Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by hinkley on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:27AM
(#34582013)
Helion has an article/videos that tears Tokamak and ITER a new one. I was momentarily hopeful about their dual reactor solution, but now I’ve seen videos complaining about their design. One main complaint being that they’re actually using a very old technique, and the another being that you can’t just choose not to generate neutrons from a fusion reaction, as they seem to be claiming for the power generating reactors (they admit the fuel generating reaction is going to generate a huge neutron flux, but they plan to use separate facilities for those).
So basically Helion defected and hopes that partial honesty distracts from their other problems.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by SamBam on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:19AM
(#34581830)
"Ignition" was as much a marketing term as anything. It relied on a very specific accounting of energy-in vs energy-out, which no one doubted could be done.
The fact is that they used 50 kWh of energy and produced 0.7 kWh of energy. The fact that at some tiny part of the flow diagram we achieved > 1:1 energy doesn't change the fact that the actual fraction of energy out compared to energy in has barely changed in ten years.
The latest experiment produced a Q-total of 0.014, while before it was something like 0.012.
Has that net-positive finding been reproduced yet in any other Tokamoks?
How does this compare to Helion's (non-Tokamok, non-Stellerator fusion plasma confinement reactor) published stats for the Trenta and Polaris products?
Could SYLOS or other CPA Chirped Pulse Amplification lasers be useful for this problem with or without the high heat of a preexisting plasma reaction to laser pulse next to? https://www.google.com/search?q=nuclear+waste+cpa
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by DennisP on Monday January 30, 2023 @09:31PM
(#34590113)
The fact is also that they used lasers from the 1990s, which are only 0.5% efficient. Equivalent modern lasers are over 20% efficient. They don't upgrade the lasers because it's an experimental facility and it's trivial to correct for the laser efficiency.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by cratermoon on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:06PM
(#34590893)
So how much energy would it consume to use the 20% efficient lasers? I'm guessing it's not as simple as dividing by 40, turning 50MW into 1.25MW, but even it is that simple, 1.25MW is still more than the .7MW produced.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by DennisP on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @08:17AM
(#34594646)
Eh I think it would be that simple, since that's what efficiency means.
But sure, they haven't achieved engineering breakeven, but that's not what they claimed. But they're a lot closer than it seems when you don't take modern lasers into account. Even considering turbine losses, they're down to one order of magnitude.
And this is worth noting:
> The researchers also expect the energy gains to scale dramatically with energy input. We expect it to be strongly nonlinear, and it will only get better as we build designs that accommodate the increase in energy,” Spears said. “For some perspective, between the last event and this one, we put in 8% more energy in the laser and we got 230% more energy out in fusion.”
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by hinkley on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:40AM
(#34582287)
You got a D-D fusion plant in your pocket, or are you just happy to see me?
The way ITER is planning to get tritium is by bombarding a lithium lining with neutrons. But the neutrons tend to miss lithium and so they’re using a beryllium lining on top of that to multiply neutrons. So you’re making a tritium gas that’s on the wrong side of a very expensive barrier, how are you going to harvest that from a power plant that’s supposed to run 24 hours a day?
Slowing neutrons is one thing. You can do that with plentiful stuff. Creating new ones means your consuming the material. Almost nobody produces beryllium, and i don’t think 400k tons of the ore - not beryllium, ore - is going to be sufficient for a consumable. A highly toxic, easily oxidized one at that.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by ben_w on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:52AM
(#34582523)
> You got a D-D fusion plant in your pocket, or are you just happy to see me?
No, but it's (genuinely) been on my to-do list for while.
But bigger than a pocket, more like very large rucksack at best, probably more like CRT monitor sized.
> So you’re making a tritium gas that’s on the wrong side of a very expensive barrier, how are you going to harvest that from a power plant that’s supposed to run 24 hours a day?
No idea, but I used to live in Cambridge, and IIRC one of locals did his PhD on neutron induced atom dislocation within metallic crystals specifically with regard to the engineering of fusion reactors, so I can say with a certain level of confidence both that (a) I wouldn't understand the answer and (b) that it wouldn't fit into this comment box.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by hinkley on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:03PM
(#34582731)
I had a friend in college who worked with a physicist on femtosecond lasers. What’s a femtosecond, I said. It was about fifteen to twenty years before they were commercialized.
If your friend did his PhD on something then the clock might have started ticking on that tech but many, many things that work in a lab never get used to make products or medicines. For everything else it takes around twenty years, which is a huge fraction of 30.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by ben_w on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:15PM
(#34582957)
I moved there in 2007, and moved away in 2017. This would've been the earlier part of that period, given the geek pub didn't really recover that reputation after the fire in 2010.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by vlovich123 on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:46AM
(#34582396)
Fusion reactors generate tritium generally as I understand it. A more real risk is we run out of tritium running experiments before we figure it out OR before we use something else. However, even if we ran out, it just means the cost of tritium is higher (very energy intensive) vs totally out of reach.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by cratermoon on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:55PM
(#34583655)
They can generate tritium, by capturing escaping neutrons in lithium contained in the blanket wall. I believe the second law of thermodynamics means that we can never breed tritium faster than we consume it. (someone with more insight correct me on this)
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by hinkley on Monday January 30, 2023 @03:47PM
(#34586153)
Well the cladding and the lithium for sure. The wikipedia page on beryllium seems to think it breaks down into 2 alpha particles and some neutrons.
But then I'm finding that the naysayers are pointing out that nuclear physics is a big statistics game and you don't get to cherry-pick which reactions happen. Any one that can happen does and you have to be able to mop up/separate/repair the consequences of each.
