News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:20PM (#34085138)
I've spent many years studying YEC and interacting with YEC's. I've even spent some time on the YouTube YEC debate circuit. I've come to one over-arching conclusion: the roots of YEC belief go down to the very foundations of one's philosophical outlook. Specifically, it is rooted in an acceptance of teleology [1]. It is a very long chain of reasoning from there, but this it the thing that most detractors of YEC miss: this reasoning is logically sound [2]. And because of that, you cannot successfully combat it with logic. You have to go to the very roots of the belief and address its foundations, which is to say, you have to deal with the fact that YEC's accept teleology as a philosophical foundation, and it is very hard to dislodge someone from that position without also sending them into a spiral of existential despair. That is the reason that these beliefs are so persistent despite being so violently at odds with [EDIT: the scientific view of] reality.

---

[1] Teleology is the assumption that things have a purpose. The divergence between teleologists and whatever its opposite is (scientists?) is that the latter starts by asking what is the cause? and the former starts by asking what is the point? Everything can be traced back to that initial flapping of the butterfly's wings.

[2] An extremely abridged version goes something like this: a cursory inspection of the world around us seems to indicate that it was designed. So let us adopt that as a hypothesis. What would be expect to see? Well, one thing we would expect is that the designer might have provided a manual to go along with his/her/its designed creation. And lo and behold, there is such a manual. Actually, there are many such manuals. Collectively they are referred to as holy texts. The logical rabbit warren branches out from there.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by mfer on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:39PM (#34085394)
What I find interesting in all of this is the number of assumptions that are made on all sides. The assumptions are often not documented or discussed. It's easy to look at religion or YEC to pull out the assumptions. Yet, I've found assumptions show up in all views on the topic.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:39PM (#34085391)
I've only done it twice, but both times were with very logical people, engineers.

My conclusion was that we had different base assumptions. They assumed that an omnipotent God existed. With that assumption, it's quite straight forward to build a logical case for evolution.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:40PM (#34085408)
> They assumed that an omnipotent God existed.

I actually doubt that they assumed that. Much more likely their belief in an omnipotent God was based on some more fundamental assumption, like that the Bible is true.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:54PM (#34085561)
Yes they believed in more than the omnipotent God. However, the omnipotent God was the base assumption in their argument. It didn't require belief in the Bible as a base assumption for their argument to hold together, only a belief in an omnipotent God.

The robustness in their argument was probably so it would hold up for both literal Bible adherents and figurative Bible adherents.

IIRC it was some sort of adaptation of an argument for a literal Bible. IIRC it was something like this:

If you believe in a figurative Bible you believe in an omnipotent God. If you believe in an omnipotent God, then (steps elided because I can't remember them, but they were logical), thus proving a literal Bible thesis and a figurative Bible thesis were equivalent.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:59PM (#34085622)
OK, I've never met a religious person who admitted to this as their base assumption, and I've talked to a lot of religious people (I run a weekly Bible study). It seems like a really weird thing to assume. But my experience is obviously not exhaustive.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:19PM (#34085867)
That's not their base belief. It's their argument's base assumption.

Nobody ever states their true base assumptions when arguing anything. Most people don't know the base assumptions of the argument they are making. It takes a lot of analysis to tease it out.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:11PM (#34086452)
> It's their argument's base assumption.

According to them, or according to you? Because if it's according to you then I'm pretty sure you're just wrong. (But of course unless we can consult with one of your subjects there is no way to resolve this so we should probably just drop it.)

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by krapp on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:01PM (#34085656)
> It didn't require belief in the Bible as a base assumption for their argument to hold together, only a belief in an omnipotent God.

Young Earth Creationism is, as I understand it, entirely based on a literal interpretation of Genesis - the "young earth" part specifically referring to using the Old Testament from Genesis as a basis for counting geologic time.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:21PM (#34085901)
If your argument requires a belief in the literal interpretation of Genesis, it's not a very robust argument since most people don't believe in a literal interpretation of Genesis.

