News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by lrvick on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:11AM (#34081654)
Does not matter. If it is their property they should be able to stack cars in their yard and call it art if they want.

Telling other people what they can do with their property is fundamentally reprehensible.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by showerst on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:20AM (#34081782)
If I move next-door to you and start a garbage dump out front, this affects you substantially doesn't it? People should have to pay for their externalities.

I think the policy in question is stupid, but so is being absolutist about it.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Workaccount2 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:27AM (#34081888)
The people who most commonly hold views like this are people who live deep in the sticks. It's ideal policy for people who live in a vacuum.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by bittercynic on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:36AM (#34082031)
Current laws in many places do a pretty good job of accounting for that - you have a lot of leeway in your backyard, but more limits on what you can do in places visible from the street.

In my neighborhood, with lot sizes around 6000-9000 square feet, this seems like a reasonable compromise.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by lrvick on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:08PM (#34084181)
I live in an area with similar lot sizes, and front yards are gardens, gaudy makeshift gift shops, junkyards, art displays... it is pure chaos. I would not have it any other way. Keeps the HOA types from moving in.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Ancapistani on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:41PM (#34084588)
Funnily enough, that's pretty close to the way it's seen "out in the sticks".

I'm happy to live next door to a grumpy old dude with six derelict cars rotting in his back yard. It keeps my property value low, which in turn keeps my taxes low and keeps the type of people away who would otherwise have an issue with my doing metalworking in my own workshop because of the noise.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by itsoktocry on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:34AM (#34081997)
>The people who most commonly hold views like this are people who live deep in the sticks.

Yeah, if only us people in the sticks were as sophisticated and selfless as the city folk. Meanwhile your team is bulldozing homeless encampments to protect property values.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by hospadar on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:49AM (#34082208)
Yeah sick burn! (not sarcastic!)

I'm put in the mind of the other thread today about wrongly judging something as over-complex.

What you can do on your property definitely affects nearby properties and it seems to me that we need a fairly subtle, localized, maybe complex way to deal with this. Different rules in the city/country, different rules for the industrial park/a neighborhood. I usually lean pretty "do what you want on your property" - in my town there's a lot of "we must preserve the character of our town [and prevent apartments or anywhere poor folk could possibly afford to live]" folks who seem to always be white and living in the expensive part of town.

I don't think any simple "TOTAL FREEDOM" or "NO MESSY CARS" rule is every going to be very just or effective.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ghaff on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:02AM (#34082414)
I live in a semi-rural farm town with a lot of small scale farming and orchards. (It's a right to farm town which means people can farm and raise animals if they're over some (low) acreage.) No one generally pays much attention to rusty farm equipment, and yes, the odd broken down car here and there.

But much as I dislike "Your grass is too long and your garden too unkempt" school of HOAs, it's not hard to see why neighbors in a neat suburban development might object to someone moving in with a bunch of junked cars on their lawn.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ponow on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:40AM (#34082944)
Those people concerned about the potential for some new neighbor's junk cars can get everyone now to sign an agreement (attached to deed) preventing said. Of course there will be some holdouts, which you'll have to bribe. So it's clear that making a local law in lieu of said agreements is effectively a subsidy to those who would have had to pay this bribe.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ghaff on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:47AM (#34083029)
Pretty hard for me to see that working most places. Why would the seller want a restriction on a property they're selling which can only decrease the value of the property? And if you're going to ban junk cars you probably want to ban a bunch of other things too. Congratulations! You've just created a HOA.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by yellowapple on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:00PM (#34083222)
> Congratulations! You've just created a HOA.

I'm pretty sure that's the above commenter's point. You don't need the county to implement some blanket law (that, in my experience as a former Sacramento County resident with family still there, is very inconsistently enforced). If you want to be an insufferable prick who micromanages your neighbors' properties because you're too patently greedy to accept an entirely-hypothetical and negligible drop in your house's value (thanks, by the way, for your contribution to Sacramento's housing crisis! We all appreciate being priced out of homeownership by wannabe investors!), then do what other greedy insufferable pricks in that situation do and form an HOA.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by jollyllama on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:44AM (#34082134)
The irony of this is the only real solution, in a property rights framework, if you care so deeply about the aesthetics of your neighbors is to live on a large tract of land. It's totally backwards.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by michaelt on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:16AM (#34082611)
I believe the traditional American solution is a "homeowners association" where some neighbourhoods strictly police the length of your lawn, other neighbourhoods don't, and you can choose when buying your home which type of neighbourhood you want.

They implement this entirely through covenants and deed restrictions, with no state involvement at all, as I understand things.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ponow on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:36AM (#34082897)
Exactly. Since all member property owners voluntarily restrict their own deeds, nobody is forced to do anything. It's completely voluntary, unlike town bylaws that can oppress minorities, like those who fix cars on their own property. These bylaws are clearly subsidies, because if you'd have to bribe those who aren't disposed to agree otherwise.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by aksss on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:46AM (#34083018)
That’s it. I live in middle of our city in an increasingly rare SFH-zoned neighborhood, one of three adjacent in our community council. Two have covenants, mine does not. Had a choice to buy in either, I chose the no-covenant one. We have a lady walking her two goats down the street periodically, one neighbor used to have an old square body pickup in side yard with a tree growing up through engine compartment (hood long gone). I like it. My friend across the way in other neighborhood tells me laughable stories of enforcement letters and such. To each their own. Choice is good - I like this approach better than city-wide laws. One of my key political principles is that laws should be as local as possible and the need skeptically examined.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by oceanplexian on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:39AM (#34082935)
I don’t live in the sticks and I don’t have a view like this at all..

