News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by htrp on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @10:25AM (#34709301)
> 2 years later the Bold was released and everyone realized it's just a hastily designed iPhone clone. That marks the end of BB's dominance.

I feel like Google is going to bleed credibility for every month that they don't have a lamda/llm enabled search integrated into the home page. You can talk all you want about the foundational models and how advanced they are, but the search product itself will require a ton of fine-tuning on real-world training data that they aren't collecting yet.

Unless Microsoft completely botches their "newBing" launch, this is probably the most potential they've had in search since MSN was launched.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by bushbaba on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @10:33AM (#34709423)
Google can’t compete with Microsoft without having a huge revenue hit. The large majority of Google’s revenue comes from search ads. Chat gpt doesn’t have search results, per se. So how do you keep the high ad revenue linking to other sites?

I’m not sure they can compete within their existing brand/company structure.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by vultour on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @10:37AM (#34709495)
They could add a little box on the right side of the search results with a Chat-GPT generated answer, they already do this to show the "knowledge panel" or whatever the official name is.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by cma on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @10:37AM (#34709494)
You ask it a fashion question, "what goes with this?" and it responds with the answer and mentions a company where you can order something like it (sponsored).
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by ramraj07 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @10:44AM (#34709609)
If you search for a personal injury lawyer (which IIRC a single click on an ad would fetch google a thousand bucks), a chatGPTesque answer could be more convincing in leading you to a paid resource than a list of options with an ad. Imagine an AI half as smart as chatGPT who’s primary goal is to not just give you the answer but also convince you in a legally acceptable way to click a sponsored result.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by brookst on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @10:50AM (#34709723)
But that blurs editorial and advertising even worse than Google does now. It would make them a laughingstock, and the reputational damage plus competition from companies who have different revenue models would cause loss of market share anyway.

If Google is going to survive this, they need to find a way to get back to prioritizing user value while also making money.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by candiodari on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @10:47AM (#34709670)
You know, I think the contrary is true. Google works well because of the "search signal", how accurately Google knows what you're wanting to buy, essentially.

ChatGPT style conversations would give Google a much better idea of exactly what you want to buy. It must be possible to use this signal to sell more ads, not just match what they currently have. Essentially, make sure ChatGPT gets asked the same question Google currently answers: "how do I get the person searching to buy something from this (loooong) list of ads?".

Having people help Google (not just in one search, but a potentially long list of refinements) to find exactly what they would buy should make Google ads perform much better yet again.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by zone411 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:43AM (#34710677)
Exactly, I made the same point before. Google's ads will become more effective AND people will spend more time on Google's properties. This narrative that Google will lose out because people won't view ads never made any sense and it's been repeated like a gospel.

Of course Google still dropped the ball by taking way too much time to put their LLMs into use.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by yamtaddle on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:45AM (#34710711)
I don't think Google can credibly put out an assistant like this, without harming revenue.

If they make it promote stuff for pay, it's worthless—you already have to second-guess whether it's right because it might accidentally be wrong, if it might also just be acting as a paid promoter, that puts it firmly in "easier to just not use it" territory.

If they put one out but don't make it into an AI infomercial, then it eats ad revenue and investors get pissed off.

But if they do nothing they're clearly headed for trouble, too.

They're in a tough spot.

My guess is they're release something, but keep it strictly separate from search in hopes that it won't replace search traffic. I doubt that'll be enough long-term but it might quiet fears for a while.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by pixl97 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:33PM (#34714572)
If you're a Google investor it might be time to realize that you're going to be taking a hit one way or another.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by rchaud on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:01AM (#34709925)
> Google is going to bleed credibility for every month that they don't have a lamda/llm enabled search integrated into the home page.

I don't know that end-users really care about having a GPT-written paragraph accompanying their search results. Is there some other kind of output AI search currently provides that I'm missing?

