able to hire the people you want in a timely manner, you can create _lots_ of postings, on different channels, at different levels of seniority, with different kinds of focus, etc, as a desperate and ineffective measure of getting some qualified applicants in your pipe.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by csa on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @09:21PM (#35162379)
Exactly.

I’m fairly certain that there were quite a few job postings that were one of the following:

- one of several for the same position, framed in different ways (as parent reply suggested)

- fishing for a unicorn candidate who undervalued themselves

- absolute fantasy… no one who was qualified for the job would take it with that company for what they were offering

I think that some of this may have been used as an illusion to project growth where there was none.

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by Gimpei on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @09:27PM (#35162444)
But that would always be the case and wouldn’t explain the pandemic bounce. You need there to be a sudden relative increase in this type of behavior at the beginning of the pandemic.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by csa on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:07AM (#35164884)
> You need there to be a sudden relative increase in this type of behavior at the beginning of the pandemic.

1. Increased funds available to VC due to low interest rates and hot tech companies.

2. Many tech companies having a pandemic-fueled field day.

3. VCs pushing startups to hire aggressively to meet current demand (smart) and prepare themselves for the remote work, tech revolution paradigm shift (smart in moderation, less smart when leaned into too aggressively).

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by linuxftw on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @09:27PM (#35162442)
> - absolute fantasy… no one who was qualified for the job would take it with that company for what they were offering

This is what we call the 'I can't find any qualified domestic candidates, so I need to sponsor an immigrant' hiring strategy.

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by itqwertz on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @09:53PM (#35162682)
Don’t forget the diversity boost from this strategy!
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by yathaid on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:47AM (#35164754)
>> I’m fairly certain that there were quite a few job postings that were one of the following

Can you show the analysis for this claim?

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by csa on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:02AM (#35164848)
1. Have many personal and professional contacts in the tech industry.

2. Interact with said people.

3. Occasionally look at job postings to see what’s up.

4. Draw conclusions, usually via some sort of triangulation (i.e., not just using one source).

That’s the process.

Other than that, it’s anecdotal with many, many data points, and it’s completely not scientific (nor was it claimed to be).

Feel free to believe me or not — I am just an observer and a peripheral participant in the performance art that is the tech world.

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by crowbahr on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @10:31PM (#35162993)
Job postings on Indeed doubly so.

If you're looking for jobs on Indeed I'm confused as to what you're doing. I found nothing useful there when looking in February, meanwhile LinkedIn was incredibly useful.

Did about 15 interviews and accepted an offer. No issues.

Indeed never had a single attractive company to apply to in that time: It was all consulting.

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by wyclif on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @10:58PM (#35163196)
Can confirm. I don't think I've been shown a single authentic job posting on Indeed. It's mostly low-quality consulting filler.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by azemetre on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:23PM (#35163414)
Man I thought it was just me, but yeah Indeed is truly terrible. My only way of getting interviews has been linkedin (both applying to and getting messaged) or directly applying on company's websites thus far in my career.

Are there any other job boards that are actually authentic?

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by irrational on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:00AM (#35163680)
Stackoverflow used to have a really good job board that we got great candidates from. I was really sad to see it go away.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by bbbnnnmmmkjkj on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:48AM (#35164008)
Agree with this. Forgot they removed the board as it’s been kind of a while now. One thing I didn’t really like was having your stack overflow profile be relevant in hiring decisions - probably good for some/many devs though
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by kyawzazaw on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:09AM (#35164165)
good results with otta.com
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by MichaelRo on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:37AM (#35164690)
I heard GlassDoor also has jobs but I never used them, only LinkedIn and Indeed (I'm EU-based).

Never got hired through Indeed but they have a few jobs that aren't on LinkedIn.

Also, is it me not knowing to use Indeed or does their interface not support the most basic thing? EU-wide search. With LinkedIn I type "European Union" in the location box, shows me all EU. Indeed, I have to select every individual country, it's much more limiting and I'm getting bored fast.

Sure, I can select "United States" but dudes, having EU countries listed individually with no option of doing a whole area search is like having to manually search "Arkansas" or "Oklahoma" jobs in the US, it's retarded and myopic to say the least.

