Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig...
by SAI_Peregrinus on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:47PM
(#34086194)
"mammals have mammary glands" was not a listed axiom. There are two axioms, of the forms: "all X perform action Y", and "All D are members of X". There conclusion of the form "All D perform action Y" is sound. The second axiom contradicts observation, but axioms don't have to correspond to reality for the logic to be sound.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig...
by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:07PM
(#34086410)
> "mammals have mammary glands" was not a listed axiom. There are two axioms, of the forms: "all X perform action Y", and "All D are members of X". There conclusion of the form "All D perform action Y" is sound.
No,valid, not sound. Soundness is validity plus true premises, and any sound conclusion is true of logical necessity. A valid conclusion is true contingent on the truth of the supporting premises.
> but axioms don't have to correspond to reality for the logic to be sound.
False, premises being true is part of the definition of soundness.