News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by ortusdux on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:13PM (#35159761)
*could be the last of its kind built in the US
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by nosianu on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:21PM (#35159874)
The article further explains why that may not work out.

To quote:

> the industry is betting on advanced nuclear reactors to save the day.

> It’s a bad bet.

The main points:

> The advanced and small modular reactors (SMRs) under development face a raft of economic, regulatory, technological and temporal risks.

and

> The advanced reactor closest to market in the U.S. is being developed by NuScale, which has a nonbinding agreement to build a first-of-its-kind SMR project in Idaho. The company has already raised its projected power cost from $58 per megawatt-hour to $89, even though it’s still years away from even beginning construction.

and

> Advanced reactors such as TerraPower’s Natrium, which are significantly different in design from existing light-water reactors, face an even steeper regulatory climb. And they’ll have to contend with broken or nonexistent supply chains because the more highly concentrated uranium fuels used by most advanced reactors are currently unavailable in large quantities outside of Russia.

Which leads to this summary at the end:

> Regardless of rosy messaging from DOE and the industry, it’s almost certain that Vogtle 3 and 4 are going to be the last big nuclear reactors coming online in the U.S. for a long time.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by wkat4242 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:31PM (#35160043)
Yeah here in Holland they have the same pipe dream. They want to start new reactors rise should come online by 2040, delays obviously not included.

It's a big bullet point for the hard right party VVD that think this way they can continue business as usual. But it'll come way too late for that. I'm sure their buddy's corporations will have some nice pork from it though.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by belorn on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:56PM (#35160427)
We will see in 2040 if countries who made a different decision has lower carbon footprint. There is seemingly a lot of countries betting that green hydrogen will become energy storage solution in 20-30-50 years, and thus they can use natural gas/coal while waiting and continue with business as usual.

Only time will tell which bets in the energy grid was good and which was bad for the environment. The last bet that many countries did on buying natural gas from Russia ended up being quite bad for Europe.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by wkat4242 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:00PM (#35160504)
Hydrogen is just as much of a pipe dream IMO. Producing, compressing is all very inefficient and it leaks through its tanks quickly. Which is a real big problem not only because of the energy wasted but because it's a much more potent greenhouse gas than CO2 is!

The bet on buying natural gas was a bad one for the environment for the start obviously, no matter whom we bought it from.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by pfdietz on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @10:47PM (#35163111)
There's a lot of bad faith pearl clutching over hydrogen, but industry already makes and uses 700 cubic kilometers (if measured at STP) of the gas each year, so obviously the problem of manipulating it is solvable. I read that the cost of a hydrogen pipeline might be about 8% higher than the cost of a natural gas pipeline, per unit of energy transportation capacity.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by wkat4242 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:17PM (#35163356)
Most of that gas comes from cracking fossil fuels which is much more efficient. But does contribute to climate change.

I just don't see it really solving anything at a large scale. Perhaps for some applications like perhaps airplanes but for many others just using batteries would be a much better option.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by pfdietz on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:23PM (#35163405)
The point is not where the gas comes from, the point is that we have pipes, valves, compressors, sensors, etc. etc. that can handle it. Hand wringing about how the stuff is impossible to work with is just nonsense. Some care is needed with materials.

Batteries are of course a better option for short term storage and probably most vehicles. But there are storage use cases where hydrogen is far superior to batteries, such as very long term energy storage.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by _hypx on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:27PM (#35161832)
Green hydrogen is a good idea, but it doesn't excuse us from coming up with alternatives. We still want more than one solution to tackle the climate change issue.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by bjourne on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:57PM (#35160450)
The situation may be analogous in Sweden. Building nuclear reactors was a huge part of the right-wing parties campaign. They even promised to start construction 100 days after they won the election. Unsurprisingly that promise fell through. No private companies have been willing to invest in nuclear and, thankfully, the government has not yet decided to plow hundreds of billions of taxpayer money into new reactors.

Imo it's all culture war populism. Renewable energy and saving the planet is for little girls, nuclear power and driving fossil fuel cars is for real men or something.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by Maursault on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:54PM (#35160406)
Wishful thinking. The problem with nuclear energy is not is not the risk of meltdown. It is not the waste, not directly. The problem is economics. Light water fission reactors are the least expensive nuclear reactors we know of, and even these can not break even. Every other design is even more expensive. For nuclear energy to work it must be profitable. Economics is nuclear energy's Achilles' heel, and its only hurdle.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by PaulHoule on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:18PM (#35160842)
That's what people thought in 1980.

