News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:41AM (#34710642)
> I feel like Google is going to bleed credibility for every month that they don't have a lamda/llm enabled search integrated into the home page. You can talk all you want about the foundational models and how advanced they are, but the search product itself will require a ton of fine-tuning on real-world training data that they aren't collecting yet.

I love ChatGPT as a source of inspiration, but I don't think I'd want it alongside my search results. In particular, when I'm searching the web I want results with at least some degree of accuracy. Admittedly, random websites aren't always accurate either, but I at least have strategies for assessing whether I trust the source. I can't trust a single thing ChatGPT says to actually be true.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by TrevorJ on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:21PM (#34711353)
Google already has an issue with accuracy - the snippets they choose are often not very correct.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:25PM (#34711422)
Yes but I think they're correct a lot more often than ChatGPT. And they give the source!
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by visarga on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:35PM (#34712562)
Search "What is the world record for crossing the English Channel entirely on foot" and see precision Zero. None of the responses match the query. It should say - not found. Or actually find that people attempted to illegally cross through the Channel Tunnel.

Usually when I search for error messages for a specific version of software it will respond with other versions. That is useless. That's not what 24 years worth of excellence in search should look like.

At the very least they should collate a dataset of say, one million queries, and try to use a LLM to find the correct answers using search. A better search ranking model will make the LLM generate more correct answers. Iterate until score is improved. Just make the result solve the task.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by throwawayapples on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:25PM (#34713422)
asking ChatGPT gives very interesting results (didn't check accuracy):

> What is the world record for crossing the English Channel entirely on foot

As of my training data, the world record for crossing the English Channel entirely on foot is held by Christof Wandratsch, who completed the swim in 8 hours and 58 minutes on August 25, 2018.

> Swimming isn't on foot

My apologies, you are correct. The English Channel is typically crossed by swimming. The world record for swimming the English Channel is held by Benoît Lecomte, who completed the swim in 8 hours and 1 minute on July 23, 1998.

> That's faster and earlier... what did Christof Wandratsch do that was different

Christof Wandratsch completed a cross-Channel run, covering the distance between England and France on foot. This is a different feat than swimming the Channel, as it involves running across the Channel Tunnel, which connects England and France beneath the seabed.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by MaxDPS on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:29PM (#34713510)
I think that is till better than ChatGPT's answer which was:

"The fastest recorded time for crossing the English Channel entirely on foot (without the aid of swimming or any other means of transportation) is 16 hours and 34 minutes, achieved by British endurance athlete Damian Hall in August 2021."

So, it seems like it made up an answer instead, which I think is much worse that Googles response.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by pkulak on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:03PM (#34712055)
Maybe, but you can at least see the context, where it came from, all that. In my house we have a habit of asking our Google Home "Hey, Google, can rabbits eat..." and then you can see where the info came from and make a pretty good decision on if this random vegetable you have will kill your pet. If AI chat stuff takes that over, I'm out.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by gardenhedge on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @06:26PM (#34717194)
It's incredibly frustrating. They're often completely wrong.
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by patapong on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:40PM (#34713697)
I disagree. The other day, I was debugging an issue in a web application. Only on iPhones, dragging an element around left odd residue on the screen. I googled the issue but was completely unable to find a solution, even though I consider myself a seasoned google user. I asked the question to ChatGPT, which immediately gave me the way to fix the issue.

Having a ChatGPT answer next to the google result would have saved me a bunch of time, and I could see it coming in useful in many cases.

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by msikora on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @05:25PM (#34716378)
Exactly same experience. ChatGPT is now my go to source for programming problems. It is usually correct (or correct enough) and when it is correct enough it saves a ton of time vs Google search and then going through dozens of StackOverflow or GitHub pages that may or may not have an answer.