Chat-GPT can be used for this: returing interesting results. The ads don't have to be served through chat-GPT, but could be given as a side result.
Isn’t that pretty much what the Yellow Pages used to be? As long as you know what you’re getting…
If you wanted to find the number of a particular restaurant, the white pages were far more efficient.
The yellow pages were primarily useful when you wanted a list of restaurants, not a specific one.
Something else that was nearly 100% ads: the old Computer Shopper magazine. As I recall, they printed just enough editorial material to qualify for the "literature" postal rate rather than the "advertising" rate.
These are all ads. The enemy isn't ads, it's an extremely intrusive and adversarial advertising industry posture.
Ads are useful, they tell me where and what things are available. The problem is that everyone uses the methods originated with patent medicine to sell everything.
The methods of selling patent medicine are simply the methods of confidence men; the "medicine" was probably just some unholy mix of alcohol and mercury. Patent medicine marketing emphasizes secrecy, because they're usually mostly frauds; and also because to any extent they are not fraudulent, they want to be exclusive and not copied. Patent medicine marketing also emphasizes leads, surveillance and secret dossiers. When you're selling dreams, you have to know what people are dreaming about; you also have to know how much they have to spend.
Our advertising problem is a legislative problem. We find it very difficult to police this kind of behavior because it is so widespread among the powerful (and is usually what got them powerful.) It is also completely rational behavior because the methods of con men will sell more regardless of the quality of the product i.e. a good product sells even better using underhanded methods. So there's simply no way to protect your world from being run by the best con men without creating legal obstructions for them.
And why I'm using Google less and less. I've literally had the entire first page be all ads.
"Help me buy whichever budget electric range Wirecutter recommends at the moment".
> Okay, here's the store near your home that is selling the Frigidaire electric range that Wirecutter is currently recommending, at the best price.
> Would you like to buy it online at roughly the same price or get the address of the store?
Can you explain how this is any different than what Google does?
E.g. imagine when you search via chatgpt. It googles : search phrase, search phrase + reddit, search phrase variation 1, variation 1 + reddit, var 2, etc... all in parallel almost then uses that to mini-tune an ai model to find the stuff that best matches what you're really wanting to find, and then scrapes top ten for results.
The only difference, which is not an improvement, is that you've suddenly given Wirecutter total power. At least if you make users visit the site and read a bit of the review, the reviewer has the hurdle of writing some text that can convince a human reader that the results are not totally bought and paid for.
If you are having a sale, you are going to be near the top of the results for any reasonable sorting scheme. (An actual sale, not here's 50% off of my bullshit price)
And searching Google for "buy lawnmower" is a good way to buy something you didn't want or need. Even if you actually needed a lawnmower. The only people it helps are those who don't care whether the item is good, and don't care about the price at which point they might as well just walk into the nearest store and buy the first one they see.
I think the revenue assumption here lies on the fact that GPT generates content when the web wait for the user to provide the content. Generates congent, for lawyers or hospitals for example - pardon my lack of imagination. So a basic business model would be to charge per request I suppose.
Pretty sure you can, because Google search sucks balls. (First and foremost because it ignores context. E.g., searching for programming API documentation is tuned entirely differently compared to searching for movie recommendations.)
That said, Google is not in the search business, because there is no such thing. Google is in the context advertising business.
In fact, Google was something of a reactionary model at the time, by rejecting the push for bloated, captive "web portals" and going back to the simpler, stripped-down user experience that Altavista had succeeded with originally.
Given how bad Google's results have become, I think you can certainly outdo it. Anecdotally, it's amazing how often I find myself reaching for ChapGPT these days to find basic facts that Google can't. I think Google is right to be afraid.
Before ChatGPT, I would spend a lot of time searching on Google for the right API call and the response structure:
Problem: I need a simple Python script that list roles in an AWS account that has at least one of a list of command line specified policies.
Before ChatGPT: I would look up the api call to list the roles (the API service area of AWS is huge), then look up the API call to list the policies for the role and then look up the API call for the “paginator” that pages through all of the results since the API call only returns 50 results at a time.
After ChatGPT:
“Write a Python script that allows me to specify a list of AWS IAM roles that contain at least one of a given list of policies”.
I get “working” code and then I start polishing it.
“Use argparse with required parameters and use a paginator to iterate through the roles”
Again expected results.
“I need the list of ARNs printed out as a comma separated list”.
I copy the code into VSCode, test it, and I’m done.
Later on for another project, the customer prefers JavaScript. I copy the code into ChatGPT, and tell it to convert it into JavaScript. It works perfectly and is idiomatic JS along with proper async/await handling
And trust me, once u google stack overflow enough pretty soon you won’t need to ask anyone how to output a csv
https://stackoverflow.com/questions/66127551/list-of-all-rol...
And then there is the context switch. This is just one little script as part of a larger system where I’m designing an entire system. It’s much easier if I’m already writing out a long set of documentation, diagrams, slides, etc just to open ChatGPT and keep writing English.
Not to mention when you’re juggling a couple of projects and one is Node and one is Python.
And just in case you are trying to gatekeep, I’ve been programming for a few years - let’s just say my first hobbyist code was in 65C02 assembly language in 1986
ChatGPT gave me a specific answer with the command line arguments that I specified and allowed me to specify a list of policies and output the result in the format I needed
Google gave me a code snippet that I had to modify for my use case.
Despite this objective comparison, in users' view Google's results were much much better.
I remember a German CS professor telling me eyes in eyes with obviously a lot of schadenfreud "Google will kill you".
And I answered "No they will become as us, big, fat and ugly".
Order is a pretty big part of tbe value prop of a search engine, so ”nearly the same” results but “not in exactly the same order” is not as much similarity as you seem to be implying.
Even Google doesn't change the order of answers based on the user's context. Otherwise it wouldn't say in Google Web Console "your site appears in nth position"
“Absolute correctness” is an irrelevant standard. Order can affect satisfaction without "absolute correctness" being a thing that can even be assessed meaningfully.
> Even Google doesn’t change the order of answers based on the user’s context.
Yes, it does. [0]
> Otherwise it wouldn’t say in Google Web Console “your site appears in nth position”
I think that reflects the experience of a no-context user (e.g., not logged in or otherwise tied to a history to provide context.)
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contextual_searching#Automatic...
Search is dead, spammers killed it and Google was happy about it because it has become an answer machine where they can say the answer is whoever pays the most. Greatly deteriorated experience from what it used to be.
Now someone builds an answers machine with much much better user experience with all that data which Google can no longer surface.
I don't know if Google can quickly match that function but even if they do, are they going to be able to replicate the experience if the answers machine choose the answers by a bidding war?
Taken in that context puts it in a different light.
Transcribing this profound insight of Buckminster Fuller to the current debate: You cannot out-do google by inventing "smarter" search. You need to create a new business model that makes the old one obsolete.
Is there any evidence that all this algorithmic magic is enabling new business models that are not based on adtech more likely? It would be a blessing (presumably, because things can always drift further into evil) but, so far at least, there is little to point to such an imminent disruption