Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig...
by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:07PM
(#34086410)
> "mammals have mammary glands" was not a listed axiom. There are two axioms, of the forms: "all X perform action Y", and "All D are members of X". There conclusion of the form "All D perform action Y" is sound.
No,valid, not sound. Soundness is validity plus true premises, and any sound conclusion is true of logical necessity. A valid conclusion is true contingent on the truth of the supporting premises.
> but axioms don't have to correspond to reality for the logic to be sound.
False, premises being true is part of the definition of soundness.
No,valid, not sound. Soundness is validity plus true premises, and any sound conclusion is true of logical necessity. A valid conclusion is true contingent on the truth of the supporting premises.
> but axioms don't have to correspond to reality for the logic to be sound.
False, premises being true is part of the definition of soundness.