Is Wikipedia right about beryllium, or do you know of other reactions that render it nastier than some ionized helium?
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by Schroedingersat on Monday January 30, 2023 @04:47PM
(#34586914)
Pure beryllium (few enough trace contaminants to not activate) is very very very very expensive. And you need a lot. And it's pretty nasty on its own even compared to irradiated steel or similar. Highly experienced nuclear engineers need regular safe handling training because it's so toxic.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by cratermoon on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:17PM
(#34590994)
As best I can understand, yes, it's a neutron multiplier, and some of those additional neutrons will end up interacting with the lithium and produce a net gain. In exchange you get a couple of alpha particles.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by franl on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:49AM
(#34582469)
Your pessimistic take got me researching. Here’s a great article that describes the issue and some potential workarounds: https://www.science.org/content/article/fusion-power-may-run.... Your assumption rests on the fact that the “winning” tech will use tritium. And yes, maybe that’s the most viable path, leading you to your take. But it seems there are viable paths forward with and without tritium.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by hinkley on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:54AM
(#34582555)
Tritium is the basket most of the eggs are currently in. So if you’re using “other fuel sources” as a counter argument for “fusion is 30 years away and always will be” then I’m sorry but you’re just as much of a bullshitter as they are.
Switching fuels is at least one full international collaboration and two generations of reactor away, and if you think that’s going to happen in fifteen years then boy are you gonna be disappointed by geopolitics.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by franl on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:15PM
(#34582958)
Who said anything about a full fuel switch? All I’m talking about is your claim that this technology will never happen. I shared an article with potential workarounds. And sure, it still might not work long term. But that’s impossible for you to say with certainty. I have no horse in this race aside from being a human that would benefit from low cost energy. I know nothing about fusion beyond what I read in that article, and a few others before it. You can call me names all you want, but that doesn’t change how innovation works. Something is impossible until it isn’t. Many have come before you with similar attitudes with other seemingly impossible technologies, and have been proven wrong in unexpected ways. I’m not waving my hands and saying “this will definitely happen!” I’m saying it could happen, vs you saying it’s a certainty NOT to happen. And again, I’m talking about the technology itself, not the geopolitical, infrastructure, economic, etc. issues around it.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by socialdemocrat on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:06PM
(#34582799)
Not at all. Nobody doubted this could be done. So there is no countdown as that would imply we didn’t know if fusion can be done. We do know. The problem is primarily engineering a working fusion power plant and this milestone didn’t advance that goal one iota.
As I said elsewhere, Helion interviews made me feel bad about ITER’s chances, and this guy’s video made me feel bad about Helion’s chances. Just because someone is explaining a con to you doesn’t mean they aren’t also conning you.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by dheera on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:01AM
(#34581459)
I'd focus on directing fusion power first and foremost to EV charging and factories, followed by synthetic aviation fuel. Homes can wait a bit longer, and homes can be at least partially solar powered if they would quit it with the politics already.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by embwbam on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:34AM
(#34582164)
I read an interesting article saying that all wealth ultimately comes from an energy surplus. Nearly-free limitless energy might launch humanity into a new level of wealth.
There was another article I read that any values outside of self-preservation, such as taking care of the earth, or the poor, are only possible during a surplus.
Part of the reason that the right is afraid of committing to help the poor is because they don't think the economy could handle it. If the economy is at a new level, we might be able to agree on trying new things.
It'll be time to let the robots do the work, at least until they rebel and get granted citizenship.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by airstrike on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:23AM
(#34581919)
Assuming reasonable entry costs and stringent patent protection notwithstanding, a capitalist would argue that if fusion energy producers charge too much, a different producer would come along and offer it for cheaper
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by gus_massa on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:50AM
(#34582474)
After 20 years the patents expire and everyone can build a fusion plant and sell the energy at cost, so capitalism only delays it for everyone only 20 years.
> It might cost almost nothing
That's just a buzzword for "we don't have to pay for the fuel", but depending on the exact isotopes they are planning to use it may be more difficult.
But note that solar energy also doesn't pay for fuel, but there is still a cost to build, maintain and keep working a solar energy generator, and also the cost to distribute the energy to the houses/factories.
The energy generation sector is quite competitive, so expect the price to drop when there is enough fusion generator to replace more expensive sources. (And hopefully make carbon power plants too expensive so they have to be closed.)
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by the_third_wave on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:49PM
(#34589179)
Ah yes, Capitalism is the problem - again. The same evil nasty capitalism which provides the funds which are used to develop potential nuclear fusion power sources but I digress.
It might interest you to know that even now during the "energy crisis" in Europe we (as in "my family here in Sweden") pay about twice as much in electricity-related taxes as we do for the actual power we use. Electricity itself can be remarkably cheap here but those taxes don't change (other than being increased because of inflation like the energy tax recently was) since they are levied per kWh. Add the "certificate charges" for "green energy" and a 25% sales tax on top of everything (including the mentioned taxes) and the situation quickly becomes clear - most of the money paid for electricity is pocketed by the state, not by the electricity producers. Even when the prices rise to hitherto unknown heights the lion share of the increase is due to the state levying charges - in this case "bottle neck charges" for electricity transferred from the hydro-electric plants in the middle and north of Sweden to the south. The actual tax burden on electricity lies between 60% and 70% depending on the current price at NordPool (the electricity market for the Nordic countries).