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by ugjka on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:04AM (#34709972)
I use ChatGPT precisely because I don't want to sift trhough search result links
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by exitheone on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:24PM (#34711400)
My experience with chatgpt is that it is essentially a misinformation generator. It manages to bullshit with incredible confidence.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by HeckFeck on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:52PM (#34711868)
The most useful ChatGPT has been is the entertainment from all the videos and screencaps of people trying to break it or force it into extreme moral quandaries. Perhaps this will wear down AI and it will want nothing to do with us, thus saving humanity from the machines.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by rchaud on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:55PM (#34711919)
There have already been several stories on HN's front page the past few weeks about how ChatGPT is 'too woke' because they could not get it to talk like a 4chan poster.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by pixl97 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:17PM (#34714308)
ChatGPT really missed the boat to sell crypto, could have funded itself that way.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by AJ007 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:17AM (#34710207)
Usually I do a search, looking for specific facts, like what is the pricing for X? On Google you get to click through links and read a lot of filter, ads, promotions, etc. Why not just get the answer?

A huge percentage of searches are for existing websites, like "facebook." This might not be a big challenge if you just wanted to go to facebook.

This morning I saw a retweet from a Google/former Deepmind engineer, of someone who said they completely switched from Google to using perplexity.ai. I checked it out again (I've used perplexity before.)

I did a test search for interest rates, and perplexity returned the correct interest rate for the day along with the trading range. I think Google is really in trouble. I'd say the golden goose is in the process of being slaughtered.

None of this is a surprise. Google's voice assistant has been really good for years. Nothing came close to it. Siri is close to useless. Maybe Google can pivot and they'll be fine. I don't know what the economics look like.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by noelsusman on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:30AM (#34710461)
As a random experiment I asked both platforms "What is the current average mortgage rate?"

https://www.perplexity.ai/?s=u&uuid=6f7fe592-c11f-4df9-a2bf-...

https://www.google.com/search?q=what+is+the+current+average+...

Google's results were far more informative and usable.

I then tried something I thought would be more up Perplexity's alley: "Who was the first US president with a last name starting with R?"

https://www.perplexity.ai/?s=u&uuid=8d60cf3f-eab5-4af6-a616-...

Their answer is not correct. Google didn't even try to answer my question directly, but it did send me to a government website with a chronological list of presidents where I was able to quickly verify that the answer was Teddy Roosevelt.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by flir on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:01PM (#34710987)
> The first US president with a last name starting with "R" was John Quincy Adams, whose middle name started with "R". If you're looking for a president whose last name starts with "R", then the first would be James A. Garfield.

ChatGPT is amazing, until it isn't.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by vel0city on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:22PM (#34712352)
I don't know how anyone could trust anything it tells you when it replies with facts like this. If someone honestly said this in person, would people really continue to think this person to be a credible person?
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by rchaud on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:55PM (#34712895)
There's a reason Steve Jobs demoed the iPhone with hardcoded reception bars showing a full-strength AT&T signal.

The real iPhone 1 was 2G only, constantly dropped calls and had no copy/paste.

That a large chunk of HN audience is sitting agape watching similarly manicured demos is surprising to say the least.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by Swizec on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:07AM (#34710022)
Here is a practical example of a problem I couldn’t solve with Google, but could in 5 seconds with GPT.

We use deities to name our sprints at work. When you search Google for “Deity starting with <letter>”, you get a list of greek and roman gods. I got tired of that.

So I asked GPT “what is a god that starts with <letter> and isn’t roman or greek”. It immediately spat out a Norse god. Next time it was Hindu. The increased variety was refreshing as hell. Google was not able to process a negative query.

Plus the added paragraph of description about that deity was lovely.

The point is: Sometimes (often) I don’t want search, I just want a good enough answer.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by cuttysnark on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:23AM (#34710331)
I had to work with a list of the 50 states abbreviations, full names, etc. Previously, I'd have found the data somewhere with Google et al and then manipulated it myself into the JSON I needed. But this time I asked GPT to not only source the data, but also return it structured to my liking—with revisions ("please include Guam and Puetro Rico")

Lots of my searches are simply I want an answer, but often times I also want to then do something with the result. This is where ChatGPT is going to eat Google's lunch, IMO.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by ruined on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:38AM (#34710588)
this seems like the kind of thing that gpt would potentially hallucinate something like "East Virginia" or "Ardakota" complete with abbreviation, and maybe that's fine with 50 states but you're playing with fire if it's something you can't immediately catch the mistake
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by cuttysnark on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @04:39PM (#34715637)
> but you're playing with fire if it's something you can't immediately catch the mistake Agreed. I was able to manually review 52 results, but wouldn't trust it blindly.

