News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by mjevans on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:43PM (#34089067)
Can we please just get rid of the 'noise' look and embrace digital acuity already? This might be one reason I tend to prefer animated content over live action.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by rtev on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:03PM (#34089235)
To many film artists, what you’re suggesting seems like the equivalent of hardcoding a custom massive bass boost into commercial headphones because “it makes music better”. It might seem better to you, but you’re modifying someone’s art, which is actively detracting from the film for many.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by knaik94 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:33PM (#34089452)
The artists' intent argument doesn't hold up, but is one that continues to be used as justification for "tradition". Most people aren't watching movies strictly in IMAX or even a color calibrated TV. Most default TV settings, even on the most high end devices, have things like dynamic saturation and motion smoothing on by default. The most popular brands of headphones do have custom eq from the factory, most people don't listen to studio monitor style flat audio. Most people don't realize there is a difference.

The meaning of art is up to the viewer, not the artist. There's nothing wrong with having a preference, like using things like temporal denoising or increasing/decreasing saturation. Even an IMAX movie theater isn't enough because that's not what the film was graded with. Pretending that art shouldn't be modified because it moves away from the artist's intent is a bad faith argument. There were certain House of Dragon color grading decision that made me feel very disappointed, and I was watching in Dolby Vision on a nice high dynamic range TV.

Artists' intent is useless if 99.999% of the population can't enjoy the actual art.

https://www.vulture.com/article/why-house-of-the-dragon-epis...

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by rtev on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:49PM (#34089562)
Your first paragraph seems to be “others are already doing it”. That’s a problem, not a justification for doing more of it. It’s a shame to see embedded analog grain stripped out because it was inconvenient for a dev team. It strikes me as a good example of the bad reputation developers hold for constantly prioritizing their own convenience over the end user’s experience.

To address your second- I think that’s an example of the “slippery slope” fallacy. I’m stating only that film noise and grain is a big part of the atmosphere of many movies and shouldn’t be removed; I’m not suggesting that a viewing experience needs to be done in a world-class theater under perfect conditions to capture artistic intent. Anyone with a basic HD television can see analog noise and grain.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by knaik94 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:13PM (#34089712)
We fundamentally disagree on how removing film grain, or changing things like saturation, affects end user experience. I don't believe it harms the viewing experience in a meaningful way. I respect that you care about artists' intent, but I think you're assuming more people care or notice than actually do. I don't believe adhering so strictly to the artists' intent will lead to a better watching experience. For some films where only a 1080p master remains, if you don't denoise before upscaling and then adding in artificial film grain, it'll look terrible.

There is an endless list of poor Bluray and UHD Bluray transfers where the the film grain makes it unwatchable. The unfortunate thing is that the nicer the display is, the sharper the image and the more distracting the grain. In some cases, I would trust the AV1 endcoder decoder to do a better job at adding a more reasonable amount of grain than the 4k transfer did. It's not a slippery slope, bad transfers and poorly color graded films/shows already exist. Mistakes exist in both directions, the UHD remaster release of Terminator 2 is a exceptionally horrible example of too much DNR. In my opinion T2 is bad enough to bring real actors into the uncanny valley.

The developers aren't doing anything different from what films do when going through an analog to digital transfer.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by jychang on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:14AM (#34090093)
... you don't think changing things like saturation affects viewing experience in a meaningful way???

Jesus. Every engineer who's worked on color implementation just choked on their drink.

You can literally scroll down a little further and find blog posts on how iMessage green vs blue saturation creates tiny changes in readability. The human experience matters a lot more than what engineers (who can't tell apart two shades of women's fingernail polish) decides matters.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by knaik94 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:32AM (#34090805)
You're making a lot of incorrect and dismissive generalizations. If you're able to notice the differences in color calibration and film grain, more power to you. Most people can't explain the difference between the saturation in video when watching something on a phone compared to watching it on their TV, if they even detect it. For what it's worth, I just did a Farnsworth-Munsell 100 hue test and got a perfect score again. I'm not sure why telling apart fingernail polish shades would make a difference in how meaningful or noticeable changes in saturation or film grain are to people.

Readability is dependent on screen brightness and difference in contrast between background and foreground colors. These decisions aren't based on what engineers assume matters, it's dependent mostly on A/B testing and perception psychology. It's the same kind of research that went into making the OPUS audio codec and deciding which parts people will notice missing and which parts don't really make a difference. Tiny to moderate changes in visibility/readability make a much smaller difference than you imagine.

https://www.colorblindnesstest.org/farnsworth-munsell-100-hu...

