It doesn't change that it is harmful abuse. I'm sorry you were subjected to that kind of abuse, even though you believe it was justified.
There's nothing to suggest it serves a legitimate purpose.
Well there's nothing if you disregard personal testimony as stockholm syndrome.
I don’t disregard anything as Stockholm Syndrome, since that doesn’t exist.
However, I do disregard anecdotal conclusory testimony about causative processes, as a general rule. I’ll accept testimony about facts plausibly within the knowledge of the person testifying as being (barring special reason for suspicion on those points) as trustworthy as the person testifying.
No, I disregard anecdote to the extent it makes claims which are conclusory rather than observational.
I weight anecdote very lightly in any case, though.
Well nothing except my personal experience which you clearly disregarded by categorizing me without any evidence as a victim of violence nor do I see this as abuse(obviously).
No offense taken by the comment btw I just don’t believe you are correct in your attempt to analyze my particular situation.
You literally describe the violence you were targeted with.
Your personal view that this violence was justified and is part of a beneficial pattern of violence does not negate that it is violence.
If there were data showing improved outcomes among this group compared to those not subjected to violence, there'd be reason to listen to their accounts, but since there isn't independent evidence to support these claims, and it's not a controlled sample, their anecdotes have little value.
I have at least 2 memories where I have been spanked really hard from my parents due to being misunderstood. What's the consequence of that? Who is going to punish the parent? In children's view, that's a major punishment for no correct reason, what does it teaches about law?
Hitting a child to teach them could be better than some alternatives. But it's definitely not the best approach. It seems like an option for those without any idea on what else to do.
I am also pretty sure that if violence is the only thing you respect, it's the only lever others have
What you're telling people is that assault by the state against children is acceptable.
> Neither instance caused any psychological damage
Really now? I would consider acute fear to be, at the very least, psychologically detrimental, if not to you then to the vast majority of people. Generally, fear is not conducive to a healthy learning environment.
a) that corporal punishment is the only or only effective way to ensure nobody or at least less students have to fear other peers b) corporal punishment is any effective at all c) the necessity to fear some peers has a strong connection to whether they are 'controllable'
All three claims seem to be disputed.
Parents are notoriously shitty people.
What can I say? It is America, give them mass shootings, death penalty and spanking. For each it's own.
George Orwell would love this New Speak of yours, for he was also subject to such "physical discipline" and had no fond memories of it.
Corporeal punishment can be harmful to children and may lead to long-term negative outcomes, such as increased aggression, mental health problems, and poor academic performance.
That’s not to speak to who’s enforcing it and on who.
For example, it's easy to make the argument that time-out, a common negative reinforcement strategy among parents, constitutes emotional mistreatment. After all it is just a form of solitary confident, and solitary is known for how it emotionally wrecks adults.
Also, there are legal and cultural definitions of child abuse and, at least where I'm from, corporeal punishment isn't necessarily abusive.
What!
So any form of self defense is abuse? I'm not sure you've thought this through. Trivializing complex issues is the kneejerk response for many, but there isn't a simple moral line of thinking that billions of people have overlooked.
It doesn't make it good; it makes it necessary, and for that reason we often consider it legitimate.
If an adult tried to assault my son, and he hit back, I wouldn't consider it good, but I would be proud he felt able to defend himself against a violent attacker. Even if that attacker was a teacher.
> > So any form of self defense is abuse?
> Yes, it's abusive
Abuse is a term used to describe impropriety of action. The idea that impropriety is used to counter impropriety is not coherent. Self-defense is proper (suitable, appropriate, etc) use of force, insofar as an individual values safety of their person. Self-defense is necessarily not abuse. I dont think any amount of rewording will change this.
If we restrict it to the impropriety of action, then I agree it does not apply to self defence, but that was not the meaning of my reply. I of course can't speak to the poster of the original statement, so if we interpret it as impropriety of action, I agree with you; in the broader sense allowed by the other dictionaries I stand by what I wrote.
If society creates an unsafe environment, then sometimes violence is necessary as a means to fight an abusive regime and cause change. That does not mean it's a nice thing - last resorts seldom are.
That you think I'm the "kinder, gentler" crowd is your mistake. I just don't like injustice, and punching down against someone unable to defend themselves is one of the worst forms of injustice.
Said no modern, respectable scientist who has studied the phenomenon within the last thirty years.
...said some guy on a forum.
From 2006: https://www.apa.org/pubs/journals/releases/bul-1284596.pdf "There is general consensus that corporal punishment is effective in getting children to comply immediately while at the same time there is caution from child abuse researchers that corporal punishment by its nature can escalate into physical maltreatment,"
The meta-analysis study that "decided things" in 2021: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34197808/
A critique to that point in 2022: A Response to Heilmann et al.’s (2021) Narrative Review - https://psyarxiv.com/5xbnm/download?format=pdf
Much like Abraham Wald pointed out in WWII, many studies are unintentionally magnifying the statistical outliers incorrectly. As Greg Wilson once said - (summarized) Gender inequity in science being biologically gender influenced is settled as false. The efficacy of corporal punishment is a scottish verdict.
