News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by tacker2000 on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @06:48AM (#34968275)
So it seems innovation is now completely non-existent at FB, and their new modus operandi is to throw shitloads of cash at any new fad that surfaces in the media and see what sticks.

Thats tells you a lot about whats going on and what kind of people work inside there.

They seem to be a dead man walking.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by reaperducer on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @07:28AM (#34968523)
their new modus operandi is to throw shitloads of cash at any new fad that surfaces in the media

Cryptocurrency. Voice assistants. VR.

What else?

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by siva7 on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @08:54AM (#34969285)
You have to think Big, not just in terms of single product areas like VR but how it fits all together in the Metaverse. Zuck is a genius in this regard
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by qsort on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @08:57AM (#34969319)
I can't tell if this is parody or not, which admittedly makes the comment 10x better.
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by baobabKoodaa on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:06AM (#34970827)
Did someone say AI on the blockchain... inside Metaverse?
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by rchaud on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @12:11PM (#34971828)
Leveraging computer vision to transpose virtual dog ears on to your photos and videos? Seemed to work out for Snapchat, briefly.
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by gbasin on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @08:57AM (#34969315)
When was that not the case? Only time I can think of is A/B testing facebook.com and maybe the transition to mobile feed?
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by whoisjuan on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @09:20AM (#34969559)
A simple Google search would show how much FB has contributed to the AI/ML community.

I hate seeing these comments in HN. No substance. Just saying whatever to jump into the FB hate bus.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by PartiallyTyped on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @09:24AM (#34969595)
While there have been a few public failures that were rather ... embarrassing ... and had their plug pulled off quickly, I don't think anyone can, in good conscience, claim that Meta has not been supportive of the AI/ML community, both in terms of research output and in terms of tooling [1].

[1] https://pytorch.org

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by moregrist on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:08AM (#34970852)
Exactly. These are all R&D tools and papers. I think the criticism is quite valid if you look at actual products.

It’s also a fair criticism of most of big tech wrt AI, and a lot of AI/ML: there’s a lot of cool-sounding R&D, but so far there are few (arguably no) resulting products.

Maybe we’re starting to see that change, maybe not. Bing/ChatGPT is promising, but ... nascent. A lot of this has echoes of the self-driving revolution.

Whenever I read techno-optimists on this site, I cannot help but think back to 2014-ish when they all predicted that there would be no truckers in 5 years and dramatic changes to infrastructure to support a wave of self-driving vehicles.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by neuronic on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @09:26AM (#34969620)
It is also questionable EVEN IF Facebook is just throwing cash at fads and has stopped being innovative. That doesn't mean shareholders will lose out which is the ONLY thing that counts.

The inevitable nature of large corporations is to become bureaucratic and slow, yet many of them exist for decades without being innovative. It's sufficient to just buy out whoever is innovative in the market - Microsoft just bought into OpenAI big time. Other than incrementally developing its 40yo operating system Microsoft copies AWS, Netflix for games, Sublime Text and Macbooks while throwing some random cash at garage projects that amount to effectively nothing that can exist without subsidies (Hololens).

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by jillesvangurp on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:27AM (#34971157)
It's a valid point though.

There's a difference between running a research lab and a product organization. I used to work in a research lab (Nokia Research). Lots of cool research. But product divisions routinely ignored what we were doing. Not invented here, not a priority, we're busy moving deck chairs around on our Titanic, etc. Very little industrial research translates into customer/product/share holder value.

Facebook, like several other big companies, pays a lot to keep some very smart people on staff. They constantly come up with new stuff that they publish about and that also result in patents. That's not the issue.

