News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by 323 on Monday December 19, 2022 @12:22PM (#34054721)
It seems the Mastodon ecosystem has serious problems scaling.

Most of the servers are closed to registrations, and we are just talking about a couple million new users over 2 months. What if 100 mil users want to move?

Are we going to relive the Twitter history, which crashed every time Justin Bieber tweeted?

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by DiNovi on Monday December 19, 2022 @12:33PM (#34054860)
it’s not built to scale as a feature. it won’t be the twitter replacement but some people might stay once they understand the benefits of small niche communities
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by vorpalhex on Monday December 19, 2022 @12:28PM (#34054791)
That's a feature, not a bug.

Each server in the fediverse should stay relatively small.

Consider running your own for your friends.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by nerdponx on Monday December 19, 2022 @12:30PM (#34054820)
Or pay a hosting company to run one for you. At least you get to control your own community and moderation.

Even if you are still subject to the whims of your hosting company, you still retain a fair amount of autonomy unless you are running a community like Kiwifarms (in which case I find it hard to be sympathetic anyway), or your hosting company happens to be located in a jurisdiction with enforced censorship laws.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by drstewart on Monday December 19, 2022 @12:48PM (#34055062)
Exactly. The average person is dying to pay to have the privilege of an extra job moderating and administrating their own social feed! This is a bulletproof plan that really understands consumer behavior.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by vorpalhex on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:19PM (#34055541)
Who says unpaid? Make your friends buy you dinner or throw some cash your way.

One of the benefits of the fediverse is that you can experiment with new payment models.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by BoorishBears on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:35PM (#34055742)
I can't tell if this is satire in response to sarcasm, could you clarify?
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by vorpalhex on Monday December 19, 2022 @02:37PM (#34056573)
Not satire!

You're providing a real service to your friends - a mastodon server. It takes real time, real skill and real money (buying hardware or renting a vps) to do this. Your friends should compensate you and it's fair to ask them to do so.

How you do this is up to you.

I host a gameserver for my friends. This is a really nice bit of hardware in a datacenter. It costs me $600 a year directly and maybe 4-6 hours a month. I have about 8 folks who play on it with regularity.

For my friend group, we "compensate" via trading food, either cooking for each other or catching dinner out. That works well for my friend group and I perceive this as fair.

Your friend group may be different. You may literally ask them to throw in $5 a month or maybe you trade services (your barber friend gives you a free haircut on occasion, whatever).

There isn't a magic equation of what is fair or right for your circumstance.. and it's ok to experiment. Part of why the fediverse is good is that these experiments can be run.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by BoorishBears on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:19PM (#34057107)
Then it's not really a good faith reply to their point is it?

The problem presented wasn't how you pay, it's the fact that you pay and take on moderation duties and curation.

Getting reimbursed by friends doesn't change that, and if anything it convolutes the latter part of the problem by leaving the door open to some awkward dynamics.

A centralized group chat that needs funding to stay alive sounds like a pretty awful product.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by vorpalhex on Monday December 19, 2022 @11:56PM (#34061710)
All things require funding. There are no exceptions. My discord guild also requires time and money.

So it goes.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by BoorishBears on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:37PM (#34071272)
I don't think you have any reply to the topic being discussed.

The point is that people went from an experience where they didn't take money out of their pocket every month unless they wanted to, and didn't have to curate for others or moderate for others.

I pay for a game server and won't accept a dime from my friends for it not so I can feel like king of some fiefdom, but so we can enjoy a game amongst ourselves.

If moderation is the part of that experience that you're cherishing, it's no wonder you can't relate to the complaints others have.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by vorpalhex on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:42AM (#34095294)
> The point is that people went from an experience where they didn't take money out of their pocket every month unless they wanted to, and didn't have to curate for others or moderate for others.

That was basically a vivid hallucination. You offshored the mod work to underpaid contractors in foreign offices and paid by selling your focus and privacy. You didn't have to feel guilty because some nice folks in fancy clothes with a big PR department told you it was cool.

Those folks in the fancy suits are realizing it's too hard to make money that way.

You can still chase that bargain. You will see more and more ads. Your privacy will only get more invaded. Eventually you will have to pay.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by nerdponx on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:20PM (#34057116)
You are aware that an entire generation of Internet forums operated (and still operate) this way, right?

Big forums had big hosting costs and required donations from members, had issues with spam, had to source volunteer moderators from the community, etc., just like big Mastodon instances today.

