News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by matthews2 on Friday March 03, 2023 @09:57AM (#35010395)
Background: the original Lena picture comes from the Playboy Magazine, and the model doesn't want people to use it.

https://pursuit.unimelb.edu.au/articles/it-s-time-to-retire-...

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by rom-antics on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:22AM (#35010768)
That article doesn't support the headline. The closest it gets is saying nobody asked her beforehand, but she doesn't say after the fact that she wants people to stop.

Meanwhile, from the people who actually bothered to talk to her[1]:

> In her view, the photograph is an immense accomplishment that just happened to take on a life of its own. “I’m really proud of that picture,” she said.

This whole situation reminds me of GitHub, Fuck Your Name Change[2]. People want to drum up outrage and don't care one bit about the people involved.

Is it really worth erasing a piece of computing history because of some kids virtue signaling about a picture that was taken before they were born?

[1]: https://www.wired.com/story/finding-lena-the-patron-saint-of...

[2]: https://mooseyanon.medium.com/github-f-ck-your-name-change-d...

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by iameli on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:45AM (#35011087)
Did you watch the video? She said that she would like to retire from having her picture used in this way.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by rom-antics on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:52AM (#35012040)
I don't see a video in either article. Link?
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by josephcsible on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:16AM (#35010670)
Contrast that case with this one: https://www.boredpanda.com/unflattering-donald-trump-chin-ph...

Why is it that in the former, everyone says you're a horrible person who deserves to be cancelled if you ignore the subject's wishes to not use the picture, but in the latter, everyone says it's a great thing if you ignore the subject's wishes to not use the picture?

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by abofh on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:22AM (#35010770)
Exceeding scope; I took your picture and used it in an ad campaign, I exceeded scope. I took your picture as president of a country and used it in a blog, I didn't.

This is a trivial discussion, but that's your answer

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by bee_rider on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:40AM (#35011016)
It actually is not great that people decided to go after Trump’s various sensitive physical traits. He’s an awful person and there are many far more substantial things to criticize him on. Making fun of his weight, even though it feels good to say negative things about a bad person, reinforces the idea that this is somehow a valid criticism.

I can see why people do it. He’s the worst, it feels good to say negative things about him. And he also has a tendency to go for shallow physical descriptions of people as criticism. So it has the feeling of “turnabout is fair play.” But it is a failure to restrain lesser instincts.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by smcl on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:02AM (#35011333)
This is a good point, it may be cathartic, it may be deserved but it isn't really helpful.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by bee_rider on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:16AM (#35011491)
Plus it brings us into the world of the crass and stupid, where Trump has the home team advantage.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by smcl on Friday March 03, 2023 @03:03PM (#35014313)
I think you got downvoted because on face value that looks like a cheap shot. But in truth it does play well with Trump's fanbase when he takes aim at an opponent and starts talking smack about them publicly. Those opposed to Trump, it seems to me, tire easily of that and prefer a bit of civility, or at least the pretence of it.

So what you're saying is roughly "when you engage in petty slap-fights with Trump you kinda are playing to his strengths" - which is true.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by raincole on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:21AM (#35010760)
Correct answer: because one is politican and the other isn't

Real answer: because people have double, triple, multiple standards.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by Steltek on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:22AM (#35010767)
Because ridiculing world leaders is essential to liberty and free exercise of democracy? Especially POTUS, which is arguably the top of the heap. You don't need to agree, believe it has any merit, or anything like that. It's more important that the right exists than how it's used.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by smcl on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:29AM (#35010851)
Lena has been used for years and this use doesn't necessarily result in you being "cancelled", it might make your colleagues say "hey, can you use something other than lena?" though. The model is a pretty private figure and has not given us any reason not to respect her wishes, so if she has asked the community not to then it's only decent to refrain from using her picture.

Trump is an extremely controversial person who has stirred up no end of trouble and to boot has dished out more than his own fair share of bodyshaming. It does not surprise me in the slightest that people are not willing to extend him the courtesy of not sharing a picture of him that he doesn't like.

I'm not in the business of using or distributing these pictures, so I am quite happy not using either. I'm just attempting to explain why people feel this way. I personally quite like the Ethically Sourced Lena, it made me smile :)

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by googlryas on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:06AM (#35011389)
I love how mostly liberal(and good) viewpoints about the badness of body shaming go out the window when it comes to their enemies. Whether it was about his weight, or penis or hand size. Heck, there was even a popular statue made of a nude trump with a micropenis which people were lining up to have their picture taken with.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by teachrdan on Friday March 03, 2023 @12:33PM (#35012679)
This is a false equivalence. The reason people make fun of Trump for being ugly is because he himself mocks others based on their appearance -- particularly women. This is akin to queer activists in the 80s outing closeted gay Republicans who were advocating for anti-gay laws.

Turnabout is fair play. If Trump doesn't want people to make fun of him for his physical qualities, he shouldn't do the same for others.

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/16/us/politics/trump-women-i...

https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2019/08/donald-trump-protest...