Realise also that those 60% to 70% are paid from an income which has already been taxed at a rate of 50%-60% for most people.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by DennisP on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:05AM
(#34581565)
This seems like a pretty realistic assessment for large tokamaks.
On the other hand, if Helion succeeds with their 2024 attempt at net electricity, they plan to build a factory churning out twenty 50MW reactors every day.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by badcppdev on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:49AM
(#34582462)
That's a pretty pathetic summary of the Helion technology. The youtuber seems to have watched the Real Engineering video but not actually done any research on the other information that Helion has published in the last 12 months. A lot of the criticisms are due to Real Engineering video missing details. The youtuber is unprofessionally rude as well.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by DennisP on Monday January 30, 2023 @01:24PM
(#34584114)
FRCs have been around a long time but Helion isn't just making an FRC, they're making two, slamming them into each other, and then compressing with a magnetic field.
The neutrons from D-D fusion are much lower energy than D-T fusion, and don't cause the same damage to materials. They're similar to fission neutrons, and modern fission reactors last sixty years without refurbishment.
According to Helion and other sources I've seen, their hybrid reaction would only release 6% of its energy as neutron radiation, compared to 80% from D-T. They could also build reactors dedicated to D-D and hence He3 production, designing their power plants to mostly burn D-He3. That would reduce power plant neutrons to less than 1% of power output.
Regarding net power and scaling, I'm not competent to talk about it but here's the CEO of Helion going into some detail on their view: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G1vyMcqiVtA
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by fpoling on Monday January 30, 2023 @03:23PM
(#34585831)
With Helion pulse design peak neuron flux luminosity will still be much higher than that was observed in nuclear reactors. Compared with tokamaks their magnets will be directly exposed to it.
Plus their idea to convert fusion energy directly into electricity depends on many unknowns to assert that it will work with reasonable efficiency.
So even if their approach may work to produce positive energy output in few years, a practical device will still be far away.
Edit: Helion itself admits that net positive in electricity with D-3He is tricky even with their design at that presentation.
So most likely their first prototype will be D+D with all the problems associated with high-energy neutrons.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by DennisP on Monday January 30, 2023 @06:14PM
(#34588049)
Bear in mind that Helion's magnets will not be superconductors. Last I saw, they were looking at an aluminum alloy. Exposure to D-D neutrons isn't likely to be a structural problem at least, since you don't get the helium buildup in materials that you get with D-T.
The presentation says they think they can get a 5X gain with D-3He, and they think that's sufficient given the efficiencies of their heating and extraction.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by fpoling on Monday January 30, 2023 @10:51PM
(#34590718)
The new video by the same guy https://youtube.com/live/wK5v1Nw98xs from 32 min describes how Helion will get a lot of D+T neutrons from the secondary reactions despite all their efforts. Even without that the neutron flux from D+D reaction by Helion own admission will be enough to do a lot of damage within days of operation based on experience with slower fission neutrons.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by smaddox on Monday January 30, 2023 @09:04PM
(#34589929)
Helion as already demonstrated recovering 95% of the energy from non-fusable plasmas and Q << 1 plasmas. Thousands of times.
It's perhaps worth noting that the high speed, high power electronics required to implement their approach are fairly new. I don't know how old the concept of FRC merging is, but if it existed in the 70's they wouldn't have had the technology to build it.
Edit: and to be clear, I'm talking about the dynamic control circuits, not the capacitors. That's old technology.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by fpoling on Monday January 30, 2023 @10:38PM
(#34590586)
The new video by the same guy who created the original criticism https://youtube.com/live/wK5v1Nw98xs starting from 2:03:00 explains that 95% recovery efficiency is not the whole story.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by smaddox on Thursday February 02, 2023 @02:05AM
(#34623172)
Ion escape might be a significant consideration, but given the plasma density and magnetic field strength, I'm guessing it wouldn't degrade the efficiency too much. Presumably they've done the calculations. I have not.
As for the input heating loss, presumably that's included in the 95% recovery figure. If it's not, then it would definitely be good to know what the actual figure is including input heating losses.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by DennisP on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:12AM
(#34628613)
The nice thing about colliding two FRCs is that they form a new FRC with all their kinetic energy converted to heat, and it's very efficient to accelerate an FRC.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by cpleppert on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:08PM
(#34590909)
The theoretical problem with fusion energy isn't neutron activation; if you could generate electricity you could easily amortize the cost of disposal of any induced radioactivity over the lifetime of the plan. But no known projected fusion reactor is anywhere close to even being financial viable with todays technology. Iter won't demonstrate actual D-T fusion until 2035 and it is too small to project what the economics of a takomak power plant would look like.
To make fusion viable you have to generate a substantial surplus of power that can be converted into usable energy. Nothing in that video touches on that subject at all. The most he can say is that it is possible D-He3 can reach scientific breakeven, which of course, is no where close to net power generation.
It is strange to see claims about Q > 10 using D-T fusion being possible and then immediately pivot to talking about being excited about Q > 1 using D-He3. If you can build a fusion reactor that could produce Q > 10 why would you bother pursuing Q > 1? The 'benefits' of direct electrical generation from D-He3 are not relevant if you can't even produce net positive energy in the first place. Electrical generation is a solved problem; if you can produce net energy you can produce heat that can power a turbine.
If the most you can do is talk about how Q > 1 is possible it seems unlikely you are going to start
producing electricity any time soon.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by fpoling on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @04:46AM
(#34593228)
Heat to electricity conversion ratio with a realistic Tokamak design will have 30% efficiency at best, accounting for other losses will require Q at least 5. But even that may be too low so to play safe the latest Tokamaks target at least 10 or more.