Small forums had few of those issues because the scale was smaller. The problem was not that nobody wanted to run a small forum: it's actually kind of fun to be a forum admin for your friends, and only one person in the group actually needs to be the admin. The problem was that nobody wanted to be on a small forum because it was small.

Now you can have it both ways: a small instance with trivial running cost and moderation demands, but all the benefits of being on a huge forum with thousands of concurrent users.

See also: Discord servers. Administering a Mastodon instance that you pay someone to host is not much more difficult than administering a Discord server. If people found it difficult to moderate a Discord server, why would so many friend groups, gamer groups, content creators, sub-Reddits, and software projects have their own small Discord servers? The answer is that the cost of moderating a small group of people is really small because small groups are easy to moderate, and the main downside of a small group isn't really relevant when the small group can follow and interact with anyone in the huge federated network.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by darkwater on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:27PM (#34058650)
> You are aware that an entire generation of Internet forums operated (and still operate) this way, right?

And yet many of them died or, better put, most of the new forums were never born nowadays because communities moved to centralized, managed solutions (Facebook, Telegram, Discord, Slack etc)

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by kitsune_ on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:41PM (#34058827)
Most of the focused niche discussions around the globe still happen in forums (and subreddits).
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by darkwater on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:39AM (#34065697)
Reddit is as centralized as a platform could ever be.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by kitsune_ on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:01AM (#34067747)
I didn't claim otherwise
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by nerdponx on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:51PM (#34075239)
what's interesting about Reddit is that moderation is (in theory) decentralized and handled independently by each sub. Only account creation and discovery are centralized, from the perspective of an average user experience. The whole point of a federated system is that you get the best of both worlds: global discovery and one single account/login for all communities, but you retain per-community moderation.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by nerdponx on Monday December 19, 2022 @09:20PM (#34060745)
I mostly attributed this at the time to UI/UX improvement in the centralized platforms, and not needing so many different logins for different communities.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by kitsune_ on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:39PM (#34058809)
I was 'web socialized' in the 90's. IRC, web forums, and so on. Before that we had BBS. This is nothing new. And nothing prevents a major player to enter the fediverse btw.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by nerdponx on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:48PM (#34076417)
> nothing prevents a major player to enter the fediverse

Apparently Tumblr intends to implement ActivityPub, so it might be happening sooner rather than later.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by BoorishBears on Monday December 19, 2022 @12:54PM (#34055167)
I mean you're certainly free to paint it as a feature, but Mastodon is getting pushed very heavily by many Mastodon users to Twitter users as a backup (see "movetodon.org", which starts with "Log in with twitter") so I the scaling issues deserve more than the "that's a feature!" I see thrown at every person who brings them up

> Each server in the fediverse should stay relatively small.

Certainly doesn't vibe with the project owners pushing a set of "blessed" servers to every visitor: https://joinmastodon.org/servers

I think this is the biggest reason Mastodon will stay a fringe platform. No one who enjoys it will accept anything of its issues as valid criticism, and if you point out the fact that such a mentality will keep it from getting popular, the reply will be "good! I don't want it to get big!"

Meanwhile the project itself very clearly wants to get popular, and it's clearly being sponsored with the intent that it should become more and more relevant, much to the chagrin of those who were using it before it was cool.

It seems like eventually the cool kids who start to shut out the new kids to stave off an Eternal September, leaving the project in an awkward spot and a steady decline for everyone involved as the old guard shifts energy to building taller and taller fences around their respective echo chambers. (Now what was that about registrations again?)

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by fleddr on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:57PM (#34058324)
Serious question: if a community is so small as to be just your friends, why not start a Whatsapp, Telegram, Discord group? Free, fully managed, content preserved, well established.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by OctopusLupid on Monday December 19, 2022 @07:43PM (#34059989)
Don't forget Matrix.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by EarlKing on Monday December 19, 2022 @12:50PM (#34055098)
I've tried telling people before that the Fediverse doesn't scale, that decentralized solutions where nobody is paying for anything only work for flashcrowds (i.e. torrents), and ultimately this is going nowhere... but nobody wants to hear it. Everyone is sure that "torrents work, so this will work", neverminding the fact that the entire peer-to-peer ecosystem only works as long as there are people to seed, seeding costs money, and there's plenty of content out there with zero seeders. You'd think that would clue people in that this isn't going to work, but there it is. Hell, you'd think the history of Usenet and FidoNet would've given people a clue, but nobody wants to hear that either.