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by KaiserPro on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:32AM (#34091527)
The problem is, like 24fps is that film grain makes things feel "filmic".

The hobbit doesn't feel like a film in 60fps. it feels like a play, or something from TV.

Now. to your point, that motion smoothing stops this, its not strictly true. There are still artefacts that happen because its film. this then becomes the marker for "film".

> The meaning of art is up to the viewer, not the artist.

yes, but the delivery is key. your point about imax doesn't really add up. Unless you are printing out IMAX prints (which most people don't) they you'll at least do a technical grade for the IMAX to make it look like the version that the DoP/director agreed.

The House of Dragons chose to make it look like that. Mainly because I suspect the director was trying to chase the fashion for removing colour from everything. Grading, like most things is prone to fashions, and pushing against "what came before" is par for the course. Some people do it well, others are shite.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by fao_ on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:27PM (#34089412)
To be fair, in the mid-2010s that's basically what consumer headphones did -- e.g. Beats, etc.

Before I got my Shure SE215-es I ended up doing a lot of research to figure out which headphones were actually going to give me a reasonable balance between treble and bass.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by brookst on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:36PM (#34089856)
Headphones/speakers and music production are locked in a prisoner’s dilemma. If you get accurate reproduction equipment, you have to Hope the content wasn’t mastered to sound good on Beats/etc.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by arprocter on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:52AM (#34093826)
215 actually has more bass than the 425

The Aonic 3 is my daily, although using the cable that came with the 425 (EAC64BKS - more pliable than the transparent one)

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by fao_ on Saturday December 31, 2022 @06:36PM (#34201877)
> 215 actually has more bass than the 425

Sure, but I don't see where I said the opposite! I didn't say the SE215 was the op of the line, just that I did a lot of research first :)

Part of that research included finding out that the SE215 was only 80 quid, but the SE425 was 300+ quid...

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by eru on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:22PM (#34089363)
You could interpret mjevans' plea to be for artists to embrace this style in their 'true art'. Not as a plea to Netflix to alter any existing films.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by bee_rider on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:53PM (#34089585)
This analogy seems off. In your analogy, it is suggested that playback devices be made somehow worse, while the request is for the recording to not have the effect applied.

I’d say it is more like asking musicians to stop adding feedback — another phenomenon that began as an error but became an artistic tool — to their songs. Or requesting that sound engineers stop the engaging in the loudness wars.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by bobsmooth on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:55PM (#34089597)
If someone wanted to make a black and white movie, would you insist that they make it in colour?
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by bee_rider on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:57AM (#34090307)
I’m not a film producer, so I’m not in a position to insist on that sort of thing.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by kbenson on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:24AM (#34090437)
Insist? No. Make a plea because you think it's stupid or harmful or counterproductive? Everyone should feel free to do that.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by bee_rider on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:47PM (#34099236)
Sure but it is a lot easier to attack people’s preferences if we consider having a preference to be equivalent to wanting dictatorial control over every creative project.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by unsupp0rted on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:02AM (#34090651)
I prefer color, so I’d insist with my dollars and attention, yes.

Same if someone wanted to make a silent movie or ask me to join a dating site where all the profile photos are daguerreotypes.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by lukifer on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:44AM (#34090872)
I recently learned that Darabont intended "The Mist" to be shot in B&W, and the studio wouldn't allow it. While I'm sure the cinematography would have been vastly different if filmed in B&W, a quick Handbrake recompress let me simulate it, and honestly it worked really well. In addition to the "Twilight Zone" vibe, the CGI monsters looked much better without color.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by petodo on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:56AM (#34091702)
Why even use Handbrake and not just turn saturation on your TV/display to zero? Seems much faster solution and you can decide whether you wanna color or B&W option with same video file.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by mrguyorama on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:02PM (#34096336)
Modern CPUs and GPUs can re-encode an HD video in like an hour or two, while you are free to do other things. It's not exactly "wasted" time.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by petodo on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:58PM (#34098582)
that's hour or two longer than it takes to adjust saturation to 0 on display device, even just setting up encoding software takes longer, so it's waste of time

what's the benefit of doing this? you waste your time and you lose color option, I see no advantages over just adjusting saturation

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by lukifer on Monday December 26, 2022 @07:57PM (#34143685)
I'm a data-hoarding AV nerd who keeps hand-rips on a big NAS anyway, wasn't exactly out of my way :) I now have both the color and B&W versions on tap with the rest of the collection.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by llanowarelves on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:19PM (#34089742)
In music, many engineers add "color" (artifacts like tape noise and analog "warmth" (subtle saturation/distortion which were undesirable side-effects of the original circuitry)).
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by ilyt on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:38AM (#34091147)
But it is a tool to be used tactically, on a specific instrument or sound, to achieve specific effect. They don't master in 24bit/192kHz then just dump it to tape and send it.