Literally, the sights and sounds of the neighbor running a garbage dump is less reprehensible to me than dealing with a bunch of racist busybodies in an HOA. At least if you have a problem with the neighbor, you you can put on some headphones or build a privacy hedge. If you have a problem with the HOA they can fine you indefinitely and then foreclose on your house, kicking you out on to the street.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mc32 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @07:30PM (#34088221)
Today HOAs hit older people more than anyone else. So, yeah, there are busybodies who complain about noise and complain about lawns and house paint.... do you know who they tend to be, immigrant professionals who've bought their first house and use the HOA to get the old folks who are slower and now of lesser means busy keeping up with the bylaws.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by lrvick on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:02PM (#34084098)
I live in the bay area suburbs. Broken down cars in neighbors yards all around me. Idgaf. They paid for it and can use it as they please.

These are homes. Property value whiners need to find a neighborhood of empty investment houses to police.

I keep my property simple and tidy, but if anyone dared complain about it I would seek out the most absurd yard art possible in hopes of offending them and anyone that thinks like them out of my neighborhood.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by flandish on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:50AM (#34082219)
> garbage dump

We already have laws re environment.

What really seems to happen with these discussions is dog whistles for “i don’t want them poors next door.”

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Tyrek on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:26PM (#34083576)
The difficulty here, as in many cases, comes down to uneven enforcement and unclear lines. Consider the typical example of a consistently noisy neighbor and filing a noise complaint - in many/most cases, often nothing gets done.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by flandish on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:41PM (#34083823)
That difficulty lies in the system - which can be resolved/upgraded via various means.

But the “concept” of one’s property as investment “outranking” one’s property as a homestead is, in my mind, part of the core concern here. Maybe it’s too “meta” but we already have laws re noise, etc as well as a system in place to modify broken laws.

Appreciate your reply!

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by SyzygistSix on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:37PM (#34085377)
Or weirdos who like art and vegetable gardens.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mc32 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @07:24PM (#34088188)
Not necessarily so. Lots of expensive developments have HOAs so it's not about making life difficult for people of little means as they cannot afford property in these places -or even rent in these places. Yet, the neighborhood want to have some governance over the development. I prefer less oversight, but some oversight is appreciated to keep things from becoming unmanageable. On the other hand trailer parks, where many poor live, seem to not care much about appearance.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by zoklet-enjoyer on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:52AM (#34082238)
A garbage dump could stink up the place and create a health hazard. Some broken down cars won't hurt you
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Volundr on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:35AM (#34082881)
While I'm largely in the camp of "it's my property I can do what I want" (this is why I made sure to buy a house without an HOA) the idea that a broken down car sitting there can't affect someone beyond being an eyesore isn't necessary true. I can say from personal experience that even a car that was in decent shape when it was parked over a sufficient number of years will dump it's miscellaneous fluids on the ground, get really smelly as the interior starts to decay and become home to any number of insects and wildlife. I also wouldn't care to speculate on what the tires, paint and metals are leeching into the ground as they slowly degrade.

Sure this isn't going to be an issue with a car on blocks for a few months, even a year, but I've seen cars essentially abandoned long enough if you wanted to move them you'll have to literally dig them out and remove them in pieces.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by xjlin0 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:31AM (#34082822)
Sure about it? I've seen broken down cars leaking oil to the ground.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by zoklet-enjoyer on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:36AM (#34082888)
I've seen running cars leak oil and antifreeze
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by yellowapple on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:03PM (#34083263)
Wait until you hear about what fully-functional cars routinely leak into the ground and atmosphere :)
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by jandrese on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:10PM (#34084224)
Certainly the total level of contamination is like 5 quarts of oil in this case? Unless the person is constantly refilling their leaking junker? Maybe offer them a drip pan?

Military vehicles often have dedicated drip pans that they put under the vehicle every time they are parked because it's easier to do that than fix the leaks.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by rascul on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:03PM (#34084879)
> Military vehicles often have dedicated drip pans that they put under the vehicle every time they are parked because it's easier to do that than fix the leaks.

In the units I was in, any vehicle that had any fluids in the drip pan would get a thorough check next Monday to find the leak and would be in the shop as soon as the part came in.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by showerst on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:12PM (#34084242)
I mean this sincerely -- if you were looking to move, to someplace urban like Sacramento and you saw two houses, and one had a neighbor with multiple broken down cars in the yard and the other didn't, would you value them same all else equal? Like if it really came down to it, that wouldn't be a factor _at all_?

I'm positing (without evidence) that for most people it would be a factor, so the home owner would suffer some amount of real money harm. Much less harm in rural Alabama, much more harm in lower Manhattan.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by lrvick on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:42PM (#34084595)
I would gladly pay -more- to be near broken down cars. High chance they will not tell me what to do with my own property.

I would not even accept a free home in an HOA neighborhood.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by showerst on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:46PM (#34084655)
Fair enough! I'm surprised by how many people feel this way in this thread.

Out of curiosity, do you also think that the majority of Americans feel that way? My guess is it's gotta be at least 90/10 that would be less likely to move next to a broken down car place, certainly enough to affect the buyer pool in a city.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by BurningFrog on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:16AM (#34082614)
If bad smell or clouds of insects enter your property, I'm no longer just affecting my property.

If my property just looks untidy, it's much harder for me to accept you have a case.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by underdeserver on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:36AM (#34082900)
It does affect my property, because if I want to sell my house it has less value if my neighbors are filthy. Would you like to live next to a garbage dump?
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by yellowapple on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:52AM (#34083105)
Your first mistake was treating your house as a speculative asset instead of a house. Pardon me if I don't give an iota of a rodent's buttocks about your precious "property value".
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by underdeserver on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:51PM (#34083963)
I'm not rich. I don't have a portfolio of properties. It's not a speculative asset, it's where I poured all my life savings into. And if I need to move, it can make a difference between a small, cramped apartment and a spacious, livable one where I'm moving to.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by burntwater on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:54PM (#34085570)
Pouring all your live savings into a single asset is your personal choice. It still doesn't change the argument that a home should not be a treated as an investment vehicle. Even if you do choose to use a home as an investment vehicle, putting ALL your life savings into is a poor choice; you should probably downsize and split the savings among other vehicles.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by underdeserver on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:12AM (#34091013)
It's not an investment vehicle. I just didn't want to be beholden to landlords, so I bought where I live, and it's expensive.