If you're not willing to pay for the services you require... you're going to have a bad time. That is the ultimate lesson of the Fediverse.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by jacquesm on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:32PM (#34055718)
Two observations: (1) maybe it doesn't need to scale for people to ultimately have a much better experience and (2) bottlenecks tend to be identified and resolved up to the limit of the scaling laws and hardware improvements, bandwidth cost reduction and storage cost reduction tend to over time make the impossible thing from yesterday feasible today.

Keep in mind that Torrents tend to be much larger than your average Tweet/Toot/Whatever and that the interconnects between the servers need to transport only those messages for which there are subscribers, something that could be optimized for.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by Zak on Monday December 19, 2022 @02:40PM (#34056625)
Being based around a protocol rather than a single piece of software, it will likely end up that servers intended to grow large will run different software than servers intended to stay small.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by jacquesm on Monday December 19, 2022 @02:44PM (#34056670)
That could well happen, a bit like the difference between say 'gmail' and your own private mail server. The big trick will then be to stop it from becoming siloed again.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by pwinnski on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:01PM (#34058369)
I suspect that key to the future of the fediverse is likely to be a more efficient piece of software than mastodon.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by Zak on Monday December 19, 2022 @07:43PM (#34059992)
I expect very large servers will be commercially operated and running bespoke software. When Tumblr adds ActivityPub support, it will be the largest Fediverse instance by far.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by factormeta on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:26PM (#34069095)
hmmm didn't know Tumblr was planning on doing that. Any more info on this?
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by Zak on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:40PM (#34070236)
They announced it, oddly enough on Twitter. Techcrunch reported it, among others. Flickr is also considering it.

https://techcrunch.com/2022/11/21/tumblr-to-add-support-for-...

https://twitter.com/donmacaskill/status/1594945727255699457

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by jacquesm on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:32PM (#34072901)
It will probably immediately cause those directly upstream to find some new bottlenecks in their implementation.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by Karrot_Kream on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:16PM (#34058524)
> (1) maybe it doesn't need to scale for people to ultimately have a much better experience

Big, heavy doubt. This Twitter debacle has generated ridiculous, crazy amounts of drama and emoting, the likes I haven't seen on the net in ... a while. This kind of emoting and drama stirring only works when the pot is large. A storm in a small teapot really isn't much. It reminds me of the high drama that used to happen on large IRC channels run by teens in the early '00s, where you'd wake up and some portion of the server got muted or banned for some completely opaque but intensely personal reason. (I was one of the teens so I'm not implying like I was much better than the rest of them lol.)

I'm in 20-something small Matrix rooms/spaces and Discord guilds and none of them are nearly this dramatic. The kind of folks that seek engagement on Twitter IMO are in it for the high drama that you can only get on a large social platform. The folks that stay on the Fediverse are looking for something entirely different. I'm hopeful that some folks try the Fediverse and realize they didn't need Twitter at all (not in some sense of Twitter anger, but more that it's good for folks who want to socialize in smaller spaces be aware that it's very possible to do that on the net right now.)

FWIW If you're trying to build a small community and afraid of scaling issues, I still think hopping onto Matrix or Discord (preferably in that order) is a better idea. Synapse might be heavyweight but it's still lighter than running Mastodon, and if your community doesn't want to federate, you can run the much lighter Dendrite (or even lighter Conduit which is a bit more raw.) There's a large ecosystem of clients on all the big platforms for Matrix. Discord being a centralized, closed system has all of these problems solved as well.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by cactusplant7374 on Monday December 19, 2022 @06:17PM (#34059241)
> maybe it doesn't need to scale for people to ultimately have a much better experience

It certainly needs less features. I'm sure quite a bit of Twitter's infrastructure is dedicated to ads and analytics.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by jacquesm on Monday December 19, 2022 @06:40PM (#34059474)
That's a good observation, a federated, non-commercial messaging platform has a different tech footprint than one that needs to be monetized to the max to satisfy a bunch of shareholder and generate quarterly earning reports.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by cactusplant7374 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:27PM (#34071103)
Plus, it's written in Rails. [0] I love Rails but they could switch to something else and tweak it to the extreme. There were very popular sites in the past (i.e. Slashdot) that didn't have many servers and were extremely performance tuned.

https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by elsjaako on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:35AM (#34063668)
There's also no full text search on Mastodon, and no single server has access to all the posts on the federated system.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by Zak on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:09PM (#34055385)
It will be interesting to see what happens when larger commercial services like Tumblr and Flickr enter this space. There's a good opportunity for startups to experiment with social apps and sites that would have previously struggled to build a large enough network to be useful; support ActivityPub and you have a network.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by jeffbee on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:03PM (#34055293)
Twitter only works because it is centralized. The fediverse works less and less well as the number of federated instances increase. It has anti-scaling properties. And, on the non-technical side, it has a disorganized anonymous set of moderators you've never met or ever heard of, with no particular guiding philosophy or rules, and these guys have total access to your profile and they can do anything they want.