If your argument requires a belief in an omnipotent omniscient God, it's a lot more robust because a small majority of people believe in an omnipotent omniscient God.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by krapp on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:34PM (#34087297)
Young Earth Creationism is a Christian fundamentalist framework masquerading as science. They may not mention the Bible in order to keep up the facade of simply presenting an alternate scientific viewpoint, but requiring a belief in the Bible is still non-negotiable, since their entire thesis, as such, draws from it.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @07:07PM (#34088066)
Certainly my exposure to them is limited and I'd like to keep it that way, but in my experience you've got it backwards.

The literal Bible is the goal, not the base assumption. They want to prove that the Bible is literal truth. Evolution disproves the literal Bible, therefore they must disprove evolution and/or prove creationism.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by maria2 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:26PM (#34085226)
How can something be both logically sound and violently at odds with reality? What you’re saying is that those who hold YEC beliefs have an inconsistent belief system, but the belief in YEC is constructed with valid arguments within that belief system. That’s like the opposite of logically sound.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:43PM (#34085441)
I should have qualified that with "violently at odds with the scientific view of reality" (I've gone back and edited my original comment). And it's not hard to see how this can happen. Quantum mechanics is pretty violently at odds with most people's intuitions.

> those who hold YEC beliefs have an inconsistent belief system

No, that is absolutely not what I am saying. Their belief system is, for the most part, logically sound, and so it is consistent. But it is violently at odds with science, and so they end up with conspiracy theories to explain why scientists believe in evolution so overwhelmingly. Conspiracy theories are improbable, but they are not inconsistent.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by mfer on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:51PM (#34085523)
> it is violently at odds with science

What is science in this context? Is it the scientific method? Is it the popular view among scientists as a whole (many of whom are not experts in areas they don't work in)? Is it the view of scientists in a niche? What happens when scientists in a niche disagree (they do all the time)?

I'm guessing you mean the popular view of scientists and most people see it conveyed through media, pop culture, etc.

If physicists believe/agree with/state evolution what's the science foundation to look at them as an expert to trust? Would I trust a mechanical engineers view on circuit design because they are an engineer just like electrical engineers?

Being curious I've read works from physicists who view an ancient universe and YEC (they really do exist). I've done this in good faith to try to understand how intelligent people with advanced degrees can come to different conclusions.

I bring this up to show the complexity, views, and assumptions to what we quickly call science.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:57PM (#34085598)
> I'm guessing you mean the popular view of scientists

Yes, though your use of the word "popular" puts an unfair spin on it. There is overwhelming consensus (like 99%) among working biologists (who are in the best position to evaluate the evidence) that evolution is true.

Yes, there can be complexity and nuance. But evolution is quite literally one of the least controversial issues in all of science.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by gjsman-1000 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:12PM (#34085779)
There is one issue though - how many biologists are religious in any way? According to BioMed Central, biology has more atheists than any other field. So, either they are all convinced that religions are false - or they are hardly the most impartial deciders, and are great at making sure any newcomers don’t get different ideas.

Just that fact would make a religious person laugh their head off at taking their perspective. Even from an atheistic perspective, can we rule out the possibility of an echo chamber?

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:33PM (#34086022)
> According to BioMed Central, biology has more atheists than any other field.

According to Pew, the percentage of scientists in biology and medicine who profess no religious belief (41%) is lower than geology (47%) or physics (46%). So your claim is questionable at best.

But for the sake of argument let's suppose it's true. So what? If you took a survey of astronomers I'm pretty sure you'd find that the vast majority of them are convinced that flat-eartherism is false. But that's not because they are prejudiced, it's because the astronomical evidence is overwhelmingly against the flat-earth hypothesis, and so it's hardly surprising that there aren't very many flat-earthers among people who study astronomy.

Likewise, the biological evidence is overwhelmingly in favor of evolution. That is why virtually all biologists, including the religious ones, believe it.

BTW, notice that religious belief also declines with age. This supports the hypothesis that the more you learn the less likely you are to be religious. And that is evidence against your (implied) hypothesis that belief in evolution is the result of atheistic prejudice.

---

[1] https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2009/11/05/scientists-a...

