News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by rippercushions on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @04:19PM (#34699822)
Building empires is quite standard in management. I work at a FAANG as a manager and have been told that, in practice, if I want to get a promotion to the next level, I'll need to grow my team large enough to have other managers reporting to me first. So my primary target is to convince the powers that be to give me headcount, and what my team actually does is strictly secondary.

Now I'm a mere peon, but this replicates up the chain increasing an order of magnitude each level, meaning up top you get VPs backstabbing each other to take over the victim's headcount and wrangle that sweet SVP promotion.

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by indigochill on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @04:26PM (#34699931)
But if you were CEO and you wanted to, how would you engineer the incentives such that actually productive managers succeeded? Or is there something about corporate structure that makes it impossible?
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by pc86 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @04:37PM (#34700113)
I would think an easy way - and coincidentally, the best for business - would be to make it too dangerous to be the stereotypical office politics back-stabbing VP type. Make it known that that behavior will land you out on your ass, with no severance or parachute, and no recommendations for future employment.

But, I've never seen that in practice. Maybe the politics of the C suite mean you want those office politics back-stabbing folks around to take those high level positions?

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by Tyr42 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @04:42PM (#34700200)
I mean, then the backstabbers just need to frame someone for backstabbing and get their path cleared up.

You also need a good way to tell apart the backstabbers from the good guys.

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by dh2022 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:01PM (#34701153)
C-suite people from different companies end up working together on company boards later in their career. To fire with cause and no severance and no parachute some back-stabbing VPs would make it more difficult to work with said back-stabbing VP later on a company board.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by adventured on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @04:38PM (#34700143)
First, you have to hire exceptional people, if you can.

If you can't get good enough people, you're going to fail hard inevitably no matter what you do (if you've got a quasi monopoly moat it may take a long rot to get there).

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by version_five on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @04:52PM (#34700319)
Give them a budget and agree on a set of accountabilities. The same model as buying a managed software consulting project.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by dan-robertson on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:57PM (#34701107)
Paying for consultants often isn’t a good use of money though, right? Like often the problem is that the right metrics are hard to know in advance and they are typically games in a way that makes it easy for the consultant to meet them without actually delivering what is desired. I think they also make it hard to take (calculated) risks which isn’t necessarily what you’d want.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by Consultant32452 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @04:52PM (#34700322)
Step 1: Read every Dilbert comic

Step 2: Realize that what you requested is impossible for sufficiently large organizations

Step 3: Negotiate a golden parachute for yourself. Don't hate the player, hate the game

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by ninjagoo on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:07PM (#34700476)
There might be fundamental incompatibilities here because of orthogonal goals - if you're an ambitious person in a corporate hierarchy won't one (or maybe even primary) goal be to climb the ladder? And if you're a founder won't your goal be to 'grow the product or service'?

Now one way to climb the ladder may be to grow the product or service, but in a larger org the ability to influence a product or service in a major way might be a bit limited, with decision-making at the business level being controlled by upper echelons. So the ladder-climbing process would select for different skills and temperament than founding/running a company.

Essentially, in a corporate hierarchy, we're asking people with ladder-climbing skills to become business people as they reach the top, and not everyone can make that transition successfully. In fact, I'd go so far as to say that very few can actually make that transition successfully.

Human brains learn through feedback [1]. To become a good business person, you need to run a business and get feedback just like a real founder/CEO, including business failures. Your question essentially becomes - how can a CEO structure incentives so that managers at all levels become good business people?

It's a great question, to which there is no simple answer that I know of. Would appreciate any pointers to potential solutions.

One way could be to treat each team at a certain level (say no more than 50 people) as a business of its own. It might not be the most efficient way for the corporation to deliver on its objectives, but it would likely create a lot of business-savvy managers. But now you have a pool of business-savvy folks that want to get paid like founders, and that might not be possible in a corporation. In terms of (in)efficiency, you could have duplicate teams that provide similar services, wasting resources, and adding costs to spin up new teams as existing ones fail or move on.