A big part of the high cost of the LWR is the cost of the steam turbine and associated heat exchangers (a typical PWR has several of those, each of which is as big as the reactor vessel) These very large systems inflate the balance of system costs such as the size of both the confinement and auxillary buildings.

It's no accident that they stopped building coal burning power plants at the same time they stopped building nuclear plants. Neither one could compete with the low capital cost of gas turbine power plants fueled with methane.

Old literature expected that HTGR power plants with steam turbines might be able to beat the LWR in economics, that fast breeder reactors would be more fuel efficient but have higher capital costs. Today there is some expectation that a fast reactor with a closed cycle gas turbine could undercut the capital cost of an LWR. Now that kind of gas turbine is not a bird in the hand and will take some development, but the potential reward is huge... Such a turbine would almost fit in the employee break room of the turbine house of an LWR.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by philipkglass on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:39PM (#35161173)
Nuclear plant and coal plant construction didn't really stop at the same time, though. In the early 21st century before the fracking boom took off in the US, natural gas prices were rising. This spurred a small (and hopefully the last) spurt of new coal plant construction in the US. Their operating start dates cluster around 2010 though construction starts were earlier:

https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=30812

The bad news is that coal fired power can be cheaper than gas fired power when gas prices are high. If it were just about the cost of steam equipment, we would have seen a similar burst of nuclear reactors starting to operate in the US around 2010. Nuclear power plants are sadly more expensive to build and operate than coal plants.

The good news is that falling costs for renewables and storage make it very unlikely that the US will build any more coal-fired plants on economic grounds.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by pfdietz on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @10:17PM (#35162863)
The US has not built a new coal fired power plant for ten years now (932 MW Sandy Creek Energy Station in Texas, came online in 2013). Do we even have the industrial infrastructure to build one now?
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by Maursault on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @10:33PM (#35163011)
It no longer makes economic sense to build coal power plants as 99% of US coal plants are more expensive than renewables.[1] This is pretty bad news for nuclear, as nuclear is 5x–6x more expensive to build than a coal plant.

[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/energyinnovation/2023/01/30/99-...

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by Maursault on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @10:29PM (#35162975)
> Today there is some expectation that a fast reactor with a closed cycle gas turbine could undercut the capital cost of an LWR.

No there isn't. Check your figures. Breeder reactors literally cost twice as much as light water reactors of comparable power.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by PaulHoule on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @09:52AM (#35168339)
That is the old data from the 1980s. That assumes you have heat exchangers with miles and miles of pipe that will fail annoyingly (but not catastrophically) if a pinhole leak causes water to contact sodium.

If you are working at higher temperatures with printed circuit heat exchangers the whole thing is dramatically smaller.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by Maursault on Thursday March 16, 2023 @09:13AM (#35181477)
The data is current. It has not and is not possible to build a breeder reactor for less than a water cooled reactor. And breeder reactors are more costly to operate. Nothing has changed.

Make it profitable, and you can have all the breeder reactors you want.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by Accujack on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:59AM (#35164074)
>The article further explains why that may not work out.

The article is basically anti-nuclear propaganda, with its conclusions based on the same lack of understanding and fear that's always been the problem.

I wouldn't be surprised to see the US extend the life of existing nuclear plants and potentially even build a few more of the old design when push comes to shove. In time climate change will force the government to act, and if the new reactor types aren't ready and the needed breakthroughs in energy storage plus the needed world wide smart grid to enable renewables, there won't be another choice.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by manfre on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:15PM (#35159779)
Hard to tell if it's purely for the clickbait or leaning heavily on shortening the title.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by wesoff on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:39PM (#35160160)
Headlines limited to ~70 characters.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by melling on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:30PM (#35160021)
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by Gwypaas on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:43PM (#35160220)
2040? 2050? Which problem are we solving?
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by melling on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:03PM (#35160553)
From the SAME sentence: “suggested that some might enter commercial operation before 2030”
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by Gwypaas on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:11PM (#35160718)
Why did you skip half the sentance?

