Ai can be used to moderate discussions however , if it is trained to remove low effort in an unbiased way
> Ai can be used to moderate discussions however , if it is trained to remove low effort [or otherwise undesirable content]?
See https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/sorry-i-still-think-i-... for more on this topic.
If that’s the case, 100.00% open might not be optimal if 99.9% open yields better results for the resulting community.
The purpose of the internet hasn't been to be an open forum since sysadmins were blocking the talk.* hierarchy and kicking entire nodes off of usenet for spam or abuse.
The solution I see is that everyone have their own AI filters, customised as they see fit. You can include or exclude specific people and topics, make it as diverse or narrow as you like, allow challenging opinions or not. One of the filters can be to detect AI bots. Don't make the world conform to you, be selective and just skip the bad parts.
With the advent of large language models we already have that, indirectly - the LM is a synthesis of everything, but we let it generate only conditional to our intentions. All the view points are in there for us to reach, it depends on us how we relate to them.
I think people are going to trust their own AI tools that are running on their own computers more than they trust other people and especially other AI. We already know we can't face the future onslaught of information with the old methods, we need help. AI is going to be our first line of defence and our safe space, "a room of my own" in this crazy times.
Then maybe we should reduce the scale of the megaphones. Current networks are just unpleasant because it's mass hysteria on global level. Scale isn't everything.
I think future forum owners will be continuously finetuning their AI filters to fit their community standards.
I follow really interesting people for their thoughts about one topic (say, Movies), but whose tweets about topics like politics I really dislike (not necessarily things I disagree with, usually I just dislike the tone).
Shouldn't be too hard to fine tune a LLM to do this, definitely something worth a try.
Most notably, kids were in school with people their age, adults were at work, etc. 1st grader intellect and emotional interactions partitioned from 5th grade, partitioned from 9th, partitioned from college, partitioned from post-college.
For another example, the "grownups' table" and the "kids' table" at a holiday dinner.
Though, as a kid, I definitely benefited from listening in on the grownups on the Internet.
For example, businesses that involve $$$ reusable delivery containers don't work well because they want to give first-time customers a discount not a surcharge. Whatsapp was ridiculously cheap - something like $1/year - but they still decided that worked against their network effects.
There are some markets where you pay upfront and on an ongoing basis, like buying a printer and ink or a games console and games - but they often subsidise the upfront cost with profit from the ongoing costs.
I'm not sure how well a $5-to-join social network would work for that reason. Sites like metafilter survive - but with five moderators and one coder, they're not going to be replacing twitter, facebook or HN any time soon.
if those site could convince important/popular people for exclusivity, they could pull it off; i imagine it can work like spotify exclusive podcasts, or some such, since most people don't actually produce content, but consume.
Their mistake is having growth as a goal rather than a happy community.
I'd say HN is one of the few forums competitive on quality of discourse vs metafilter, but its business model is essentially loss-leader for VC/incubator activities, so it's a bit of an odd duck itself.
My boss of a multimillion dollar company took offense at being charged $1/year to use Whatsapp back when it came out and started getting popular, so it did have an effect
My eyes practically rolled out of my head when I heard him complain but that really stuck with me
I believe even a nominal amount would keep most people out, and that's by design. Also you don't need huge numbers to build a personally interesting community. Even a few dozen dedicated people can be plenty.
I have the same issue. People place so much trust in their preferred sources of information and don't question anything they read. Because of this I have a hard time discussing anything beyond the most basic things with many friends, since they just repeat talking points and opinions of others.
It's so enlightening when I do find someone who's well read on a subject and can have an actual conversation about it. Even better if they have a different opinion and give you some new bit of information that makes you think about your opinions or perception of knowledge. Or, when you can agree to disagree because you have the similar understanding of a subject, but have different values or preferences. Moments like that can make me really happy sometimes.
People have always been this way, but the Internet and social media are really not helping.
I think the optimism of the early internet was due to a dominance of users with that kind of personality. It wasn’t apparent to that type of person that others are not excited by that perspective hopping opportunity and not only would not take advantage of it once being online was more accessible, but would actively use the same technology to further silo and entrench themselves.
You better start believing in vetted online communities Miss Turner, you're in one!
It may not be vetting by moderators, but HN's dated frontend definitely acts as a forcefield against many kinds of people.
I find the idea of the site intriguing yet I'm not sure what I could contribute.
(although it would be an amusing way to shut the site down if he gets tired of maintaining it...)
