The next season I told everyone to pay up front. $120 dollars, cash. Same price as every week in total, but up front.
Turns out when people paid up front they came more often and we had no payment issues from there out.
Smaller 'clubs' are better, even if they are just forums. Discussion can't scale beyond a certain number of active user accounts without a large drop in quality. It's kind of hard to tell what that limit is because every forum has a large number of mostly quiet lurkers who simply want to read and follow the discourse. SA's $10 fee created a barrier to entry, and the culture of bans being regularly handed out to bad posters encouraged people to lurk until they were ready to make good posts. Upvotes and downvotes as popularized by reddit and reddit-like forums served as a kind of substitute for that effect but they don't work well with as many users as those websites have.
I'll launch the next iteration after the first of the year, this time there might be a fee attached, at least a minimal amount to pay for the SaaS product we'll use to organize and collaborate.