News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by geocrasher on Friday December 30, 2022 @09:52AM (#34185543)
And to think that just a few years ago reusing a rocket even once was an incredible feat!
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by Maraguy on Friday December 30, 2022 @09:57AM (#34185589)
We're fast approaching the golden age of rockets.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by imglorp on Friday December 30, 2022 @10:56AM (#34186171)
Now we need the corrupt, entrenched, fossilized, competition to catch up. It's clearly not a tech problem but a business one.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by matheusmoreira on Friday December 30, 2022 @10:53AM (#34186141)
Before I learned about SpaceX, I thought it was literally impossible to reuse rockets because they burned up in the atmosphere or something. After all, not a single space agency in the world was doing it. Surely the smart engineers working in those places had good reasons.

Watching SpaceX land rocket boosters on target again and again is kind of magical, like something out of Kerbal Space Program. I wonder how long it's gonna take to get a fully reusable rocket. They're working on the Starship and it's supposed to be fully reusable.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by aisengard on Friday December 30, 2022 @11:40AM (#34186678)
The only thing that burned up in the atmosphere for the Space Shuttle program was the fuel tank. All the other components, including the booster rockets, were recovered and refurbished for reuse.

The innovation here isn't about reusability at all, it's about the economics of reuse. Maybe landing a rocket back on the pad rather than recovering them from the ocean makes it cheaper to reuse, has there been a study around that?

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by gitfan86 on Friday December 30, 2022 @11:44AM (#34186722)
Right, for the Space Shuttle the shortest interval on a back-to-back mission was 63 days.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by SEJeff on Friday December 30, 2022 @11:58AM (#34186925)
And I believe that the Falcon 9 with the fastest turnaround was B1062 with 21 days between flights. The previous record (also from a Falcon 9) was two separate boosters who launched and relaunched 27 days apart.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by ericd on Friday December 30, 2022 @11:52AM (#34186825)
Yeah, SpaceX’s reuse is much, much simpler than the shuttle booster refurbishment. At the extreme, Starship is intended to have no refurbishment between flights - refuel and fly again, so that the cost of each flight will be mostly the fuel cost, on the order of single digit millions. Falcon 9 I believe is trickier since its kerosene fuel generates a lot of soot compared to the methane engines of Starship, and can be fouled. If you’ve ever used a camp stove with kerosene vs methane, one leaves your stove covered in black soot.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by bumby on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:40PM (#34187445)
>Starship is intended to have no refurbishment between flights - refuel and fly again

Surely this entails a host of quality checks between flights? What is that cost estimate at?

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by ericd on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:42PM (#34187474)
This is based on pretty old info, which probably comes from an offhand statement by Musk, so big grain of salt, but I think they’re hoping to get it to be on par with a jetliner, which if I understand correctly is just a maintenance schedule based on # of flight hours. Not sure if that’s going to be feasible given the difference in the violence of the flight profile.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by bumby on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:45PM (#34187504)
That would be interesting to hear how they come up with those maintenance schedules. Even with the uptick in flights, it doesn't seem like they'd have the dearth of reliability data to make that determination with reasonable accuracy. But maybe they have a lot of internal reliability data we're not privy to.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by Faark on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:22PM (#34188043)
The reliability data will be collected by inspections. Also from memory, their fleet leaders tended to do Starlink launches. Loosing one of those might suck, but can still be sold as due to pushing boundaries and something that wont happen to customers. They need backup launch equipment, ofc.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by bumby on Friday December 30, 2022 @02:10PM (#34188692)
The gold standard for reliability studies involves collecting in situ failures though. You can infer a lot from inspections on non-failed components, but it's not as useful as having actual failure data. When I'm referencing their in-house data, I'm referring to failures (whether in situ or as a bench experiment)
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by tuatoru on Friday December 30, 2022 @02:42PM (#34189083)
Just FYI, "dearth" means scarcity. Perhaps you meant wealth.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by bumby on Friday December 30, 2022 @05:24PM (#34190802)
Thank you.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by SEJeff on Friday December 30, 2022 @11:56AM (#34186887)
Landing the rocket back on the pad requires significantly more fuel for most missions. The reason most Falcon 9s do landing at sea instead of RTLS is due to this. They have to boost up and out over the ocean to the correct insertion coordinates, and then they run out of fuel (for the mission). When they run out of mission fuel, they just use gravity and fall straight downwards to land on a drone ship.