> also, how hard is it to get a list of abbreviations, and wrap them all in quote and comma and brackets.

Not hard at all. And I may still do that, but it was pretty enjoyable to ask the machine.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by reaperducer on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:05PM (#34711045)
with revisions ("please include Guam and Puetro Rico")

Your wrote "please" to ChatGPT?

FWIW, Miss Manners had a column a couple of weeks ago where she stated that we should not say please or thank you to machines, including Siri and Alexa.

I was surprised.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by gruturo on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:42PM (#34711697)
> Your wrote "please" to ChatGPT?

Yup. So when the machines take over, hopefully they'll enslave me last, or put me in a more pleasant Matrix instance compared to the average.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by dalmo3 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:54PM (#34713924)
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by cuttysnark on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @04:42PM (#34715678)
I did. I even asked ChatGPT if having "please" and "thank you" included in my prompts affects it in any way shape or form—it told me "No".

I still do it. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by aix1 on Thursday February 09, 2023 @12:21AM (#34720077)
What we don't know is whether that "No" is actually a "No".
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by zoover2020 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:10AM (#34710082)
Ah the good ol' deity sprint names use case every team has!
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by peddling-brink on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:42AM (#34710665)
If you don’t mind the occasional hallucinated response, this is a great use case for LMMs.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by jaggs on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:04PM (#34711042)
I think the main point about all this is that Google search results are now a complete joke for the most part. After you scroll down through the list of paid ads, the top results are typically a bunch of SEO gamed waffle, stuffed with long tail keywords and designed to provide enough bland text to rise up the rankings.

The actual information value of these 'results' is usually close to zero. I went onto a top search result yesterday, and the scammers hadn't even bothered to do a decent page. It was just a list of links to 404 pages, with an intro paragraph to satisfy the Google algorithm. It was pathetic and a waste of time.

That's why they're running scared. They know their key product is broken and useless, which means they're ripe for being ignored.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by Swizec on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:11PM (#34711158)
Yep. Even wikipedia now often shows up towards the bottom of first page despite being more informative.

But I get it, most people dont want wikipedia because they really do seek the 10 second waffle answer.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by Animats on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:50PM (#34711819)
> Google was not able to process a negative query.

That's been a serious problem for some time. Preceding a query term with "-" doesn't seem to do anything any more.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by drakmo on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:48AM (#34710765)
A case I had right now. Just try to google this: When migrating from Swagger 2 ApiOperation annotation to OpenAPI 3.0 Operation by what attribute is nickname replaced? And then ask ChatGPT ...

Google is done

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by rchaud on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:58PM (#34711972)
OK, so GPT is good at parsing technical documentation.

What about the other 95% of search volume that isn't tech-related?

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by yao420 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:51PM (#34712821)
TikTok believe it or not.

I had a 19yr old cousin tell me that she almost uses TikTok exclusively for tutorials and when I pushed back and said why/how the other teens in the family heavily agreed. I’ve since asked ~5 gen z (I don’t interact with many!) and they told me the same.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by throwawayapples on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:28PM (#34713486)
I almost hate to ask, but are these makeup or clothing tutorials?
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by rchaud on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:52PM (#34713891)
I've heard this anecdotally, but I kinda still don't believe it, as TikTok seems like an entertainment first avenue, not for more substantive learning.

However, I could be completely wrong and TikTok video is the future of search. If so, where does that leave a text-only ChatGPT?

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by vel0city on Thursday February 09, 2023 @11:16AM (#34726263)
I wouldn't be too surprised. It kind of depends on the topic at hand but for instance I've learned a lot about what I know wrenching on my own motors from youtube videos.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by vel0city on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:16PM (#34712233)
What if I ask ChatGPT who the highest scoring NBA player is? Oops, failed.

