News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Israelis Destabilizing Democracy and Disrupting Elect... by giraffe_lady on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @10:40AM (#34805237)
How, I'm genuinely curious. I know that's a common response to it but I find it hard to see.

Even a slight view into the history of israel should allow you to see that there is a valid and consistent basis for its opposition wholly separate from antisemitism, even if you don't endorse that opposition.

As well, non-israeli jews make up a significant portion of the leadership of these groups. Which doesn't inherently make it not antisemitic, I guess, but definitely indicates the situation is much more complex than simple antisemitism.

And also that yes, in the real world that will attract antisemites who oppose israel for that simple reason. In my experience though pro-palestine activists in the US are fairly sensitive to this dynamic and vigilant about not aligning with antisemitic groups who would be willing allies.

Re:The Israelis Destabilizing Democracy and Disrupting Elect... by localplume on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @10:59AM (#34805570)
It often falls into https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Ds_of_antisemitism. Criticism is legitimate, criticism of the current government is legitimate, but when one side starts genocidal chants but backpedals and states it isn't anti-semitic then its hard believe them. It probably really depends on who the activists are/what organizations they are with etc.

From https://thehill.com/opinion/international/454958-the-truth-a...

"There are many challenges in Israel, not the least of which is the plight of the Palestinians. This is a real challenge that needs to be addressed with urgency, coupled with the very priority of Israel’s security. Our energy should be more focused on what we can do to move toward peace, what we can we do to lift up the Palestinians in a sustainable way, and not isolate Israel in an anti-Semitic way.

BDS is not about the “pursuit of civil and human rights.” It’s not about the First Amendment. It is an attempt to demonize, delegitimize and apply a double standard to Israel—all three of Sharansky’s indicators. And we, as members of the Jewish and broader communities, should be willing to partner wholly with anyone truly committed to such an end, and not merely using it as cover for implicit anti-Semitic gains." "

At best its counter productive to peace, at worst its anti-semitic.

Re:The Israelis Destabilizing Democracy and Disrupting Elect... by alldayeveryday on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:20PM (#34808215)
Complete and utter pilpul you've deployed here. By your logic, only Israel/jews are permitted to define what is and isn't legitimate criticism. Let's walk through an example:

Robber: (takes your wallet)

Me: "hey, you took my wallet. You are a criminal."

Robber: "you are demonizing me. Also, are you calling everyone a criminal or just me? This is not legitimate criticism. The framework I invented (3D) to dictate what is and isn't legitimate criticism of me proves this."

Me: "guess I'm a nazi now"

Re:The Israelis Destabilizing Democracy and Disrupting Elect... by AzzieElbab on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @02:53PM (#34809665)
You honesty do not see a problem with casually labelling Jews as robbers?
Re:The Israelis Destabilizing Democracy and Disrupting Elect... by sangnoir on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @04:36PM (#34810920)
They did no no such thing.
Re:The Israelis Destabilizing Democracy and Disrupting Elect... by AzzieElbab on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:46PM (#34812680)
Because context doesn’t matter?
Re:The Israelis Destabilizing Democracy and Disrupting Elect... by dang on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @10:26PM (#34814609)
We've banned this account for using HN primarily for political and ideological battle. That's not allowed here, regardless of what politics or ideology you're for or against.

If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

Re:The Israelis Destabilizing Democracy and Disrupting Elect... by luckylion on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:29PM (#34807369)
> Even a slight view into the history of israel should allow you to see that there is a valid and consistent basis for its opposition wholly separate from antisemitism, even if you don't endorse that opposition.

I've commented it somewhere else before: it looks to me that the "behavior-based opposition" is essentially "being a state while jewish", similar to "driving while black". There's plenty of valid reasons to pull people over and check their vehicles, police does it all the time. Yet when a cop exclusively pulls over black drivers, while the percentage of black drivers isn't close to 100%, it's probably not about the driving.

If someone allies themselves with Erdogan and Hamas, their critique isn't because of behavior, but because of who's the one doing it. Another fun example of that is the UN human rights council where such fine and outstanding human rights' advocates as Afghanistan, Qatar and Russia investigate israel. I'm sure you'll see my point: whatever they care about, it's certainly not human rights.

> In my experience though pro-palestine activists in the US are fairly sensitive to this dynamic and vigilant about not aligning with antisemitic groups who would be willing allies.

I've always been under the impression that it's mostly them being far left that keeps them from embracing the far right. To me they've never seemed shy about their ideas for israel's future, they're just not saying the quiet part out loud. They're academics after all, they understand that being too obvious will make the general population recoil in disgust.