If used as element to paint the scene noise is fine and can work well, but the trend to just slap the grain on anything "coz that's how movies looked before" is just silly.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by CuriouslyC on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:55AM (#34093221)
That is typically done to genres of music where it makes sense though. A lot of hip hop, funk and stoner rock have a certain vintage aesthetic they're going for which tape noise and overdrive help achieve. The analogy to video would be VHS artifacts for retro-80s content or sepia tones for early/mid-20th century stuff.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by ilyt on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:34AM (#34091123)
It's noise dude, you can add it back in but removing it is hard. Exact opposite of your analogy
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by knaik94 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:12PM (#34089284)
Similar to dithering, I believe film grain does help you resolve finer visual details. Having no texture would cause issues when trying to match things shot on different cameras as well. I agree with you that many movies and shows are guilty of adding so much grain it becomes distracting, but I was watching Schindler's List in UHD and loved how natural it looked. Things like clothing just felt more real and I didn't realize until the end that it was because of the expertly used film grain. The value of grain becomes obvious when you look at clips of that movie online.

https://www.audiocheck.net/audiotests_dithering.php

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by jibe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:22PM (#34089366)
>it was because of the expertly used film grain

That is an interesting way to frame it. I see it more as an expert use of 35mm film and lighting, and the grain is just present because it is inherent to the medium.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by knaik94 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:48PM (#34089555)
When going from film to digital, you have to modify the source noise in some way and there's no way to avoid it. A 1 to 1 transfer is possible, but I haven't come across any. Instead I have seen so many times where films either denoised too much or added too much artificial grain during the transfer. Starting from a very good source definitely helped, but film is limited in certain ways that digital isn't. Additionally, color grading for HDR10 and Dolby Vision was done. I didn't think that HDR would make a huge difference in a mostly black and white film but it does. The second picture comparison is what encouraged me to rewatch the movie again. [1]

[1] https://www.hdnumerique.com/dossiers/962-test-4k-ultra-hd-bl...

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by ilyt on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:41AM (#34091170)
It honestly looks more like the first one was recorded with slightly higher brightness, every "old" scene is brighter
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by miragecraft on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:13PM (#34089293)
To my eyes, a lot of film sets look too pristine when shot as-is, the grains help to make the sets look a little dirty and worn for that added realism.

Alternatively you can paint/airbrush every set piece to add that used/worn look, but I don’t think it’s economically feasible.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by eru on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:25PM (#34089391)
That reminds me of an anecdote: one of my teachers in high school was on the German version of Family Feud. That was back in the days of analog TV.

He told us how shabby the set looked like in reality. But none of that was visible on PAL tv.

I guess that's the opposite of the effect you were talking about.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by miragecraft on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:38PM (#34089492)
Pretty sure you’re talking about CRT TV’s scanline effect.

It leaves gaps in the image for you brain to “fill in the gap” and add perceived detail.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by eru on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:43PM (#34089522)
I don't think so? I'm just talking about low resolution (and low quality) in general.

Interleaved scanlines are a great trick to increase the temporal resolution, but don't do much for (or against) spatial resolution.

Or what do you mean by scanline effect?

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by janee on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:24PM (#34089385)
Personally I find it helps with immersion for content of that era.

E.g. the non-digital aesthetics of Tarintino films contribute a lot to their style in my opinion.

Plastering fake film grain ontop of something is not really my ideal, but going full film is also probably not something people can really afford in terms of time and budget...unless you're someone like Tarintino who's already at the top

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by woodruffw on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:08PM (#34089261)
I think a lot of digitally introduced noise looks pretty bad, but it's hard to imagine noise removal actually improving movies that actually were shot on film.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by newZWhoDis on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:08PM (#34089263)
Film students are more likely to have HPPD from their college years, so to them the film grain effect is normal.

(kidding)

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by elevaet on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:21AM (#34090123)
HPPD: Hallucinogen persisting perception disorder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hallucinogen_persisting_percep...

Total tangent here, but in my opinion, most HPPD are optical/perceptual defects that everyone experiences all the time, but normally our minds block, filter, or compensate for. Taking psychedelics makes people aware of these defects, and once you notice them, you can't "unsee" them.