There's not a lot of room for downsizing.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by TheCleric on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:55AM (#34083155)
Where does this logic end though? If I disparage a publicly traded company, and I somehow lower their stock value, do shareholders have a right to stop me?
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by inetknght on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:56AM (#34083165)
> if I want to sell my house it has less value if my neighbors are filthy

Cry me a river about your house value. If you want to invest then invest in people. Homes should not be your investment vehicle. Homes should be homes.

If you have a filthy neighbor then you should help them to not be filthy. Unfortunately laws can have real costs that some people can't afford.

Does your neighbor have a garbage dump on their property? Perhaps you should offer to take their garbage to the dump. Perhaps you should offer to pay for their garbage service. Perhaps you should offer to help them store their collectibles somewhere that won't destroy them from the elements. Perhaps you should try to understand your neighbor instead of decrying your precious lost home value.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by showerst on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:27PM (#34083578)
I have experience on this, and let me tell you, some of the people who believe in the 'fundamental right to have broken down cars in my yard' are _not_ the sort of suffering neighbors who need a community and some understanding.

When one of these folks moved in next to my parents my attempt to come introduce myself and drop off a sixer of beer was met with a shotgun.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by inetknght on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:34PM (#34083712)
> I have experience on this, and let me tell you

I also have experience on this, and let me tell you: neighbors' rights end at the property line (laws otherwise notwithstanding). I don't give a flying fuck about your resale value.

It's certainly not neighborly to be asocial but there's absolutely nothing wrong it and I'm glad you learned quickly that your new neighbor doesn't want to be disturbed.

Again, I don't care about your home's sale value. But demonstrate to me that something I'm doing on my property affects your safety and I will take action to rectify the problem. If I don't then you certainly have laws that can help you.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by showerst on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:59PM (#34084064)
That's nice that you don't care, people who cost others money rarely do. I hope you move somewhere next to other neighbors who are on the same page, and it all works out fine, and i mean that non-sarcastically.

That's why I'm a proponent of these types of laws. You take an action that costs me $X, and then the state comes along and says and you can undo the damage, (easy in this case), compensate me, or go to jail and they'll sell your house.

Again, just to be crystal clear here: I don't think there should be a law punishing you for working on your car, or painting your house an ugly shade of green or growing your own tomatoes or whatever. But here in the United States houses are the biggest purchase most people make and if go to such an extreme you make it so I can't sell mine, that's no longer you living your life without hurting anybody.

In the case with the gun-toting the rude neighbor, he ended up being more than rude, and went to prison for abusing his children. The bank that took his house cleaned it up, so it all ended sort of tragically. I often wonder what could've gone differently to lead to a better outcome there.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by showerst on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:41PM (#34084581)
inetknght it looks like we hit the flame war reply limit.

Only thing i'd like to respond to is that my view has nothing to do with making money or using the house as a business. Whether the house is worth the same, more, less than I bought it for is irrelevant to the question of if I am suffering financial harm from my neighbor's action.

If you do something that costs people money, then you make them whole, whether in occurs on your property or not, and whether they're in a mansion in the hills or a 500sf 1br condo.

I agree that houses shouldn't be investments and our current system is crazy, but it's completely orthogonal to the point at hand, except in the case of pushing more Karen types to take their financial stresses out on their neighbors =P.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by inetknght on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:47PM (#34085488)
> If you do something that costs people money, then you make them whole, whether in occurs on your property or not

By that logic, you're costing me money simply by owning land instead of me, or by working for yourself instead of for me. I demand you make me whole! /s

No, that logic does not hold up to the reality that people matter and that different people have different opinions about what to lawfully do on their own property. That inherent difference is fundamentally what is at discussion here. I argue that it is effectively impossible to hold your neighbors' (and their properties) responsible for your own properties value unless you can demonstrate problems with safety or the environment.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by inetknght on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:09PM (#34084197)
> That's nice that you don't care, people who cost others money rarely do

That's quite reductive and very typical of people who only care about money.

> I hope you move somewhere next to other neighbors who are on the same page, and it all works out fine, and i mean that non-sarcastically.

I did, in fact, move where there isn't an HOA.

> here in the United States houses are the biggest purchase most people make

Yes, they are.

> and if go to such an extreme you make it so I can't sell mine, that's no longer you living your life without hurting anybody.

I completely disagree. It's not that you can't sell yours. It's that you can't sell yours for a profit. Too bad, homes should not be profits.

If you want your home to be for-profit then you should run a home business instead. Then it's crystal clear that you don't own a home but instead own an investment vehicle with all of the not-caring-about-actual-humans that goes along with it and all of the business taxes for it too.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by underdeserver on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:48PM (#34083921)
I agree. Homes should be homes, not garbage dumps.

I'm not a real estate investor. Let's say I'm moving to a big city. My current house's value is the difference between a 2 bedroom and a 3 bedroom apartment there.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by inetknght on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:26PM (#34084408)
> Homes should be homes, not garbage dumps.

Sure, absolutely. But different people have different definitions of "garbage dumps". To me, the only real garbage dump is that wherein pests can thrive or toxic materials can leak.

I've seen the other side of things where something that's simply "not new" but completely functional is considered garbage.

> Let's say I'm moving to a big city. My current house's value is the difference between a 2 bedroom and a 3 bedroom apartment there.