The efficacy and/or benefit of corporal punishment, is undecided.
The last link you provided is a methodological critique of another study, and its authors are of questionable authority (for instance, a dev psych professor at a private Christian college).
Gershoff's contributions to the debate are not a singular paper.
https://www.unmc.edu/newsroom/2002/06/28/dr-larzelere-featur... includes a response from Robert E. Larzelere, Ph.D., which quotes Gershoff as the source of the quote referenced.
Or maybe, just maybe, go the other way and treat kids like people and avoid teaching them that abuse is normal.
Violence is the second most effective form of persuasion known to man, following shame.
We do use violence in limited fashion, around the world, today. In some societies, unmitigated violence was acceptable for a time. Why is it always curtailed? Unequivocally, murder is more effective at achieving settlement in many disputes. Expediency is not the only concern. Society is built on maintained relationships and mutual agreements, not wanton acts of passion to form networks that are more effective and stable than the individual.
Children are not considered fully informed or stable. Shame is difficult to instill, when there is no preconceived notion of social acceptance. Violence is the natural fallback. Is picking up a child and moving them out of the way of a vehicle, when they don't want to be moved, violence? No. Violence isn't simply an action, but the act and intention and efficacy. Modern societies have balanced these concerns and limited them to self-defense and purposeful administrative allowances for violence (police, army).
What does? citation obv
A quick, preemptive edit:
If you take the time to get the ranked list of journals in developmental psychology and then search for this question in those journals, you'll find the consensus gets significantly stronger. As you've already shown us, if you instead go the other direction, and find un-reviewed papers co-authored by professors at private Christian colleges, you can find counterexamples.
https://www.gse.harvard.edu/news/uk/21/04/effect-spanking-br... - This study determines that spanking (as well as other stimuli, like observed violence) may influence behavior negatively. This is used as justification to determine that spanking is detrimental. The study does not expand this to corporal punishment overall, state sponsored or otherwise.
https://sites01.lsu.edu/faculty/pfricklab/wp-content/uploads... - This had 98 subjects recruited from two school systems in the southeastern United States.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3447048/ - This is basically a narrative summary of some existing studies, leaning heavily on -
* https://www.repeal43.org/docs/CP%20research%20US%20Nov%2012....
* https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5094178/pdf/nih...
* https://www.researchgate.net/publication/261705604_The_effec...
Getting access to papers directly is often troublesome, so there may be an additional step of clicking on a link to get the PDF. 2/3 of these papers focus on effects of pre-school corporal punishment (ages 2-6) exclusively, which is hard to correlate to the topic but provides solid evidence that corporal punishment (without qualification) for infants correlates to behavioral problems.
I would not agree that there is consensus nor is there conclusive data in regard to corporal punishment in schools (post-preschool). This is not an issue of convenience, but has large social implications. If you could provide something a bit more compelling, I'm open to it. I don't have a vested interest, other than a higher standard of proof, such that I can defend conclusive evidence.
I took some time off from the thread, to ensure I had a fresh perspective. You want to ascribe an alternative motive (like nobody will read what I wrote) and that's fine. I read it (if nothing else) to ensure I have sufficiently recorded my thoughts for future me. This is useful when I want to refer back to this discussion, which happens fairly often over the years.
> Your problem isn't that I refuse to read things I disagree with; it's that you didn't find anything for me to disagree with.
You are correct. It's not a problem for me. GL with whatever.
I claim undecided.
You claim "broad consensus", for some value of broad that you have curated from sources...at least nothing beyond what I've cited.
I don't think anything has changed. GL
The greatest generation that built this country into what it is were subject to corporal punishment. Today, Asian immigrants use corporal punishment and their kids vastly outperform the children of native born Americans. Maybe there is no correlation between those things, but that is much more concrete evidence than some papers in a psychology journal.
As my sibling commenter notes, we have a neat little case study here, too: we allow corporal punishment in public schools in a minority of states. Overlay outcomes by school district; how's it working out?
We don't
So in the absence of any evidence that corporal punishment works, the obvious answer should be to not do it.
That you seek to compare abuse with saving a child from being hit by a vehicle is a astonishing. We recognises the necessity of physical contact that would sometimes be unlawful when that contact is necessary all the time, irrespective of age.
This attempt at acting as if this has anything to do with children's age or development in order to allow it to be used to justify abuse of children that'd be a crime when carried out against adults fails in that basis: we know how to recognise the difference.
