if those site could convince important/popular people for exclusivity, they could pull it off; i imagine it can work like spotify exclusive podcasts, or some such, since most people don't actually produce content, but consume.
Their mistake is having growth as a goal rather than a happy community.
I'd say HN is one of the few forums competitive on quality of discourse vs metafilter, but its business model is essentially loss-leader for VC/incubator activities, so it's a bit of an odd duck itself.
My boss of a multimillion dollar company took offense at being charged $1/year to use Whatsapp back when it came out and started getting popular, so it did have an effect
My eyes practically rolled out of my head when I heard him complain but that really stuck with me
I believe even a nominal amount would keep most people out, and that's by design. Also you don't need huge numbers to build a personally interesting community. Even a few dozen dedicated people can be plenty.
For example, businesses that involve $$$ reusable delivery containers don't work well because they want to give first-time customers a discount not a surcharge. Whatsapp was ridiculously cheap - something like $1/year - but they still decided that worked against their network effects.
There are some markets where you pay upfront and on an ongoing basis, like buying a printer and ink or a games console and games - but they often subsidise the upfront cost with profit from the ongoing costs.
I'm not sure how well a $5-to-join social network would work for that reason. Sites like metafilter survive - but with five moderators and one coder, they're not going to be replacing twitter, facebook or HN any time soon.