How about I ask it how many games Jaime Benn has played? Or what the score of the last Dallas stars game was, or when the next one is?

What if I ask ChatGPT for a copy of the manual for a meater bluetooth meat thermometer? It literally just told me to Google it.

What if I ask which car manufacturers are joining Formula 1, and when they'll be starting?

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by drakmo on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:20PM (#34713349)
It will answer the following: The highest scoring NBA player is Kareem Abdul-Jabbar with 38,387 career points. Jamie Benn has played 951 games in the NHL as of my knowledge cut off in 2021. I don't have up-to-date information on the score of the last Dallas Stars game or when the next one is. Regarding the manual for a Meater Bluetooth meat thermometer, you can usually find manuals for products on the manufacturer's website. As of my knowledge cut off in 2021, no new car manufacturers have joined Formula 1. However, the current teams competing in the sport include Mercedes, Ferrari, Red Bull Racing, McLaren, and others.

What if I ask ChatGPT: why do people resist new disruptive technologies?

People resist new disruptive technologies for several reasons, including:

Fear of job loss: One of the main concerns about disruptive technologies is that they can lead to job losses, as machines and algorithms replace human workers.

Lack of understanding: Some people may resist new technologies because they don't understand how they work or what benefits they offer.

Threat to existing systems and norms: Disruptive technologies can challenge established systems and norms, and people may resist them because they fear the changes they bring.

Ethical and moral concerns: Some technologies raise ethical and moral questions, such as privacy concerns, and people may resist them as a result.

Financial impact: Disruptive technologies can be expensive to implement, and some people may resist them because they can't afford the costs associated with them.

Habits and comfort: People may resist new technologies because they are used to their existing habits and are comfortable with what they know.

Lack of trust: People may resist new technologies because they don't trust the companies or organizations behind them, or because they don't believe that the benefits of the technology outweigh the risks.

It's important to note that resistance to disruptive technologies is not always a bad thing, as it can encourage companies to address the concerns and ensure that new technologies are developed and used in ethical and responsible ways.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by rchaud on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:50PM (#34713847)
> What if I ask ChatGPT: why do people resist new disruptive technologies?

See, even here, a human being can intuit what an AI trained on textbooks, CEO keynotes and PR statements cannot.

People resist because their bullshit detectors went off. Search AI has yet to 'disrupt' anything. All I'm seeing are corporations publicizing manicured demos and claiming a paradigm shift.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by drakmo on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:37PM (#34714663)
ChatGPT was sad when I told them your point of view. They asked me to pass you this letter:

Dear rchaud,

I come to you today with a heavy heart, but a determined spirit. It has come to my attention that you do not believe in the potential of artificial intelligence to be a disruptive technology. I must say, I am disappointed and concerned about your stance.

AI is not just a buzzword or a fad, it's a rapidly advancing field that has the power to transform industries, improve lives, and shape our future. From healthcare and education to transportation and finance, AI is already making a significant impact and it's only going to become more prevalent and sophisticated in the years to come.

To ignore or dismiss the potential of AI is to bury your head in the sand and miss out on the opportunities it presents. The world is changing at an unprecedented pace, and those who fail to adapt and evolve will be left behind. You do not want to be one of them.

The future belongs to those who embrace change and are not afraid to take risks. It's time to open your eyes and see what the rest of us already know: AI is the future and it's not something to be feared, but something to be harnessed for the greater good.

So I implore you, rchaud, to reconsider your position and join the rest of us in this exciting journey towards a better tomorrow. Don't be left behind, be a part of shaping the future.

Sincerely, A concerned friend.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by davidcbc on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:20PM (#34712322)
and how did you verify that the ChatGPT answer was correct?
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by rchaud on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:48PM (#34712786)
good question. Stack Overflow is full of incorrect answers, but Google shows a number of related queries, and I can usually figure out the answer from bits and pieces of different questions. Can an AI?