If that's a problem then that's your problem. I assume you'd be moving for work, in which case bring it up with your employer. You should not treat your home as a monetary investment vehicle. If I were moving for family or to get away from neighbors, then that's simply the cost for peace of mind. That's a cost that I have decided to take upon myself. That's a cost that I will have decided to spend to improve myself. That's absolutely not a cost that the neighbor has imposed upon me.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by avgDev on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:55PM (#34085576)
I have no idea where you live, but where I live there are certainly laws because of people like you.

I don't want to see a car in a driveway on jackstands for months/years.

I don't want to hear a race car daily.

I don't want to hear your shitty music.

There are laws about type of fences, structures and other building codes.

There are laws what you can store on your property.

There are laws about business you may be conducting on your "home" property.

If you cannot live and obey by some basic rules, you need to go somewhere where your neighbor is at least a few minute drive.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by chasd00 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:41PM (#34084586)
> Cry me a river about your house value.

you're the reason HOAs exist, it's a shame because HOAs suck but at least you have some idea of standards the neighborhood shares and holds themselves to.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:47PM (#34084667)
> you're the reason HOAs exist

Racism is the reason HOAs exist (both originally, and, though their direct ability to implement it has been reduced, still in their major function and effect.)

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mc32 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @06:46PM (#34087912)
India has seen an increase in RWAs recently. Sometimes people want a system to govern their community outside of government but also within laws.

I don't think one can say racism is the major function, especially in other societies that have HOA-like systems. Admittedly they tend to be the lighter version of HOAs and not the type that act like Disney Village dictatorships who find any excuse to fine residents. If the HOA is made up of residents (rather than administered by an outside party) they tend to be more representative of the wants and needs of the development and inhabitants they govern.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by dragonwriter on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:43AM (#34095311)
> India has seen an increase in RWAs recently

Not talking about RWAs in India, but, since you bring it up, there's been plenty of coverage of an upswing in racism in India, too.

> I don't think one can say racism is the major function,

Its fairly well-documented as both a historical motivation and a current function.

> especially in other societies that have HOA-like systems.

I’m not talking about “other societies” and “HOA likr systems”.

> [...] they tend to be more representative of the wants and needs of the development and inhabitants they govern.

And when those residents were selected for racism by advertising the development with (for older developments) direct and (for newer ones) coded appeals to racism, guess what one of the prominent shared wants is?

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mc32 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:14PM (#34098034)
I cede that racism played a part in HOAs historically --however, there have been many new developments since then in the 2000s and beyond with HOAs. They cannot be racist since many appeal to new immigrants (as well as all sorts of American citizens of all stripes.

In my experience, HOAs hurt mostly retirees who don't have the same cash flow as recent purchasers of homes. Again, in my experience, newcomers to the States seem to be the most vocal in asserting the bylaws, presumably to ensure their investment keeps increasing its value. In second place come the people who are considering selling their house and also want to maximize value.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by friend_and_foe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:57AM (#34083184)
"I'm getting rats because of your garbage dump" is a completely different case than "ninnies such as myself are using an eyesore that's none of their business to try to fleece me for my equity."

Artificial human created abstract excuses to save a buck are not real externalities, they're problems people create for themselves and therefore nobody else's problem.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by admax88qqq on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:44PM (#34083875)
Smell and touch are real externalities but sight is not? Why do some senses get preferential treatment?
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by anikom15 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:30PM (#34084464)
Bad smells usually indicate something toxic that destroys you by breathing it. The only analogue to that for sight is extremely bright light.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by friend_and_foe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:50PM (#34084709)
You're arguing a point I did not make.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by yjftsjthsd-h on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:22PM (#34083510)
Okay, let's run with this. Do I have the right to demand that you repaint your house, because it's starting to look bad and that drags down my property value?
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by underdeserver on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:49PM (#34083936)
HN is a hard place to be nuanced, but there's a line. No, you don't get to make me repaint my house. You do get to tell me not to dump all my garbage on my driveway. The line goes somewhere in the middle.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by lrvick on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:05PM (#34084141)
I would make garbage art in my driveway just for you.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by avgDev on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:57PM (#34085600)
Where I live, your grass cannot exceed a certain height.

Your house NEEDS TO BE MAINTANED. If paint is chipping and looking awful THE CITY will force you to take care of it.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by BurningFrog on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:06PM (#34084920)
This is of course true.

But there is a big difference between that which concretely harms you in the moment, and that which makes your home more or less attractive to home buyers.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ponow on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:31AM (#34082812)
No, you can bribe your neighbors to sign contracts to avoid whatever non-violent behavior disgusts you. Getting some majority of your friends to make a local law to do it is just a subsidy, paid for by the people whose behavior is physically harmless behavior is being constrained. Not everyone has the same pursuit of happiness.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by friend_and_foe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:55AM (#34083147)
Having a garbage dump and having a car that needs work are not the same thing. Why is it that when these discussions come up the proponents for controlling other peoples behavior always bring these ridiculous over the top stawmen with obvious answers? Why not something like "if I throw a candy wrapper in my yard and it blows into your yard that affects you doesn't it?" The same point is made, but then it becomes obvious what is and isn't an externality: me having a car in my driveway with a flat tire is not causing a negative externality for you. Me piling garbage in my yard does.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by pwg on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:58PM (#34084050)
> Why is it that when these discussions come up the proponents for controlling other peoples behavior always bring these ridiculous over the top stawmen with obvious answers?

Because if the proponents expressed their real reason, it would sound petty or racist, and as they don't want to sound petty or racist, they have to invent "ridiculous over the top st[r]awmen" to hide their real underlying reason from view.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by logicalmonster on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:07PM (#34083315)
HOAs deservedly sometimes get a bad rap for some power-tripping leaders and busy-body neighbors out there, but this is where I think HOAs can be useful.

