News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by lm28469 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:38AM (#34628032)
Automating art and paying near-slaves 10$ an hour to deliver food.

Almost the dream technocrats were predicting in the 60s, the only difference is that it's the complete opposite.

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by a4isms on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:34AM (#34627949)
Paula Progressive:

"You mean there's a shortage of people willing to work brutal hours for subsistence wages."

Charlie Conservative:

"If your job can be replaced by AI, you deserve to starve, you aren't creating value for investors."

Bertha the Bot-Writer:

"I can replace both of you with generative AI that writes highly viral, low-effort, simplistic and partisan social media posts and comments."

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by p0pcult on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:38AM (#34628029)
P0pcult permissive:

"The new artist jobs will be the people who direct the AIs creating the art."

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by gingerrr on Thursday February 02, 2023 @12:10PM (#34629640)
"Prompt artist" / "prompt engineer" is already a "title" I've seen people use in the wild.

Gross.

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by a4isms on Thursday February 02, 2023 @12:14PM (#34629736)
I find that interesting, even if I abhor its existence. Feels a little like SEO tea-leaf reading. "If I prompt this, I get that." It's like reverse-engineering the model so you can game it into doing something specific, without actually understanding how the model works and what it's actually trained on.
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday February 02, 2023 @12:40PM (#34630196)
I dunno, that sounds a lot like how I have to use Google these days.
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by bluefirebrand on Thursday February 02, 2023 @12:20PM (#34629821)
Press button get content.

Just add a second button that is "inject happy drugs" and you get a really good scifi novel that we shouldn't want to live in.

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by nickthegreek on Thursday February 02, 2023 @01:35PM (#34631082)
I don't understand why you have to abhor its existence. I play d&d. I had 2 of my players come over last night so that I could help them generate their character photos. It took 4 hours to make both their characters. It only took 4 hours because I can prompt engineer, tweak in photoshop, understand img2img blending/inpainting methods. Someday I wont have to speak to the AI in specific ways to get what I want, but until then, prompt engineering is the winning strategy. You can be a prompt engineer and understand how the model works and what it is trained on. Most people dont want to do that. Most people don't know how microwave works, but they know how to use it to get quick fast food.
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by p0pcult on Thursday February 02, 2023 @02:38PM (#34631934)
>Gross

Ironic, when you are on a site that seems mainly dedicated to people who use specialized language to direct computers to do repetitive things at scale.

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by a4isms on Thursday February 02, 2023 @02:56PM (#34632135)
It's slightly different.

Programming languages are for the most part deterministic tools that programmers generally understand and can debug. For this audience, the interpreter or compiler is not a "black box" that we only interact with by giving it inputs and seeing what it does.

Although some prompt engineers may have detailed understanding of the AI model and its training corpus, to most people using this kind of AI today the model is a black box, and it's up to them to try things.

Sure, that happens in programming too, but rarely at the level of a programming language, and much more likely at the level of a complex system of poorly documented and buggy interacting parts, such as a long-standing piece of computing infrastructure that has been iterated upon for decades, and now contains a mish-mash of components, many of which were added by people no longer around to explain how they work.

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by dawsoneliasen on Thursday February 02, 2023 @03:31PM (#34632529)
I am currently writing a blog post about this. Here’s an excerpt:

“Consider, for instance, the simple existence of the term “prompt engineering,” which describes the practice of iteratively fine-tuning the prompts you submit to ChatGPT (or whatever) to get your desired output. Prompt engineering is a matter of some identification of what the model responds to, and a lot of guesswork. It’s a matter of treating the natural language of the prompt into a formal language, almost into a programming language, manipulating symbols which lose their human meaning and intuitive structure like some sort of abstract association game. You’re working with the worst programming language imaginable.”

My angle is that using ChatGPT is like using a English as programming language, and it’s a terrible programming language. The reason “prompt engineering” is so irksome to me is that is supposed to be this new advanced mode of expertise, when in reality it’s just shitty programming.

