Actually I doubt this. But the very simple, dumb icons probably scale more cleanly.
Look at those Windows 3.1/95/98/ME/2K/XP/Vista/7 icons: They have character. You try and tell me they didn't have fun drawing the icons for MS Agent and Dr. Watson; the fun and sense of humor the devs and artists had making them just ooze out.
Modern day hieroglyphs? They aim to not confuse or offend anyone, and end up impressing noone. They aim to speak all languages and end up speaking nothing. They aim to inform everyone and end up informing noone.
Immense character; there were Easter eggs when you zoomed in on any one of those icons. Now everything is a flat dreary mess.
They look nice and skeumorphic. Flat design is just lazy design and makes things hard for users.
My parents no longer understand what's a button and what isn't. They find modern desktops really confusing.
I hate modern desktops so much I just pretend they don't exist and run bare X with tiled windows, usually one only and fullscreen.
I would disagree as to the supposed 'aims'. Most flat designers don't aim to do anything - they just kept mindlessless repeating the mantra of 'minimalism' to the point where everything looks the same.
Your use of the word 'hieroglyphs' I think is very apt - because that's what they are: hieroglyphs, and NOT icons, as earlier versions of Windows had them.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dogcow
MOOF!!!
https://github.com/mdomlop/retrosmart-icon-theme/blob/master...
Instead of replacing them with vague minimalist symbols.
Gradients on buttons to make them appear rounded and clickable are dead these days. Nothing suggests the maximize/minimize/close buttons are buttons anymore other than being abstract looking symbols that are otherwise out of place (at least until you hover over them).
Hiding all scrollbars is totally the trend these days, so the only way to know that something is scrollable is either by trying to scroll it, or noticing cut off content. If the window is sized just right so no content is cut off, it is easy to not realize scrolling is even possible until you eventually do it accidentally.
Those sorts of icons just don't fit into this type of usability harming hyper minimalism that was largely intended to save precious screen space on small mobile devices, but which are simply moronic on full sized computers. sigh
except i doubt that's the entire story. because even though pixel art doesn't scale well, you could make very nice, detailed, inspired, responsive vector graphics using SVG, which would scale up or down to any size. but that probably would cost way too much money to produce, so we're now in the era where companies have brazenly embraced 'phoning it in' as an aesthetic (e.g. material icons, bootstrap, font awesome, etc.). so far, users have either put up with it, or have been (imo) tricked into embracing it too
[0] https://www.haiku-os.org/docs/userguide/en/applications/icon...
[0] http://tympanus.net/codrops/2014/08/19/making-svgs-responsiv...
Folks look at the cool designs from that era (and late '90s Windows) and want them back. You can't have that and $0.99 apps. If you try to get that kind of design with today's design budgets, you get exactly the kind of Y2K photo app skeumorphic design that everyone hated.
The hieroglyphic-style icons remain sharp and distinct at most resolutions and densities. You also need to keep in mind the icon sets you mentioned (Material etc) are meant to be used by third parties. They're sort of indistinct and non-offensive because they're supposed to work with a site's branding. The icons are not supposed to be a site's branding. Windows' icons were part of the Windows product branding.
"Ah but hieroglyph icons of today scale better!" Well, hieroglyph icons of today scale consistently, but remember the icon designers back in the day would make different sizes of each icon to be clearly recognizable at all scales (the whole point of the .ico format!), and to me that is way better than what we have now.