On the technical side, the whole thing is lossy as hell. If I view a foreign profile on my instance it shows a handful of posts and then says that "older posts" aren't shown from other instances. Then if I go to the other instance there are hundreds of posts that aren't older, they were just missing on my instance. None of it really works or makes any sense.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by Zak on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:12PM (#34055432)
It's a push-based protocol. If somebody on your server follows the account, its posts will be on your server, but they can also be there through boosts, which leads to a seemingly random handful being populated.

A mechanism to backfill posts would definitely be a good addition.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by phoe-krk on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:11PM (#34055410)
> And, on the non-technical side, it has a disorganized anonymous set of moderators you've never met or ever heard of, with no particular guiding philosophy or rules, and these guys have total access to your profile and they can do anything they want.

Didn't you just describe Twitter?

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by jeffbee on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:17PM (#34055499)
Nobody knows what the hell is going on with MuskBird, but when it was still Twitter there was a two-sided terms of service, under which Twitter offered its users concrete, enumerated benefits. Mastodon instances do not have "terms of service" they have "rules". The "rules" are unilateral in that they bind the user and not the service provider. The entire model is strictly worse for the user than Twitter was.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by rsynnott on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:37PM (#34055783)
> The entire model is strictly worse for the user than Twitter was.

The model does make it difficult for an idiot to take over _the whole thing_ and ruin it, though.

Your position as a user on any given Mastodon instance is worse than it was on pre-Musk Twitter, undoubtedly (post-Musk it just has a CEO ruling by fiat, which I would argue is a worse situation than you have on most Mastodon instances), but it's unclear that your position as a user of Mastodon writ large is.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by phoe-krk on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:21PM (#34055570)
> Mastodon instances do not have "terms of service" they have "rules". The "rules" are unilateral in that they bind the user and not the service provider.

Of course they do. If the instance administrators do not abide by the rules they set, every user has the possibility to jump ship to an instance whose team actually does its job properly. This is undoable on Twitter, which makes me doubt that the overly general statement of

> The entire model is strictly worse for the user than Twitter was.

holds any actual merit.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by 9wzYQbTYsAIc on Monday December 19, 2022 @09:34PM (#34060831)
This is probably the right post to refer everyone to the Mastodon Server Covenant, which does bind the service provider to some level of consistency: https://joinmastodon.org/covenant
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by Groxx on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:59PM (#34056097)
>The fediverse works less and less well as the number of federated instances increase. It has anti-scaling properties.

In some ways, and for some purposes, this is very likely a feature. A good amount of the fediverse wants small healthy communities, not Twitter but federated (i.e. everything going everywhere all the time).

I will absolutely agree that it's sub-par for almost anything happening now, which is a problem. But it's experiencing unprecedented growth - there will be growing pains, just like non-federated things do when they have unprecedented growth.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by drewzero1 on Monday December 19, 2022 @02:20PM (#34056362)
Every instance has its own moderation policies, and the user has the option of moving to another instance (and keep being able to interact with the fediverse at large) if they clash with the mods or don't think they're doing enough. Instance maintainers are named and contactable if you have issues with them or other users. If you don't trust them with your account, move to an instance that you can.

What can you do if you have issues with the moderation team at Twitter? Honest question-- I've been off Twitter for over a decade and hear about everything there second-hand.

This sword cuts both ways for the fediverse (allowing bad actors to just move to another instance, for example) but on the whole I find it allows for a more people-centric approach to online community.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by jshen on Monday December 19, 2022 @02:33PM (#34056533)
Federated systems are more resilient, which is the half of the trade-off you leave out. Also, “scale” is too vague a term in this context. It could mean efficiency or it could mean uptime. These are very different, and federated systems will have higher “uptime” in the sense that one instance crashing won’t cause all to crash. However, it will be less efficient, but there are huge efficiency gains to be had with the current design.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by unshavedyak on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:06PM (#34056923)
> that decentralized solutions where nobody is paying for anything only work for flashcrowds (i.e. torrents), and ultimately this is going nowhere... but nobody wants to hear it.