People who don't want to risk having an eyesore next to their house should choose to move to a neighborhood with an HOA. People who value personal freedom on their property should choose to move to an area without that. In theory, everybody should be happier.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Gracana on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:13PM (#34083399)
Unfortunately, in some places it can be very difficult to avoid HOAs. In my area they are nearly ubiquitous.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by jandrese on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:08PM (#34084180)
Sadly HOAs are mostly powerless in these situations. They can send angry letters to the homeowners and even threaten them with leins against their house, but actually getting those liens is a time consuming and expensive process so they usually won't actually do it. Plus they aren't a penalty to someone who is never planning to sell the property. They'll leave when they die or when the bank forecloses on them.

HOAs only have power of people who actually care about being a good neighbor. They're basically only useful for harassing honest people and maintaining shared spaces. You only need a HOA if your community has a pool/park/community center/parking lot that is owned by said community.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:03PM (#34084113)
As long as it's in compliance with the existing runoff and and "downwind smells" rules that apply to such facilities (which you are probably ignorant of or you wouldn't be making this comment) I don't really give a crap. It's his property. My right to do whatever is predicated on his right to do whatever.

Source: I live by a dump. You wouldn't even know it was there if it weren't for the obvious dump traffic.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by AlexandrB on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:36PM (#34084524)
> People should have to pay for their externalities.

I think this sounds nice in theory, but you open to door to neighbours expecting payment for positive externalities as well. "I just renovated my driveway and slightly increased your property value, pay me."

It also seems absurd to manage relationships between people living meters from each other by the same mechanisms we manage the operations of multi-billion dollar corporations. What next? Charging your kids for services rendered after raising them?

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by NegativeLatency on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:16PM (#34085062)
> I just renovated my driveway and slightly increased your property value, pay me.

Sounds similar to the result of having an HOA/condo association, shared payment for maintenance upkeep and improvements

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ethbr0 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:33AM (#34081977)
Yeah. I get where the HOA side is coming from and believe they should have some ability to create communities like that for people who want to live in them.

But what we should be doing is capping HOA-covered SFH at a max % of an area, to ensure people still have freedom to live in non-HOA housing if they chose.

If someone wants to give up their freedom for pretty sidewalks, good for them. But it shouldn't be the only option.

Instead, a lot of areas have local government mandating/empowering HOAs for the sole purpose of not having to deal with their community issues, at the expense of placing people under the rule of petty, non-professional tyrants.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by hansel_der on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:28AM (#34081892)
while i appreciate the freedom sentiment, i would think that there's a stark difference in any freedom in regard to population density.

in most german citys there is a set of acceptable colors to paint your house in (i.e. there is most certainly some authority that tells you what you can do to your property in any regard)

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by hyperpape on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:36AM (#34082032)
> in most german citys there is a set of acceptable colors to paint your house in (i.e. there is most certainly some authority that tells you what you can do to your property in any regard)

Out of respect for cultural differences, I won't protest you having this rule in Germany, but it doesn't sound great to American ears (I do acknowledge that Americans have disagreements about such things, but I think I speak for the norm that this sounds like people being busybodies).

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Volundr on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:45AM (#34083001)
Depending on where you (want) to live in the US your going to have a hard time finding a home not covered by an HOA, and that HOA will almost certainly restrict your house colors.

Not defending it, just observering that the difference for much of the US population is who is enforcing it, not if the rule exists.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by hyperpape on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:47PM (#34083910)
I'm not a fan of HOAs, but there is a big difference between thinking that a hyper-local opt-in association is worthwhile and thinking that it should be part of the legal requirements.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ponow on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:48AM (#34083050)
Yes, Germans do not take liberty seriously. You could handle the color constraint by contract, but it's easier to force people than bribe them to sign voluntarily.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by hef19898 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:58AM (#34083202)
Well, only if there is a "Bebauungsplan" (a plan that describes the requirements of buildings and surroundings, up to the type of trees for example). If there is not, and where we built there isn't, no such limits exist. Beyond your states general laws covering buildings and such.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by hansel_der on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:01PM (#34084848)
i recon most (all?) cities have that
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by hef19898 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:53AM (#34090604)
Not even close. These plans are limited to certain areas, usually for those, sometimes surprisingly small, areas that have just recently been opened for construction. At least in my experience, there certainly are statistics to be found around that. E.g. we don't have one neither, my parents have one so, including the kind of trees to be planted in community places.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by bumbledraven on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:26AM (#34081867)
What are your thoughts on laws that prohibit a property in an residential zone from hosting, e.g. an auto body shop or convenience store?
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by eppp on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:50AM (#34082210)
There should be jobs closer to homes in general. Building massive sprawl with no transportation isn't ideal either.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by thatguy0900 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:21AM (#34081785)
I think if you buy land in a residential neighborhood then you do owe some concessions to neighbors, not many people want to live next to your rooster coup or mosquito laden abandoned pool.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mschuster91 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:19AM (#34081759)
> Telling other people what they can do with their property is fundamentally reprehensible.

One man's freedom ends where another man's freedom begins. Fine if you're doing small scale car repairs on your own car in a residential zone, not fine if the smell from your hacky welding job disrupts my enjoyment of my property.

If you want to do shit that impacts your neighbors, go and rent a garage in an industrial or commercial zone.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by hyperpape on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:34AM (#34081987)
There is a point where this is reasonable (no one has a right to let dead animals rot on their residential property), but it's also possible your sensitive nose is ruining your neighbor's ability to enjoy his property.

You're free to join a homeowner's association which will micromanage not only smells but also the location of your garbage can.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mschuster91 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:39AM (#34082060)
> You're free to join a homeowner's association which will micromanage not only smells but also the location of your garbage can.