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by mfer on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:54PM (#34086253)
When I was a senior at my university I took a biology class. It was mostly freshmen. The class was lectured by a professor and graded by a teachers assistant who was a PhD student.

Being 22 as a senior, I would regularly head out to the bar at night and on the weekend. I got to know the TA for the class. One night he admitted that the professors would not let students going for a PhD get one if they had any religious belief of any kind. They only allowed atheists or strong agnostics through.

I've heard about this kind of thing happening. That was the first time I had someone in the system point blank tell me about it.

It's worth knowing there is merit to the accusations about the beliefs in this area being filtered or otherwise shaped.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:26PM (#34087231)
> One night he admitted that the professors would not let students going for a PhD get one if they had any religious belief of any kind.

And how would he know? That doesn't seem like the sort of thing a professor would confide to a grad student. It could end their career.

I think it's much more likely that your TA was lying to you in service of his own political agenda.

In any case, it is manifestly untrue that this is widespread because half of all working biologists profess to hold religious beliefs.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by maria2 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:10PM (#34089277)
Even if this anecdote were true, it’s just an anecdote. It’s important not to let anecdotes influence you emotionally. All types of individuals, religious or otherwise, do messed up things. Cherry picking examples that fit your world view is a great way to succumb to confirmation bias.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by yongjik on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:58PM (#34086925)
> So, either they are all convinced that religions are false - or they are hardly the most impartial deciders, and are great at making sure any newcomers don’t get different ideas.

If some news article suggested that biologists are not impartial because most are men of European descent, there will be pitchforks and bonfires in the ensuing HN thread.

Religious affiliation is just as irrelevant.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by saasdev on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:51PM (#34089954)
This is not true and much of evolution has and is still debated today. Public universities make you believe otherwise but if you spend half an hour researching you will quickly find much of the foundations of evolutionary theory has been challenged by recent scientific discoveries
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:46AM (#34090560)
The details are debated. The basic fact of it is not.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by mfer on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:43PM (#34085446)
> violently at odds with reality

Most of the views people have that they call reality are conclusions drawn from interpreting observations based on assumptions. They aren't repeatedly observable or a case where the observation is shows "reality" without interpretation based on assumptions.

This is how people come to different conclusions.

Learning to understand the different assumptions people make for all views was enlightening for me, personally.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by aidenn0 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:52PM (#34085547)
> How can something be both logically sound and violently at odds with reality?

Firstly, logical soundness has little to do with reality; here's a logically sound argument:

All mammals nurse their Young

Ducks are mammals

Therefore ducks nurse their young

Obviously the statement "Ducks are mammals" is false, garbage-in, garbage-out, but the logic itself is sound.

Now there was an entire field of philosophy called "Rationalism" that had a chief tenet that innate ideas and deductive reasoning was superior to sensory information. Rene Descartes formulated "I think therefore I am" because any empirical evidence of the existence of an item is suspect, but the logical statement that "if a thought occurs, then some being must be doing the thinking" is irrefutable.

Be aware that there are many epistemologies besides empiricism.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:04PM (#34085687)
> Firstly, logical soundness has little to do with reality; hmm.here's a logically sound argument:

> All mammals nurse their Young

> Ducks are mammals

> Therefore ducks nurse their young

> Obviously the statement "Ducks are mammals" is false, garbage-in, garbage-out, but the logic itself is sound

This is not sound, merely valid. A logical argument is sound if it is both valid and its premises are true. This is valid, but the premise “Ducks are mammals” is false.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by mbg721 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:55PM (#34085571)
A way this is pointed out in college logic courses is that in a truth-table, if your "if" statement is false, then all "thens" are true.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by maria2 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:55PM (#34085574)
“Ducks are mammals” contradicts “mammals have mammary glands”. When this type of contradiction happens, we call the logical system inconsistent.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by aidenn0 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:03PM (#34085677)
It's still logically consistent if I claim that ducks have mammary glands, and any duck to the contrary has had them surgically removed by the government.