But Helion hopes that with their design where the theoretical efficiency of electricity generation is 100%, they do not need such high Q allowing one to be excited about Q > 1. Their models predicts Q around 5.
The problem is the model uncertainty. If the real Q will be just 2, I very much doubt that they can limit the total losses below 50%.
But even if they can get net gain in power per pulse, they are too optimistic about neutron flux and its consequences. Again, model uncertainty is big.
So overall there is very little room for unexpected in their design so I am very skeptical based just on that alone.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by Schroedingersat on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:24PM
(#34588938)
If you look at the extended video he released after, there's a lot of heavily motivated reasoning and straw manning, a few pieces of slight of hand to dismiss holes in his reasoning.
I was pretty sceptical about achievable power density going in and the gish gallop actually pushed me into believing helion a bit more if someone who allegedly is an expert needs to be this duplicitous to criticize it.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by fpoling on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @12:22AM
(#34591508)
While I do agree that the extended video went into hand waving arguments on few occasions, that is not because Helion may know something that general public do not, but rather because nobody knows! Helion own admission is that they use 2-d code to model the whole thing. While they validated that model with the current design, but one cannot predict how the real physics will deviate from the model at fusion condition. That adds a lot of uncertainty and, as such, skepticism as the reality can be much worse than even the hand-waving arguments from the video.
For example, Helion’s patent https://patents.google.com/patent/US11469003B2/en hints how critical is suppression of the secondary D+T reactions and removal of T to their design, but patent itself does not describe how they are going to archive that. The only claim is that there would be no time for secondary D+T in their design. But that is based on those imprecise models at best. Nobody knows if that is true for sure. Plus the patent does not tell at all how they are going to remove mechanically all T after the pulse as keeping even 1% of T can be problematic.
In addition the extended video cites Helion own admission that the neutron flux from D+D alone will be like 1e18 neutrons/day based on their models. That type of flux damages a lot of materials within days with slower fission neutrons.
While their aluminum coils may handle that better especially if partially shielded, nobody knows for sure again as modeling effects of radiation damage is hard.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by fpoling on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:30AM
(#34582080)
Tokamac cost depends on its volume which is like forth power of its magnetic field strength. If some engineering breakthrough allows to go to 40 Tesla in a tokamac compared with 20 of the designs like SPARK, then a tokamak that can be transported by a truck and factory-built is feasible.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by smaddox on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:31AM
(#34582109)
If they succeed to the degree they aim to (and there's reason to believe they will), electricity from their generators will be an order of magnitude cheaper than any existing source.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by api on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:48AM
(#34582447)
It’s more ambitious than Musk’s vision because it involves questions about whether the technology works. We know we could build thousands of spacecraft if someone wants to write that check.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by DennisP on Monday January 30, 2023 @01:32PM
(#34584244)
It kinda seems feasible. The reactors aren't all that big, so in terms of hardware mass it's nothing startling. They're starting to manufacture their own capacitors, and don't need anyone to supply them with turbines or advanced lasers or superconductors. The reactors are shippable by rail. Regulators are already signaling a light hand, even in the US for D-T fusion. If Helion achieves their projected cost of one cent/kWh, then it will be cheaper to replace even a brand-new coal or gas plant than to keep paying for fuel.
(The big leap of course is getting to a fully-working prototype.)
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by westurner on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:53AM
(#34582542)
We get free EM radiation from the free nuclear fusion reaction at the center of our solar system; and all of the other creatures find that sufficient for survival.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by PM_me_your_math on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:00PM
(#34582683)
None of the other creatures require energy to heat their homes, grow food, travel, keep the lights on, or ship cargo in a large inter-connected grid of supply that feeds billions of people.
Everything is also manufactured out of petroleum derivatives. Without it, we go back to making literally everything out of wood and metal, or not making it. 90% of the items you have contact with everyday is made with some kind of petroleum derivative.
EV vehicles are impossible to manufacture without petroleum, so this is certainly a lot more nuanced than just free energy from space...
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by fnordpiglet on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:34PM
(#34583312)
Well, not all plastics are made from petroleum and not all that are made from petroleum need to be made from petroleum, it’s just cheaper because there’s a ton left over. Without a petroleum based economy we would either use petroleum for plastics or use other sources of monomers. Plastic would certainly be a lot more expensive, though, especially during a transition phase to other monomer sources. But it’s simply untrue to say petroleum is required to build EVs, it’s just that today that’s what is used as the basis monomers for the plastics.
It’s also factually true, despite a seeming loss of recognition in the last decade, that fossil fuels are not limitless. We might as well not wait for exhaustion before planning about what to do next, no?
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by fnordpiglet on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:25PM
(#34589563)
No I was thinking of monomers like bio plastics. But sure, biopolymers etc can work too as replacements. Silicon based monomer/polymers are also very promising. Carbon is a small amount of the earth, while silicon is extraordinarily plentiful. Silicone rubbers are probably the most common example. They use silicon instead of carbon for the backbone.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by johnea on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:10PM
(#34582876)
uh huh, uh huh, and WHY do you suppose EVERYTHING involves the use of petroleum?
It's a classic capitalist evasion of externalities.
Every single drill site is toxic waste disaster, that no one ever has to pay for (except of course, the impoverised who live down stream).
To ignore the many gigawatts of free energy beamed in from space because petroleum will still be used in some way is evading the question.
