Re:It's legal to hit children in school in 19 American states
by tptacek on Saturday January 21, 2023 @07:24PM
(#34472588)
This is a strange response, because every single paper you've linked to supports my argument, directly.
Re:It's legal to hit children in school in 19 American states
by Supermancho on Friday January 27, 2023 @06:16PM
(#34553125)
It's not strange _at_all_ to present all aspects of an unknown in a good faith effort to determine the truth. That being said, it's not surprising you decide something is settled only based on things you agree with.
Re:It's legal to hit children in school in 19 American states
by tptacek on Sunday January 29, 2023 @09:16PM
(#34575088)
We are definitely the only two people reading this, and you're likely to have the last word because it's not going to occur to me to go back and reread a 2-week-old thread, but if you'd like to rebut anything I say in the future, I recommend presenting evidence that contradicts my argument rather than evidence that supports it. Your problem isn't that I refuse to read things I disagree with; it's that you didn't find anything for me to disagree with.
Re:It's legal to hit children in school in 19 American states
by Supermancho on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:11PM
(#34582893)
> you're likely to have the last word because it's not going to occur to me to go back and reread a 2-week-old threa
I took some time off from the thread, to ensure I had a fresh perspective. You want to ascribe an alternative motive (like nobody will read what I wrote) and that's fine. I read it (if nothing else) to ensure I have sufficiently recorded my thoughts for future me. This is useful when I want to refer back to this discussion, which happens fairly often over the years.
> Your problem isn't that I refuse to read things I disagree with; it's that you didn't find anything for me to disagree with.
You are correct. It's not a problem for me. GL with whatever.
Re:It's legal to hit children in school in 19 American states
by Supermancho on Monday January 30, 2023 @01:59PM
(#34584720)
So far you have dismissed some studies as poisoned by contradictory interest and characterized some studies as supporting.
I claim undecided.
You claim "broad consensus", for some value of broad that you have curated from sources...at least nothing beyond what I've cited.
I don't think anything has changed. GL
https://www.gse.harvard.edu/news/uk/21/04/effect-spanking-br... - This study determines that spanking (as well as other stimuli, like observed violence) may influence behavior negatively. This is used as justification to determine that spanking is detrimental. The study does not expand this to corporal punishment overall, state sponsored or otherwise.
https://sites01.lsu.edu/faculty/pfricklab/wp-content/uploads... - This had 98 subjects recruited from two school systems in the southeastern United States.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3447048/ - This is basically a narrative summary of some existing studies, leaning heavily on -
* https://www.repeal43.org/docs/CP%20research%20US%20Nov%2012....
* https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5094178/pdf/nih...
* https://www.researchgate.net/publication/261705604_The_effec...
Getting access to papers directly is often troublesome, so there may be an additional step of clicking on a link to get the PDF. 2/3 of these papers focus on effects of pre-school corporal punishment (ages 2-6) exclusively, which is hard to correlate to the topic but provides solid evidence that corporal punishment (without qualification) for infants correlates to behavioral problems.
I would not agree that there is consensus nor is there conclusive data in regard to corporal punishment in schools (post-preschool). This is not an issue of convenience, but has large social implications. If you could provide something a bit more compelling, I'm open to it. I don't have a vested interest, other than a higher standard of proof, such that I can defend conclusive evidence.