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by throw009 on Friday March 03, 2023 @06:04PM (#35016224)
If you think that decency is a human right and not a privilege to be given out only the the worthy then you're a hypocrite for treating people the way they treat others.

If on the other hand you think that special grounds deserve special rights then go ahead. I have an apartheid to sell you though.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by googlryas on Sunday March 05, 2023 @11:46AM (#35031264)
I've never heard "body shaming is bad unless you're body shaming a body shamer".

It misses the point in that there is collateral damage for body shaming as well - if you mock trump's weight because he is a bad person, you're still implying "fat=bad" to every good fat person out there too.

So am I allowed to mock those liberals physical qualities now, since they mocked trump for mocking someone's physical qualities? If they don't want to be moved they shouldn't do the same to others.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by shultays on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:07AM (#35010536)
Huh, I remember reading about her finding it interesting, even attending one image processing conference as a guest, but maybe I misremembering?

edit: apparently she changed her mind later

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by jtriangle on Friday March 03, 2023 @05:33PM (#35015959)
She was championed up until a few years ago as the "Queen of JPEG", and was fairly active in that community.

Rightly so too, it's an image of her, but, more importantly, that image is very difficult to compress efficiently and maintain acceptable quality. There are other images that could have been used, but, an image of her was used, and she enjoyed the celebrity from that until recently.

She is allowed, of course, to change her mind, much as the rest of the world is allowed to consider her past behavior when deciding how they respond to her changing her mind.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by dsr_ on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:11AM (#35010596)
The more personal an artifact is, the more I think the subject's wishes should be taken into account.

https://qntm.org/mmacevedo is a much more in-depth examination...

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by mytailorisrich on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:16AM (#35010679)
The model in question posed for nude pictures in Playboy...

The whole 'controversy' is pure spin in an age when everything has to be controversial.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by CharlesW on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:41AM (#35011035)
> The model in question posed for nude pictures in Playboy...

This is the problem. You're implying it's okay because she asked for it, when the unlicensed reproduction of Disney IP would be treated very differently.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by mytailorisrich on Friday March 03, 2023 @12:49PM (#35012827)
Well the copyright holder may indeed have something to say about it.

But I have a hard time believing that there is anything morally wrong with using a cropped version of such picture for technical and scientific research... that's just looking for controversy where there is none.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by logimus on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:09AM (#35010568)
Really some computer vision guy told she was at some conference to give out signatures.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by sorenjan on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:15AM (#35010651)
In 1997 and 2015.

From the picture's Wikipedia:

Lenna is so widely accepted in the image processing community that Forsén was a guest at the 50th annual Conference of the Society for Imaging Science and Technology (IS&T) in 1997.[18] In 2015, Lena Forsén was also guest of honor at the banquet of IEEE ICIP 2015.[19] After delivering a speech, she chaired the best paper award ceremony.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lenna

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by nemo44x on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:23AM (#35010787)
Is Playboy exploitive or empowering today? I can't keep up.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by pseudalopex on Friday March 03, 2023 @03:42PM (#35014732)
Every day is the day when people have individual opinions. And those opinions can be more complex than good or bad.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by nemo44x on Friday March 03, 2023 @06:44PM (#35016525)
Sure, but what’s the correct opinion right now?
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by seventytwo on Friday March 03, 2023 @09:58AM (#35010417)
Didn’t realize the model doesn’t want people using it. That holds more weight in my mind than the fact that it was in playboy.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by enriquto on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:05AM (#35010514)
It's not so clear that she doesn't want people to use that image. She has assisted several times at image processing conferences, and has stated recently that she was proud of the fact that so many people used that photo. The documentary linked above shows footage of herself talking about the photo, but she never really says people should not use it. The website hosting the documentary has several heavily editorialized quotations that suggest that.

That said, this new "lennart" is hilarious and I would like to use it instead of the original one.

EDIT: here's a 2019 interview where she appears to pose with the same hat again : https://www.wired.com/story/finding-lena-the-patron-saint-of...

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by pseudalopex on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:20PM (#35017825)
“I retired from modelling a long time ago. It’s time I retired from tech, too. We can make a simple change today that creates a lasting change for tomorrow. Let’s commit to losing me.”

She can be proud of her work and not want it used where it makes other people uncomfortable.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by sorenjan on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:08AM (#35010551)
It's not really up to models to decide what their pictures gets used for though. Why should this be different?

From what I gather it's not because she's uncomfortable with it being used, it's because of controversy other people have drummed up:

> When I asked her if she had heard anything about the recent controversy around her image, she seemed alarmed at the thought that she could have a part in hurting or discouraging young women. I sent her some articles about the Lenna and later gave her a call to see what she made of them. The photo, she said, doesn’t show very much—just down to her shoulders—so it was hard for her to see what the big deal was.

https://www.wired.com/story/finding-lena-the-patron-saint-of...