In short, performing RTLS requires additional fuel. This is fuel that can no longer be used to boost the payload into the correct orbital insertion. So all RTLS missions tend to be lower performance missions that don't need the full power of the Falcon 9 / Heavy since they have fuel to spare for RTLS.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by mlindner on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:06PM (#34187016)
Note that for the Space Shuttle, the external tank was large proportion of the fuel-carrying capacity of the vehicle, i.e. "most of the rocket". And for the solid rocket boosters they were not fully recovered as they ejected the rocket engine bell just before impact with the water which sank to the bottom of the ocean on each launch.

Additionally, solid rocket boosters are some of the hardest things to re-use as the process of re-filling them is more like re-manufacturing them than actual true re-use. The sections (they had 4 sections) need to disassembled and refilled with the epoxy that is the solid rocket fuel. They were additionally made of steel rather than aluminum so were not substantially valuable components to recover versus the high end aluminum alloys in the external tanks.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by nordsieck on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:42PM (#34187472)
> The innovation here isn't about reusability at all, it's about the economics of reuse.

It's about both.

SpaceX showed that the 1st stage of a rocket can be reliably reused in production. Which is really important from an architecture perspective because 2/3 stage rockets are just more efficient than 1/1.5 stage rockets (mostly due to the propellant mass fraction term of the rocket equation).

To give some examples, the payload mass fraction of some reusable rockets is:

* Shuttle(partial reuse): 1%

* Falcon 9(partial reuse): 4%

* Starship(full reuse, in development): 2%

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by raverbashing on Friday December 30, 2022 @10:57AM (#34186186)
To be fair to the older models, I think the main issue is: only "recently" (let's say, some 30yrs ago), we have had computers and sensors fast enough to manage an automated reentry of rocket stages (and ship drones as well)

And SpaceX had to iterate a lot to get this working as well

It is rocket science

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by dotnet00 on Friday December 30, 2022 @11:47AM (#34186761)
The older model also didn't incentivize the things needed to support a reusable rocketry program. Companies were encouraged to have bloat and making satellites was still extremely expensive so there wasn't anywhere near enough demand to justify producing and reusing a handful of boosters.

Ariane space was still arguing that reuse wasn't viable for them due to their low flight rate only until a handful of years ago. As far as I'm aware, ULA's CEO still insists that anything more than their proposed engine segment reuse is going to require too high of a flight rate to pay for itself (IIRC he said they'd need 10 flights per booster).

This is also part of why SpaceX's model works. Even when disposable F9 is much cheaper than previous rockets in its class.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by bumby on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:37PM (#34187401)
>The older model also didn't incentivize the things needed to support a reusable rocketry program.

I assume you mean the cost-plus contracting model? Or is there a different incentive mechanism you're referring to?

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by dotnet00 on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:19PM (#34187997)
Cost-plus is part of it, but also just the launch vehicle acquisition process in general.

Early on, SpaceX's biggest hurdle was getting payload contracts. IIRC they had to sue the government several times to overturn bad acquisition policies. Government acquisition processes weren't suited to supporting small new entrances into the launch market and there was somewhat of a belief that you weren't a credible launch provider unless you were as large as Boeing or Lockmart.

In comparison nowadays it's relatively normal for lower cost programs or ones which can accept some loss to try flying on less proven rockets. New bold approaches to designing, building and flying rockets aren't immediately dismissed as just young naive engineers who haven't had the reality of spaceflight beat into them.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by bumby on Friday December 30, 2022 @02:14PM (#34188743)
What was determined to be bad acquisition policy?

My understanding is that early contracts were awarded to ULA because SpaceX wasn't certified for military payloads. That, combined with your statement, implies the certification process levies bad requirements. Do we know what these bad requirements were?

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by dotnet00 on Friday December 30, 2022 @04:23PM (#34190271)
As Musk had pointed out at the time, the requirements were essentially just large amounts of paperwork (since if NASA considers F9 reliable enough for cargo and even crew, it's kind of ridiculous to suggest it can't handle a GPS satellite), such that it was unreasonable for USAF to buy multiple years worth of launches without competitive bidding despite obviously having another option almost through certification. At the time they had made that award, SpaceX was already mostly through the certification paperwork with zero changes needed to the rocket.

Besides that, although not a lawsuit, Lori Garver's book "Escaping Gravity" goes into a lot of depth regarding the behind the scenes political struggle regarding commercial cargo and commercial crew and how Congress and some parts of NASA leaned on the idea that they couldn't tolerate any failure as a means of trying to disqualify anyone but ULA,Boeing etc from those programs.

