What does? citation obv
A quick, preemptive edit:
If you take the time to get the ranked list of journals in developmental psychology and then search for this question in those journals, you'll find the consensus gets significantly stronger. As you've already shown us, if you instead go the other direction, and find un-reviewed papers co-authored by professors at private Christian colleges, you can find counterexamples.
https://www.gse.harvard.edu/news/uk/21/04/effect-spanking-br... - This study determines that spanking (as well as other stimuli, like observed violence) may influence behavior negatively. This is used as justification to determine that spanking is detrimental. The study does not expand this to corporal punishment overall, state sponsored or otherwise.
https://sites01.lsu.edu/faculty/pfricklab/wp-content/uploads... - This had 98 subjects recruited from two school systems in the southeastern United States.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3447048/ - This is basically a narrative summary of some existing studies, leaning heavily on -
* https://www.repeal43.org/docs/CP%20research%20US%20Nov%2012....
* https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5094178/pdf/nih...
* https://www.researchgate.net/publication/261705604_The_effec...
Getting access to papers directly is often troublesome, so there may be an additional step of clicking on a link to get the PDF. 2/3 of these papers focus on effects of pre-school corporal punishment (ages 2-6) exclusively, which is hard to correlate to the topic but provides solid evidence that corporal punishment (without qualification) for infants correlates to behavioral problems.
I would not agree that there is consensus nor is there conclusive data in regard to corporal punishment in schools (post-preschool). This is not an issue of convenience, but has large social implications. If you could provide something a bit more compelling, I'm open to it. I don't have a vested interest, other than a higher standard of proof, such that I can defend conclusive evidence.
I took some time off from the thread, to ensure I had a fresh perspective. You want to ascribe an alternative motive (like nobody will read what I wrote) and that's fine. I read it (if nothing else) to ensure I have sufficiently recorded my thoughts for future me. This is useful when I want to refer back to this discussion, which happens fairly often over the years.
> Your problem isn't that I refuse to read things I disagree with; it's that you didn't find anything for me to disagree with.
You are correct. It's not a problem for me. GL with whatever.
I claim undecided.
You claim "broad consensus", for some value of broad that you have curated from sources...at least nothing beyond what I've cited.
I don't think anything has changed. GL
The greatest generation that built this country into what it is were subject to corporal punishment. Today, Asian immigrants use corporal punishment and their kids vastly outperform the children of native born Americans. Maybe there is no correlation between those things, but that is much more concrete evidence than some papers in a psychology journal.
As my sibling commenter notes, we have a neat little case study here, too: we allow corporal punishment in public schools in a minority of states. Overlay outcomes by school district; how's it working out?
We don't
So in the absence of any evidence that corporal punishment works, the obvious answer should be to not do it.