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by Yoric on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @08:42AM (#35167400)
EU-based dev here. Recently, I've been using:

- Hired (1 lead, did match my profile but not what I wanted to do);

- HiredSweet (0 leads);

- WellFound (a few interesting leads);

- Hacker News Who's Hiring (a few interesting leads);

- Hacker News Who Wants to be Hired (a few interesting leads);

- LinkedIn applying (a few interesting leads);

- LinkedIn messaged (dozens of leads);

- Reddit /r/rust (a few interesting leads).

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by SoftTalker on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:24AM (#35164264)
I can’t figure out why there seems to be a new heavily advertised jobs/employment site every couple of years. The first one I remember was monster.com. Now it’s Indeed. There have been a number of others. Why do these sites spring up, seem to be everywhere, and then get replaced after a couple of years?
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by zeckalpha on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:40AM (#35164347)
Indeed has been around since 2004, Monster since 1999.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by mech422 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @05:14AM (#35165685)
Heh - way back yonder - Dice.com used to be Awesome!
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by zrobotics on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:05AM (#35163719)
It may be a location thing, but in the upper midwest I see just absolute garbage on LinkedIn and just mostly garbage on Indeed. Both are full of consultancy garbage, but LinkedIn refuses to show me local jobs. I suspect they don't want to return a mostly empty search page, so they fill the results with Accenture consulting listing that are supposedly for my smallish metro. Indeed at least shows me local listing.

Although my situation might be a hit niche for this board, since I'm in a small area and I'm not interested in remote work for mental health reasons. But odd that a geography change causes such a complete reversal of which site is better. LinkedIn is still worth it for the professional network features, but honestly I kinda would prefer the Craigslist interface since that is actually searchable.

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by Yoric on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @08:39AM (#35167357)
I'm a tech lead in France with a detailed resume and LinkedIn sometimes shows me positions as a nurse in the US. No clue how their algorithm works, but I'm not highly confident in its quality :)
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by kadoban on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:44AM (#35163985)
My last search, Indeed was great. They did free, decent resume consultation with me, and assigned me some rando to point out some good listings to apply for here and there (that surprisingly were generally well curated). Got several interviews and a job in short order.

(no affiliation, they just were surprisingly helpful... I still don't know why, my situation at the time did not make me an amazing candidate or anything)

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by vasco on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:32AM (#35165421)
> I still don't know why

It paid for this ad and others you may have spread around recalling the situation.

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by kadoban on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @09:05AM (#35167712)
Maybe. If so, that's the _one_ type of marketing that I'll happily support, just doing a good job and waiting for your customers to tell people.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by 0xNOTVALID on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:36AM (#35165061)
I’ve noticed that many applicants for positions at my company from Indeed.com are entirely unqualified. Often truck drivers, etc. for a software engineering role and the resume will have no engineering related experience.

I’ve been told that many of these applicants are people applying to jobs they have no hopes of getting interviewed for. In many states you must prove you are actively looking for a job to collect unemployment benefits.

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by Gigachad on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @10:38PM (#35163057)
I noticed there were a lot of job listings for crypto which just stayed up for ages. I suspect they had trouble hiring as they need someone smart enough to work on this stuff, while also lacking the ethics to avoid scamming people, and often being dumb enough to be scammed themselves in to having part of their payment be rug pull tokens with conditions blocking selling for x months/years (after the pull)

These no hope listings probably inflated numbers a fair bit.

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by Osiris on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:06PM (#35163262)
As someone who worked in crypto, this assessment does not match my experience. I was always paid via normal payroll methods and never in tokens.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by Gigachad on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:28PM (#35163450)
Have one friend who was paid like this. Obviously not universal but it seems more prevalent than other jobs.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by SamReidHughes on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:08AM (#35164149)
I've been offered payment in tokens. I don't know if they'd have had conditions, though.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by dehrmann on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:51AM (#35164404)
Way back in ~2012, I remember Coinbase (or maybe another exchange) paid some people in Bitcoin, but that was a while ago.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by HideousKojima on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:13AM (#35164562)
I had an interview for a crypto startup in late 2021 and they asked if I would be ok with part of my compensation being in their token.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by otikik on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:31AM (#35165407)
What about the scams, any experience there?
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by matsemann on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:37AM (#35165468)
You didn't deny the scam or ethics issues. Was that intentional?
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by stavros on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:47AM (#35165539)
I have coworkers who were offered tokens in a previous engagement. They were given the option to sell the tokens as soon as they received them (and receive cash instead), and they made quite a lot of money from them.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by senttoschool on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:08PM (#35163278)
Crypto companies have a more sinister reason for keeping job postings up.

