News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by raziel2701 on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:07PM (#34253903)
It's crazy that AMZN announces this and the stock goes up in after hours trading. People are losing their livelihoods yet rich people only care about the potential higher profits.

This is very disconnected from reality, amzn needs consumers to buy their products. If layoffs keep piling up higher and deeper something is going to break and hello recession!

Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by lcw on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:21PM (#34254023)
In general layoffs especially when they are proactive, which in this case they seem to be, show investors that the company is being fiscally responsible. This isn't an indication that Amazon is going to increase profitability it's a sign to investors that they are taking in recession indicators and adapting accordingly. It doesn't seem malicious it seems perfectly reasonable and sane. Of course it's Amazon so there is another layer of context, but this is a rational and normal investor response.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by asdff on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:48PM (#34254299)
I don't understand how its rational unless you assume staff have negative value. They don't, they have positive value, nothing gets done without staff. More staff means you output more work and make more money. Staff should be the last thing to cut.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by gwright on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @08:16PM (#34254572)
That isn't the way a business works. There is no intrinsic value to "staff", positive or negative. The value comes from the way staff (or any other resources) is utilized. Building twice as many widgets by building and staffing a second factory could have a huge negative value if there is no demand for twice as many widgets in the market, for example.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by haimez on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @08:37PM (#34254761)
Staff does have a negative intrinsic value- they are paid salaries. If (and only if) the business can deliver on some arbitrary stated goals, it’s more valuable if it can do so with fewer people on staff.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by gwright on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @09:19PM (#34255058)
I was obviously referring to the net change in business value. Additional employees can be result in a net negative or a net positive return on investment depending on how they are utilized. That was what I was trying to communicate.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by asdff on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:33AM (#34256776)
So then the solution is to not fire people, but manage them better on something more profitable. What makes you more money in this pet example you've set up: having 1 widget factory, or two factories producing different widgets that are both in demand? The latter, obviously, or else amazon would still be entirely in the business of selling books today.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by gwright on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:51PM (#34264571)
> but manage them better on something more profitable.

Well, yeah. I mean the entire endeavor of operating a for-profit business is to find the combination of resources/effort/ideas that creates value. The problem space is enormous though and more often leads to failure than success. If you see a successful combination though, stop posting here and start your own business!

Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by sokoloff on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @08:09PM (#34254506)
A $10 bill has positive value as well. Nevertheless, buying them in bulk for $15 each is a bad idea. (Merely having positive value is not enough to make something a good purchase.)
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by lcw on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @08:10PM (#34254515)
Staff has negative value when demand growth doesn't meet a companies forecasts. You are right there should always be positive output from staff, but it doesn't mean that there is a demand for said output.

I think when you say value you aren't speaking fiscally. If that's the case then I would say I'm not trying to minimize the output of workers being laid off. I'm just saying that the value of their output isn't marketable to consumers, so from a capitalist perspective a company should rationally make adjustments.

Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by asdff on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:36AM (#34256788)
If the value of their output isn't marketable, put them on a project that is. Having the workers suffer from their manager's decision makings for these divisions is cold and cruel.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by WalterBright on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @08:18PM (#34254590)
If staff produces less value than they cost, then they get cut.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by asdff on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:35AM (#34256784)
Why not come up with better projects for said staff that help the company? Why should they suffer from being mismanaged?
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by WalterBright on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:43PM (#34263518)
> Why not come up with better projects for said staff that help the company?

If you can think of better projects, you can become their competitor and hire their staff away.

Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by quickthrower2 on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @10:35PM (#34255583)
Also a stock can go up because it reveals information that is not as bad as previously thought.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by bdcravens on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:36PM (#34254165)
How else would you value a stock? It's fractional ownership in a company; bottom line matters. Also, many people who aren't "rich" own stocks.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by WalterBright on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @08:19PM (#34254601)
I started buying stock with my first real job.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by pessimizer on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @09:56PM (#34255315)
> Also, many people who aren't "rich" own stocks.

