https://theintercept.com/2018/11/22/israel-boycott-canary-mi...
https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2018-10-04/ty-article/.p...
Even a slight view into the history of israel should allow you to see that there is a valid and consistent basis for its opposition wholly separate from antisemitism, even if you don't endorse that opposition.
As well, non-israeli jews make up a significant portion of the leadership of these groups. Which doesn't inherently make it not antisemitic, I guess, but definitely indicates the situation is much more complex than simple antisemitism.
And also that yes, in the real world that will attract antisemites who oppose israel for that simple reason. In my experience though pro-palestine activists in the US are fairly sensitive to this dynamic and vigilant about not aligning with antisemitic groups who would be willing allies.
From https://thehill.com/opinion/international/454958-the-truth-a...
"There are many challenges in Israel, not the least of which is the plight of the Palestinians. This is a real challenge that needs to be addressed with urgency, coupled with the very priority of Israel’s security. Our energy should be more focused on what we can do to move toward peace, what we can we do to lift up the Palestinians in a sustainable way, and not isolate Israel in an anti-Semitic way.
BDS is not about the “pursuit of civil and human rights.” It’s not about the First Amendment. It is an attempt to demonize, delegitimize and apply a double standard to Israel—all three of Sharansky’s indicators. And we, as members of the Jewish and broader communities, should be willing to partner wholly with anyone truly committed to such an end, and not merely using it as cover for implicit anti-Semitic gains." "
At best its counter productive to peace, at worst its anti-semitic.
Robber: (takes your wallet)
Me: "hey, you took my wallet. You are a criminal."
Robber: "you are demonizing me. Also, are you calling everyone a criminal or just me? This is not legitimate criticism. The framework I invented (3D) to dictate what is and isn't legitimate criticism of me proves this."
Me: "guess I'm a nazi now"
If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
I've commented it somewhere else before: it looks to me that the "behavior-based opposition" is essentially "being a state while jewish", similar to "driving while black". There's plenty of valid reasons to pull people over and check their vehicles, police does it all the time. Yet when a cop exclusively pulls over black drivers, while the percentage of black drivers isn't close to 100%, it's probably not about the driving.
If someone allies themselves with Erdogan and Hamas, their critique isn't because of behavior, but because of who's the one doing it. Another fun example of that is the UN human rights council where such fine and outstanding human rights' advocates as Afghanistan, Qatar and Russia investigate israel. I'm sure you'll see my point: whatever they care about, it's certainly not human rights.
> In my experience though pro-palestine activists in the US are fairly sensitive to this dynamic and vigilant about not aligning with antisemitic groups who would be willing allies.
I've always been under the impression that it's mostly them being far left that keeps them from embracing the far right. To me they've never seemed shy about their ideas for israel's future, they're just not saying the quiet part out loud. They're academics after all, they understand that being too obvious will make the general population recoil in disgust.
For bonus points, can you explain why BDS is bad policy for the USA without calling it anti-semitic?
https://www.aljazeera.com/amp/news/2017/1/11/exclusive-israe...
There are also US laws in some states that prohibit divesting of universities from Israel, which were specifically written due to influence by lobbies. They breach the principle of freedom of association of the first amendment.
https://law.pacific.edu/law/conferences-and-symposia/boundar...
Look at anti-boycott laws
https://www.hrw.org/news/2019/04/23/us-states-use-anti-boyco...
Also BDS is an anti-semitic organization. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-54999010, https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-48312928, etc.
But if you refuse AJ as a source, how about Jewish Voice for Peace?
You can find articles from a variety of different sources on the silencing of activists due to lobbies.
https://www.jewishvoiceforpeace.org/2018/07/take-action-stop...
Also Jewish Voice for Peace is another biased source. I hate refuting articles based on that but its run by Jew-hating Jews. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_Voice_for_Peace "JVP has come under criticism from other Jewish groups that have branded the movement not only as anti-Semitic but also traitorous", "The Jewish Bulletin of Northern California wrote in 2003 that "the mainstream Jewish community" viewed "Jewish Voice for Peace as a group of radical Jews who air dirty laundry by criticizing Israel when the Jewish state is under attack. Some go as far as to label the members self-hating Jews." etc etc.