I was wrong about them having to sue "several times" though.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by bumby on Friday December 30, 2022 @05:31PM (#34190877)
A small nit: the DoD and NASA are two different customers who don't have to align on their risk thresholds. Just because NASA is okay with a particular risk, doesn't mean that the DoD should be. What I've seen happen in some cases is one side essentially says "That may be okay for them, but we don't trust their level of oversight and want it done our way." I would push back a bit on the "mostly certified" as being sufficient; you're either certified or you're not.

I've seen the paperwork argument cut both ways. It can definitely create a bureaucratic mess. On the other hand, one of the things NASA tries to drive is "risk informed decision making". Part of this process involves writing waivers when a requirement can't/won't be met to document what the new risk is (and they have to document that they find that risk acceptable). A lot of times, this process was dismissed at "just large amounts of paperwork" but in dismissing it, they made it very hard for decision makers to fully understand what the residual risk was. It was interesting to me that paperwork was used as an excuse to not commit to the process, but when it was streamlined, it still wasn't used. To me, that feels more like avoiding accountability than avoiding needless paperwork. This misunderstanding of risk is at the heart of most of NASA's spaceflight mishaps.

I wasn't aware of Garver's book, but thanks for bringing it up. Sounds like a good read.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by justapassenger on Friday December 30, 2022 @04:02PM (#34190048)
You need economy of scale for reuse to makes sense. Space launch market still isn’t that big, and even for spacex half of their launches are from their internal project, starlink. Jury is still out if this is actually economical, as we don’t have insights into their financials and they keep on raising money (so we don’t know if some portion of that goes towards flacon subsidies).
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by matheusmoreira on Friday December 30, 2022 @04:27PM (#34190310)
There is no doubt that a reusable rocket will be more economical. You need cheap rockets first to get economies of scale. It's gonna be big in the future.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by reddog on Friday December 30, 2022 @11:29AM (#34186553)
Except that the space shuttle solid rocket boosters were recovered and reused.

From Wikipediea: "Out of 270 SRBs launched over the Shuttle program, all but four were recovered – those from STS-4 (due to a parachute malfunction) and STS-51-L (destroyed by range safety during the Challenger disaster).[6] Over 5,000 parts were refurbished for reuse after each flight. The final set of SRBs that launched STS-135 included parts that had flown on 59 previous missions, including STS-1.[7] Recovery also allowed post-flight examination of the boosters,[8] identification of anomalies, and incremental design improvements"

Also the rockets on the shuttle itself were landed and reused.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by ktpecot on Friday December 30, 2022 @11:42AM (#34186697)
Calling the shuttle reusable is such a massive stretch. It’s like the shuttle of Theseus they basically had to rebuild it every time and it cost something like 1.5 billion dollars. Basically could’ve built a brand new rocket every time.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by dylan604 on Friday December 30, 2022 @11:52AM (#34186821)
Recovery of the first stage of SpaceX rockets is not even close to being the same thing as reuse of the shuttle. Surviving re-entry is a completely different set of specs than floating through atmosphere at a much much slower rate of descent.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by ktpecot on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:08PM (#34187048)
I mean from a technological point of view sure, but that just shows how bad the design was(compared to what we know now). The falcon program shows that it’s obviously way more economical to just ditch the 2nd stage and reuse the booster. F9 launches cost sub 20 million and a shuttle launch costs on the order of a billion. Squabble over whatever details you want about performance or who had to do what R&D but F9 is clearly in a different league.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by dylan604 on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:39PM (#34187432)
> Squabble over whatever details you want about performance or who had to do what R&D but F9 is clearly in a different league.