Something like this might be more feasible at a societal level - a capitalistic structure that encourages the growth of smaller size businesses while inhibiting the growth of mid- to large corporates.

Open source organizations actually seem to be the closest that I've seen that seem to operate this way.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5eW6Eagr9XA

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by mooreds on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:09PM (#34700504)
Hire people with the right kind of ambition, says Ben Horowitz: https://www.fastcompany.com/1685869/right-kind-ambition
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by deltree7 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:22PM (#34700649)
I know HN hates him, but Elon Musk has figured this out and that's why he will always deliver outstanding returns compared to others.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by stuff4ben on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:31PM (#34700765)
How exactly has he figured this out? I see an egomaniac that drives his employees as if they're just cogs in a machine.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by rippercushions on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:53PM (#34701036)
Per this thread, this seems preferable to letting managers spend all their time building empires.

Also, if you're working for any large company, you are a cog in the machine.

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by dasil003 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:54PM (#34701060)
I think both you and the GP are missing the essence of what Elon is. He is neither an amazing operator and businessman, nor is he a slave driving demon. He does have a huge ego and need for attention, I'll give you that, but fundamentally he is someone who cares more about solving big problems than he does about money or people. The push to deify or villify him is all about satisfying ones own judgement, but personally I find those reductive opinions to be far less interesting than actually looking at the various things he's done and evaluating them on their own merits.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by uxcolumbo on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:11PM (#34701953)
Not sure.

He seems like a ‘slave driving demon’. Best example how he treated the folks at Twitter or his other companies… demanding ‘hardcore’ hours and exactly like you said… he doesn’t care about people… doesn’t care whether they burn out or creating a culture where bullying is accepted.

I don’t think he really cares about solving big problems, it’s just a front to feed his big ego… he wants be seen as real life Tony Stark.

If he really cared about solving big problems like the climate crisis etc he wouldn’t have wasted his time with Twitter.

He wouldn’t have come with a stupid idea like the hyperloop and trying to derail a high speed rail project.

What he has achieved is he inspired more people to become engineers and problem solvers and have a positive vision of the future. But his big ego and narcissistic traits have ruined it and more and more folks see what he really is.

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by dasil003 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @11:25PM (#34704116)
No argument with what you said, but I give him credit for Tesla and SpaceX. Those are more ambitious than the vast majority of SV companies funded over the past couple decades.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by uxcolumbo on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:53AM (#34704995)
Yes true, that’s what I meant by he inspired others.. to join him to solve humanity’s problems.

At the beginning his ambitions were probably more aligned to this vision, but he probably got more jaded over the years, realised it’s effin hard and his narcissism got the better of him.

It’s a shame the way he treated the Tesla founders. Also I never saw him credit his various teams, it’s always about him.

Tesla and SpaceX are successful despite his involvement, because ppl care about creating more sustainable solutions for humanity… it’s a great mission.

/rant over ;)

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by StanislavPetrov on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:47PM (#34701710)
One thing he figured out was that he could cut 75% of the dead weight employees and still have a product that 95% of the users are just as, if not more, satisfied with (despite all the predictions of imminent destruction).

I would argue that administrative and organizations bloat is a very real problem across virtually every large business. The bigger the business, the worse the bloat problem.

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by scarface74 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:28PM (#34700737)
His company hasn’t delivered outstanding returns as far profits. Tesla’s stock is mostly hype.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by chris11 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:36PM (#34700841)
Twitter is private, but Elon definitely destroyed value when he took it over.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by icedchai on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:08PM (#34701242)
Well, he did overpay by at least 50%.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by negamax on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:17PM (#34701353)
He also paid 4x the price. And took out his frustration and vindication on employees. Doesn't come across as someone with sound judgement or vision
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by ahiknsr on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:02PM (#34701875)
> outstanding returns compared to others.

Like this? https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/jan/03/twitter-s...

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by ReflectedImage on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:12PM (#34701963)
So the tactic is stock market manipulation and PR?

You can't do it, but you can fool idiots on the internet that you can!

