News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by jmyeet on Saturday February 25, 2023 @09:39PM (#34942527)
There are three important lessons to take away from the East Palestine derailment disaster:

1. All sides of the US political system represent corporate interests. Contemporaneously, Biden's DoJ filed an amicus brief in support of Norfolk Southern's case currently before the Supreme Court to limit lawsuits [1], the kind that will inevitably result from this kind of chemical release. And yes, the same Norfolk Southern;

2. Media isn't so much politically biased as it is a tool of and for corporate interests. The East Palestine case had a virtual media blackout for the first 1-2 weeks. Concurrently there was wall-to-wall media coverage about a Chinese balloon, a complete non-story. Think about that and why; and

3. As much as many will make (often legitimate) complaints about social media, independent reporting on East Palestine on social media absolutely forced the administration's hand into having to respond. Black clouds from burning vinyl chloride visible from planes flying by (and probably from space), dead fish in rivers, etc were getting wide distribution on Tiktok, Twitter and elsewhere.

There is failure here at every level. There is no single bad actor. A partial list:

- Allowing railroads to skirt safety to chase higher profits aka Precision Scheduled Railroading ("PSR");

- Failure of safety systems to detect and prevent such a crash;

- Failure to identify and disclose what had been and potentially could be spilled. Vinyl Chloride was known about quickly but there are other like contaminants that didn't come to light until later;

- The Ohio governor playing politics and not calling for Federal help;

- There are some large question marks with what Norfolk Southern did with that extra time. Who knows what evidence "disappeared"?

- The carriage carrying vinyl chloride itself was only preserved after a social media backed public outcry really forced the administration into action and the NTSB got involved;

- The administration's response was terrible. Biden could've absolutely forced Ohio's hand here by just talking about or even visiting the site;

- McKinsey alum and likely future presidential hopeful Pete Buttigieg as Transportation Secretary failed to respond in any way, probably not wanting to upset future donors;

- Testing at the site and the surrounding areas has largely been inadequate, mainly in what they're testing for or, more specifically, what they aren't testing for. There are contamination experts who have independently talked about this;

- Policy around what constitutes a hazardous train and the requiring brakes upgrades were rules initially proposed in the Obama administration, watered down after lobbying, repealed under Trump and not resinstituted under Biden;

- No one will go to jail for this and that's really what needs to happen. Fines are just the cost of doing business;

- You may find that liability for cleanup and compensation ends up being limited in some way. Fun fact (and example): Congress passed a law to limit liability for nuclear plant operators in the case of a disaster [2].

This is a systemic problem. It is not a Democrat vs Republican issue. Both sides are united behind corporate interests. Deregulation is nothing more than increasing profits by shifting costs to the public. The government is complicit in this.

I don't know how many times we'll need to pollute the environment and poison people before we start cottoning on to this.

[1]: https://www.levernews.com/bidens-doj-backing-norfolk-souther...

[2]: https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF10821#:~:te....

Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by gymbeaux on Saturday February 25, 2023 @10:07PM (#34942668)
The kinds of people who will read this comment are by and large not the people who need to take heed of its message. You’re yelling “fire” in a movie theater full of deaf people.
Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by somehowlinux on Saturday February 25, 2023 @10:15PM (#34942702)
Maybe one of them reads lips and can inform others.
Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by akira2501 on Saturday February 25, 2023 @10:12PM (#34942694)
There are very few rail companies and the sector is considered by some to be highly monopolized. You can draw easy connections between this situation and all three of your points.

If you let a company grow too large it's essentially impossible for the government to effectively regulate.

If you let a company grow too large it's essentially impossible for profit news companies to effectively cover it.

If you let a company grow too large it will eventually act in a manner so ridiculously irresponsible that you can literally observe the consequences from outer space.

This is a failure with seemingly a very simple root cause.

Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by hackernewds on Saturday February 25, 2023 @10:21PM (#34942741)
Why is it "essentially impossible"? It is entirely possible minus corruptible will
Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by paulryanrogers on Saturday February 25, 2023 @11:11PM (#34942951)
Perhaps because of regulatory capture. Though i would probably file that under corruption.