Not that it really matters that much, it's a historical curiosity by now.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by hidelooktropic on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:10AM (#35010586)
It is completely reasonable for a model to be told their work and their likeness will be used for one purpose and for them to not be OK if it is used for another, I don't see how being a model excludes you from the right to have an agreement about releasing your creative input.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by vidarh on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:10AM (#35010573)
She doesn't have any way to force people to stop, but that doesn't mean people can't take her opinion into account.
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by sorenjan on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:12AM (#35010621)
Her opinion doesn't seem to match the articles claim:

> Lena doesn’t harbor any resentment toward Sawchuk and his imitators for how they appropriated her image; the only note of regret she expressed was that she wasn’t better compensated. In her view, the photograph is an immense accomplishment that just happened to take on a life of its own. “I’m really proud of that picture,” she said.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by pseudalopex on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:45PM (#35017954)
“I retired from modelling a long time ago. It’s time I retired from tech, too. We can make a simple change today that creates a lasting change for tomorrow. Let’s commit to losing me.”[1]

Being proud of her work doesn't mean she thinks people should have to see it in their work.

[1] https://www.thedrum.com/news/2019/11/19/gender-equality-ad-c...

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by shadowgovt on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:13AM (#35010627)
So there's contracts and there's intent and morality.

The argument you have presented is analogous (like, right next door; they share a side-yard, their kids go to the same school, and they co-organize the neighborhood potluck) to the argument that you and I have no right to our data not being thrown in a big hopper to generate an AI that is designed to operate directly counter to our personal interests.

After all, if you didn't want thousands of websites hoovering up your information, transferring it to a central clearinghouse, and that clearinghouse building an AI to put you out of a job... You should never have logged onto those websites, right? Those TOS clearly said they could use your data for any purpose. The contract was quite clear (had we bothered to read it).

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by sorenjan on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:21AM (#35010745)
So your argument is that stock photography of humans are unethical unless every model signs a new model release for every use? Is it immoral to use András István Aratós image in memes too?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hide_the_Pain_Harold

I have no issue with user data being used to build ML models, although I don't agree with you about the close proximity between a model's photo being used for photo research and anyone's data being used for everything.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by bee_rider on Friday March 03, 2023 @12:18PM (#35012426)
“Because of controversy” seems like an unnecessarily dismissive way of putting it. It is entirely possible that she didn’t mind having her image used in and of itself. It sounds like she didn’t mind the use of the photo, but changed her mind when she found out that it was making other people uncomfortable, which seems… totally reasonable, right?
Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by Findecanor on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:20AM (#35010736)
... And here I had tracked down her address and was about to mail her a print-out, with a request to ask her to sign it.

I had been planning to display it in a glass cabinet next to my Melitta teapot and Luxo jr lamp and ball. (and if anyone has a lead on a terracotta rabbit, please let me know ;)

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by iamflimflam1 on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:01AM (#35010450)
Yes, this definitely changes things. Previously the model didn't seem to be bothered and seemed to find it all quite amusing.

People change their minds and we should respect their wishes.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by josephcsible on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:19AM (#35010716)
> People change their minds and we should respect their wishes.

When you sign a contract that says "in return for a bunch of money, you agree that other people can use this picture of you", you shouldn't get to keep the money but change your mind about the picture.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by iamflimflam1 on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:01AM (#35011318)
Strictly speaking, she was paid money by playboy to appear in playboy - not to appear in the many research publications that have carried the image.

None of the researchers using the image had permission to use it nor did the journals that published the papers.

Playboy did decide in the end to look the other way as it was good publicity.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by benj111 on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:03AM (#35010470)
Really? Presumably she was paid.

I don't know what the copyright situation is, but assuming she doesn't hold that I don't know what the issue is.

Isn't it like trump objecting to images of his in court accompanying a news item?

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by Version467 on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:09AM (#35010569)
That she likely has no legal recourse does not mean that developers and researchers cannot respect her wishes.

It's not like this specific image has an inherent property that somehow makes it the superior test image.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by jerf on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:19AM (#35010705)
To me, that's the real kicker; there's absolutely no cost whatsoever to respecting the wishes.

If anything, it's not a great image; the standard scan is a bit washed out and doesn't have a full color range. (I can't speak to whether this is a characteristic of the scan, which is now from a very old scanner, or the original image, having never seen the original in print.) No one test image can capture everything an image algorithm might want to test, but more full use of available colors would probably still be advantageous.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by benj111 on Friday March 03, 2023 @03:45PM (#35014769)
>It's not like this specific image has an inherent property that somehow makes it the superior test image.

Surely that fact that it is the standard test image makes it a superior image.

If there's a format that I can't reproduce, there's a good chance there's an image of Lena to compare against.

Re:Ethically Sourced Lena Picture by vidarh on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:08AM (#35010557)
Do you not see the difference between the issue of whether it can legally be used, and the issue of whether or not it's nice to keep using it when the person involved would prefer it not be?

She, like Trump, is entitled to her opinion. And sometimes people want to respect people's opinions, sometimes not.