My personal experience with this is that very mild astigmatism causes diffracted halos around light sources. I never noticed these until taking psychedelics. Now I always notice them, but they're certainly caused by defects in my eyes' lenses and not by some permanent direct effect of psychedelics. Similar with floaters, visual snow, POV effects and so on.

Many of these effects/defects become exaggerated whilst tripping and hence get noticed, then when people sober up and still notice them, they think it's something new, rather than realizing it's something that's been going on unnoticed the whole time.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by newZWhoDis on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:28AM (#34092989)
I agree, but AFAIK the most common symptom is amplified “visual snow”. While everyone has some level of visual snow, an increased amount such that it’s visible during the day/on bright surfaces would certainly be annoying
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by elevaet on Friday December 23, 2022 @02:50AM (#34103298)
I think many people complaining about visual snow really just never noticed that it's a normal part of human visual perception to have a bit of it (I remember noticing it as a kid, staring at the ceiling), but I do believe that there are these extreme cases that are real, and can't be explained with my model. It would be very annoying and concerning.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by gsich on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:46PM (#34089086)
Film grain is nice and not only a technical "issue".
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by kennedywm on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:55PM (#34089164)
Why is it nice? Is it that you're used to seeing it and its absence feels wrong? Wouldn't you become accustomed to its absence with exposure? I've found this to be the case for me.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by davidmurdoch on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:23PM (#34089374)
Maybe it's like photography. I can edit a photo of a landscape to look how it looks in person, or I can edit it to look, to me, how it feels to see it in person, or edit it for some other feeling, of course.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by aidenn0 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:00PM (#34089206)
Adding noise improves the perceived detail, which is important at low bitrates.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by eru on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:26PM (#34089401)
Well, to achieve a low bitrate, you have to fake the noise. That's the whole point of the submission.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by gsich on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:58PM (#34089191)
It gives a movie texture. Compare Lord of the Rings vs. The Hobbit. Even bad (for todays standard) CGI fits perfectly vs. the clean fake looking one.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by pmarreck on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:54PM (#34089151)
"nice" is not a rational argument, it is a qualitative/subjective/irrational one
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by woodruffw on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:01PM (#34089215)
This is why I, for one, only watch movies that have no subjective quality!
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by have_faith on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:20PM (#34089345)
Fight Club without the grain is irrational
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by gsich on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:58PM (#34089186)
True.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by zeroimpl on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:13PM (#34089716)
I know it’s referred to as film grain, but digital cameras also have grain, and the amount of grain will vary from shot to shot depending on lighting, shutter speed etc.

Adding extra fake noise to the movie solves a few problems such as ensuring a consistent look from scene to scene, as well as avoiding video artifacts like banding.

It’s also an artistic choice just like the choice to use telephoto lenses that blur backgrounds into fuzzy balls of light.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by rasz on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:31PM (#34089818)
>I know it’s referred to as film grain, but digital cameras also have grain, and the amount of grain will vary from shot to shot depending on lighting, shutter speed etc.

2004 Collateral and 2009 Public Enemies were early all digital movies full of digital noise, it looks BAD.

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by speedgoose on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:14AM (#34090094)
Many recent shows on Netflix have shots full of digital noise, and I read on HN that’s because of using RED cameras.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by mrguyorama on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:06PM (#34096384)
Linus Tech Tips uses RED cameras and doesn't seem to have that much of a problem.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by Kye on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:27AM (#34092640)
The noise floor seems to get lower and lower with every generation of camera. Eventually, no one will remember a time when using a high gain (ISO) revealed sensor/pipeline noise.
Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by npteljes on Thursday December 22, 2022 @05:58AM (#34092115)
We could do more FPS too, but the issue is that these defy the audiences' expectations, so suspension of disbelief is impacted, so the story suffers because of that. In fact, producers kind of have to do a lot of things, purely for the fact that audiences now expect it on screen. TVTropes has a great article about this issue in general, not just regarding to film grain and frames per second:

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/RealityIsUnreali...

Re:Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis by MrScruff on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:26AM (#34092976)
There are good reasons why both the VFX/post production and music production industries have done vast amounts of research into accurately modelling every 'imperfection' that resulted from the pre-digital processes. If you remove all the imperfections, you end up with something that is sterile.

Digital production methods are great at producing data in very predictable, reliable ways. But our brains our great at spotting patterns, and they can tell really quickly if something is unchanging and can be ignored. So while the challenge in the analogue world was creating order (a faithfully reproduced signal) from chaos, in the digital world it's flipped. We need to find ways of adding some chaos to make the resulting signal interesting to our brains.