However, from there to product features is where it goes wrong. Most of Facebook's product portfolio hasn't changed substantially for quite some time. And they haven't really launched any noteworthy new stuff either. Publishing a paper doesn't really count. It's nice and it will no doubt help other companies to succeed where Facebook is clearly struggling to succeed.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by loudmax on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @12:28PM (#34972106)
That is my outsider impression of what's going on at Google. The ChatGPT interface that Microsoft is rolling out absolutely should have come from Google first. I'm sure they actually have the technology, and they've probably had it for years now. What Google lacks is any sort of leadership or discipline to turn a prototype into a marketable product.
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by jillesvangurp on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @01:32PM (#34972946)
I didn't want to bring it up but, yes, Google is obviously struggling with the disconnect between what they are doing in terms of research and product as well. And they are pouring billions into the research. They even spun off alphabet as a company to do all the blue sky research. With so far not a stellar track record. Mostly their revenue is just Google running on autopilot and vacuuming up ad revenue wherever it can.

Most large companies struggle with this. A lot of former industrial research labs have either disappeared entirely or became a shadow of their former selves. IBM, HP, etc. used to do lots of blue sky research. Xerox Parc was a big deal and they obviously failed to productize. But of course inspired Apple and quite a few others. It's a tough topic. I don't think many companies have figured this out.

There are positive examples of course but mostly the return on investment for open ended research in a corporate setting is not as high as it should be considering the valid research that gets published and then fails to get monetized by the companies doing the research.

OpenAI, is the smart counter move. Spin off a company, fund it, and then license back the technology. MS seems to have learned from it's past efforts in MS Research.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by uoaei on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:47AM (#34971496)
You are missing the "now" in the parent comment.

They are talking about actions in the last year or so.

Meta's open source projects that they own are maintained now by eager volunteers, not staff.

Anybody could see how Facebook is floundering, Instagram can see the iceberg approaching, and changing anything major in Whatsapp will piss off literally billions of people.

They've cornered themselves, so now they're reaching for literally anything that could save them. That seems reasonable as a failing company, except when every action they make affects entire markets and legitimizes trends on a very shaky basis.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by didntreadarticl on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @09:22AM (#34969567)
No fan of Meta but this week they did publish this, which is supposed* to outperform OpenAis models parameter-for-parameter

https://ai.facebook.com/blog/large-language-model-llama-meta...

* not sure if it actually does though

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by seydor on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @09:36AM (#34969723)
When did facebook innovate? They are known for copying everything from everyone. FacebookAI is the most important think to come out of them , but it s not really related to FB's core business
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by bretticus on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @09:48AM (#34969842)
PyTorch, React, GraphQL, Jest, FBOSS for data center networking, the list goes on.

Companies dream of creating just one of these.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by seydor on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:13AM (#34970168)
Now which of those are used by facebooks users
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by baobabKoodaa on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:42AM (#34970503)
Well, let's start with React. It's used by 100% of Facebook users.
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by throwaway1777 on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:15AM (#34970957)
Almost every request is graphql. ML also… all the ads and feeds use it.
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by seydor on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @02:36PM (#34973777)
React is an innovation, in what exactly? It bloats the web with needless javascript and abstractions. It's a convenient shortcut for people making native mobile apps. It's not taking the world forward
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by dougmwne on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:45AM (#34970540)
Not to mention tons of contributions to VR. They may have mismanaged the PR on that, but the product, as it exists is quite a thrill.
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by jklinger410 on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:01AM (#34970759)
Didn't they also contribute heavily to PHP?
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by xhkkffbf on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:06AM (#34970818)
Yes, their virtual machine was amazing. It brought all of the JIT technology and really sped up their PHP stack.
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by potamic on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:17AM (#34970983)
rocksdb, zstd compression, buck build system are also noteworthy that have far reaching impact across the industry.
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by HybridCurve on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @06:15PM (#34976308)
PyTorch was based on Torch, which facebook did not create.
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by timeon on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @09:51AM (#34969881)
I'm not fan of Facebook but what about React? Also if we are talking about "AI": https://mapwith.ai
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by seydor on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:13AM (#34970163)
Never used it , always thought it looked like an overcomplicated mess to keep people busy
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by seydor on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:53AM (#34970649)
People don't go to facebook because of react however. Sure any big company solves their scale problems in innovative ways.
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by mynameisvlad on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:59AM (#34970741)
You are the one who set up the goal posts. Just because you don’t like where you put them up doesn’t mean you can change them once people prove you wrong.