> The first commercial plants are not expected before 2040–2050,[3] although the World Nuclear Association in 2015 suggested that some might enter commercial operation before 2030.[4]

An optimistic 2030 from 8 years ago, with about zero progress to date.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by PaulHoule on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:21PM (#35160892)
The US shouldn't have shut down the FFTF. Had we not shut down advanced reactor development we could be 15-20 years ahead of where we are.

Talk about Gen 4 reactors started around 2000, test reactors and development projects for Gen 4 reactors are going into high gear.

https://www.world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/Chinese-molten-s...

It would be nice if these were coming online in the next 10 years but don't think our need for energy suddenly expires in 2030 or that we'll be completely happy with renewables by 2040.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by Andrex on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:56PM (#35161433)
We'd be 15-20 years further down a dead-end, possibly.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by melling on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:22PM (#35160905)
I skipped it because you mentioned that part. I was merely trying to complete it.

The United States went to the moon in 8 years.

Where does “zero progress” come from?

The same article lists projects.

We’ve all heard of TerraPower, for example?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/TerraPower

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by nl on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:47PM (#35161299)
I read the World Nuclear Association's "Small Reactor Dashboard"[1] (worst dashboard ever: it's 70+ page embedded PDF).

There's only one 4th generation nuclear reactor actually producing power anywhere that I could find on the list, the HTR-PM in China which was connected to the grid in 2022.

Terrapower is one of many companies that have some funding but nothing produced. To quote the Wikipedia link you posted:

> [in 2022] DOE gave TerraPower cost-share funding through the Advanced Reactor Demonstration Program (ARDP) to test, license and build an advanced reactor within seven years.

Let's see where they are in 7 years...

[1] https://www.oecd-nea.org/jcms/pl_78743/the-nea-small-modular...

[2] https://www.powermag.com/china-starts-up-first-fourth-genera...

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by m463 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @10:23PM (#35162919)
8 years is probably the maximum length of time a project can live, given the political cycle.

I had a friend who worked in nuclear, and progress was dictated by changes in washington every 4 or sometimes 8 years.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by stevenally on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:15PM (#35159780)
Thanks. Saved me a click.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by megaman821 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:22PM (#35159895)
It could easily be the last of its generation and its size built in the US. Is there any non-SMR on the horizon?
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by _hypx on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:43PM (#35160218)
I'm going to come out and say, not even the last of its kind. Support for nuclear power is directly proportional to real, intellectually motivated support for clean energy (this is not related to the people that make dumb protests). And as that continues, we will see more conventional nuclear reactors being built.
Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by joseph_grobbles on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:47PM (#35160280)
Nuclear is catastrophically expensive. Nuclear stagnated not because of those "dumb protests", but because economically it turned out that they made very little sense. Projects always went massively over budget, and then had a lifespan cost multiples idealist notions.

Are they expensive because of overbearing safety requirements? Partly, sure. On the flip side, Fukushima has now cost hundreds and hundreds of billions in direct costs. If nuclear power plants didn't have a civil exemption where governments bore the potential liability of damage (which is almost infinite), they would be unbuildable.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by _hypx on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:23PM (#35161783)
And yet still cheaper than doing nothing. Same is true of half-solutions or pretend solutions. In reality nuclear is more than cheap enough to do the job. If upfront costs is really an issue, then we should subsidize it.

And even with all nuclear disasters included, it is still cheap enough to do the job. If it is uninsurable, then government should insure it. Again, still cheaper than anything else.

Re:Georgia’s big new nuclear reactors could be the last buil... by Zigurd on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:04PM (#35160564)
i recently had a VC in a couple new gen reactor companies call me a Negative Nancy. I'm not. I follow the developments. There is one venture, TerraPower that isn't just making another run at fast or pebble bed reactors, generally at a smaller scale. Only TerraPower has the vast risk capital backing needed to try what they are doing, but even they might license a technology to get to market sooner than they can by developing their TWR.

It seems like PBRs have the most readily fixable problems, but even those are probably decades away from putting power on the grid.

I would bet a number of the venture funded reactors will die of a "liquidity mismatch" with their investors. Some appear to be leaning on developing technologies and patents in anticipation of encountering that problem.