It may be harder to be corrupt when there is more competition in a market because each participant is less able to afford paying for your integrity.

Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by thepasswordis on Sunday February 26, 2023 @10:29AM (#34946263)
The justification the Biden administration gave when they broke the brewing strike was that supply chains are "essential infrastructure".

The implication there is that the train people can do whatever they want, because their industry is so important.

Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by jmyeet on Saturday February 25, 2023 @10:46PM (#34942852)
> If you let a company grow too large it's essentially impossible for the government to effectively regulate.

Tell that to China [1]. Not to get sidetracked, this isn't a statement about the merits of what China did here, just the fact that they could do it and did it.

You are alluding to corporate consolidationg being a problem, which it is, but that's only one facet. For example, the "money = speech" regime we've been in since Citizens United v. FEC is another big one. Another big one is Reagan era propaganda that many continue to treat as fact despite decades of evidence to the contrary (eg trickle down economics, deregulattion).

The solution for the rail freight industry in particular is to nationalize the whole thing, which of course will never happen.

[1]: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-56448688

Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by thepasswordis on Saturday February 25, 2023 @10:36PM (#34942810)
This is a great comment, however I just want to add some context. Brakes likely had nothing to do with this incident. The problem was a worn/damaged axle bearings.
Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by vxNsr on Saturday February 25, 2023 @11:13PM (#34942966)
You make a lot of good points but this one:

> Policy around what constitutes a hazardous train and the requiring brakes upgrades were rules initially proposed in the Obama administration, watered down after lobbying, repealed under Trump and not resinstituted under Biden;

Is irrelevant to this situation, better breaks would not have fixed this situation as the actual cause of the derailment was a failed axel. The breaks thing is a partisan talking point meant to deflect blame from the current administration.

Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by anonymouskimmer on Sunday February 26, 2023 @12:14AM (#34943255)
I've read that it's possible that better brakes could have resulted in fewer cars derailing.

https://www.statnews.com/2023/02/21/east-palestine-train-che...

> The current, age-old technology of hydraulic brakes meant that in the Norfolk Southern train’s case, when one car derailed, the entire train contracted and expanded like an accordion, sending many more cars off the rails.

I'm not positive it's accurate though, as the other articles I've read which mention cars accordioning mention that this is due to car placement (lighter loads between the engine and the heavier tanker loads). https://www.wfmj.com/story/48419813/lawsuit-alleges-poor-rai...

Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by vxNsr on Sunday February 26, 2023 @06:44AM (#34944805)
The other point to make is this train wouldn’t have qualified for the Obama regulations anyway so the whole point is moot.
Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by tptacek on Saturday February 25, 2023 @11:23PM (#34943020)
I don't know how you can take away the idea that the media is a tool of corporate interests, given that it's running stories about how the water in East Palestine is giving schoolchildren rashes and headaches, despite the fact that it hasn't been impacted at all by the derailment --- East Palestine draws its water from 5 wells that are presumably some of the most tested water in an America, and nothing has changed since before the derailment.
Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by jmyeet on Saturday February 25, 2023 @11:58PM (#34943186)
It's an issue of what stories get covered, how much they get covered and what angles are covered.

Example: the China balloon. This really serves the interests of the military-industrial complex (ie the "balloon gap" [1]) while playing into xenophobia.

As for East Palestine, you cannot overstate how much Tiktok altered the media narrative [2]. Train derailments actually happen all the time [3]. Norfolk Southern treated this as business as usual, including offering an insulting $25,000 to a town of 5,000 [4].

Mainstream media essentially had their hand forced by social media and circumstance into covering something they otherwise were ignoring.

[1]: https://www.barrons.com/articles/china-spy-balloon-defense-s...

[2]: https://www.wired.com/story/east-palestine-ohio-train-derail...

[3]: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/often-trains-derail-more-thin...

[4]: https://www.yahoo.com/now/norfolk-southern-giving-25-000-200...

Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by Natsu on Sunday February 26, 2023 @12:30AM (#34943319)
I saw something recently responding in the same vein, but to other stories: https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/the-media-very-rarely-...
Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by stevenhuang on Sunday February 26, 2023 @12:20AM (#34943269)
Consider that the alternative explanation for what we're seeing is maybe the balloon thing was just more interesting.

Mind you there is still the ongoing predicament with the 3 other unidentified objects that were presumably shot down that the military is strangely quiet on.

FYI the reason many are interested is because of the UAP/UFO connection. If what we've actually tried to shoot down were ET craft, that would be kinda headline grabbing wouldn't you think?

Train derailment happen all the time and for precisely this reason it may not garner as much genuine interest, irrespective how genuinely terrible a tragedy it was.

Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by washadjeffmad on Monday February 27, 2023 @10:49AM (#34957796)
The repetition of "train derailments happen all the time" is like introducing Chernobyl by saying power plants have service disruptions all the time. Not the story.

A train carrying a compound specifically recommended not to be transported by rail because of the hazard it poses as an environmental contaminant, the malfeasance and corruption that led to it being delisted and being on that train, and the subsequent political and legal maneuvering so as to minimize liability while mobilizing media to misdirect and trivialize the risk and endangerment to a town of people is the story.

Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by wombatpm on Sunday February 26, 2023 @01:23AM (#34943564)
TikTok altered the narrative.

This is why the US Government keeps freaking out about TikTok. They don’t know who gets to pull the strings with the algorithm. Is it pro environmental, antigovernment, anticoporate? They don’t have to censor, just figure out what slant do they want to promote ever so gently. And right now the US government is freaking out because they don’t know when or why the Chinese government exercises its control

Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by anonymouskimmer on Sunday February 26, 2023 @12:05AM (#34943208)
As of two days ago much of the testing had been botched in various ways: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/east-palestine-ohio-water-sam...

We'll see eventually, hopefully.

Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by woolion on Sunday February 26, 2023 @03:20AM (#34943970)
Great summary. I feel there could be a second one post detailing the finances of the political actors. They are not purely failing to do the job to represent the interest of their constituents by chance or by mistake. A simple start is just how much Norfolk Southern is giving, but that's a tiny fraction of the whole.

There are "failures" at so many levels that if these were indeed "mistakes", you would expect at least some people in the system to speak up. It's mind-boggling that despite the tragedy nobody within the system finds the moral courage to speak up. Except maybe the railwork workers that the current WH is trying to curtail.

Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by boppo1 on Sunday February 26, 2023 @05:05AM (#34944392)
>more specifically, what they aren't testing for. There are contamination experts who have independently talked about this;

More info on this part?

Re:Medical Response to a Vinyl Chloride Release from a Train... by anonymouskimmer on Sunday February 26, 2023 @01:35PM (#34948025)
Byproducts of combusting these chemicals, breakdown products as these chemicals degrade. Dioxin still hasn't been tested for as far as I am aware[1], and it is a known byproduct of the combustion of Vinyl chloride.[2] And it is believed that the atmospheric conditions present at the time of the combustion would have lead to its localized spread in the area. (can't find the reference for this at this time)

[1] - https://www.wtae.com/article/us-epa-considers-future-tests-f...

> "I'd have to consult my team," said EPA Administrator Michael Regan on Feb. 21, when asked at a news conference whether authorities had tested for dioxins in East Palestine. "I'm not quite sure if we're testing for dioxins yet. I know that it's under discussion."

...

> “The incomplete combustion byproducts of those chemicals – we have no idea what they are,” he said. “And they can potentially be highly toxic or carcinogenic.”

> Gao pointed out that when chemicals such as vinyl chloride burn in the open, it’s not possible to ensure a “complete” chemical reaction. It is therefore impossible to know for sure which byproducts are created without experimentation.

[2] - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10705663/

> Dioxin values measured in soils and plants were in the natural range of 20 ng I-TE/kg DS. These values increased to 8300 ng at the very seat of the fire only. With the water used for fire fighting vinyl chloride penetrated into the groundwater revealing values of up to 73 mg/litre.