That said, this new "lennart" is hilarious and I would like to use it instead of the original one.
EDIT: here's a 2019 interview where she appears to pose with the same hat again : https://www.wired.com/story/finding-lena-the-patron-saint-of...
She can be proud of her work and not want it used where it makes other people uncomfortable.
From what I gather it's not because she's uncomfortable with it being used, it's because of controversy other people have drummed up:
> When I asked her if she had heard anything about the recent controversy around her image, she seemed alarmed at the thought that she could have a part in hurting or discouraging young women. I sent her some articles about the Lenna and later gave her a call to see what she made of them. The photo, she said, doesn’t show very much—just down to her shoulders—so it was hard for her to see what the big deal was.
https://www.wired.com/story/finding-lena-the-patron-saint-of...
Not that it really matters that much, it's a historical curiosity by now.
> Lena doesn’t harbor any resentment toward Sawchuk and his imitators for how they appropriated her image; the only note of regret she expressed was that she wasn’t better compensated. In her view, the photograph is an immense accomplishment that just happened to take on a life of its own. “I’m really proud of that picture,” she said.
Being proud of her work doesn't mean she thinks people should have to see it in their work.
[1] https://www.thedrum.com/news/2019/11/19/gender-equality-ad-c...
The argument you have presented is analogous (like, right next door; they share a side-yard, their kids go to the same school, and they co-organize the neighborhood potluck) to the argument that you and I have no right to our data not being thrown in a big hopper to generate an AI that is designed to operate directly counter to our personal interests.
After all, if you didn't want thousands of websites hoovering up your information, transferring it to a central clearinghouse, and that clearinghouse building an AI to put you out of a job... You should never have logged onto those websites, right? Those TOS clearly said they could use your data for any purpose. The contract was quite clear (had we bothered to read it).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hide_the_Pain_Harold
I have no issue with user data being used to build ML models, although I don't agree with you about the close proximity between a model's photo being used for photo research and anyone's data being used for everything.
I had been planning to display it in a glass cabinet next to my Melitta teapot and Luxo jr lamp and ball. (and if anyone has a lead on a terracotta rabbit, please let me know ;)
People change their minds and we should respect their wishes.
When you sign a contract that says "in return for a bunch of money, you agree that other people can use this picture of you", you shouldn't get to keep the money but change your mind about the picture.
None of the researchers using the image had permission to use it nor did the journals that published the papers.
Playboy did decide in the end to look the other way as it was good publicity.
I don't know what the copyright situation is, but assuming she doesn't hold that I don't know what the issue is.
Isn't it like trump objecting to images of his in court accompanying a news item?
It's not like this specific image has an inherent property that somehow makes it the superior test image.
If anything, it's not a great image; the standard scan is a bit washed out and doesn't have a full color range. (I can't speak to whether this is a characteristic of the scan, which is now from a very old scanner, or the original image, having never seen the original in print.) No one test image can capture everything an image algorithm might want to test, but more full use of available colors would probably still be advantageous.
Surely that fact that it is the standard test image makes it a superior image.
If there's a format that I can't reproduce, there's a good chance there's an image of Lena to compare against.
She, like Trump, is entitled to her opinion. And sometimes people want to respect people's opinions, sometimes not.