Nowhere did you say that Facebook’s innovations have to be the reason the end user uses the product, or even used by the end user at all. All you said is that they have never innovated. That is the bar. And it is clearly extremely low as Facebook has done lots of innovating with products used by developers all the time.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by seydor on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:16AM (#34970981)
I know we are in a bubble. Facebook did not grow because of graphql or vr, it grew because it copied and bought anything in sight. I guess most ppl are too young to remember, however.

I guess you could say that fb created some innovations, mostly in their labs, but they are not in the business of innovation

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by mynameisvlad on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:22AM (#34971082)
> Facebook did not grow because of graphql or vr, it grew because it copied and bought anything in sight. I guess most ppl are too young to remember, however.

> but they are not in the business of innovation

Who in this thread claimed they are in the business of innovation or that something is innovative only if it affects their direct customers? This entire response is a strawman, plain and simple.

Once again, your clearly defined bar is, and I quote:

> When did facebook innovate?

Stick to the bar you set and be humble when it’s clearly proven to be a dismally low bar.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by seydor on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:37AM (#34971345)
i did. i said their FB AI innovations are not related to their core business.

As much as we try to sugarcoat it, facebook is not known as a mobileUI or languageML company

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by mynameisvlad on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:51AM (#34971562)
Well it just so happens that most of the things people replied with (in fact, all of the things except PyTorch) have nothing to do with AI innovations, so great we can all agree to call them real innovations. Which is what they all are. And what you claimed Facebook doesn’t do.

The fact that you’re continuing to double down is astounding.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by seydor on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @02:38PM (#34973796)
It's more astounding that people forget what facebook is, what facebook does, and who is its target audience (not developers).
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by mynameisvlad on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @03:23PM (#34974315)
Those would all be great arguments… had that been where the goal posts were set.

But, referring back to all my previous posts, you set them at “when did Facebook innovate”.

Maybe next time you comment, you actually read what is being criticized and stick to that, rather than this strawman you keep putting up.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by rvz on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @12:07PM (#34971781)
Please. This is an escape hatch attempt to avoid being accountable for setting up goal-posts which have been easily met whilst you trying to also move them.

Even outside of AI with PyTorch, Facebook invented React and has been pervasively used by hundreds of millions of developers and billions on the web.

If neither of those are examples of Facebook's innovations on both the web and AI, then I don't know what is.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by seydor on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @02:04PM (#34973387)
> on both the web and AI

any company with tons of money is going to build some stuff thats innovative by virtue of hiring people completely irrelevant to its core product. FB is a social networking and ads company and it was not particularly innovative at that. It was not a web development house or an AI powerhouse, and it's still not (that's not where it makes its billions).

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by rvz on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @02:29AM (#34979704)
> any company with tons of money is going to build some stuff thats innovative by virtue of hiring people completely irrelevant to its core product.

So by your own goalposts, they DID release innovations then?

> FB is a social networking and ads company and it was not particularly innovative at that.

I wonder what those psychologists and engineers who worked on the Like button with the team who built the AI that is used from that, to Ads and the social graph would say about the billions of dollars and stock value that it has made for Facebook.

Again, you set those exceeding low goalposts for your point. If not even that is an example of an innovation relevant to Facebook's business and made it billions of dollars, then perhaps nothing is.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by greatpostman on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @10:50AM (#34970606)
Facebook invented PyTorch
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by avalys on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:04AM (#34970798)
What product innovation has Google produced in the last 5 years? Microsoft?
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by resource0x on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:08AM (#34970860)
Pearson Airport in Toronto is voted one of the worst airports in North America. They routinely lose your baggage, delay the flights indefinitely, people have to sleep on the floor, etc. - totally dysfunctional airport. This problem is not new - it has persisted for years. Finally, they found a solution: throw AI at it! Here's the announcement: https://www.narcity.com/how-pearson-airport-air-canada-new-a...