Here in Germany, that is usually governed by city codes anyway, no need for an HOA - trash cans usually have to be in a separate room indoors (for large complexes) or in an enclosure (e.g. [1], the first grab off of Google). We don't need micromanaging HOAs (and don't have them outside of condo complexes), because decades upon decades of experience have led to a democratically agreed set of basic rules - in this case: society has democratically decided that they don't want trash bins standing around in the open, partially because that's a fucking eyesore, partially because free-standing bins just attract vermin and pests.

[1] https://www.vidaxl.de/e/vidaxl-mulltonnenbox-fur-3-tonnen-20...

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by hyperpape on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:29AM (#34082783)
Your own choice of example was the smell from welding. With regard to releasing toxic or environmentally damaging chemicals, you are on much more solid ground.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mschuster91 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:46AM (#34083019)
For what it's worth, it would be better if people knew how to weld and how to prepare a workpiece for welding. Back when I worked on cars myself at a local hobby garage (common here in Germany, sort of the car equivalent of a makerspace), the amount of people who didn't strip off plastic attachments or removed paint was so excessive that my favourite shop imposed a rule "idiots setting stuff on fire or causing excessive smoking while welding have to bring in a crate of beer".

I definitely would not want to live next to someone learning how to use a welding rig.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by yellowapple on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:13PM (#34083400)
> Last time I checked, fuel and many other fluids in cars are carcinogens or otherwise toxic.

Judging by the sheer number of Prop 65 warnings slapped on everything in California, that's hardly unique to automobiles.

Besides, it's already illegal to dump such fluids. Enforce the existing reasonable laws instead of introducing new unreasonable ones.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by akerl_ on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:31AM (#34081948)
Do you know of any examples of jurisdictions that recognize a property owner's right to protection from neighboring property owners' smells?

I've heard several anecdotes about people whose neighbors picked up a hobby that generated downwind impact, but the only times I've heard of the neighbor being made to stop were in cases where an HOA existed.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mschuster91 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:35AM (#34082015)
I'm German, we have a ton of court cases dealing with smell emissions (mostly, grills and heavy smokers), and these almost always end up with the emitter losing because they impact their neighbors in an amount that courts see as unreasonable. Basically, "don't be an arsehole" in legalese.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by akerl_ on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:42AM (#34082107)
Interesting. It's worth pointing out that in general (though I'm still curious if there are examples here), the legal landscape in the US is weighted heavily in the other direction. One of the examples I'm directly familiar with was a friend who ended up moving because their neighbor picked up meat smoking as a hobby, and the wind was carrying nearly 24/7 smoke downwind into my friend's house.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mschuster91 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:46AM (#34082159)
> and the wind was carrying nearly 24/7 smoke downwind into my friend's house

At that point, he'd probably get a C&D order filed against him for emissions and a decent fine on top as well.

That's why I love the German system: people are protected from the influence of bad actors, not the other way around.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Zpalmtree on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:53AM (#34082257)
smoking meats makes you a 'bad actor'?
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mschuster91 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:09AM (#34082511)
As soon as a neighbor is impacted so massively they are forced to move away, yes it absolutely makes you a bad actor.

FFS, if you plan on taking up a hobby that causes pollution, do at least the bare minimum and check out with your neighbors first and install appropriate mitigation measures (filters and scrubbers). Or, if you want to be a really good person, offer your neighbors some pieces of meat in exchange for tolerating the emissions.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:23AM (#34082705)
>As soon as a neighbor is impacted so massively they are forced to move away, yes it absolutely makes you a bad actor.

Civic engagement with the goal of infringing upon your neighbors' right to use their property in whatever manner they see fit frequently meets these criteria. You are the bad actor.

Furthermore, policy informed by sentiments like yours have been tried and failed. Strict separation of commercial and residential activity is why places like LA and SF are the sprawled suburban wastelands they are today. You wanna live in the city? That means dealing with city stuff, which means hearing and smelling your neighbors and maybe a good old fashioned riot every 50yr or so. If you would prefer bugs, heat and the occasional devastating weather event every several decades move to Florida.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mschuster91 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:30AM (#34082792)
> Furthermore, policy informed by sentiments like yours have been tried and failed.

We have been running this kind of policy for decades in Germany, and the only ones complaining are people who don't care about their neighbors and society but only care for themselves and their enjoyment.

> That means dealing with city stuff, which means hearing and smelling your neighbors and maybe a good old fashioned riot every 50yr or so.

Surprise, I'm living right in the inner area of Munich. The only thing causing noise here is the street with an active 5-10 minute service bus line, and that's gotten better as the buses began to be switched over to hybrid and recently electric models. When we make a bbq event or a birthday party, it's customary here to ask the neighbors if it's OK, and to offer to come around for a beer and a steak. It's called "not being an arsehole on purpose", a concept that seems to be very foreign to Americans, at least on Reddit.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ghaff on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:12AM (#34082562)
In the US, a lot of places have restrictions on raising livestock for example which can certainly have downwind impact. My town is a Massachusetts right to farm town (as many are) though I don't know the exact details of the bylaws in my town.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by newaccount74 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:45AM (#34082154)
Welding smells a lot less than someone smoking a cigarette, so I doubt people would complain about that.

However, the noise of someone preparing stuff to weld with an angle grinder would definitely be annoying.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Mezzie on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:39AM (#34082929)
I wish people took noise pollution more seriously.

The same people complaining about car/mechanical work are the ones who have no problem with consistent leaf blowers/lawn mowers/parties/etc.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by hyperpape on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:32AM (#34082839)
Unfortunately for anyone making a fuss about this, most suburbs tolerate the scourge of gas powered leaf-blowers every weekend, starting at an ungodly hour, and they're often louder than an angle grinder.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by 83 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:44AM (#34082989)
Depends on the welding, stick welding gives off plumes of smoke and vapors. Tig welding is the opposite and very clean.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ryandrake on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:54AM (#34082285)
Or, you can just talk to your neighbors about it ahead of time and come to some agreement. I know this relies on having sane, reasonable neighbors which is not a given.