At its core I understanding banning BDS like that seems bad, but it has been massively co-opted by anti-semites that it is no longer acting in good faith at all, and supporters frequently violate the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Ds_of_antisemitism.
reading https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel_Anti-Boycott_Act I can understand the POV but I don't think its a constitutional violation? It doesn't ban it, as the jewishvoiceforpeace article also states. If you read the original legislation anyways, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_Administration_Act_of_1... and https://web.archive.org/web/20100612131929/https://www.bis.d... "They have the effect of preventing U.S. firms from being used to implement foreign policies of other nations which run counter to U.S. policy." Thats fundamentally what it is about.
https://www.salon.com/2022/02/02/anti-bds-law-in-texas-free-...
As for “self-hating Jews” I’m not sure those people would describe themselves as such. Much has been written about differences in the US Jewish community, but for an example of diversity of views on Israel among US Jews, you can see this pew research article.
https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/05/21/u-s-jews-ha...
Anyways, I think the evidence should be evaluated instead of labeling a source anti-this and anti-that without further investigation. You can even look at the BBC, which you cited, as being implicated in caving to pressure from pro-Israeli lobbies to censor itself.
https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20210602-bbc-sparks-outrag...
from the salon article
"Hanen "acknowledged that [a] pro-Palestinian view is protected by the First Amendment," said Abbas. "That may sound like little crumbs, but that's a controversial take, and it's a blessing."" its not a prevention of being pro-Palestinian or demonstrating any pro-Palestinian activtism, but specifically about BDS in the context of federal law regarding commerce and boycotting.
Trust me, I know about the differing opinions in our community. But there does tend to be some who reject their identity to appease the people persecuting us...
With the final link, the BBC really tries to be impartial so it makes sense they would review content? If they never add it back, or add an edited form back then I'd be more concerned. Plus "Foulkes explained that the series will be suspended from the site whilst an editorial review is carried out and that once the review has been completed, the BBC will decide which content to retire permanently and which to reinstate and / or edit."
My sides.
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/27/world/middleeast/bds-isra... - "Critics say B.D.S. is actually counterproductive to resolving the conflict, because it rejects Israel’s right to exist in spite of settled international law; encourages Palestinians to insist on the right of return for all refugees, which Israel is unlikely to ever accept in negotiations; pressures only one side to make concessions; and discourages bridge-building efforts between Israelis and Palestinians on the grounds that they “normalize” Israel. They say its rejection of the Jewish state distracts from debate over how to end the conflict and plays into the hands of right-wing Israeli opponents of a Palestinian state."
So its anti-semitic at worst but honestly unproductive at best.
https://thehill.com/opinion/international/454958-the-truth-a...
"There are many challenges in Israel, not the least of which is the plight of the Palestinians. This is a real challenge that needs to be addressed with urgency, coupled with the very priority of Israel’s security. Our energy should be more focused on what we can do to move toward peace, what we can we do to lift up the Palestinians in a sustainable way, and not isolate Israel in an anti-Semitic way.
BDS is not about the “pursuit of civil and human rights.” It’s not about the First Amendment. It is an attempt to demonize, delegitimize and apply a double standard to Israel—all three of Sharansky’s indicators. And we, as members of the Jewish and broader communities, should be willing to partner wholly with anyone truly committed to such an end, and not merely using it as cover for implicit anti-Semitic gains."
Looking at the Wikipedia article for Washington Examiner, it does not seem credible either.
(Context: I am American Jew who is Israeli citizen and grew up in Israel.)
For a much more nuanced view re ADL's claims (from a source you may find more trustworthy than me) I recommend reading https://forward.com/news/521941/jewish-campus-antisemitism-g...:
--------------------
''' The first reports from George Washington University last October were alarming: Someone had broken into a fraternity house and desecrated a Torah — tearing the scroll and dousing it with laundry detergent. The story spread like wildfire online; hundreds joined a campus vigil against antisemitism.