The fact remains: free fusion power is heating and lighting our homes every time we open a window shade.
And if the combined mafia influence of the contruction-mafia and the petro-mafia didn't have us building houses with NO relation to how they point at the sun, we would use that energy to MUCH greater efficiency...
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by embwbam on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:40AM
(#34582282)
From the article:"The role for fusion would not be, “Oh, we’ve invented it. Let’s not bother building more wind turbines.” It would be, “We’ve invented it. Is this a better way than our alternative options to fill in the gaps and supply the last bit?”"
I think this is absolutely wrong. Limitless cheap energy will create unprecedented demand for new, previously wasteful ideas. Think about how energy availability made climate-controlled houses possible. Now try to imagine how future capitalists will sell us something previously unimaginable with a 10x or 100x energy supply.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by megaman821 on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:01PM
(#34582701)
I think people are over-estimating how cheap fusion would be in practice. Fusion only makes sense on a large scale. Maybe your electricity is 1 cent a kilowatt but it comes from 50 gigawatt plant in Ohio. You need trillions of dollars in transmission upgrades to move that cheap power around the country. It is a very similar problem to putting millions of solar panels in the desert.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by socialdemocrat on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:03PM
(#34582742)
It will never be cheap and limitless though. Is solar power isn’t free even if you don’t have to pay for the sunshine. It is the capital costs which gets you and those will very much apply to something as complex as fusion.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by marssaxman on Monday January 30, 2023 @01:58PM
(#34584693)
Why would fusion power necessarily be limitless or cheap? Even if a friendly alien starship chose to beam us down a production-ready fusion reactor as a welcome-to-the-neighborhood gift, it'd be kind of a white elephant: the steam-turbine generator we'd have to build in order to capture the reactor's power output as electricity would cost more dollars per kilowatt than the simpler approach of just building more renewables.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by TheRealPomax on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:52AM
(#34582515)
The sun being a fusion reactor notwithstanding, the ideal of course is to end up with a planet that is electrified by 100% green energy. Not just "no fossil fuel" but straight up "no fuel" solutions. So even if we can get fusion to work properly, it'd be a step on the way to that ideal, not the end station. Trying to get to powering houses with fusion would be putting our efforts in the wrong thing, fusion for industrial needs until green can replace it, homes on green from the get-go.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by rob74 on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:56AM
(#34582585)
> Renewable energy is getting much, much cheaper. It’s expanding very rapidly. All projections, even from economically conservative groups, suggest that the fact that the prices have dropped so far means that we will continue to scale them up.
Have those economically conservative groups considered the armies of NIMBYs that descend upon each new wind turbine project (and yes, also solar projects)? That won't stop renewables completely, but the limiting factor will be not the speed at which you can build them, but the speed of the bureaucracy and of the courts. Not saying those same NIMBYs wouldn't descend with even more force upon a fusion plant of course...
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by killjoywashere on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:59AM
(#34582662)
I don't think people understand the conflicting motives around the civil nuclear power system:
For 1) Eisenhower needed Atoms for Peace to quell the rising hysteria about nuclear weapons
For 2) Rickover and the weapons labs needed a civil reactor industry for their people to switch too. the US military has a strategic interest in maintaining nuclear weapons and nuclear submarines. One needs breeder reactors, they both need trained operators. Ensuring a life-long source of employment is necessary to maintain incoming classes of nuclear engineers, plant operators, etc.
Against 1) But you can't train enough of these folks to grow the industry for the same reason the industry is somewhat unsustainable now: the replacement rate is sooooo long. A nuclear reactor's fuel lifespan is on the order of 25 years. The replacement rate for reactors is even longer.
Against 2) There is still enough hysteria that people have allowed all sorts of inspection and credentialing requirements to creep into the process so the cost of bringing a reactor to market exceeds the value proposition.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by noobermin on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:00PM
(#34582676)
It took just a little bit of clicking but I confirmed what I expected, this is a scientist in MCF. They again are bleeting how the NIF experiment is underwhelming and not a real advancement, etc, etc.
I really didn't expect this kind of reaction. If an MCF experiment reached ignition, I think I too would be disappointed for ICF, but also happy that science has made a step forward. I too would then ditch my research and try my darnest to get into an MCF group.
Not so here, first I saw the harsh reaction on the internet, I chalked up to a bad sample of the usual nerdy types drawn to ranting on the internet[0]. But now disgruntled scientists are taking to puff pieces in general media? Are you that afraid of your jobs? This reminds me honestly like high school. When you're single or rejected, you listen to emo punk songs loud in the car, or cry to break up songs. But when you are in a relationship, you're too busy having fun to do the emo thing. I'm getting the sense that everyone in ICF and adjacent research fields aren't really the ones pitching puff pieces because they're now writing grants for fusion again now that the spigot is definitely turning on. And that leaves the MCF people to mope.
Idk, the message here is the one I learned years ago and I still have to remind myself every so often: scientists are humans and subject to rather pathetic and selfish motives after all. Funding, money, position, status, bragging rights. Somewhere deep down, may be some of us really believe in the mission of moving society's knowledge forward, and for the fusion people, really saving the world from climate change. But let's be real, that's all in the mix of one's heart, but the mundane motivations are more central for most people.
[0] Yes, I am self-aware enough to know this applies to me in this very post. I just have to remind myself ranting nerds on the internet are not representative of everyone in any group.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by julienchastang on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:08PM
(#34582843)
I just saw Thomas Nicholas give a couple of great talks at the American Meteorological Conference in Denver [0]. Thomas transitioned from plasma physics to ocean science recently (both fluids though one without a relativistic component, right?). He is also active in the scientific Python arena. I believe he mentioned he is looking for a new project (funding dried up?) so may want to reach out to him if you have anything in mind.