I built a single engine airplane in my suburban garage over the course of six years, and it involved lots of specialized (and loud) tools. Air compressors, rivet guns and other pneumatic tools. Before starting, I visited both neighbors and gave them a heads up to see if they had any problems with it. We agreed on night and weekend curfews for the air compressor and tools and that was that.

I swear, 90% of our laws we wouldn't even need if people weren't total assholes.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by reasonabl_human on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:35AM (#34082873)
Whoa! Do you have a build log posted somewhere? What platform did you build on?

I think I just discovered a dangerous new rabbit hole…

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ryandrake on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:35PM (#34083719)
E-mail is in my profile.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by c22 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:23AM (#34082700)
When I moved into a denser neighborhood I traded out my small noisy air compressor for an old large one that operates very slowly. You can't even tell it's running from outside my garage, let alone outside my property. Even standing right next to it you can engage in normal-voiced conversation and no ear protection is needed. Unfortunately such machines no longer seem to be available new.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by theginger on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:23AM (#34082708)
If one of your neighbors had said had just said no would you have just not done it? If you did it anyway based on when you thought it was reasonable to make noise until who would of been the assholes them or you?
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ryandrake on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:35PM (#34083714)
I would have absolutely taken steps to address whatever their concerns were, including insulating/soundproofing my garage.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by sosborn on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:31PM (#34083660)
When I was growing up in the 80's we had a neighbor that built a plane in his garage. It was fascinating to watch it develop over the years and it really taught me a lesson about persistence.

I really wish I had a time lapse of that build.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mistrial9 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:56AM (#34082308)
this thread has lost the distinction between light industrial zoning, community aesthetics and personal behaviors. In the "USA" is not really useful because, due to history, these laws in one State can be very different than in another USA State; that property ownership is generally a County level authority; and City rules can be different again, by zoning.

There is no shortage of stupid, destructive behavior among humans, agree. However zoning is generally exactly to keep light industrial activity (poisons, smells, leaks) away from residential areas (children, people with illness, health). The personal Auto blurs that distinction and yes, is a source of poisons and bad aesthetics.. so there is work to do.

Two items -- people from Asian countries, or the Global South, or others, do have really different cultural aesthetics than Germans about houses and yards; secondly there is a different fundamental agreement in America about how to allocate rights and responsibility to land owners. Is it not true that most Germans do not own a home? Is it true that the Catholic Church in Germany is the largest apartment owner, by a large margin?

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mschuster91 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:16AM (#34082610)
> Is it not true that most Germans do not own a home?

Yes, only about 47% own the home they are living in [1] - partially due to a strong history of government-provided and cooperative-owned housing, partially because land values around suburban and urban areas have exploded so far that young people can't ever hope of owning anything.

> Is it true that the Catholic Church in Germany is the largest apartment owner, by a large margin?

Good question. The Catholic Church is extremely intransparent, so serious estimates can't really be made [2]. The real estate market is extremely fractured - even the largest players Deutsche Wohnen and Vonovia, with something like 550k homes, own just 2% of the market combined [3]. The Catholic Church has been estimated at about 130k units in the past [4], so they are while certainly a large player still not the largest, not even close.

[1] https://www.destatis.de/DE/Themen/Gesellschaft-Umwelt/Wohnen...

[2] https://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/soziales/katholische-kirch...

[3] https://www.tagesschau.de/wirtschaft/unternehmen/vonovia-deu...

[4] https://www.domradio.de/artikel/zwischen-investment-und-sozi...

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by rhn_mk1 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:18AM (#34081748)
There's a limit to that. If you dump a barrel of something, and it leeches into the ground water, or washes out into the neighbor's yard, then what you do matters.

Cars have fluids that aren't exactly environmentally friendly.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by lost_tourist on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:29AM (#34081930)
If you signed an HOA agreement you have to abide by it. It's as simple as that barring local laws about junk in your yard
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by lost_tourist on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:31PM (#34097447)
Downvote me if you like but it's true.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:57AM (#34082335)
I agree on principle, but principle can have edge cases. I live on a 10-acre rural property, surrounded by similarly sized plots. A lot of the people out here are small business owners who run their businesses from home, so there is equipment and supplies all over their properties, etc. One of my neighbors likes to randomly shoot skeet and do target practice with his rifle. Another one likes riding four-wheelers, etc, up and down the adjoining property line.

Hell, I have three broken down vehicles on or near my driveway for years and no one's said a thing to me about it. At least they're on their own wheels and not up on cinder blocks :-)

How people want to live can be irritating, but we all moved out here for the space and more freedom to live our lives, so we have to try to get along. I'll put up with the noise from your shotgun at noon, but when you start setting off cherry bombs at 9PM, then I'm going to be pissed and you'll hear from me.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by showerst on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:35AM (#34082874)
I think much of it depends on density. If we're in a tight suburb with 1/4 acre plots, my neighbor's weed infested yard with a broken down car makes it much harder to sell _my_ house. If they move in after I do it's plausible that costs me a hundred thousand dollars or more, by no fault of my own.

If they're on 10 acre lots with trees where I can't even see it, and my neighbor is just doing reasonable stuff to run a small business on ground with no zoning, who cares? On the other hand I can still hear it, so we might share similar positions on noise after hours.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ponow on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:46AM (#34083022)
What does it mean to own property? Does that meaning depend on a democratic majority? If so, then you don't have private property. Whatever restrictions you want to impose on neighbors due to high density can be done using contracts (added to deed). You don't need these laws. But people don't want contracts, because it's easier to force people to abide by rules that you can't get them to voluntarily agree too. These laws are a subsidy, because you'd have to bribe some people to sign agreements to accept certain restrictions.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by showerst on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:59AM (#34083212)
> You don't need these laws

I don't want to go around proposing a HOA-style contract with every single person in earshot / downwind every time I move, and hope we can come to terms I can afford.