It's all about marketing for crypto companies that have tokens on exchanges. Their goal is to raise the token price so they can dump on retail. Having many active job postings show that they're active in development and they plenty of money to keep the project going. If they don't have any job postings, it can be interpreted that they've already rug pulled.

It's all part of how they fool the gullible.

There are literally analytics companies that use job postings as a data point for crypto companies to see if they're active or rug pulled.

Keeping job postings up is free.

Source: Worked in and consulted for a few crypto companies years ago and analyzed many crypto scams.

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by danjac on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:26AM (#35165001)
I subscribe to a couple RSS feeds for some remote job sites.

A very large % of jobs are for crypto (ok "fintech" but look closely it's crypto) in March 2023. I wonder how these companies are still going, or maybe the listings just haven't been taken down yet.

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by tempsy on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:07PM (#35163266)
The “day in the life of being a tech worker” tiktoks felt like the top for me.

People filming themselves eating free snacks and doing yoga and whatever else other than working.

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by Beaver117 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:04AM (#35163709)
Nah, they were making those years ago too. 2021 was a much crazier time.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by Apocryphon on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:20AM (#35164968)
Yeah, the "day in the life of a software engineer at X name brand company" has been on YouTube for years and definitely predates the TikTok trend. It dates to at least a few years prior to the pandemic.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by kadoban on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:00AM (#35164832)
Tiktok is optimized for clicks (or at best amusement), not honesty.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by danjac on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:30AM (#35165016)
The reality for most of us I suspect was sitting at home on our couch fixing an obscure bug in a CI pipeline while half-listening along to an all-hands meeting.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by Yoric on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @08:44AM (#35167424)
...while helping the kids do the homework (during the lockdowns).
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by glenngillen on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:59AM (#35164080)
They’re a terrible measure. From a comment I made about this assumption elsewhere on HN a few weeks ago:

I am hiring at an early stage startup myself. There is absolutely no way we’d extend offers for all of the roles we have open if a candidate arrived for all of them next week. Growing that much so quickly would be a disastrous onboarding experience for most of the new hires and potentially risk our ability to build a consistent culture with the team. So we’ll hire whichever candidate(s) successfully complete the process first and then pause the other roles until we’re ready to onboard more people. Then there’s also the reality at this stage you need people who can wear multiple hats. And there’s a bunch of roles where your ideal candidate doesn’t have a neat pre-established label. So sometimes we’ll post the exact same role with different titles to try and make sure it gets the attention of someone who most strongly aligns with one of those job titles.

At a previous place we worked remotely, and so the same job would be posted as both remote and then also as a dozen different specific city locations too. But if we were hiring multiple of any roles you wouldn’t multiply that, you’d just post the one listing(s) and keep it open until all the positions were filled.

A jobs page is a marketing artefact for potential hires, it’s not a financial reporting/forecasting tool.

TLDR: don’t make any assumptions from a job board about how many roles a company is realistically hiring for.

Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by sgerenser on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @09:17AM (#35167886)
This would also explain part of the uptick in postings post-pandemic, as companies become more open to hiring remotely are more likely to post dozens of identical job postings in a variety of cities.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by petesergeant on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:56AM (#35164447)
Actually I used to work producing data from job posting stats. I think there’s a strong correlation between job demand and job posts (job posts cost money, after all!) but as you point out, it may not be linear, as the more desperate people are to hire, the more they’ll post.
Re:Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Indeed.com job postings d... by dehrmann on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:57AM (#35164451)
They don't necessarily match, but the aggregate directional numbers are meaningful. Indeed postings aren't free. The mismatch between tech and overall also matches the broader narrative about a tech recession, but the rest of the economy is doing sorta ok, at least until January 2023.

So you're right, but it matches enough things that I wouldn't dismiss it.