Yet somehow we are told to accept violence against children we're not ourselves willing to be subjected to.
I don't know what "healthy attitude to violence" is when there's a disagreement by what "violence" means. So I'll have to await some clarification, other than simply sharing your unspecified views. Police carry weapons in modern societies across the globe. Claiming violence does not produce lasting compliance is an interesting belief that is not shared by the majority of the world, so I find this claim uncompelling. There are exceptions ofc, like Japan, where a large part of the peacekeeping force patrols without weapons. While it is effective at times, the lack of efficacy can also be seen on Youtube.
> That you seek to compare abuse with saving a child from being hit by a vehicle is a astonishing
I did not compare them directly. I illustrated the use of the term "violence" is overly broad, as unconsented forceful action is not unwarranted. The question is degree, intent, and efficacy, as stated. Please don't misrepresent my statements. You are imagining I meant "abuse", which is another broad term that is dishonestly equated to "corporal punishment" or "violence". I have trouble teasing out what you specifically trying to communicate, other than a strong disdain for corporal punishment without qualification.
It's a belief that is backed by the total absence of evidence of a lasting effect on compliance from the use of violence. That societies continue to condone the use of violence despite the total lack of anything to suggest it works speaks to the pathology of the political process, not to the efficacy of violence.
There are situations where violence becomes necessary, such as self-defence or a defensive war, as a means to achieve short term compliance absent other alternatives, but anyone who believes in a beneficial long term effect on compliance is a fool.
Fixed it for you.
Here's the basic problem:
- Most punishments for kids outside of mainstream cultural norms are harmful
- Most punishments in anger are harmful
Living within that context, I don't use corporal punishment, and I think it would be harmful to my child. However, I am not at all ready to generalize the results to outside of that context.
Another way I'd frame it: The research evidence is at the level where I'm glad to call it a best practice (which I follow), and encourage others to do so. It's not yet at the level where I'm ready to judge people -- especially in other cultures -- who don't.
I suspect a thorough investigation of the African Americans beaten in the streets by cops would find that being beaten by their parents as a child is not substantial protection against being beaten in the streets by cops.
Its a convenient rationalization, though.
We have an unfortunate history where investigations OF African Americans BY white Americans led to not only incorrect but also very unfortunate conclusions.
My own memory is of the time I wasn't hit. I was in elementary school. The principal was out shoveling snow off of the sidewalk where it crossed a driveway. I was out on recess, and I hit her with a snowball. She didn't hit me, though school policy allowed it at the time. Instead, she just had me shovel the snow. (Duh... what did I think was going to happen?)
I got smacked, but in a way that was traumatizing(?) as I remember every second of it decades later. Still, it did actually encourage me to improve the thing I got smacked about and probably led to me being as successful as I am (such as it were.)
There is a rational argument for corporal punishment of kids. A human brain isn’t fully developed until age 25. You can’t reason with kids. There is a place for physical consequences that kids can understand with their limited cognitive capabilities.
The move to ban corporal punishment doesn’t seem to have produced equally effective alternatives. At least from my experience in America, it seems like parents just simply put up with poorly behaved kids. It’s a sort of luxury belief. In a subsistence economy you need kids to behave because mistakes can be fatal. In rich country, you can put up with poorly behaved kids because you just have so much margin.
I'm sure your kids will be fine; they have lots going for them.
What’s your standard for “fine?” Mind is gainfully employed and married with kids by 30, maybe a year or two later, and never divorced. This is nearly guaranteed for someone of my economic class where I am from, but unfortunately in America the odds are unlikely that all three kids will be fine.
And, of course, the other half of the argument is hard to knock down: incidence of corporal punishment clearly doesn't track good economic outcomes. The opposite is much closer to the truth; it probably is the truth, for in part mechanistic reasons (hitting kids damages them, impedes their ability to succeed).
Sorry meant to link this Reddit thread the first time: https://www.reddit.com/r/asiantwoX/comments/2ibwkq/why_asian...
> "Asian" is more than half the world's population; the "model minority" thing is problematic in part because lots of Asian families have poor socioeconomic outcomes in the US. But the cohort captured by the study overlaps pretty completely the cohort of children you're implying have unusually good outcomes.
Closer to the opposite is true. Well assimilated second and third generation Asians don’t do any better than similarly affluent white Americans. It’s the kids of poor Asians—children of Indian gas station owners or Chinese restaurant workers, etc.—that have unusual outcomes. Asian kids raised in the bottom 20% of the income distribution are 2.5x more likely to end up in the top 20% as comparably situated white kids: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/03/27/upshot/make-y....