You hand me an egg to put in my own incubator and raise myself? Well someone swapped the duck while I wasn't looking before the mammary glands developed.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by SAI_Peregrinus on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:47PM (#34086194)
"mammals have mammary glands" was not a listed axiom. There are two axioms, of the forms: "all X perform action Y", and "All D are members of X". There conclusion of the form "All D perform action Y" is sound. The second axiom contradicts observation, but axioms don't have to correspond to reality for the logic to be sound.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:07PM (#34086410)
> "mammals have mammary glands" was not a listed axiom. There are two axioms, of the forms: "all X perform action Y", and "All D are members of X". There conclusion of the form "All D perform action Y" is sound.

No,valid, not sound. Soundness is validity plus true premises, and any sound conclusion is true of logical necessity. A valid conclusion is true contingent on the truth of the supporting premises.

> but axioms don't have to correspond to reality for the logic to be sound.

False, premises being true is part of the definition of soundness.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by SAI_Peregrinus on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:10PM (#34085760)
The axioms can contradict a particular view of reality. The "scientific" axioms assume that objective reality can be observed (they reject solipsism). Solipsistic axioms don't accept this, only the state of one's own mind can be directly observed so it's the only objective reality under these axioms. Religions accept the existence of one or more gods as axioms, usually with some extra axioms declaring the properties of such god(s).
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by afiori on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:21PM (#34085896)
A reasoning is logically sound if it applies valid reasoning rules on well formed propositions.

Young earth can be both false and logically sound, in that case it would also be the case that some of its assumptions or models need to be wrong.

Another example of a logically sound yet wrong theory is the Ptolemaic model of the solar system, if nothing else because by Fourier analysis it follows that you can approximate well any periodic orbit using enough epicycles.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by Teknoman117 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:28PM (#34085248)
For the uninitiated, what is "YEC"?

Google wants to define is as "Young Entrepreneur Council" but I doubt that's what you're referring to.

Edit: Thank you kind internet strangers.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by BuyMyBitcoins on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:35PM (#34085353)
Young Earth Creationist. It’s a kind of creationism that posits the world is somewhere around 6,000 to 10,000 years old. That number was arrived at through interpreting scripture as inerrant and correct.

This is in contrast to other forms of creationism which have different interpretations of just how long events that happened in the scripture took place. For instance the days of creation need not be modern 24 hour days.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by mikedelago on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:32PM (#34085301)
I believe it's "Young-Earth Creationist"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Young_Earth_creationism

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by jeannot12 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:32PM (#34085315)
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by gjsman-1000 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:29PM (#34085267)
Young Earth Creationism
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by hammock on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:25PM (#34085222)
What is teleology and what is the alternative?
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:30PM (#34085285)
I've updated my comment to answer that because I figured not everyone would know. But the TL;DR is that teleology is the assumption that existence has a purpose.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by hammock on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:38PM (#34085384)
Thanks. I find it interesting that you are using root-cause analysis to explain the situation of philosophers who reason in the direction opposite to causality
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by gjsman-1000 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:33PM (#34085328)
Can you scientifically prove existence has no purpose?
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by moate on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:41PM (#34085415)
No, but that's not how science works. The general assumption is that the person making a provable conclusion (ie. that there IS a purpose) has the burden of proof.

If I claim to have a magical invisible dragon in my garage it's on me to prove otherwise, not for you to prove it doesn't.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:44PM (#34085455)
No, I can't. I can't prove anything scientifically. That's not how science works. Science doesn't prove anything. Science seeks the best explanations to explain observations. I see no evidence that existence has a purpose, and so the best explanation for that lack of evidence is that there is no purpose. But I can't prove it.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by Mikhail_Edoshin on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:58PM (#34086307)
This is not the best explanation. This is a scientific explanation. Due to the nature of that cultural phenomenon science is only allowed to use statements of a certain kind: suitable to build rather precisely defined logical models and then draw conclusions that stay entirely valid under the same assumptions. This is a very useful abstraction in a way. Yet it is limited.

Take good art, for example. Something like "A Christmas Carol". It it markedly unscientific. Yet it also explains certain things about reality. Things that are rather hard to arrive to in a scientific way. And maybe that explanation is actually better?