But the sum of all people who aren't "rich" don't own very much stock (as a proportion.) And 99% of the ones that do own that stock indirectly through a fund with added management costs and management risk.

Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by _heimdall on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:30PM (#34254108)
Market analysts often view cost cutting measures like layoffs as a favorable sign for near term growth. While it makes a lot of sense to view this as an indicator of trouble, it's more often spin as an indicator of a well led company that recognized the problem and is already on the way back up.

Synically, an argument can be made that those largely driving the markets are looking for any reason to make money. It doesn't actually matter much what the news is, just get ahead of the market movement then start turning dials and pushing sentiment.

Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by sys_64738 on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:22PM (#34254025)
A business is run to maximize shareholder value. Cutting costs is part of that equation.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by asdff on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:49PM (#34254308)
It's not really maximizing shareholder value though. In this case its like cutting off your leg and claiming you lost weight.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by jethro_tell on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @09:22PM (#34255087)
It might be. If you pay in stock, juicing the stock number of you can could save thousands on the backend in wages paid out in total shares.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by devmunchies on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @09:48PM (#34255259)
if the employees that were cut were working on a product that was losing money, then its more akin to liposuction. Its not about the employee's skills either, it's the business unit. If you start cutting database or network engineers on the AWS team, now we're talking about cutting off limbs.

Put another way, lots of startups are failing or are going to fail in this environment. Layoffs are like killing "internal startups" that aren't moneymakers.

Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by asdff on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:30AM (#34256764)
Why is it better to lay people off than to just put that labor on something more profitable? If labor isn't productive that's not a labor issue, thats a management issue from them mismanaging their labor. It's a shame these workers have to suffer from being mismanaged.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by devmunchies on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:59PM (#34264701)
>If labor isn't productive that's not a labor issue, thats a management issue from them mismanaging their labor

You're assuming that any group of talented people can have a 100% track record of success. Some startups (or projects) just fail and it has nothing to do with the talent.

You gotta take bets on new products/markets and sometimes they don't pan out. Sometimes it's just a market issue. There's not always a way to know if it was going to fail beforehand either. If we want innovation, then unfortunately I think these types of sh*tshows are part of the deal, although a 17,000 layoff is pretty gnarly.

Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by twblalock on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @09:54PM (#34255291)
Amazon is one of the largest online retailers, and one of the largest vendors of compute capacity to other companies. They are better positioned to see a downturn coming than almost anyone else. What makes you think they got it wrong?
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by asdff on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:27AM (#34256751)
I don't think they got it wrong, I just think layoffs are foolish because staff generate the profits for your business. Does Amazon really need to cut costs? For 2022, revenue was up 15% year over year. The only thing bad going on with Amazon in this economy currently is their stock price, not their profitability or how much cash they have or how many workers they are able to afford.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by pessimizer on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @09:59PM (#34255333)
More like losing weight and claiming that it's become easier to walk.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by asdff on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:31AM (#34256769)
People are acting like workers are belly fat, I see them as bone and muscle and organs. A business cannot generate a profit without its workers performing profitable work. If the workers aren't doing something profitable, look at your managers dictating that work, not the labor that is along for the ride.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by twblalock on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @09:53PM (#34255288)
Also, it's worth remembering that the number of Amazon shareholders, and the number of people impacted by Amazon's stock price as a component of index funds, is vastly larger than the number of Amazon employees.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by adoxyz on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:14PM (#34253959)
Laying people off reduces one of the biggest costs to an organization, thus making it more profitable (even if in the short term), thus the stock price rises. Stocks are always forward looking and investors believe that by cutting down costs and re-focusing will make amazon worth more in the future.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by asdff on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:50PM (#34254334)
How can a company be more profitable with less workers if the workers are the source of the profits?
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by HDThoreaun on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @08:36PM (#34254751)
Alexa lost $10 billion last year. Those workers were the source of losses through their salary.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by mattrighetti on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @08:27PM (#34254672)
That’s the point, they’re laying off unprofitable orgs. What makes you think that more workers translates to more profitable?
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by 8note on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @08:10PM (#34254514)
The workers aren't the source of profits in all cases.