It’s true that the “model minority” label is misleading as applied to Chinese or Indian people who come here under H1B to work at Google. The fact that those people do well is just filtering. But don’t forget that the American immigration system is one of chain migration. Those immigrants bring over family who often aren’t affluent. But the kids of those people also tend to do very well. And then there are the myriad groups who mostly didn’t come to America through systems like H1B that filter for educated, affluent people. The poverty rate among Vietnamese, who came here as refugees, in 1980 was higher than among black people. Today the median household income of US-born Vietnamese is significantly higher than for white Americans. The same is true for Filipinos.
My point is that when you allude to the academic success of Asian American families, you are discussing exactly the cohort that thread complains is overindexed in the study. The study (and the thread) support my argument, and gravely undermine yours.
Hitting children is not a good way to improve academic outcomes. All the evidence we have right now suggests that, at best, it does nothing; at worst, it damages children and leads to markedly worse outcomes.
Grounding and taking away their computer is a physical consequence that kids can understand with their limited cognitive capabilities. It's not clear to me why their still-developing brains would be an argument for inflicting violence on them. Is there any level at all of physical abuse you couldn't support with this logic?
> In rich country, you can put up with poorly behaved kids because you just have so much margin.
A self-sustaining long-term advantage.
> A self-sustaining long-term advantage.
The empirical evidence is the opposite: developed countries became rich under one kind of culture, and due to social changes in the last half century their social capital is crumbling. On myriad indicators, from loneliness to birth rates to social trust, these countries are on an unsustainable path. Literally: they have been reduced to importing people from countries with “backwards” (but perhaps, if we are honest, more viable) cultures.
How exactly is this a rational argument? You're essentially arguing in favor of corporal punishment against people until the age of 25, since you stated that a 'human brain isn't fully developed until 25' and 'you can't reason with kids'. Do you believe that college students should also be beaten by their professors for being disruptive?
And in comparison it's common knowledge that the worst way to train animals is through violence. We can reason even less with a dog or a cat than we can a teenage individual, but in your view it's rational to punish kids with violence but doing the same to an animal is abuse.
I can tell you that getting hit didn't teach me anything useful at all. Certainly not about reason. It taught me that when reason fails you just rely on your temper. We weren't "corrected" by the punishment in a long term sense, both of my brothers and I just emulated it (to varying degrees).
If you have boys, be careful about modeling physical aggression for them as a norm. You might, say, hit the oldest one as punishment and then weeks later the younger one somehow has a broken arm. Or something happens at school.
We weren't exposed to the world that my dad was growing up in WWII China -- an occupying army, factories blowing up, etc. That doesn't make it a luxury belief that you shouldn't hit your kids. There are consequences to it that reach beyond the lessons you want to teach them.
And if effectiveness were the only criterion against which to judge an act, then maybe one would be justified in supporting violence and threats of violence against children. (Although even there, in aggregate, I’m skeptical that corporal punishment is effective.) But in any case, not all effective actions are morally sound.
Stressing this out is enough of a reply.
But my mother told me once, that when she was in school her teacher was fixated at one girl and did beat her often and mostly for no good reason. The girl was from a poor family, and my mother was upset by the unjustice, but never spoke up, IIRC.
So YMMV.
At the end, I think such occasional injustice is the lesser evil compared to the sheepish society and nanny states that are the consequence of the pathetic antiviolent decadence we have nowadays in most of the nation states.
Care to elaborate?
The antiviolence should be clear reading the most comments to the original post. Denying the violent part of the nature of the monkey horde Homo sapiens is pathetic. And that in all industrialised nations - if not in all else as well-, throw-away society and obscene consumerism are the dominant hype should be obvious.
What the fuck kind of shitty human being is this? Can you even imagine doing that? Putting someone’s hands flat on a desk and hitting as hard as you can with a ruler? That’s some next level twisted psychopathic shit here.
> I actually have a fond memory of it now
There’s your psychological damage. That’s not a normal reaction, even years after.
> It was deserved and fixed the problem at hand and by example to the other students
2 questions for you:
- did it fix anything? Did you learn a lesson or were you just scared of getting caught? I guarantee the only lesson other students learned was « don’t get caught »
- assuming it fixed the issue somehow, was physical abuse the only way to do that?
Personal experience: Every school I attended through 12th grade had corporal punishment in place. In 5th grade I was punished by a Catholic Nun who broke a ruler over my hands as they were laying flat on the desk. It was deserved and fixed the problem at hand and by example to the other students. (haha no pun intended). I actually have a fond memory of it now as they made my parents pay for the broken ruler. We laugh about it now and then. It happened again in HS and remember being scared shitless because it was being administered by a teacher with a good rep for painful swats. It solved the issues that time as well. Neither instance caused any psychological damage to me(that i’m aware of) and helped keep our learning environment a place where people can actually go to learn.
Corporal punishment is no longer practiced in my state. I would support it if it came back. It’s an effective tool.