Florida already has the worst teacher shortage in the nation: https://www.clickorlando.com/news/local/2023/01/22/our-child...
This is completely insane. How can this be even remotely constitutional? Please tell me at least the current Florida legislature is deeply unpopular because of their commitment to censorship and opposition to education.
Having a library of books is an easy way to encourage literacy, probably even the best way. It is not the only way.
Far more important to the development of literacy in children is the presence of books in the home. There are decades of statistics on the impact of just having a stack of books in the same home as the child.
All of this is also failing to touch on the problem that drew this overreaction. To be sure it is a huge over-extension of what the government ought to do. But the thing it was a reaction to... That never had anything to do with literacy, and everything to do with ideology. When one uses literacy as the shield, and depends on the perpetual good graces of people one has spent years demonizing on ideological grounds, one should expect damage to the very thing everyone thought was sacrosanct.
Of course, but that's not something schools have control over. Unless they can give a child a book on loan to take home. And that requires books in the school. And because different children have different interests and different reading issues, a wide selection of books is better than a narrow one.
> That never had anything to do with literacy, and everything to do with ideology.
Do you mean that the ban is about ideology, sacrificing children's access to reading in order to indoctrinate them into a state-approved ideology?
> When one uses literacy as the shield, and depends on the perpetual good graces of people one has spent years demonizing on ideological grounds, one should expect damage to the very thing everyone thought was sacrosanct.
They clearly don't think it's sacrosanct if they're sacrificing it this eagerly to hurt the people they want to demonize. I guess we're talking about gay people here? They want to demonize gay people, and want to restrict the book supply in order to indoctrinate children with that?
I'm not saying the law is right, or even that the stance of the parents are correct. But trying to say these moves are solely about literacy is ignoring where all this started.
I also believe that most of this backlash is about children being able to freely access information that contradicts their parents' worldview. I have also seen strict parents punish their children for expressing differing beliefs and values. Queer kids get physically abused by their religious parents. I absolutely believe schools should be a safe place for students to learn and experiment with ideas and values.
Not to mention, strict informational control has long been a mechanism for abuse. I think there's probably a nexus between parents who object to their kids reading what they want and parents who utilize various physical and psychological abuses as "discipline".
I'd strongly prefer exposing kids, in an age-appropriate manner, of course, to the whole breadth of human ideology and life experiences, with different views on it, and teaching them to think for themselves.
But mostly, I've got a kid that's struggling to read, but has a couple of very strong interests (trains!) that I leverage to get him to read more. Restricting the diversity of books available because they need to go through some slow approval process first, will make it harder for him to access books that he's eager to read. Because the whitelisting process means that even books that aren't even the slightest bit objectionable, won't necessarily be available, and may have to wait until more mainstream books have been approved.
High schoolers are going through puberty and many are sexually active so statutes (s. 847.012) banning "detailed verbal descriptions or narrative accounts of sexual excitement" in books are just puritanical nonsense. That would definitely rule out ASOIAF and probably 1984. I'm pretty sure it would even rule out some young adult novels I read in high school and high schoolers are the target audience.
For lower grade levels I suppose there is maybe a more reasonable argument to be had over what is age appropriate but "felony for unapproved books" seems like a pretty absurd conclusion to reach.
Frankly I don't think I need any cover to demonize parents calling for book bans.
I’m not sure I follow.
MAS*H would be condemned as anti-veteran today.
I'm not sure I follow.
Government regulations rarely make any logical sense
PhDs -- yes. They're expected to teach or TA.
Most of my mentoring and tutoring experience came from new hires at work.
The lowest scores on the ASVAB are for things like cooks or truck drivers, or things like fuel filtration specialists aka gas station attendants in cammo.
None are qualified to teach Calc I but some might not be qualified to teach much of anything.
[1]https://www.fldoe.org/finance/fl-edu-finance-program-fefp/ft...
[2] https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d13/tables/dt13_203.20.a...
How many Kindergarten libraries do you think have pornography in them? Seriously. What has given you the impression that this is happening? What proof have you been offered?
This is very obviously an attempt to control what kids are allowed to learn from the top down using “pornography” as an excuse.