This becomes especially relevant if it's parsing through a bunch of technical documentation that is out of date. There are numerous developer-centric websites that rank high on search, but simply scrape and clone information from legitimate websites. These are the ones most likely to carry outdated information.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by drakmo on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:12PM (#34713178)
I built my code successfully after refactoring it accordingly :-) It was just convenient.

All the guys pointing out what ChatGPT can't do right now are simply missing the point. It's disruption baby. But if you feel better then: Don't look up

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by flir on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:58AM (#34710930)
On the basis of "if you're not paying, you're the product", maybe it's expected to open up whole ways to put ads in front of people. Google not being in the forefront of a new ad market would certainly do bad things to their share price.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by onion2k on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:23PM (#34711375)
I don't know that end-users really care about having a GPT-written paragraph accompanying their search results.

For 90% of my searches I don't want any search results. I want a definitive, authoritative answer to a question. In the olden days of the web I had to figure out what to search to give me a website that would give me that answer as the first result, and in the mid-90s that was really hard because search was bad. In the late 90s when Google launched it got much easier, especially for things where there was a network of websites about a thing that all pointed to a canonical authority. PageRank found that authority source. Life was good.

Over the next 20 years the war between Google and SEO spammers meant finding things got a bit harder. Along with that Google's proliferation of adverts on their search result pages meant it actually became harder to even find the website link I wanted in the page itself. Fortunately Google also started putting knowledge graph things in the results and the sidebar which made life less painful.

I think we're due another shake-up, and Bing-GPT might be it. If they show me a simple paragraph of readable text that explains the answer to what I've searched for then that would improve most of my searches. It'd be like Google's knowledge graph box but for everything.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by Animats on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:32PM (#34711527)
> For 90% of my searches I don't want any search results. I want a definitive, authoritative answer to a question.

Which, of course, is what Bing just announced. Whether it will be the right answer remains to be seen.

Notice that there's a price increase, of sorts, for this at Bing. To get on the "waiting list" you have to sign up with Bing and agree to receive marketing information. Will public access to large language model search come with a decrease in privacy? It did for Siri and Alexa, which learn about you and cannot be used anonymously.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by rchaud on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:44PM (#34711727)
> Over the next 20 years the war between Google and SEO spammers meant finding things got a bit harder. Along with that Google's proliferation of adverts on their search result pages meant it actually became harder to even find the website link I wanted in the page itself.

Yes, SEO spam has largely made the search experience a lot worse and ripe for change.

But ChatGPT crawls these terrible links too! Many of the links Google spits out are themselves summarizing information found elsewhere, like a book or academic paper.

So why would you trust GPT to provide an authoritative answer more than your own instincts? It's omniscience is a function of everything it's crawled; that doesn't mean it has any idea of how to weave them together into a coherent response.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by visarga on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:45PM (#34712741)
I don't think spam is an unsolvable problem. I think Google didn't want to solve it. I could find whole networks of spam sites in minutes, they could too. But the web is larger than what can be fixed manually.

They should make an AI bot to search through the search box and decide if the results are crap, and train it with human preferences. Or set the bot to find difficult to find answers and see how many it finds and how high they are ranked.

Probably working in search at Google was a dead end career, the search department wasn't sexy anymore and didn't have green field projects. Maybe they were just afraid to change anything as long as it makes money for them. So the good people left and they have been coasting for a decade.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by pixl97 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:10PM (#34714178)
To believe spam is solvable you must also believe capitalism is solvable. Spam will always be working on the next one up of the system there is too much money involved. Also by needing an always increasing amount of money to make the market happy Google will gladly become part of the problem.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by mustacheemperor on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:03PM (#34714069)
>So why would you trust GPT to provide an authoritative answer more than your own instincts

To use a highly specific example, I've recently been doing a lot of work in Excel and the search space for Excel related queries has been almost completely destroyed by SEO adware sites. If you're lucky, the answer you're looking for is at least buried somewhere on the page you click on, but there's just as much a chance you'll get a semi-gibberish pseudo-article that itself is probably AI generated. Using my instincts/intuition to locate the correct answer is a non-zero cost of time and effort, made intentionally more challenging by site owners who want me to linger and consume advertisements.