Falcon 9 First launch attempt 2007 [0]

Shuttle First launch 1981 [1]

I wonder if there's an advantage to having 26 years of watching someone else before designing yours? You also act like the rockets from the shuttle were not reused. They always (except for 2 instances) came back with the shuttle. The SRBs were also recovered, so it's not like these were wasted.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Falcon_9_first-stage_b...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by ktpecot on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:00PM (#34187715)
I’m not disputing SpaceX had the advantage of learning from peoples mistakes. And I’m not arguing that they didn’t physically get the engines and boosters back I’m just saying that calling the space shuttle and F9 both reusable may be semantically true but is really not giving an accurate representation.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by dylan604 on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:06PM (#34187819)
SpaceX is also contributing to the increasing amounts of space junk. How long is the second stage just floating around after delivering payloads? Once the shuttle delivered payloads, it just left nothing but space.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by Robotbeat on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:37PM (#34188251)
Almost Immediately after the payload is deployed, the second stage does a deorbit burn. So maybe an hour? Each Shuttle launch ended with ditching the enormous external tank into like the Indian Ocean, far more dry mass in the atmosphere/ocean than a Falcon 9 upper stage. (Also, the ET was about $100-150 million apiece.)
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by dylan604 on Friday December 30, 2022 @02:07PM (#34188657)
I was not aware of the second stage doing a de-orbit burn. TIL
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by JumpCrisscross on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:38PM (#34188256)
> Once the shuttle delivered payloads, it just left nothing but space

The Shuttle unintentionally shed all sorts of nonsense during flight.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by ktpecot on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:23PM (#34188057)
Lol are you just making stuff up now? The second stage re enters the atmosphere and burns up.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by dylan604 on Friday December 30, 2022 @02:07PM (#34188644)
No, it was a legit question. It depends on the payload though right? For StarLink deployments at LEO, I'm sure it re-enters soon-ish. But what about for higher altitude launches of other types of satellites? How long does the second stage float around?
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by mlindner on Friday December 30, 2022 @03:08PM (#34189417)
If you have questions I'd suggest asking them as a question. Your post read as a statement of fact with a rhetorical question attached.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by dylan604 on Friday December 30, 2022 @04:11PM (#34190164)
"How long is the second stage just floating around after delivering payloads?"

How much more of a interrogative statement does it need to be made to be considered asking a non-rhetorical question?

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by geocrasher on Friday December 30, 2022 @06:24PM (#34191366)
If you take it out of context of your post, yes, it looks like a well posed question. When read in context it looks rhetorical and that's how I took it, too. Perhaps you didn't intend that. But that is how it came out.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by mlindner on Saturday December 31, 2022 @07:54AM (#34196033)
As a standalone question that's fine, but in context it's a rhetorical question as you already state your assumed answer.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by mlindner on Friday December 30, 2022 @03:05PM (#34189377)
A brief look would have you find that for most (but not all) launches the second stage de-orbits after one or two orbits and isn't even left in orbit for a day. (For some launches it's impossible to de-orbit the stage and no matter which provider you launch with will leave a second stage as junk in orbit.)

Also, this isn't just SpaceX, every launching country/company leaves second stages in orbit, some, unlike SpaceX, don't even try to dispose of their second stages and leave all second stages in orbit.

I'd recommend reading up more on the topic as I think you read something at some point and think that SpaceX is an especially bad actor in the space when in fact they are one of the most responsible actors, if not _the_ most responsible actor, in the space launch sector at the moment.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by dylan604 on Friday December 30, 2022 @04:10PM (#34190151)
SpaceX is launching stuff at an incredible rate. That's the great thing, but it also means that as they continue to launch, the amount of 2nd stages left behind will only increase.

I didn't read anything one time in weird corner of the internet like seem to want to insinuate. There are plenty of sites where you can see the items being tracked. There is a large number of second stages in orbit that are not coming back any time soon. It might have been some coincidental bit of luck that on one particular perusal of one of these sites I just happened to click on 2 such items. Again, as they continue to increase the rate of launches, this will become an issue. And obviously, I don't believe SpaceX is the only such party doing this. That's just an unintelligent comment to have made.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by mlindner on Saturday December 31, 2022 @08:04AM (#34196088)
> SpaceX is launching stuff at an incredible rate. That's the great thing, but it also means that as they continue to launch, the amount of 2nd stages left behind will only increase.

You seem to be saying that all entities globally should as a whole launch less objects into space, as you imply that putting more objects into space is a net negative. That's fine to think but I strongly disagree that we as a planet should launch less objects into space.

> There is a large number of second stages in orbit that are not coming back any time soon.