1) consent (whether it mentions sex or not)
2) the child's own body (in ways designed to help them recognize and avoid things like sexual abuse)
3) queer issues of any kind, but especially trans issues
as pornographic, regardless of the actual content, so that they can ban it and claim they're saving the poor children from horrible, horrible sexual material.
This is not a new movement; conservatives have been trying to ban queer people from any kind of public visibility for decades by claiming that their very existence is sexual, ignoring the fact that heterosexual romance and sex is being shoved into our faces constantly, often in far more blatant ways, and often in media explicitly aimed at children. They're merely redoubling their efforts now that it's becoming clear that society at large is starting to genuinely accept trans people, which they cannot abide.
This isn't new. Florida teacher shortage has existed for a long time. It's because Florida doesn't pay their teachers. This isn't likely to change anytime soon because Republicans have had a stranglehold on Florida since 1999, and they are notoriously anti-education.
Is it anti-education, pro-poverty, or both?
They really got you vibing on that us v them toxicity don't they.
The data[0] doesn't support that claim.
[0] https://worldpopulationreview.com/state-rankings/welfare-rec...
Of course you can live on welfare alone. Many do, and in fact it can become a full time job just to stay on welfare, especially when it becomes multi-generational.
Source: a partner who worked in the welfare offices and dealt with such people (of all races).
This isn't my experience. Many who came into asking were even on minimum-wage jobs, just trying to survive.
Source: I worked in welfare offices and dealt with many people.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_and_terr...
Florida would have a booming economy if the governor's office and state administration was entirely staffed with armadillos. Florida's economy and low taxes are fueled by tourism, and since tourism is unlikely to go anywhere, neither is the booming economy, which has boomed through every administration, Republican or Democrat, since the end of WWII. There is nothing the fascist Santos administration could possibly do to either hurt or help Florida's economy, no matter how deeply he indulges his narcissism.
[1] https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2022-elections/exit-polls
EDIT: Since I can't reply the the threads below me, "education" can't just be had in the classroom. In fact as an experienced developer almost all of my education was outside the classroom. I suspect this is the case for most fields.
EDIT 2: Higher skilled "educated" people like neurosurgeons, urologists and orthodontists vote Republican[3]
Which has been true since the dawn of value exchange. That's part of why the outcry against "inequality" citing differences in income between a 20-year veteran of some career versus a new entrant in the market are so tough to swallow.
Wait twenty years... they'll be the same... Unless we change the rules to take it all away from everyone.
What you're describing is vocational training. Education typically includes forced ventures outside of one's own narrow worldview. That's why Republicans hate education. They want cogs with saleable vocational skills who won't question the narrow worldview that is preferred on the right.
https://flgov.com/2020/06/24/governor-ron-desantis-signs-his...
And is about to raise them more but with some possible union restrictions attached:
https://www.wfla.com/news/desantis-call-for-more-teacher-pay...
Working as designed. They cannot possibly be so ignorant as to claim good intentions.
But most ITT are outraged "florida won't let us show porn to children!"
Destroying public education has been a right-wing goal for decades. Making it a crime to teach is just the latest tactic.
Attacks on teachers never ‘as bad as right now’: union chief (2022) https://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/3621251-attacks...
Right-Wing Money Is Greasing the Anti-Teachers Union Skids (2018) \https://www.tucsonweekly.com/TheRange/archives/2018/07/13/ri...
The Right-Wing Assault on Teachers’ Unions https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/opinion-the-right-w...
or recall Scott Walker and what he did in Wisconsin.
Or even look at the article currently under discussion, which makes it a FELONY for a teacher to have the "wrong" books in the classroom. How can you say that is not an attack on teachers?
I challenge you to contact any person who has worked in public education for more than 5 years and get their view on the right wing. I think you'll find that there is an organized and well funded attack on US public education, which is driven by the right wing.
When "policy measures" include using state violence it's dishonest to not call them "'attacks' and 'assaults'".
https://www.heritage.org/the-given-name-act
(It claims to be about pronouns, and encouraging anti-lgbtq smears, but, if you read the bill, you'll find the reality is much worse.)
There are thousands of examples like this going back decades. You used the words "right wing", but I suspect you don't know what they mean. For example, you should read up on the blocking of the equal rights amendment, which was arguably the founding moment for the right wing in the US. It would have prevented discriminatory hiring by the US government.