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by potatolicious on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:05PM (#34701205)
A few thoughts having worked at a bunch of large companies before, with varying degrees of rewarding empire-building.

- The orgs most susceptible to rampant empire-building are ones where execs seem disconnected from the product. IMO the best way to discourage rampant headcount growth is for upper-level execs to scrutinize hiring needs. Some orgs (especially pre-2022) have been apt to approve headcount growth without sufficient oversight as to what the new people are actually supposed to be doing, and whether or not they're necessary. Loose hiring policies result not only in corp bloat and high expenditures, but reward empire-builder managers more than product-oriented managers.

- To double down on that point, part of the problem is that in too many companies execs and managers don't speak product. The point of hiring is ostensibly to ship more/different/better product, but when execs themselves do not speak product hiring becomes divorced from this underlying goal. You hire so your seniors have juniors to mentor. You hire so a manager can get promoted. You hire to "expand your scope". But at the end of the day there is only one valid reason to actually hire: so the company can produce more/different/better products that it otherwise cannot do without hiring. This is especially true at companies like Google and Meta where the PM track and Engineering tracks are fully decoupled.

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by mooreds on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:08PM (#34700482)
I remember in my first job, one of the older guys telling me that at a certain size of company, it's all about the turf battles between the upper level managers. And as a line level employee, you just want to be on the right side of the battle.

Sounds pretty miserable to me; I suppose that's why I've stayed at smallcos/startups my entire career.

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by andix on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:26PM (#34700694)
I think once a company hits around 2-5k office workers, the whole company can be occupied with internal processes, without delivering any value at all.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by rot13xor on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:40PM (#34700893)
Communication overhead, like edges in a graph, scales quadratically. The computing analogy is going from 1 core to 8 core CPU gives far less than 8x performance if your task is not parallelizable. The solution is compartmentalization and clear interface boundaries, which is why microservices are so popular. Instead of 5k people working on 1 project, have 100 projects each with 50 people plus a few architects who define the interfaces.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:45PM (#34700949)
Oh, so that's why the linux kernel uses microservices so much.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by djbusby on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:29PM (#34701517)
Is joek? Gotta be.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by bradleyjg on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:48PM (#34700990)
It’s easy to say that but there’s lots of large, old, dysfunctional dinosaurs shipping oil, cars, or life insurance policies day in and day out.

Meanwhile there’s plenty of small, nimble, managed-by-best-practices would be disruptors not shipping much of anything.

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by thinknubpad on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:34PM (#34701574)
It's cost-prohibitive to start a new business in those fields due to large-scale regulatory capture and capital barriers. How many new car companies have been successful in the past decade without the personal fortune of a multi-billionaire?

The existentence of one or two enormous hidebound sequoias in a forest is not a good indication of its overall health.

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by wbl on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:25PM (#34702105)
And nevertheless they pay out on those policies time and again, providing a lot of social value.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by count on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:06PM (#34701227)
I think upon examination, the folks actually shipping things at those old dinosaurs are by and large unaffected by the constantly changing upper reaches of their org chart, which just becomes a drain on profits.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by munificent on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:28PM (#34701494)
The real lightbulb moment is when you realize this observation applies to almost all social structures: your school's PTA, government, militaries, large families, etc.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by gardenhedge on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:23PM (#34701436)
These bigger companies have moats e.g. life insurance is difficult business to get into and disrupt. They also have strategies to acquire smaller companies and to expand in different markets. This essentially allows them to run for a long, long time once their brand is good.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by bradleyjg on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:39PM (#34701620)
Every day Ford has to build vehicles that at least mostly work. Every year it has to make at least some changes to its line up.

It is not a do-nothing organization lost in paper-pushing. It ships.