Fwiw, speak for.. yourself? /shrug

I pay for my instance. So do many. Because it's on Patreon and fully funded right now. Yea it's small, around 16k users, but we pay because we enjoy it. Also it's ridiculously cheap to contribute, which helps.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by KoftaBob on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:38PM (#34058123)
Agreed. However, if Mastodon instances hosted attached media/images over IPFS, in theory it would lead to a significant decrease in bandwidth that those instances need to transfer themselves, as that media could be distributed p2p between users who have loaded it already.

Thankfully, there already is work being done to implement this kind of functionality, giving instances the option to serve images over IPFS gateways. Further decentralizing Mastodon needs to be a very high priority for it to be sustainable longer term.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by fleddr on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:49PM (#34058246)
I will join you in your unpopular opinion. People have become so entitled that they can't appreciate the value they have in their hands today.

Services like Twitter, Insta, FB, the like are in many ways incredible. We've forgotten all about that, but let's explore...

They're pretty much always available. They scale endlessly without you noticing. They are fast. They have apps on every touch point. They preserve your content pretty much forever, and this content exponentially grows. They have armies of people as well as advanced AI to filter out the most horrible of human depravities, so that you don't get to see it.

And for all of this, you don't pay a single penny. Yes, you'll get a few ads. You can even block those. An incredible amount of value offered, for near-zero costs.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by vlunkr on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:38PM (#34058796)
They also have obvious downsides, so I don't think there's any harm in attempting to create alternatives.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by fleddr on Monday December 19, 2022 @06:07PM (#34059125)
They do, but that's kind of my point. Libraries full of articles have been written about the negative aspects of these services. Many perfectly accurate, no disagreement here.

But think about it. We have networks in which we can connect to any other connected human being. Post near-unlimited amounts of content which is reliably preserved. We have well functioning-apps and reliable services, and relatively clean content. For the price of: 0$, and ads.

What I'm getting at is that all this stuff that we take for granted, isn't a given or free when you scale Mastodon. It costs real money to run instances which hampers growth and sustainability. There's a steep human costs to moderation.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by vlunkr on Monday December 19, 2022 @07:05PM (#34059692)
Ah, yeah I see what you're saying. Twitter may not be the best example though. Users don't pay anything, but they've also failed to turn a profit.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by DJBunnies on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:47PM (#34058885)
Terrible take, sacrificing integrity for uptime.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by fleddr on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:50PM (#34058918)
Well, this is obviously become I'm a terrible person lacking integrity.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by DJBunnies on Monday December 19, 2022 @06:04PM (#34059102)
Your words.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by datacruncher01 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:10AM (#34066907)
All those systems were built and designed during a time where free money via cheap credit was available to fund growth at all costs to become the dominant market player. That money is fading with the Fed rate increases and is looking like it may stay that way for a long time. What this means for tech is more paid everything. Expect most of the free services to disappear. Twitter, Elon or not was going to have to make major cuts to stay afloat.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by lasc4r on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:24AM (#34067126)
That's one way of looking at it, too much like explaining the wonder of efficiency that is the gasoline supply chain without mentioning CO2 though. Kinda changes the 'incredible amount of value offered' for me.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by ThePowerOfFuet on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:56AM (#34068615)
> And for all of this, you don't pay a single penny. Yes, you'll get a few ads. You can even block those. An incredible amount of value offered, for near-zero costs.

Interesting how you think that the only costs could be financial.

Also, the presence of ads is only tangentially related to impact on privacy (yes, another huge cost).

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by Octokiddie on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:49PM (#34058253)
Maybe side effects of scaling are what Mastodon users are trying to leave behind.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by pwinnski on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:00PM (#34058359)
I think there are some differences that are key.

1. The fediverse doesn't necessarily need to scale to 100 million or more people, and if it were to hypothetically hit a hard limit at 10 million, that would still be fine. Anecdotally, many people are reporting similar levels of engagement--and more positive engagement--with even a small percentage of their twitter audience.

2. Usenet failed largely because it was overrun with spam. While Fediverse moderation is distributed and therefore inefficient, it's still done, so spam doesn't seem likely to overrun anything. In theory, each server moderator moderates their own server, and any servers that don't end up blocked.

3. At least at this point in time, people seem to be willing to pay for their own servers. Many servers are running patreon accounts or similar, and most I'm aware of are running a surplus of funds. Of course, that might not always be true. Smaller server are very cheap to run.