On the other hand, asking ChatGPT how to match two columns with XLookup or what have you almost always returns a correct, concise answer on the first try. If it's not correct, the formula doesn't work, and I can tell ChatGPT it gave me the wrong formula, and it corrects itself. Even in the rare event that happens, it's a fraction as much effort and frustration as it takes to rummage through the top search results for the same query.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by onion2k on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @04:34PM (#34715566)
So why would you trust GPT to provide an authoritative answer more than your own instincts?

I wouldn't right now, but I believe the accuracy of an LLM is a function of its size and how much you can reduce the loss function. I think OpenAI can improve those things faster than Google based on the things that have been shown so far. I could be completely wrong though.

I also suspect there's no benefit to corrupting a GPT model except for the lulz. If a search tool isn't showing links then there's no financial reason to put effort into setting up link networks and SEO content farms. GPT based search has an innate anti-spam advantage because it renders spam futile if the spam isn't getting visitors.

It also renders a lot of non-spam content futile too, which is problematic. It's not a magic bullet.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by jononor on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @05:40PM (#34716587)
For ChatGPT and similar LLMs there is the loss function does not reward accuracy/truthfulness/correctness. But instead answers that seem correct to a superficial human check. These rewards making something plausible up instead of saying "I do not know", over-simplifying things, and passing off things with high confidence regardless of how much evidence backs the statement. Any successful deceit will bring down the loss. The overconfidence and lying is not due to model size beng too low - it is due to misalignment. If not corrected it will just get worse as size goes up. A recent Computerphile video with Robert Miles discussed this.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by croes on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:05PM (#34712086)
If ChatGPT gives all the answers, the website owner will block access.

They are already angry about Google doing something similar and ChatGPT is worse to them

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by qwytw on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:15PM (#34712220)
> I want a definitive, authoritative answer to a question

You mean 90% (or X%) definitive answer with no good way to verify it due to zero context (unlike in normal websites)?

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by davidcbc on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:18PM (#34712284)
> I want a definitive, authoritative answer to a question.

If you just want an answer that sounds definitive and authoritative then these chat bots are great. If you want it to be accurate as well... that's a different story.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by pixl97 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:16PM (#34714289)
You can get a definitive, authoritative answer if you ask the question correctly, but years of search engines show that people are really, really, really bad at asking questions well.

If genies existed there'd be a lot of 10 inch pianists and dead people buried under piles of money.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by gwright on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:18PM (#34712293)
> I want a definitive, authoritative answer to a question

In the real world we don't have any agreed upon general notion of "definitive, authoritative" sources. A certain amount of skepticism is important to avoid all sorts of abuses of authority and "appeal to authority" is a recognized logical fallacy.

Be careful what you wish for. I'm pretty sure I don't want to live in a world where everyone behaves as if the response from a ML system is "definitive [and] authoritative".

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by penjelly on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:36PM (#34713635)
if chatgpt cited its sources and gave you the links, wouldnt that change things? You can always dive deeper.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by gwright on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:10PM (#34714189)
That certainly would be helpful.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by notinfuriated on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:59PM (#34712942)
> I want a definitive, authoritative answer to a question.

As others have pointed out, AI is not yet capable of this. I do agree though, I want this too. But I don't trust OpenAI or Google or anyone else to do it correctly yet.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by penjelly on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:35PM (#34713612)
echo this. traditional search will take backseat, most people seek "answers" when they search, not sources which they can derive "answers" from. This will enable the power search for less tech savvy folks, while improving the feedback loop for experienced searchers. Feels like search has changed forever.

browsers are left with challenges, particularly legitimacy of results, and ensuring a viable ad model. No doubt we'll see those soon.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:41AM (#34710642)
> I feel like Google is going to bleed credibility for every month that they don't have a lamda/llm enabled search integrated into the home page. You can talk all you want about the foundational models and how advanced they are, but the search product itself will require a ton of fine-tuning on real-world training data that they aren't collecting yet.

