News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by aidenn0 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:52PM (#34085547)
> How can something be both logically sound and violently at odds with reality?

Firstly, logical soundness has little to do with reality; here's a logically sound argument:

All mammals nurse their Young

Ducks are mammals

Therefore ducks nurse their young

Obviously the statement "Ducks are mammals" is false, garbage-in, garbage-out, but the logic itself is sound.

Now there was an entire field of philosophy called "Rationalism" that had a chief tenet that innate ideas and deductive reasoning was superior to sensory information. Rene Descartes formulated "I think therefore I am" because any empirical evidence of the existence of an item is suspect, but the logical statement that "if a thought occurs, then some being must be doing the thinking" is irrefutable.

Be aware that there are many epistemologies besides empiricism.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:04PM (#34085687)
> Firstly, logical soundness has little to do with reality; hmm.here's a logically sound argument:

> All mammals nurse their Young

> Ducks are mammals

> Therefore ducks nurse their young

> Obviously the statement "Ducks are mammals" is false, garbage-in, garbage-out, but the logic itself is sound

This is not sound, merely valid. A logical argument is sound if it is both valid and its premises are true. This is valid, but the premise “Ducks are mammals” is false.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by mbg721 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:55PM (#34085571)
A way this is pointed out in college logic courses is that in a truth-table, if your "if" statement is false, then all "thens" are true.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by maria2 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:55PM (#34085574)
“Ducks are mammals” contradicts “mammals have mammary glands”. When this type of contradiction happens, we call the logical system inconsistent.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by aidenn0 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:03PM (#34085677)
It's still logically consistent if I claim that ducks have mammary glands, and any duck to the contrary has had them surgically removed by the government.

You hand me an egg to put in my own incubator and raise myself? Well someone swapped the duck while I wasn't looking before the mammary glands developed.

Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by SAI_Peregrinus on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:47PM (#34086194)
"mammals have mammary glands" was not a listed axiom. There are two axioms, of the forms: "all X perform action Y", and "All D are members of X". There conclusion of the form "All D perform action Y" is sound. The second axiom contradicts observation, but axioms don't have to correspond to reality for the logic to be sound.
Re:Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is relig... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:07PM (#34086410)
> "mammals have mammary glands" was not a listed axiom. There are two axioms, of the forms: "all X perform action Y", and "All D are members of X". There conclusion of the form "All D perform action Y" is sound.

No,valid, not sound. Soundness is validity plus true premises, and any sound conclusion is true of logical necessity. A valid conclusion is true contingent on the truth of the supporting premises.

> but axioms don't have to correspond to reality for the logic to be sound.

False, premises being true is part of the definition of soundness.