“The status quo, where Jewish students at this campus are fearing for their lives, has existed for far too long,” declared the fraternity president, Chris Osborne, choking up as he spoke.
Many Jewish students found the assertion exaggerated. The incident was upsetting, but hardly life-threatening: The “Torah” in question turned out to be a small replica, the kind you can buy for $20 at a synagogue gift shop.
And whoever entered the house the night before Halloween damaged the Torah while throwing hot sauce all over the kitchen, ripping out smoke detectors and toppling appliances; Tau Kappa Epsilon is not a Jewish fraternity and the motive of the crime was unclear.
D.C. police closed their investigation a week later without any leads. But in certain quarters, the incident was held up as a kind of Kristallnacht on fraternity row, heralding the peril of Jews at universities nationwide. The head of the Anti-Defamation League condemned it as a “blatant act of antisemitism,” and Algemeiner, a right-leaning Jewish news outlet, called it one of the year’s “most shocking instances of campus antisemitism.”
...
Even those who were sympathetic to the missions of national Jewish organizations said the attention they lavish on the campus can sometimes miss the mark. Too often, they said, the spotlight bends toward histrionics, obscures positive Jewish experiences or simply overwhelms the 18-to-22-year-olds as they seek to navigate the complex politics of Israel and Jewish identity while still making it to class on time.
“All these organizations have their own agenda,” said Jessica Carr, 21, a senior and president of GW for Israel. “Even though we might agree with them — we’re all pro-Israel — they all have their own agenda and it’s not necessarily what’s best for GW.”
Beyond college campuses, rising antisemitism in the United States has included synagogue shootings, a rabbi taken hostage during Shabbat services, and beatings of visibly Orthodox Jews in New York. The campus incidents documented by the ADL almost never involve violence and are usually related to Israel. '''
Interesting. Good article. I can see some of the acts may have been blown out of proportion, and I think it is dangerous to paint _all_ pro-Palestinian activism as anti-semitic. I mean I support all peoples having a home in Israel.
Its just a problem of engrained anti-semitism, propaganda, and students not using their brain enough of the time I guess so most pro-Palestinian activities just get taken over by the loud voices of anti-semites.
Stuff like "But most of these students “personally never experienced antisemitism and did not know of any antisemitic occurrences on campus,” Aeder wrote in a recent essay. “Their fear of antisemitism was informed not by their own experiences, but by what they read online and on social media.”" is interesting.
As for the apartheid analogy, there's some truth to it and also many differences than what happened in South Africa. The big elephant in the room is that no Palestinian leadership, ever, in the last 100 years actually accepted Zionism / a Jewish state in any kind of borders. So settlements or no settlements we are left with some kind of security control / martial law that Israel will have to keep over the Palestinians for its survival. Is that apartheid? Not in my eyes no. But the settlements are (and are very controversial within Israel btw, and some of them were dismantled). Is all this enough for anyone who identifies as a Zionist to be attacked/harassed automatically without even hearing what he has to say? For you it seems like it is. Shouldn't then Americans be spat at as soon as they open their mouths over what happened in Iraq? I mean some people say Americans murdered one million people for no good reasons why does this get a pass? The Israeli Palestinian conflict is peanuts compared to some of the adventures the U.S had and Israel at least has a good reason to fight, what's the U.S excuse?
Israel is, and will always be, internationally on the nose for what happened in that region and after the war. Even to people like me who are sympathetic to the historical persecution, brute forcing yourself onto a land you feel your people have a spiritual connection to and forming an ethnic state is fucked up.
I love Jewish people. I've met lots of amazing Israelis and understand the issues, but settling in that region was fucking silly and always going to yield this conflict and the dismay of the world.
Really? That's surprising actually. Have a good one!
I remember a professor at my university about whom a fake website claiming he sexually harassed a student was created. Of course the claims were false but because he was an advisor for the Palestine club his name was dragged through mud.