And now, this meta thing... :-)

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by xwowsersx on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:27AM (#34971155)
I'm not sure how airport logistics work, but isn't it the airlines that lose your luggage, as opposed to the airport itself? If that's right (I'm not sure it is) then it would seem unfair to criticize the airport for implementing facial recognition for boarding your flight. They are two different things — there's the airline issues and then airport-wide issues, no? Happy to be corrected.
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by resource0x on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @12:52PM (#34972440)
I don't know who is responsible for what, but in this particular instance, they work in tandem to create the most stressful experience for the passengers.

https://www.cbc.ca/player/play/2056928835691

https://www.gominplanet.com/blog/air-canada-the-worst-airlin...

My advice to anyone using Air Canada: upon arrival to the destination, don't waste time trying to find your suitcase on the carousel (it's not there anyway) - instead, go directly to the kiosk to complain about the lost luggage , otherwise you will have to stand in line for 2 hours. :-)

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by xwowsersx on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @11:15AM (#34983990)
Yikes, this sounds awful
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by JohnFen on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @03:06PM (#34974094)
I always thought that baggage handling at the airport itself was done by the airport as one of the services it provides to airlines.
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by barbazoo on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:28AM (#34971185)
"AI"

It's facial recognition.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by Insanity on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @12:12PM (#34971840)
Pearson is not the worst but depends on destination. (International flights have a nicer terminal, but national flight has been some years).

That said, Air Canada (also mentioned in the article) is also investing in AI while their default online booking process is still quite bad. Last time I wanted to book a flight with a pet, the website told me to book the flight without pet, then make a phone call to tell them I would be taking a pet with me (and cost would then depend on destination) just like two decades ago.

So I decided to use KLM and booked my flight, with pet, all through the website without needing a phone call.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by sixstringtheory on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @02:45PM (#34973868)
The one and only time I’ve flown out of Pearson internationally to go back home, it was in the top three worst airport experiences I’ve ever had out of hundreds of international and domestic trips, and the other two were understandably due to weather, while this was a gorgeous day with no delays.

Security took me almost three hours to get through, and they had a byzantine system where once you got to the end of what you thought was the entire line, you’d turn a corner to find another long one, and that happened six times.

It basically devolved into a system where it was just a huge crowd standing around, and as peoples’ flights were about to board they’d get moved to the front.

It reminded me of the freakonomics episode where they talk about the LIFO queue: https://freakonomics.com/podcast/what-are-you-waiting-for/

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by notfed on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @02:48PM (#34973900)
From the article "Pearson Airport's AI system is used during airport security to detect dangerous or prohibited items."

Uh, ok, I thought all airports have already been doing this for decades? One time I got pulled aside because the scanner thought my chocolate bar was a bomb.

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by MagicMoonlight on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:11AM (#34970895)
Their original idea came from theft. There was never any innovation, they just happened to get lucky.
Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by daqhris on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:23AM (#34971095)
Nope, they are the shoulders of a giant on which researchers and programmers are building the next AI tools and products.

See the open-source code repo of Meta Research. https://github.com/facebookresearch

Re:Zuckerberg: We're creating a top-level group at Meta focu... by a4isms on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @11:24AM (#34971115)
I can’t insist that you’re wrong, but note that it is a very normal thing in business for the leader in any space to devote large amounts of investment cash to covering moves that might turn out to be disruptive.

IBM famously did this with the IBM PC. They didn’t end up holding the lead in computing, but they certainly stayed relevant for another decade while their mainframe and minicomputer competitors struggled to get into personal computing but were late to the party.

In the pop-business book “Bottom-Up Marketing,” this is given as one of the key strategies to being the leader: Play Defence.

I wouldn’t say that a company playing defence by throwing cash at every fad that comes along necessarily means they are dying or dead. It just means they know they have to have a finger in every pie, “just in case.” It’s insurance.