I love ChatGPT as a source of inspiration, but I don't think I'd want it alongside my search results. In particular, when I'm searching the web I want results with at least some degree of accuracy. Admittedly, random websites aren't always accurate either, but I at least have strategies for assessing whether I trust the source. I can't trust a single thing ChatGPT says to actually be true.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by TrevorJ on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:21PM (#34711353)
Google already has an issue with accuracy - the snippets they choose are often not very correct.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:25PM (#34711422)
Yes but I think they're correct a lot more often than ChatGPT. And they give the source!
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by visarga on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:35PM (#34712562)
Search "What is the world record for crossing the English Channel entirely on foot" and see precision Zero. None of the responses match the query. It should say - not found. Or actually find that people attempted to illegally cross through the Channel Tunnel.

Usually when I search for error messages for a specific version of software it will respond with other versions. That is useless. That's not what 24 years worth of excellence in search should look like.

At the very least they should collate a dataset of say, one million queries, and try to use a LLM to find the correct answers using search. A better search ranking model will make the LLM generate more correct answers. Iterate until score is improved. Just make the result solve the task.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by throwawayapples on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:25PM (#34713422)
asking ChatGPT gives very interesting results (didn't check accuracy):

> What is the world record for crossing the English Channel entirely on foot

As of my training data, the world record for crossing the English Channel entirely on foot is held by Christof Wandratsch, who completed the swim in 8 hours and 58 minutes on August 25, 2018.

> Swimming isn't on foot

My apologies, you are correct. The English Channel is typically crossed by swimming. The world record for swimming the English Channel is held by Benoît Lecomte, who completed the swim in 8 hours and 1 minute on July 23, 1998.

> That's faster and earlier... what did Christof Wandratsch do that was different

Christof Wandratsch completed a cross-Channel run, covering the distance between England and France on foot. This is a different feat than swimming the Channel, as it involves running across the Channel Tunnel, which connects England and France beneath the seabed.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by MaxDPS on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:29PM (#34713510)
I think that is till better than ChatGPT's answer which was:

"The fastest recorded time for crossing the English Channel entirely on foot (without the aid of swimming or any other means of transportation) is 16 hours and 34 minutes, achieved by British endurance athlete Damian Hall in August 2021."

So, it seems like it made up an answer instead, which I think is much worse that Googles response.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by pkulak on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:03PM (#34712055)
Maybe, but you can at least see the context, where it came from, all that. In my house we have a habit of asking our Google Home "Hey, Google, can rabbits eat..." and then you can see where the info came from and make a pretty good decision on if this random vegetable you have will kill your pet. If AI chat stuff takes that over, I'm out.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by gardenhedge on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @06:26PM (#34717194)
It's incredibly frustrating. They're often completely wrong.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by patapong on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:40PM (#34713697)
I disagree. The other day, I was debugging an issue in a web application. Only on iPhones, dragging an element around left odd residue on the screen. I googled the issue but was completely unable to find a solution, even though I consider myself a seasoned google user. I asked the question to ChatGPT, which immediately gave me the way to fix the issue.

Having a ChatGPT answer next to the google result would have saved me a bunch of time, and I could see it coming in useful in many cases.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by msikora on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @05:25PM (#34716378)
Exactly same experience. ChatGPT is now my go to source for programming problems. It is usually correct (or correct enough) and when it is correct enough it saves a ton of time vs Google search and then going through dozens of StackOverflow or GitHub pages that may or may not have an answer.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:17PM (#34712252)
> I feel like Google is going to bleed credibility for every month that they don't have a lamda/llm enabled search integrated into the home page.

I feel like Google is going to bleed credibility for every month that their home page is lacking a system which almost by design is going to lie to me without me realizing at least as often as it might usefully summarize information from primary sources that I wanted to read myself.

OK, then.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by smrtinsert on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:23PM (#34714419)
Lucky for Google they already are. Somewhere on reddit someone posted about bing rejecting a prompt due to ethical reasons - something about a cover letter. If a cover letter is an invalid prompt its a good as useless.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by JustLurking2022 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @06:23PM (#34717148)
Strongly disagree - they will lose credibility if they put out something half-baked. Yahoo existed long before Google search - they won because the experience was so much better that people started calling "Googling" rather than searching.