Eg, a musician is a worker, but once they've written a song that you now iwn, you can sell infinite licenses to it, regardless of whether the musician is still being paid

Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by midoridensha on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @11:24PM (#34255933)
This is why, these days, musicians all make their money by touring. People will pay over and over to see the same person play the same song in person.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by asdff on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:20AM (#34256723)
But if you hire that musician, you can create more products you can license. The worker generates more revenue streams for you. This is why streaming companies are leasing soundstage space, to create more stuff to license themselves.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by strgcmc on Thursday January 05, 2023 @08:58AM (#34259600)
But not all types of music are equally in demand. If consumer tastes change, it would obviously make sense to layoff musicians trained to make music for a genre that nobody wants to buy anymore.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by asdff on Thursday January 05, 2023 @03:27PM (#34266059)
That's one way of thinking which IMO is a cold way to look at the world. I would say its just simply nicer to retrain your staff to meet your goals versus cutting them off and finding new staff all the time. Too bad nice typically goes against profits in this economy.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by sokoloff on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @08:10PM (#34254518)
Perhaps the conclusion is that (at least some of) the workers aren’t the source of the profits.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by monktastic1 on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @08:44PM (#34254803)
By this logic, every company should always maximize the number of employees they have, regardless of whether they have anything useful to do.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by ascotan on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @09:29PM (#34255139)
Apparently they're not the source of profit:

```Amazon initiated a broad cost-cutting review to pare back on units that were unprofitable```

Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by asdff on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:22AM (#34256731)
Seems like a better solution would have been to shift that labor to more productive uses that can generate revenue, than to throw some of the oars off your boat to go faster.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by lightbendover on Thursday January 05, 2023 @03:59PM (#34266467)
Not everyone is fungible. How can you repurpose recruiters effectively when you're not recruiting? How can you repurpose well-paid robotics engineers when you've realized you have over-invested?
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by asah on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:10PM (#34253924)
AMZN stock is held by millions of people, not just "rich"
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by rvz on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:26PM (#34254071)
> It's crazy that AMZN announces this and the stock goes up in after hours trading.

No it isn't. It is quite typical for a companies stock to spike up after a layoff announcement especially when the number was higher than initially reported.

And as always totally expected.

Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by worik on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:32PM (#34254129)
Yes it is crazy.

The craziness encompasses the entire system

Systemic insanity

Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by unforeseen9991 on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:49PM (#34254306)
It'd be crazy if they didn't. Especially after the covid bubble and running headlong into economic uncertainty.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by subsaharancoder on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @08:34PM (#34254731)
Meta stock went from a low of $89 to now $124 after the layoffs. Wallstreet loves some good bloodshed and rewards it with higher stock price!

P.S. Ex-Meta who got impacted by the layoffs

Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by HDThoreaun on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @08:38PM (#34254764)
Meta especially went up because their biggest problem is mark going rogue. Investors have no control over him and he’s been continuously signaling over the last year that he has no interest in listening to them. The layoffs were a token that showed he hadn’t totally turned his back. A bit of a unique situation.
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by pishpash on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @09:58PM (#34255326)
It also didn't go up that much. 1.7%?
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by rendang on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:44PM (#34254245)
> If layoffs keep piling up higher and deeper

To put the current situation in perspective, the last unemployment rate reading was 3.7%, a level so low that it was never hit in the entire period 1970-2018.

Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by unity1001 on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:53PM (#34254362)
You just summarized entire das Kapital...
Re:Amazon to Lay Off over 17,000 Workers, More Than First Pl... by phpisthebest on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:59PM (#34254409)
>>people are losing their livelihoods yet rich

Do you have a 401K or retirement account of any type? Chances are you are one of the "rich people" that impact that stock price.