“The Python/C++/whatever-code isn’t some obstacle that we are trying to overcome. The code is the interface that we designed to be able to program the computer, it’s what we want and need. It’s objective, explicit, unambiguous, (relatively) static, internally consistent, and robust. English has none of these properties—it’s subjective, meaning is often implicit, and ambiguous, and it’s always changing, contradictions appear; its structure does not hold up to analysis.”

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by p0pcult on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:37PM (#34633488)
English may be a shitty programming language, but wouldn't that imply that wrangling it to get what you want is--in and of itself--a skill, and not "shitty programming" as you put it?

It's definitely a form of authorship--and authorship (of a book) isn't shitty. Writing well is a craft that people hone--to induce wetware computers (i.e., brains) to "hallucinate" (using a term that seems popular with people who interface with these AI tools) what the author desires them too.

Maybe that's the difference? Programming is when you use a very formally constructed language to induce a computer to execute a desired algorithm precisely. Authorship or artistry is when you use a formally loose language (painting, sculpture, writing) to induce a computer to "hallucinate" a desired meme (in the original sense of the word, "unit of meaning").

Both pursuits are somewhat similar, but the breakpoint is the rigor of the language used, maybe?

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by a4isms on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:27PM (#34634119)
There is a term-of-art for using English to write programs: "The English-Likeness Monster." The poster-boy for this terrible UX is--ironically--AppleScript, a programming language from a company that otherwise prides itself on good user experiences.

https://deprogrammaticaipsum.com/the-english-likeness-monste...

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by bluefirebrand on Thursday February 02, 2023 @12:22PM (#34629857)
Bluefirebrand cynic:

People directing AI to create things are not artists.

At best they are art commissioners

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by Apocryphon on Thursday February 02, 2023 @12:47PM (#34630309)
You wouldn't call Jim Gordon a Batman, after all
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by p0pcult on Thursday February 02, 2023 @01:57PM (#34631409)
Is a film director an artist? They often charge others with the realization of their vision.

What about the Sistine Chapel? Jeff Koons?

http://artandobject.com/news/artist-workshops-their-history-...

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by mFixman on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:43PM (#34634329)
Were people also up in arms for the Blockbuster jobs that Netflix destroyed?
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by sam_lowry_ on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:00AM (#34628390)
I accidentally had Developer Tools open when clicking on this link... and even by today's standards what vice.com does with its own site is awful.
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by eska on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:04AM (#34628464)
„Labor shortage“ — while there’s no shortage of kids around the world dreaming of becoming animators..
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by bluefirebrand on Thursday February 02, 2023 @12:22PM (#34629870)
Those kids gotta eat so unfortunately you have to pay them more than AI.
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by 1MachineElf on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:09AM (#34628566)
If you are dealing with a labor shortage, then how can you honor an IP? If you can't honor it, then you shouldn't produce it. That there isn't a law for this is unfortunate. Until something is done, we will keep ending up with 2022 Trigun CGI remakes.
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by briga on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:23AM (#34628781)
Is there a single thing twitter mobs won’t get pissed about? I feel like twitter replies are not the best way to gauge public sentiment on this. Are the fans also mad that artists aren’t drawing each frame individually anymore?
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday February 02, 2023 @12:38PM (#34630154)
Twitter, like most modern social media, is just the Two Minutes Hate but running 24/7.

As a society our use of social media will one day be looked back on the way we look back on the Romans using lead as a sweetener.

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by Y_Y on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:07PM (#34633050)
The 1440 Minutes Hate
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by slowmovintarget on Thursday February 02, 2023 @01:53PM (#34631367)
"Hey Gupta, write me a tweet that will cause a Twitter mob to fume about celery prices!"

...

