I hate to be "defending" amazon here, but I doubt that they're doing this intentionally. In other words, they're not trying to retaliate against authors that had the audacity to have their books on torrent sites. Their behavior in this case resulted from a series of seemingly logical actions, at least when considered independently:
1. they have some sort of program which promises some sort of benefits (eg. higher royalties) in exchange for exclusivity
2. to enforce the above, they created an enforcement team to scour the internet looking for infractions
3. some worker was tasked with some vague task like "can you find this book on an alternate distribution platform?", and they were able to turn up some instances. Maybe it's not obvious to them that it's an unauthorized site (I don't pirate ebooks but some pirate streaming sites look plausibly "legit"), or they do but they don't give a fuck (the backoffice interface has a yes or no checkbox, and they're too lazy to draft an email to management informing of this edge case), so they flag that book as violating the agreement.
"Amazon is aware of the complaints and informs TorrentFreak that it’s working with the people involved to find an appropriate solution."
That's PR speak indicating they won't be reversing this policy and re-adding everyone banned. So now it's an official policy endorsed at a high level and can be criticized as such.
And with regard to the short time since publication, I don’t think the clock starts when there’s negative PR about an issue, nor when they are informed about an issue. The clock starts at the point where, if the system were well-run, they would have become aware of the issue. That is, neither ignoring an issue nor cultivating silos of ignorance should garner any sympathy.
You can see the full breakdown here: https://kdp.amazon.com/en_US/help/topic/G201541130
You can usually get Amazon to put the books back up, but it tends to take a while and is very disheartening having all your work removed. It's been a problem for years, but Amazon basically owns the market so there's not much you can do.
Isn't this actually an incredibly important part of every contract? Surely I would want any contract I'm part of to be clear about what happens if one of the relevant parties gets injured, or is unable to fulfill their obligations due to any reason beyond their control.
It's been clear for a long time now that if you use a Kindle you don't "own" the content you read on it. Very, very clear. Ironically I think it all started when an Orwell book was taken down. It's hard to feel sorry for Kindle buyers when this stuff has been known for a long time.
This whole book takedown thing is another dumb move that probably happened because someone thought it was a good idea to zealously enforce an exclusivity contract without realizing what would happen -- especially not realizing the possibility that third parties might put books on torrent sites in order to hurt the authors and get their books removed from Kindles.
When big companies do dumb things, people have a tendency to vastly overestimate the amount of thought and intention that went into it. This was probably a dumbass move by some mid-level person who thought they were helping.
In the mean time, though, I do feel like I'm doing the "right thing".
Clearly there are already ways to remove the DRM, and the lifespan of a Kindle is decades so they will not easily be able to add new DRM to the old hardware.
In my opinion, it's roughly analogous to Steam but it moves at a glacial pace.
The revenue gained from those devices is likely greater than the revenue lost from people pirating content who would actually pay for it.
There are blu-ray players which support Amazon video and they can not be updated by Amazon.
1) The Terms of Service for usage of Kindle devices are not relevant to a contract between Amazon and an author whose work is published through Kindle Unlimited.
2) Kindle Unlimited is a "all you can eat" subscription service. Users of the service explicitly do not own the books they download and read through it, just like you don't own the music you listen to on Spotify or whatnot.
No, but it's definitely relevant for Kindle users who purchased a book only to see it disappear from their devices!
Amazon also removed an anime I purchased in 2019. For a while it said it wasn't available to watch in my location. As of today it's trying to sell it to me again!
This is a common problem with digital storefronts - people think they bought something from store X, but they actually got it from store Y or on a different account.
Amazon remembers every order you've ever placed - including digital ones. Check whether you can find the order in your order history - if you can see the order, but not the item, Amazon customer support will add it to your account again.
In the case of the anime, I have the order on Amazon and can follow the link to the item. I also know a bit about the production and release of this anime in different markets and can assure you I'm not mistaken.
It was amazing!
He tried to monitize by selling it digitally on Amazon music. Amazon figured out he was sneaking around Audible, and stopped it.
Now I can’t download those “songs” - in fact they don’t exist anywhere in Amazon’s system.
Users who buy a book in a foreign country have lost the book when they got home.
Amazon accused them of flouting jurisdictions and trying to buy something not for sale in their country.
In fairness, there’s an audiobook I really, really want that isn’t available in the US Audible store, but is available in foreign Audible stores.
I really really want this book - it’s a poem I really love recited by a voice actor I really love.
But if I purchase it on a trip, or use a VPN Amazon could kill my entire Kindle/Audible collection.
So I bought the audio cassette on eBay.
Actually, no, that's even more irrelevant.
I feel like I'm repeating myself here, but: Kindle Unlimited is a subscription service. It is not the same as purchasing Kindle-formatted ebooks through the main Amazon web store, nor is it the same as a Kindle device. (Kindle Unlimited doesn't even require Kindle hardware; they're just both marketed under the same brand name.)
technically you don't own any music (aside from one you made on your own I guess), just own some kind of license to use it
Not everyone reads tech news. As long as Amazon uses "buy" rather than "rent" or "subscribe" I don't think most people will notice.
This sounds like something some government somewhere could go after Amazon for, but I very much doubt that it'll happen any time soon.
The "1984" incident happened in 2009 - nearly 14 years ago.
Amazon modified their terms and conditions to make it difficult for them to do something like that again.
I'm not sure that one example means anything in 2023.
Also, contract law varies a lot by country. What is allowed in the US may not be allowed in France for instance, adding an extra layer of complexity.
the question that has to be settled by the courts (if ever) is whether or not "buy" button is a bait-and-switch if Amazon reserves the right to rescind your purchase at any time without a refund.
which means you could go after the third party for getting the contract broken, but it's likely that what Amazon has in the terms allows them to do this.
There are limits to what contracts are allowed to legally do. And the idea that a contract can be broken, to the detriment of one side, due to the actions of a third party that neither has control over, and that the contract isn't primarily about, seems highly suspect.
Obviously there are some legitimate reasons for contracts around third-party actions -- betting, derivatives, insurance policies, and so on. Which are either for entertainment or risk mitigation.
But what Amazon is doing here simply feels abusive. However I'm not a lawyer so I don't know if there's a legal term for this type of "abuse" in contract law.