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by emodendroket on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:21PM (#34702063)
I also think that it’s suffering from fewer fit-and-finish issues than the disruptors.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by vineyardmike on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:45PM (#34701689)
By definition, you want some of those companies to be old and stable. You, by definition, want life insurance companies outlive your policy. You want big car companies to build tanks in an emergency. You want big companies with lots of employees doing whatever to just exist and keep the economy stable. All the “disruption” at the edges are just for show to find the next giants
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by greedo on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:29PM (#34702133)
I work in the insurance biz and we generally don't want to be nimble and follow best practices. That sounds crazy right? Well, best practices change over time, and fads (at least in IT if not all types of mgmt.) are far too common.

Our team has a motto of "avoiding the cutting edge" because we don't want to bleed. We still have mainframes, because the cost of migration is prohibitive. We largely host on-prem though we have some initiatives to see how the various clouds might work for us. But these initiatives have been going on for 5-6 years. Mostly because our CTO doesn't want to miss out on the cool things.

We generally don't do layoffs, 2008 was the first time in the company's history, and that was like .005% of our company staff. We're very conservative, and when you have ten figures under management, you need to be.

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by skippyboxedhero on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:33PM (#34702191)
Classic Carl Icahn story about firing a building full of people and never discovering what they did - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WSatPoD2W-o
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by emodendroket on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:20PM (#34702044)
I have been at both and frankly I think this can be even worse at a very small company because there are no guardrails to keep it from being entirely personality-driven without even a pretense of serving some larger goal.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by scarface74 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:26PM (#34700706)
You act as if this behavior is unique to management. Every leveling guideline I’ve seen for any big tech company (including the one I work for) requires you to demonstrate “scope” and “impact”.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by rippercushions on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:54PM (#34701056)
For ICs those are usually measured with product metrics, not butts in seats.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by scarface74 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:57PM (#34701110)
How many Google engineers got promoted by launching a product that was cancelled soon after?
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by satvikpendem on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:29PM (#34700746)
Isn't this exactly what the book Bullshit Jobs is about? People build mini empires as a proxy for value.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by wonderwonder on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:36PM (#34700839)
Companies get what they incentivize for.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by MuffinFlavored on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @05:58PM (#34701115)
> I work at $BIGCO as a manager and have been told that, in practice, if I want to get a promotion to the next level, I'll need to grow my team large enough to have other managers reporting to me first.

Imagine if at $BIGCO they told you that in practice, you need to reduce headcount and run as lean as possible so that your team brings as much monetary value for the company with the least amount of expense instead...

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by HWR_14 on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:18PM (#34701357)
I imagine a lot of IT folks or those in compliance would be promoted very fast and then quickly leave the company before the hidden costs caught up with them.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by greedo on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:41PM (#34702281)
That's simply counter to how $BIGCOs work. Just look at infosec for a big corporation. There's no incentive on their part to minimize cost or disruption with strict security policies and audits. The people who feel the pain are the workers, not the CISSPs pushing STIG hardening rules. And if the C-Suite starts to wonder if all the time and money is worth it? Just show them some news reports of breaches. In many industries (especially highly regulated ones), the entire audit world of Deloitte et al is designed to make things unproductive.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by davidw on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:22PM (#34701418)
I read this stuff and I want to check out of the corporate world completely. Yeesh.
Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by munificent on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:32PM (#34701549)
> Building empires is quite standard in management.

The same impulse exists in individual contributors too, which is why you see people architecting giant sprawling armies of microservices for something that could be a simple program running on a single machine.

Some people like to just show off their ability to make big things without caring enough about what it's for.

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by Traubenfuchs on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:52PM (#34701772)
I once built a series of microservices doing the same thing but with different external vendors. Originally I thought it would be best to add a dispatcher/orchestration microservice that other services would have to go through, because I thought the externally connected services would all end up with differet APIs. In the end, I managed to give all those services the same API, making the dispatcher service obsolete and overengineered. Ultimately I just shipped it because changing the architecture would have meant endless discussions with that one lead architect who actually gave nor shit about anything but pointless discussion and I was out of time. So I shipped all the services.

In the last performance review, my boss complimented the amount of new services I put into production.

I hate software engineering.

Re:Meta to Ask Many Managers to Become Individual Contributo... by willcipriano on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:37PM (#34702239)
I'd just do vistor pattern and get fired.