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:13PM (#34086475)
> This is not the best explanation.

It's the best explanation I know of for the fact that there is no evidence that life has a purpose (at least not that I've come across). Can you suggest a better explanation?

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by adamsmith143 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:35PM (#34085351)
> It is a very long chain of reasoning from there, but this it the thing that most detractors of YEC miss: it is logically sound.

OF course it's not and most counter arguments knock it on it's face at that point. Any idiot can see that just because something looks designed doesn't mean it has a designer.

>[2] An extremely abridged version goes something like this: a cursory inspection of the world around us seems to indicate that it was designed. So let us adopt that as a hypothesis. What would be expect to see? Well, one thing we would expect is that the designer might have provided a manual to go along with his/her/its designed creation. And lo and behold, there is such a manual. Actually, there are many such manuals. Collectively they are referred to as holy texts. The logical rabbit warren branches out from there.

Except all the actually useful manuals were built by man and not provided by a Designer.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by WFHRenaissance on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:22PM (#34085163)
The Catholic Church is able to merge telos and evolution. YEC should try harder.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by aidenn0 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:42PM (#34085425)
Per TFA, apparently not in Brazil...
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by jvanderbot on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:00PM (#34086323)
This point will be nitpicked , and I'm tempted to do so myself, but it only goes to show how deep rooted the conflict is when this appears at its face value to be contradictory with very reality.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by standardUser on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:17PM (#34087132)
This makes a tremendous amount of sense to me. Sorry to be political (what a crime), but I think it's a useful framework for thinking about the modern conservative movement. So much of the right now defines itself not with a cohesive ideology or specific set of policies, but rather in knee-jerk opposition to anything their supposed enemies believe. When your starting point is "these people are 100 percent wrong no matter what they say" you are now forced to explain why. And the result is a whole universe of shared lies and conspiracy theories (and people trying really hard to create some consistency or reasoning to back up those lies).
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by threatofrain on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:31PM (#34087274)
The belief that everything has a purpose is not very distinctive among Christians, so within a church, what separates young earth believers from the rest of the church?
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:55PM (#34087476)
Taking seriously the idea that the Bible -- and the book of Genesis in particular -- is the revealed Word of God.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by threatofrain on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:49AM (#34090257)
That is not much of a differentiator. Genesis is the most well known book in the entire bible. Accepting that this book is spiritually and formally canonical is a very low bar.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:47AM (#34090564)
But that is not what I said.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by threatofrain on Thursday December 22, 2022 @05:41AM (#34092003)
By spiritually canonical I mean that it's the received word of God.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by lisper on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:16AM (#34094927)
You've lost the plot. You asked me:

> what separates young earth believers from the rest of the church?

and I answered:

> Taking seriously the idea that the Bible -- and the book of Genesis in particular -- is the revealed Word of God.

The operative phrase there was "taking seriously". Many Christians profess to believe that the Bible is the revealed Word of God, but they don't really take it seriously. They play fast and loose with semantics and hermeneutics. YEC's don't. They believe that if the Bible says that the world was created in six days, then it means what it says: it happened in six 24-hour days. You crunch the numbers on the rest of the Bible's timeline and the result you get is a universe that is ~6000 years old, and so that must be the truth because God wouldn't lie. If the science says otherwise, the science must be wrong.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by ffssffss on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:45PM (#34099198)
You typically find these people in Evangelical churches that adhere to a literalist interpretation of the Bible, which is the main distinction from other sects of Christianity. These groups also tend to have out-of-mainstream views on eschatology and their own role in bringing the "end times" in the near future (often they believe it will happen in their lifetime).
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by version_five on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:16PM (#34089314)
I like the point that "logic" is not going to win the argument. I see so often people arguing against those with vastly different views and basically talking to them like children, like linking to articles or studies that explain a belief that is obvious and well known. When the source of disagreement is as you say far deeper, often outside the realm of fact and down to philosophy, and just gets ignored in favor of assuming people that disagree must be stupid