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by drivingmenuts on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:42AM (#34629070)
I wish there was some context for declaration of outrage. Are there tens of fans or ten thousands of fans upset about this? What percentages of the viewing market? It’s a bit difficult to raise empathy for three stoned Tweeters on a couch in Reseda vs thousands of unemployed artists.
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by resfirestar on Thursday February 02, 2023 @12:19PM (#34629814)
Some Twitter users do not seem to realize that the video attached to the tweet is the entire anime, and are quote-tweeting the video that they're urging people to pirate.

I point that out because maybe some of the outrage is due to misunderstanding/language barrier, since it seems out of proportion for an experimental short? Maybe it was in poor taste for Netflix's tweet to emphasize the "labor shortage", their article [1] is more about experimenting with new ways for animators to work with AI tools.

[1] https://about.netflix.com/ja/news/the-dog-and-the-boy

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by bastawhiz on Thursday February 02, 2023 @12:26PM (#34629940)
Is there actually a labor shortage? If this claim is qualified with "there's a shortage of labor willing to work for a pittance" then there's no labor shortage. I'm more disgusted with a business choosing profits over people, especially when we all know that Netflix budgets are generally very substantive. If the cost of getting the talent you need to produce the work is too high, turning to generative art is a band-aid for a real systemic problem with how Netflix is producing content. AI should be a tool: if the art can't be produced without it, you're really just scraping by. And that's a big red flag for Netflix's business, imo.
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday February 02, 2023 @01:17PM (#34630783)
> a business choosing profits over people

They will choose profits over their own suvival - they sanctionbusted to sell to nazis, choose shirt term profit over long-term growth, etc.

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by legitster on Thursday February 02, 2023 @12:32PM (#34630033)
There's an irony to me here - one of Anime's most distinctive artistic features (lower framerate, repeating frames/backgrounds) was specifically a way to increase content by reducing animator's workload.
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by jldugger on Thursday February 02, 2023 @12:58PM (#34630479)
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by jfengel on Thursday February 02, 2023 @12:33PM (#34630059)
Huh. Backgrounds have long been semi-automated. I'm sure it's putting people out of work, but it's a long-running issue.

I'm not an animator, and I'm sure I don't understand all of the issues. I could see this being terrible for new animators, who expect to get low-visibility work to get experience. Art of any kind has always been a precarious way to make a living, and it would be depressing if studios and audiences settled for something lesser to avoid paying them.

But is this a case where it frees them up to do more work? If fewer animators are involved, does that mean the same animators can produce more films? Studios are desperate for content, which is part of the "labor shortage".

Perhaps it would be an opportunity for more niche animation -- to tell more personal stories with less wide appeal because the overhead is less? There's a ton of such material on Netflix; it seems to be their bread and butter.

I don't want to get all techno-utopia, especially in a domain I don't know. My guesses are not as good as their experience. But I am genuinely curious.

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by cinntaile on Thursday February 02, 2023 @01:14PM (#34630724)
I don't really see the issue, this is how it has always worked. If someone or something can do your job good enough (not necessarily better) but for a fraction of the cost, you will eventually be forced to face that reality.
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by wilsonnb3 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @01:24PM (#34630904)
People can still be mad about it even if it is inevitable.
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by mikem170 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @03:09PM (#34632302)
It doesn't have to always work that way. There's examples of groups of people that optimize for things besides profit. Like the Amish, for example.

Not saying that this needs to apply in any specific example. I'm just trying to advocate for the idea that we can imagine different social constructs as being possible. I like to think that a society can potentially decide to do anything that society agrees they want to do, and that could include valuing people over profits.

Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by rexpop on Thursday February 02, 2023 @01:26PM (#34630946)
Really pathetic of Vice to offer no commentary on the ironic subject of the animated short — the titular "Dog" is an in-fiction AI, itself.
Re:Netflix Made an Anime Using AI Due to a 'Labor Shortage,'... by andrewmcwatters on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:22PM (#34636742)
Remember watching cartoons as a kid then growing up and realizing where the cost cutting happened based on lack of animated frames, and reused animation cycles?

The kids of the future will get to spot AI deformations, extra digits, missing limbs, non-Euclidean geometry!