Arguments against it included claiming it was a conspiracy between lesbians and government workers, and "you wouldn't want bathrooms to allow gays like desegregation did for blacks, right?", and lots of claims about how men would sexually assault women and children in bathrooms if it passed (the constitutional amendment had nothing to do with bathrooms).
More impactfully, to this day, Prop 13 is hailed as one of the biggest wins of the right wing in California, and it is largely responsible from taking our schools from top ten in the US to bottom ten.
Anyway, I'm guessing you don't support any of this nonsense based on the rest of your comment.
Nobody said it was universal. But it is incredibly dishonest to pretend that there is a huge effort to destroy public education among the right wing. Libraries are under attack across the nation, and there is a major push to dissolve the separation of church and state. This movement is underway, and it's being pushed by the right wing. That is not to say that every single conservative supports it.
> Additionally, making it a crime to teach is not a tactic that is being used by any mainstream political group or party.
Except, did you read the article? It's a felony for teachers to have wrongthink books in their classrooms. The Ministry of Truth maintains a list of permissible books. This is a law passed by DeSantis, the most likely 2024 candidate for president. If that ain't mainstream, I don't know what is.
we clearly want to a "Destroy public education" by making teachers accountable to parents which is a terrible thing according to the teachers union
//sidenote we also want to abolish all public unions (including teachers union) as public sector employees use their union to corrupt the election process in their favor screwing over the tax payer who ends up having no one in their favor in contract talks.
This sounds like trading away some freedom of association for a small group of people — ostensibly for the greater good — which isn’t very pro-liberty in my eyes. Where I live, while the taxpayers do not attend these contract talks we have the final word in that we ultimately decide to pass the school budget or not through voting.
Pure unbridled free market will crush unions anyway, both the kinds formed by corporations (collusion) and those formed by employees (union). There is no need to legislate such action as market forces influence actors towards the more economical choice.
Unless they are public sector union which face not market competition at all, as they are government employees. Thus the problem with them
I was very clear to not be "Anti-union" as you seem to claim but I am very much anti-PUBLIC SECTOR unions as there is clear conflict of interest inherent in those. Many libertrian are "pro union" for the private sector but are opposed to public sector union because of this clear conflict
The libertarian solution to the Teachers Union issue is to have schools run by private organizations not attached to the government, thus would be free to unionize and have all the union benefits.
So long as they are a public employee who vote, and who use their power to have outside influence over the ones who are supposed to be representing all taxpayers not just the ones in the union, there is a clear conflict of interest when it comes to PUBLIC sector unions.
Want to be in a union, support backpack funding of private schools and end public schools
Hell even FDR was opposed to Public Sector Unions
1) Lower grades (i.e. k-6) will often keep a bunch of books in the classroom, so the kids have a selection available if they want to (or have to) read. This way they don't have to make a trip to the library to pick out a new book, as it can often be kinda difficult for a kid to find time to visit the library outside scheduled classroom visits, and that's an extra step between a kid wanting to read and being able to, that teachers would rather not have (since it might mean less reading). Often these sorts of classroom libraries are stocked by the teacher. Such libraries may be left behind by teachers retiring or otherwise leaving teaching, and the teacher replacing them may keep part or all of the library.
2) Upper grades, where you start having dedicated English or "Language Arts" classrooms, will often keep classroom sets (that is, enough books for every kid to have one at once) of the books the classes teach. Often there will also be other individual books, plus maybe some classroom sets of books that the teacher doesn't teach (maybe they switched their program up a bit, or maybe they're left overs from a previous teacher)—a teacher may keep these around or stock such a small library themselves and let kids borrow them, because being an upper-grades English teacher tends to correspond with liking and wanting to encourage reading. Some lower grade (well, properly, middle-grade or what you might call "upper elementary", but I'm trying to keep it simple) classes may also keep a few classroom sets once the kids can read independently and full books are being taught to and read by the entire class at once (a 4th grade classroom might have a classroom set of Charlotte's Web or something like that)
That being said school libraries in America do tend to be walk in places where you can pick something up to read.
Most of the classrooms I remember fondly as a kid had a selection of magazines along the same lines as you'd find in the average dentist's waiting room plus a mix of books based on the teacher's tastes. "The Way Things Work" was a recurring favorite of mine that popped up in a lot of classrooms through my first few years of school.