The innovation here isn't about reusability at all, it's about the economics of reuse. Maybe landing a rocket back on the pad rather than recovering them from the ocean makes it cheaper to reuse, has there been a study around that?
Surely this entails a host of quality checks between flights? What is that cost estimate at?
In short, performing RTLS requires additional fuel. This is fuel that can no longer be used to boost the payload into the correct orbital insertion. So all RTLS missions tend to be lower performance missions that don't need the full power of the Falcon 9 / Heavy since they have fuel to spare for RTLS.
Additionally, solid rocket boosters are some of the hardest things to re-use as the process of re-filling them is more like re-manufacturing them than actual true re-use. The sections (they had 4 sections) need to disassembled and refilled with the epoxy that is the solid rocket fuel. They were additionally made of steel rather than aluminum so were not substantially valuable components to recover versus the high end aluminum alloys in the external tanks.
It's about both.
SpaceX showed that the 1st stage of a rocket can be reliably reused in production. Which is really important from an architecture perspective because 2/3 stage rockets are just more efficient than 1/1.5 stage rockets (mostly due to the propellant mass fraction term of the rocket equation).
To give some examples, the payload mass fraction of some reusable rockets is:
* Shuttle(partial reuse): 1%
* Falcon 9(partial reuse): 4%
* Starship(full reuse, in development): 2%
And SpaceX had to iterate a lot to get this working as well
It is rocket science
Ariane space was still arguing that reuse wasn't viable for them due to their low flight rate only until a handful of years ago. As far as I'm aware, ULA's CEO still insists that anything more than their proposed engine segment reuse is going to require too high of a flight rate to pay for itself (IIRC he said they'd need 10 flights per booster).
This is also part of why SpaceX's model works. Even when disposable F9 is much cheaper than previous rockets in its class.
I assume you mean the cost-plus contracting model? Or is there a different incentive mechanism you're referring to?
Early on, SpaceX's biggest hurdle was getting payload contracts. IIRC they had to sue the government several times to overturn bad acquisition policies. Government acquisition processes weren't suited to supporting small new entrances into the launch market and there was somewhat of a belief that you weren't a credible launch provider unless you were as large as Boeing or Lockmart.
In comparison nowadays it's relatively normal for lower cost programs or ones which can accept some loss to try flying on less proven rockets. New bold approaches to designing, building and flying rockets aren't immediately dismissed as just young naive engineers who haven't had the reality of spaceflight beat into them.
My understanding is that early contracts were awarded to ULA because SpaceX wasn't certified for military payloads. That, combined with your statement, implies the certification process levies bad requirements. Do we know what these bad requirements were?
Besides that, although not a lawsuit, Lori Garver's book "Escaping Gravity" goes into a lot of depth regarding the behind the scenes political struggle regarding commercial cargo and commercial crew and how Congress and some parts of NASA leaned on the idea that they couldn't tolerate any failure as a means of trying to disqualify anyone but ULA,Boeing etc from those programs.
I was wrong about them having to sue "several times" though.
I've seen the paperwork argument cut both ways. It can definitely create a bureaucratic mess. On the other hand, one of the things NASA tries to drive is "risk informed decision making". Part of this process involves writing waivers when a requirement can't/won't be met to document what the new risk is (and they have to document that they find that risk acceptable). A lot of times, this process was dismissed at "just large amounts of paperwork" but in dismissing it, they made it very hard for decision makers to fully understand what the residual risk was. It was interesting to me that paperwork was used as an excuse to not commit to the process, but when it was streamlined, it still wasn't used. To me, that feels more like avoiding accountability than avoiding needless paperwork. This misunderstanding of risk is at the heart of most of NASA's spaceflight mishaps.
I wasn't aware of Garver's book, but thanks for bringing it up. Sounds like a good read.
Watching SpaceX land rocket boosters on target again and again is kind of magical, like something out of Kerbal Space Program. I wonder how long it's gonna take to get a fully reusable rocket. They're working on the Starship and it's supposed to be fully reusable.