I agree, which is why we should push for regulations that require satellite operators to have plans to de-orbit their satellites at end of life and/or not launch to orbits where the launching stage cannot quickly de-orbit within a set number of years. However simply pushing for all countries to launch less things into space, as you seem to be saying, is not a good idea.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by mlindner on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:09PM (#34187053)
They also lugged a large amount of extra dry mass into space because of the mass of the orbiter. The part that was least important to re-use and most expensive to re-use is the part that was re-used the most.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by dylan604 on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:47PM (#34187528)
maybe, but it was the coolest part to re-use. whatever inefficiencies the shuttle had that people squabble over, it was a very inspiring program. not sure how much inspiration to a small kid a SpaceX launch is, but i know exactly how much the shuttle was.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by drusepth on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:03PM (#34187783)
>not sure how much inspiration to a small kid a SpaceX launch is, but i know exactly how much the shuttle was.

From what I've seen, it sounds like many kids these days feel the same way about SpaceX launches now as you did about the shuttle (incredibly inspiring). I hope that's reassuring.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by dylan604 on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:11PM (#34187898)
it is. i know that i flew my shuttle around my room much more than my apollo rockets. my fighter jets had a hard time keeping up with the shuttle in my room too. i once saw footage of the "chase" planes as the shuttle screamed past them on approach. just so much more "cool" to the shuttle than a capsule.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by Robotbeat on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:39PM (#34188272)
This video showing kids’ reaction to the Falcon Heavy inaugural launch is pretty fun. The dual-landing is absolutely insane. Straight up science fiction. https://youtu.be/A0FZIwabctw
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by mannerheim on Friday December 30, 2022 @02:06PM (#34188636)
What do kids have to do with anything? The goal is to get to space affordably and reliably; the shuttle failed on both fronts SpaceX is succeeding at.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by dylan604 on Friday December 30, 2022 @02:11PM (#34188703)
>What do kids have to do with anything?

What do kids ever have to do with anything? They are the next generation that may or may not want to be involved in whatever they might be getting inspired by.

>The goal is to get to space affordably and reliably; the shuttle failed on both fronts SpaceX is succeeding at.

Shuttle had ~135 missions (number from memory) with 1 failure at launch. The second failure was at re-entry, so assumption is that the mission deployed whatever was being deployed (if that was part of the mission). How many missions has SpaceX lost payloads on? >1? If we do percentages, sure, but to say that 1 failure at launch is unreliable is just farcical.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by mannerheim on Friday December 30, 2022 @02:35PM (#34189021)
The space shuttle killed 14 people because it was a poorly-built, designed-by-committee piece of garbage.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by ktpecot on Friday December 30, 2022 @05:19PM (#34190762)
Are you actually trying to say the mission when Columbia came apart on re entry and killed 7 people was successful? And you’re gonna say the challenger mission failure that killed people is the same as SpaceX losing a satellite and a dragon cargo capsule.

That’s one of the worst takes I’ve ever heard

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by mlindner on Friday December 30, 2022 @03:10PM (#34189439)
Rockets landing vertically is the most sci-fi thing ever and has been a staple of science fiction since the early 20th century. I think that's plenty more cool than landing it horizontally.

Anyway, coolness factor doesn't really matter for space. Economical things also tend to end up looking cool over time anyway simply because streamlined designs which are efficient tend to also look cool..

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by SilverBirch on Friday December 30, 2022 @05:32PM (#34190893)
Daddy, when I grow up, I want to grab massive government subsidies and attack trans-people, just like Elon…
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by zugi on Friday December 30, 2022 @09:12PM (#34192729)
> inefficiencies the shuttle had that people squabble over, it was a very inspiring program

Exactly. The shuttle program was designed by bureaucrats to be "inspiring." Which explains why it was such a dismal failure economically and in turns of safety - killing 14 people which is far more than any other rocket, and costing insanely more than expendables.

The shuttle program set the U.S. space program back by decades. We are only now finally starting to recover from its dismal failure.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by panick21_ on Saturday December 31, 2022 @01:15AM (#34194142)
It wasn't designed to be inspiring. That is nonsense. Non of the designers involved would ever claim that's what they did.

It was designed in an environment they couldn't iterate and test, and tried to go from very little knowlage directly to a massively complex system.

And no only that, they were very limited in terms of funding, so anything that required to much development had to be kicked.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by fpoling on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:02PM (#34186965)
The first stage of SpaceX is the most expensive part with nine engines. The second stage is just single engine. Plus SpaceX reuse fairings and the Dragon is also reusable. So re-usable parts are like 95% and expendable parts are vastly cheaper than Shuttle refurbishing.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by ploxiln on Friday December 30, 2022 @11:45AM (#34186736)
I didn't know the SRB components were also re-used!