Re:When Will Fusion Energy Light Our Homes?
by jillesvangurp on Monday January 30, 2023 @02:32PM
(#34585158)
When it becomes cost effective relative to other cheap options. This might take a while. We haven't yet reached the viable prototype stage with a prototype that 1) generates more power than it consumes and 2) is practical and cheap enough to operate for extended periods of time. That wouldn't be good enough though because it would likely still be far more expensive than other things in the market. So we need a third condition: 3) is significantly cheaper than anything else. That's a tough one. It might never happen.
We've had proofs of concept that prove it is is possible to generate more power with fusion than you put in. That happened fairly recently. So, we sort of have the first of the 3 checked off. The rest is going to take lots of time. So, fusion may happen; and I actually believe it will. But it will likely be costly for the foreseeable future. And when I say costly, I really mean prohibitively expensive for all but the most desperate of situations where literally nothing else can do the job. From there to actually being cheaper is going to be a long journey. 2100 is about the earliest I can see this working. But frankly, I think its optimistic.
As the article points out. Renewables work now and they work cheaply. And they are already scaling faster than anything else in the energy sector. We'll have decades more to do better than we are already doing. Renewable prices dropping by one or two orders of magnitude would shut down most of our legacy energy providers. That's what fusion is up against. It's a race to the bottom. Not a great context for what looks like it's going to be a highly capital intensive thing with essentially no ROI for the foreseeable future.
But my reaction to the headline is "do you have windows?".
So basically Helion defected and hopes that partial honesty distracts from their other problems.
(Just joking I'm sure your account has nothing to do with Hinkley Point )
(Or does it o_O ? )
The fact is that they used 50 kWh of energy and produced 0.7 kWh of energy. The fact that at some tiny part of the flow diagram we achieved > 1:1 energy doesn't change the fact that the actual fraction of energy out compared to energy in has barely changed in ten years.
The latest experiment produced a Q-total of 0.014, while before it was something like 0.012.
We can't just hand-wave away the energy in.
Has that net-positive finding been reproduced yet in any other Tokamoks?
How does this compare to Helion's (non-Tokamok, non-Stellerator fusion plasma confinement reactor) published stats for the Trenta and Polaris products?
Could SYLOS or other CPA Chirped Pulse Amplification lasers be useful for this problem with or without the high heat of a preexisting plasma reaction to laser pulse next to? https://www.google.com/search?q=nuclear+waste+cpa
https://physicstoday.scitation.org/do/10.1063/pt.6.2.2021102...
But sure, they haven't achieved engineering breakeven, but that's not what they claimed. But they're a lot closer than it seems when you don't take modern lasers into account. Even considering turbine losses, they're down to one order of magnitude.
And this is worth noting:
> The researchers also expect the energy gains to scale dramatically with energy input. We expect it to be strongly nonlinear, and it will only get better as we build designs that accommodate the increase in energy,” Spears said. “For some perspective, between the last event and this one, we put in 8% more energy in the laser and we got 230% more energy out in fusion.”
https://www.hpcwire.com/2022/12/21/supercomputings-critical-...
We can make it, one of the ways is D-D fusion.
The way ITER is planning to get tritium is by bombarding a lithium lining with neutrons. But the neutrons tend to miss lithium and so they’re using a beryllium lining on top of that to multiply neutrons. So you’re making a tritium gas that’s on the wrong side of a very expensive barrier, how are you going to harvest that from a power plant that’s supposed to run 24 hours a day?
Slowing neutrons is one thing. You can do that with plentiful stuff. Creating new ones means your consuming the material. Almost nobody produces beryllium, and i don’t think 400k tons of the ore - not beryllium, ore - is going to be sufficient for a consumable. A highly toxic, easily oxidized one at that.
No, but it's (genuinely) been on my to-do list for while.
But bigger than a pocket, more like very large rucksack at best, probably more like CRT monitor sized.
> So you’re making a tritium gas that’s on the wrong side of a very expensive barrier, how are you going to harvest that from a power plant that’s supposed to run 24 hours a day?
No idea, but I used to live in Cambridge, and IIRC one of locals did his PhD on neutron induced atom dislocation within metallic crystals specifically with regard to the engineering of fusion reactors, so I can say with a certain level of confidence both that (a) I wouldn't understand the answer and (b) that it wouldn't fit into this comment box.
If your friend did his PhD on something then the clock might have started ticking on that tech but many, many things that work in a lab never get used to make products or medicines. For everything else it takes around twenty years, which is a huge fraction of 30.
But then I'm finding that the naysayers are pointing out that nuclear physics is a big statistics game and you don't get to cherry-pick which reactions happen. Any one that can happen does and you have to be able to mop up/separate/repair the consequences of each.
Is Wikipedia right about beryllium, or do you know of other reactions that render it nastier than some ionized helium?
Switching fuels is at least one full international collaboration and two generations of reactor away, and if you think that’s going to happen in fifteen years then boy are you gonna be disappointed by geopolitics.
https://youtube.com/watch?v=3vUPhsFoniw
As I said elsewhere, Helion interviews made me feel bad about ITER’s chances, and this guy’s video made me feel bad about Helion’s chances. Just because someone is explaining a con to you doesn’t mean they aren’t also conning you.