I mean I do absolutely hate the new reddit redesign and almost exclusively use old.reddit, but the functionality there is on another level when compared to HN.
Actually, HN is the only social media site where my browser can consistently keep the scroll position. Animations and endless scrolling are what breaks it.
FreeMasons and premium golf clubs!
If you have an interest in, say, the math behind various AI techniques. Or maybe an interest in digging into the differences between different, (but seemingly similar), cancer therapies. (Think TIL v CAR-T). You won't get that at the golf club. You will need some kind of vetted discussion group.
Like startups, communities are growth and sucessful ones grow at an incremental replacement+ rate, where ones that grow explosively fall over on their own weight, and ones that sustain a base level just die. A plan for a vetted community is a system of harmonious growth that requires a funnel and conversion scheme that yields vetted members. I see orgs spinning their wheels and arguing over the merits of individual candidates when their real problem is they have no funnel to simply select the best n% from.
Thank you for bringing me up to date.
Any other sites you'd recommend for thoughtful discussion?
I'll launch the next iteration after the first of the year, this time there might be a fee attached, at least a minimal amount to pay for the SaaS product we'll use to organize and collaborate.
The next season I told everyone to pay up front. $120 dollars, cash. Same price as every week in total, but up front.
Turns out when people paid up front they came more often and we had no payment issues from there out.
Smaller 'clubs' are better, even if they are just forums. Discussion can't scale beyond a certain number of active user accounts without a large drop in quality. It's kind of hard to tell what that limit is because every forum has a large number of mostly quiet lurkers who simply want to read and follow the discourse. SA's $10 fee created a barrier to entry, and the culture of bans being regularly handed out to bad posters encouraged people to lurk until they were ready to make good posts. Upvotes and downvotes as popularized by reddit and reddit-like forums served as a kind of substitute for that effect but they don't work well with as many users as those websites have.
We can summarise this comment as "Eternal September"-ism.
Ref: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September
Be wary of falling trap to the feeling of: <<It has never been worse.>>
In late high school, watching the daily local television news around 6PM, I began to realise that when local news programmes interviewed local residents, they were always seeking the same response: <<It has never been worse.>>
Examples: Traffic; politics; manners; dress code; respect for elders; price of "milk and bread" (ask anyone in their 90s about it!); Internet discourse; buying/selling used cars; kids driving cars; fashion; fast food; the latest technology (radios, TVs, Internet, video games, mobile phones) ..., etcetera!
My point: Do not assume that things that are different from when you were young(er) are automatically worse. Really, really: Try harder. In 1920, "old people" were complaining about "young people" listening to too much radio -- made them "soft". Repeat for television in 1950. Repeat for Internet in 1990s. Repeat for mobile phones in 2010s. Repeat for video games in 2020s. I see this pattern repeat over and over again, and I chuckle to myself when I see old men complain about it!
As a counterpoint: This website is an amazing counterpoint/weight that "all things are getting worse all the time". I have been here for a few years now, and this community always manages to adapt to changing standards and conditions... and produce inspiring and thoughtful discourse about recent news.
And now for my over-the-top inspiring comment to end this post: Simply put: We, HN community, are the antithesis for Sturgeon's law "ninety percent of everything is crap"! (Wiki: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeon%27s_law)
What I have noticed in your comment:
>I see this pattern repeat over and over again
That's not a proof that there hasn't been a decline. It could as well be that each new generation is less competent.
Discussion can't scale beyond a certain number of active user accounts without a large drop in quality. It's kind of hard to tell what that limit is because every forum has a large number of mostly quiet lurkers who simply want to read and follow the discourse. SA's $10 fee created a barrier to entry, and the culture of bans being regularly handed out to bad posters encouraged people to lurk until they were ready to make good posts. Upvotes and downvotes as popularized by reddit and reddit-like forums served as a kind of substitute for that effect but they don't work well with as many users as those websites have.
But I get invited into discord servers for developers I work with, interests, I share, and I think it is getting to be more and more common. Some people will spend time in fake networks and probably not get a lot of value out of them other than entertainment. And others will gravitate to real networks for communication.
I've become disenchanted with the quality of the discourse. Specifically as I've entered a more senior stage of my career, I'm looking to mingle with like-minded folks in similar situations.
Thing is, these folks don't usually lurk online, and even if they do, their voices get overwhelmed by the flood of (mostly low quality) content. I'd be happy to pay a fee to become a member of a community with vetted participants.