> it's easier to force people to abide by rules that you can't get them to voluntarily agree too

The issue is that some people's concept of "ownership" means "I can do whatever I want on this property, even if it imposes a high cost on others". You can pick your scenario, from "My home, my 3am drum practice" to "My home, my burning of this pile of nuclear waste". There's no magic way of assessing the "true" costs to me by your actions next door, so we need these laws.

If you live on more space near less people, then you need less of these laws, maybe none!

I understand (and agree) that for every "My neighbors yard is a literal cow pond" there's some Karen who is mortified at the shade of off-white I painted my house. There are also unlimited historical cases of the government misusing these laws to keep poor/minorities out. The reality is there are a lot of selfish assholes out there, and so laws help give you a little recourse when one moves in next door.

I don't feel unreasonable saying I want to sleep from 11pm-7am, and be able to sell my house some day with a value based solely on the greater market and what I do to it, not the crazy guy down the street.

That said, I live in a very dense city. I'm not moving to rural Alabama and expecting to impose that on anybody 2 miles away.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by lrvick on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:22PM (#34084363)
Your property value is of no concern to anyone else that just wants to live their lives in their homes. Trying to restrict the non-violent behavior of others is a dick move no matter the lot size.

I live in a small lot suburb with roosters and I have been known to angle grind at 3 am. Neighbors say nothing. I say nothing about screaming kids, blaring music, and the dude doing late night Tuba practice. This is just people living life.

If you value total silence and no evidence of lifestyle diversity around you, then perhaps rural Alabama is a better fit for you.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ghaff on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:58AM (#34083198)
>What does it mean to own property? Does that meaning depend on a democratic majority? If so, then you don't have private property.

Property rights are not absolute--just like free speech is not absolute.

You have to pay your property taxes and, as discussed on this thread, there's zoning which may restrict commercial activity in a residential area. There are doubtless other bylaws in a given place related to noise, smells, etc. The government can take a property by eminent domain as well.

It's about being reasonable. And what's reasonable on a 10 or 100 acre rural farm is different from what is reasonable in an upscale suburban community with houses on 1/4 acre.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by dymk on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:09AM (#34082514)
Thank god HOAs exist as a counterbalance to people who hold these opinions.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mc32 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:23AM (#34082707)
Yes and no. Degrees matter. It’s the age old problem of why we can’t have nice things. People not being roughly reasonable.

Yes it’s their yard, but it’s also our neighborhood. Yes they should have autonomy but also should know how to operate within civil society. There are limits. They need not be onerous and get down to small details, but people need to be roughly reasonable.

Can I call in emergency scares and call them “artwork” of the performance kind? Things aren’t things just because I say they are a thing. One can’t walk thru a TSA line with a weapon and “call it art”.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by yellowapple on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:08PM (#34083332)
> but also should know how to operate within civil society

A society which threatens its members with state violence because they dare to repair their own property themselves on their own property is hardly "civil".

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mc32 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:13PM (#34083405)
What do you mean? I think a few months is a reasonable time to have things on blocks to be worked on. Multiple years is unreasonable.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by lrvick on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:34PM (#34084505)
Speaking as someone that grew up poor, people hoard any fixable backup cars they can in case their primary ride breaks down forcing them to invest in a weekend getting another beater running.

Not everyone has the luxury of keeping all the cars they own in running order at once.

The fact you clearly do not understand this is exactly you have have no business making rules for other peoples property.

When you make laws to restrict behavior like this, you are really trying to get rid of the poors.

If you want to help discourage this type of behavior long term, vote for better public transportation.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by duped on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:27PM (#34083591)
I feel like people get too absolutist about this. At the end of the day, people should be free to do what they want as long as it doesn't interfere with anyone else's freedom to do what they want (aka do unto others, etc).

The problem with "let people do literally whatever they want" with their property is that it infringes on my freedom to live happily/healthily on my property.

If my neighbors blast music until the early hours of the morning and they don't turn it down when asked politely, is it "reprehensible" for me to call the police to enforce my village's noise ordinances? What if they're burning refuse and it spews over into my yard and ventilation? Or if they have an uncovered fire pit close to the property line?

That's not even getting into the long term effects on the community, like if people store or dispose of hazardous waste on their property (we all share the same water table!).

I don't think it's "fundamentally reprehensible." It's part of living in a free society that balances the rights of one against the rights of all.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by beiller on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:32PM (#34084485)
Could repairing an ev in your driveway run afoul of this? Sounds like yes.

Leaking oil into the ground and air conditioning gasses into the atmosphere is already illegal. It sounds like preventing car repair is purely a nefarious regulation, whether it be an attack on rights to repair, or preventing depreciation of some over inflated asset. I would love to explain this away with simple ignorance. If so, let's just repeal this ridiculous regulation.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by duped on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:40PM (#34086114)
I once worked in an area that had a problem with smokers littering. They put out trash cans and ash trays and heavy fines. No success. They banned smoking within the area. The littering stopped, because it's a lot harder to hide smoking than hide littering.

Like another poster said, "this is why we can't have nice things." A few bad actors breaking ordinances that are unenforceable means the ordinances become more strict.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by beiller on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @08:19PM (#34088540)
I'm curious how policing the no smoking is somehow easier than policing littering your cig butt. And so what, are the anti smoking police giving smokers tickets while ignoring actual littering of plastic and pollution cause hey, it's impossible? I don't see the problem as solved. But then again I'm being a bit ignorant of your specific situation.