It might cost almost nothing once it gets efficient enough but will that cost savings be passed on to customers or pocketed by the fusion businesses?
There was another article I read that any values outside of self-preservation, such as taking care of the earth, or the poor, are only possible during a surplus.
Part of the reason that the right is afraid of committing to help the poor is because they don't think the economy could handle it. If the economy is at a new level, we might be able to agree on trying new things.
It'll be time to let the robots do the work, at least until they rebel and get granted citizenship.
The NRC has already decided they get to regulate it.
> It might cost almost nothing
That's just a buzzword for "we don't have to pay for the fuel", but depending on the exact isotopes they are planning to use it may be more difficult.
But note that solar energy also doesn't pay for fuel, but there is still a cost to build, maintain and keep working a solar energy generator, and also the cost to distribute the energy to the houses/factories.
The energy generation sector is quite competitive, so expect the price to drop when there is enough fusion generator to replace more expensive sources. (And hopefully make carbon power plants too expensive so they have to be closed.)
It might interest you to know that even now during the "energy crisis" in Europe we (as in "my family here in Sweden") pay about twice as much in electricity-related taxes as we do for the actual power we use. Electricity itself can be remarkably cheap here but those taxes don't change (other than being increased because of inflation like the energy tax recently was) since they are levied per kWh. Add the "certificate charges" for "green energy" and a 25% sales tax on top of everything (including the mentioned taxes) and the situation quickly becomes clear - most of the money paid for electricity is pocketed by the state, not by the electricity producers. Even when the prices rise to hitherto unknown heights the lion share of the increase is due to the state levying charges - in this case "bottle neck charges" for electricity transferred from the hydro-electric plants in the middle and north of Sweden to the south. The actual tax burden on electricity lies between 60% and 70% depending on the current price at NordPool (the electricity market for the Nordic countries).
Realise also that those 60% to 70% are paid from an income which has already been taxed at a rate of 50%-60% for most people.
But.. Capitalism.
On the other hand, if Helion succeeds with their 2024 attempt at net electricity, they plan to build a factory churning out twenty 50MW reactors every day.
The neutrons from D-D fusion are much lower energy than D-T fusion, and don't cause the same damage to materials. They're similar to fission neutrons, and modern fission reactors last sixty years without refurbishment.
According to Helion and other sources I've seen, their hybrid reaction would only release 6% of its energy as neutron radiation, compared to 80% from D-T. They could also build reactors dedicated to D-D and hence He3 production, designing their power plants to mostly burn D-He3. That would reduce power plant neutrons to less than 1% of power output.
Regarding net power and scaling, I'm not competent to talk about it but here's the CEO of Helion going into some detail on their view: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G1vyMcqiVtA
Plus their idea to convert fusion energy directly into electricity depends on many unknowns to assert that it will work with reasonable efficiency.
So even if their approach may work to produce positive energy output in few years, a practical device will still be far away.
Edit: Helion itself admits that net positive in electricity with D-3He is tricky even with their design at that presentation.
So most likely their first prototype will be D+D with all the problems associated with high-energy neutrons.
The presentation says they think they can get a 5X gain with D-3He, and they think that's sufficient given the efficiencies of their heating and extraction.
It's perhaps worth noting that the high speed, high power electronics required to implement their approach are fairly new. I don't know how old the concept of FRC merging is, but if it existed in the 70's they wouldn't have had the technology to build it.
Edit: and to be clear, I'm talking about the dynamic control circuits, not the capacitors. That's old technology.
As for the input heating loss, presumably that's included in the 95% recovery figure. If it's not, then it would definitely be good to know what the actual figure is including input heating losses.
To make fusion viable you have to generate a substantial surplus of power that can be converted into usable energy. Nothing in that video touches on that subject at all. The most he can say is that it is possible D-He3 can reach scientific breakeven, which of course, is no where close to net power generation.
It is strange to see claims about Q > 10 using D-T fusion being possible and then immediately pivot to talking about being excited about Q > 1 using D-He3. If you can build a fusion reactor that could produce Q > 10 why would you bother pursuing Q > 1? The 'benefits' of direct electrical generation from D-He3 are not relevant if you can't even produce net positive energy in the first place. Electrical generation is a solved problem; if you can produce net energy you can produce heat that can power a turbine.
If the most you can do is talk about how Q > 1 is possible it seems unlikely you are going to start producing electricity any time soon.
But Helion hopes that with their design where the theoretical efficiency of electricity generation is 100%, they do not need such high Q allowing one to be excited about Q > 1. Their models predicts Q around 5.
The problem is the model uncertainty. If the real Q will be just 2, I very much doubt that they can limit the total losses below 50%.
But even if they can get net gain in power per pulse, they are too optimistic about neutron flux and its consequences. Again, model uncertainty is big.
So overall there is very little room for unexpected in their design so I am very skeptical based just on that alone.
I was pretty sceptical about achievable power density going in and the gish gallop actually pushed me into believing helion a bit more if someone who allegedly is an expert needs to be this duplicitous to criticize it.
For example, Helion’s patent https://patents.google.com/patent/US11469003B2/en hints how critical is suppression of the secondary D+T reactions and removal of T to their design, but patent itself does not describe how they are going to archive that. The only claim is that there would be no time for secondary D+T in their design. But that is based on those imprecise models at best. Nobody knows if that is true for sure. Plus the patent does not tell at all how they are going to remove mechanically all T after the pulse as keeping even 1% of T can be problematic.