It's a useful clarification that the Space Shuttle program had a large amount of reuse in the design ... but it still cost over a billion dollars for each reuse, many multiples of e.g. fully expended soyuz. So until SpaceX proved that reuse could be done well, and economically, it wasn't obvious. Now it's super obvious and practically all space programs are frantically trying to catch up.

(The SS could carry fairly large ISS module payloads into orbit, while cheaper rockets/spacecraft couldn't ... but couldn't get to high orbits or beyond ... details details.)

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by fpoling on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:07PM (#34187029)
There are estimates that the production cost of Soyuz are less than 20 millions USD, https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/48592/what-is-the-...

It is not clear if SpaceX is there per flight. They still need to spent several weeks on refurbishing of the landed booster.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by Faark on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:01PM (#34187734)
We should keep in mind that Soyuz is the name of both a manned space capsule (like dragon / cst100), but also a rocket family (like falcon).

You link seems to be specifically about Soyuz MS, a capsule. No idea how much SpaceX spends on refurbishing dragon.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by Robotbeat on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:43PM (#34188352)
Several weeks on-site vs years in a factory on the other side of the country. It’s a clear win. Marginal per launch cost is on the order of $15 million, including the price of a new upper stage. More full cost including GSE and amortization on the booster and fairing more like $25 million.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by justapassenger on Friday December 30, 2022 @03:58PM (#34189999)
No outsider knows if Falcon reuse is economical. SpaceX keeps on raising money (they have a lot of going on, so that’s not surprising) and without insight into financials we don’t known if their launches are subsidized by VC money.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by zugi on Friday December 30, 2022 @09:20PM (#34192794)
You are right that no one knew that Space X's approach would work until they demonstrated it. However, it was clear that the shuttle's "reuse" approach was a dismal failure early on - even before it was built, the sheer mass shuttled to and from orbit every time was a giant red flag to anyone who understands the basic rocket equation. That also drastically limited its altitude and usefulness. In a world where practicality matters, it should have been abandoned early on in favor of a return to expendables, until we figured out something that actually worked.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by allenrb on Friday December 30, 2022 @11:45AM (#34186738)
Mostly the heavy steel booster cases were reused, iirc. I don’t believe the reuse process was ever cost-effective. As for the Shuttles themselves, so much inspection and refurb was required that it made reuse look unattractive.

SpaceX is getting the entire first stage back in mostly flight-worthy condition. Nobody outside the company truly knows how much work is done between flights but it appears to be vastly less than Shuttle.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by bumby on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:31PM (#34187314)
>mostly flight-worthy condition.

Can you expand on this? I've looked for information on how much rework they require but have never come up with a good explanation. I'm curious because spaceflight requirements are typically very stringent and refurbishing back to those requirements isn't a trivial task. A lot of the cost for Shuttle was refurbishing to meet the quality requirements.

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by 93po on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:53PM (#34187612)
I could be wrong but I believe they use brand new first stages for any manned mission because the stakes are higher. And they allow customers to elect for a brand new first stage at added cost. So the standards for refurbishment may be not quite as strict for regular payload/resupply missions because worst case scenario you're blowing up tens of millions of dollars of equipment/supplies instead of 3 human beings.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by Faark on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:14PM (#34187929)
I remember this as well, generally for nasa launches, initially. But certainly isn't the case anymore for commercial crew.

B1061 launched both Crew-1 & Crew-2, B1067 both Crew-3 & Crew-4 (with a commercial launch in-between). Crew-5 was new and Crew-6 seems to be planned as well. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Falcon_9_first-stage_b...

Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by 93po on Sunday January 01, 2023 @01:03PM (#34208834)
Nice, good to know. Thanks!
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by bumby on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:01PM (#34187737)
This makes sense and falls inline with how NASA has always ratcheted up requirements as the risk increases. The highest risk level is human-rated flight, but they also gauge things like payload cost and "one-of-a-kind" nature of payloads.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by 93po on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:51PM (#34187582)
I think someone more familiar with this than me could look at the cost of a Falcon 9 launch with a re-used first stage and compare it to a non-re-used first stage launch cost and make some assumptions/ballpark guess about how much work goes into refurb.
Re:SpaceX caps 2022 with record-setting 61st Falcon 9 launch by mlindner on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:10PM (#34187059)
They weren't fully re-used as each shuttle booster ejected the engine nozzle right before impact with the water. Additionally, they had to be disassembled before re-filling with fuel. It was re-manufacturing versus re-use.