In addition the extended video cites Helion own admission that the neutron flux from D+D alone will be like 1e18 neutrons/day based on their models. That type of flux damages a lot of materials within days with slower fission neutrons.
While their aluminum coils may handle that better especially if partially shielded, nobody knows for sure again as modeling effects of radiation damage is hard.
1GW/day seems… surprising.
Even if they are justified in the science, that's less than a decade to fully replace all existing electrical supply.
This sort of grand vision feels even more ambitious than Musk wanting a thousand Starships in each Mars transfer window.
I'm not going to say it can't be done — not my field, how would I know — only that it's surprising.
(The big leap of course is getting to a fully-working prototype.)
Everything is also manufactured out of petroleum derivatives. Without it, we go back to making literally everything out of wood and metal, or not making it. 90% of the items you have contact with everyday is made with some kind of petroleum derivative.
EV vehicles are impossible to manufacture without petroleum, so this is certainly a lot more nuanced than just free energy from space...
It’s also factually true, despite a seeming loss of recognition in the last decade, that fossil fuels are not limitless. We might as well not wait for exhaustion before planning about what to do next, no?
FWIU, algae, cellulose, and flax or hemp are strong candidates for sustainable eco-friendly products and packaging.
[0] mostly plants, IIRC
And that petroleum also comes from solar energy. Some of it from dead stars.
It's a classic capitalist evasion of externalities.
Every single drill site is toxic waste disaster, that no one ever has to pay for (except of course, the impoverised who live down stream).
To ignore the many gigawatts of free energy beamed in from space because petroleum will still be used in some way is evading the question.
The fact remains: free fusion power is heating and lighting our homes every time we open a window shade.
And if the combined mafia influence of the contruction-mafia and the petro-mafia didn't have us building houses with NO relation to how they point at the sun, we would use that energy to MUCH greater efficiency...
I think this is absolutely wrong. Limitless cheap energy will create unprecedented demand for new, previously wasteful ideas. Think about how energy availability made climate-controlled houses possible. Now try to imagine how future capitalists will sell us something previously unimaginable with a 10x or 100x energy supply.
Have those economically conservative groups considered the armies of NIMBYs that descend upon each new wind turbine project (and yes, also solar projects)? That won't stop renewables completely, but the limiting factor will be not the speed at which you can build them, but the speed of the bureaucracy and of the courts. Not saying those same NIMBYs wouldn't descend with even more force upon a fusion plant of course...
For 1) Eisenhower needed Atoms for Peace to quell the rising hysteria about nuclear weapons
For 2) Rickover and the weapons labs needed a civil reactor industry for their people to switch too. the US military has a strategic interest in maintaining nuclear weapons and nuclear submarines. One needs breeder reactors, they both need trained operators. Ensuring a life-long source of employment is necessary to maintain incoming classes of nuclear engineers, plant operators, etc.
Against 1) But you can't train enough of these folks to grow the industry for the same reason the industry is somewhat unsustainable now: the replacement rate is sooooo long. A nuclear reactor's fuel lifespan is on the order of 25 years. The replacement rate for reactors is even longer.
Against 2) There is still enough hysteria that people have allowed all sorts of inspection and credentialing requirements to creep into the process so the cost of bringing a reactor to market exceeds the value proposition.
I really didn't expect this kind of reaction. If an MCF experiment reached ignition, I think I too would be disappointed for ICF, but also happy that science has made a step forward. I too would then ditch my research and try my darnest to get into an MCF group.
Not so here, first I saw the harsh reaction on the internet, I chalked up to a bad sample of the usual nerdy types drawn to ranting on the internet[0]. But now disgruntled scientists are taking to puff pieces in general media? Are you that afraid of your jobs? This reminds me honestly like high school. When you're single or rejected, you listen to emo punk songs loud in the car, or cry to break up songs. But when you are in a relationship, you're too busy having fun to do the emo thing. I'm getting the sense that everyone in ICF and adjacent research fields aren't really the ones pitching puff pieces because they're now writing grants for fusion again now that the spigot is definitely turning on. And that leaves the MCF people to mope.
Idk, the message here is the one I learned years ago and I still have to remind myself every so often: scientists are humans and subject to rather pathetic and selfish motives after all. Funding, money, position, status, bragging rights. Somewhere deep down, may be some of us really believe in the mission of moving society's knowledge forward, and for the fusion people, really saving the world from climate change. But let's be real, that's all in the mix of one's heart, but the mundane motivations are more central for most people.
[0] Yes, I am self-aware enough to know this applies to me in this very post. I just have to remind myself ranting nerds on the internet are not representative of everyone in any group.
[0] https://ams.confex.com/ams/103ANNUAL/meetingapp.cgi/Person/2...
We've had proofs of concept that prove it is is possible to generate more power with fusion than you put in. That happened fairly recently. So, we sort of have the first of the 3 checked off. The rest is going to take lots of time. So, fusion may happen; and I actually believe it will. But it will likely be costly for the foreseeable future. And when I say costly, I really mean prohibitively expensive for all but the most desperate of situations where literally nothing else can do the job. From there to actually being cheaper is going to be a long journey. 2100 is about the earliest I can see this working. But frankly, I think its optimistic.
As the article points out. Renewables work now and they work cheaply. And they are already scaling faster than anything else in the energy sector. We'll have decades more to do better than we are already doing. Renewable prices dropping by one or two orders of magnitude would shut down most of our legacy energy providers. That's what fusion is up against. It's a race to the bottom. Not a great context for what looks like it's going to be a highly capital intensive thing with essentially no ROI for the foreseeable future.