4. I wouldn't think of torrents as an example, but rather the web itself. So so so many individual websites are out there being paid for out of pocket, and nobody seems to be worried about them all failing at once.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by crazygringo on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:49PM (#34058911)
Regarind 1), I'm sorry but that makes no sense. Barack Obama has more than 100 million followers on Twitter. So no, a hard limit of 10 million users makes no sense for any messaging service that intends to connect people across the world. That would be a showstopper if there ever were one.

Would you say the same thing about e-mail, that it "would still be fine" if it only ever scaled to 10 million people?

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by pwinnski on Monday December 19, 2022 @06:14PM (#34059201)
The world, it turns out, contains more than just hammers.

The fediverse, it turns out, isn't primarily a messaging service.

So yes, if you define X as "a messaging service that intends to connect people across the world," then X must support as many people as possible. But if you don't define X that way, then not supporting 100 million people isn't such a big deal. Millions of people are already happily on fediverse servers despite the lack of any current or former presidents there.

People who want to follow whatever Obama wants to say can do so in any number of ways. The Fediverse might be one of those ways, or not, and it wouldn't really detract from the Fediverse if it weren't.

I mean, I see stuff from the most recent former president all the time, and he's on neither twitter nor the fediverse.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by crazygringo on Monday December 19, 2022 @07:35PM (#34059932)
I'm sorry, but just a million times no.

If Mastodon isn't "a messaging service that intends to connect people across the world", then I can't even imagine what it's supposed to be. Because that is exactly what it is.

And if it somehow hit a limit at 10 million total users, then it would be a complete failure. And to say that "it wouldn't really detract from the Fediverse" if you couldn't follow popular people because some limit were hit, you couldn't be more wrong. It would detract from it entirely and totally. It would defeat the entire purpose. And just because you don't want to follow popular people doesn't mean other people don't.

Precisely because the entire point of federation is that you're not stuck with separate forums, each on their own server, that don't talk to each other. The entire point is that they communicate in order to connect as many people across the world as users desire.

Again, how is this any different from if e-mail were capped at 10 million users total? Since you didn't answer the question.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by lapcat on Monday December 19, 2022 @11:26PM (#34061527)
I think you're missing the point of a social network.

Barack Obama is not social on Twitter. You can't talk to him. You can't have a conversation. Look at his Twitter feed: when's the last time he's replied to anyone? He issues mini press releases, that's all.

You can't email Barack Obama either, by the way. I mean, you can try, but good luck with that.

You talk about a messaging service, but it's entirely one-way messaging between famous people and non-famous people.

Mastodon users aren't looking to follow famous people and be passive recipients of press releases from famous people. They're looking to have conversations with each other. In this respect, Obama is irrelevant.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by crazygringo on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:25AM (#34066310)
You're missing the point that Obama was just an example, to use the most followed person on Twitter.

There are tons of people on Twitter with over 10 million followers who interact with Twitter a ton. They're very "social".

If a social network can't handle people who are popular, then that's a real problem. And remember, people's accounts can start unpopular, and then they gain millions of followers over years. So what do you do, boot them off for the sin of saying things lots of people want to listen to and interact with?

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by lapcat on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:39AM (#34066488)
> There are tons of people on Twitter with over 10 million followers who interact with Twitter a ton.

They certainly don't interact with 10 million people. That's impossible. They only interact with a tiny subset of their followers.

> If a social network can't handle people who are popular, then that's a real problem. And remember, people's accounts can start unpopular, and then they gain millions of followers over years.

I disagree. The most popular person I followed on Twitter had 300K followers and had been on Twitter since 2006. It's really not a big deal if there are no celebrities. The celebrities can post wherever else on the web they like. Don't need them. Let them continue on Twitter, whatever. Not a problem.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by crazygringo on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:20AM (#34068029)
You're completely missing the point, again.

This isn't about "celebrities" (a word I never used), it's about popular people all around, like authors, journalists, and so on.

And sure nobody is personally replying to all of their 10 million+ followers, but those 10 million+ followers do want to follow! And popular figures absolutely interact with and reply to tons of their followers quite frequently, that's the whole point.

Frankly, nobody cares if you "don't need" anybody popular. But to argue that a place like Mastodon should make it impossible for anybody to be popular, is ludicrous. If Mastodon wanted to stay tiny for people like you, separated into little popular-people-not-supported bubbles with a some hard max limit on followers, then why would it even have been built on federation in the first place...?

The idea that an author with only a few followers could have a best-selling book, and then at some point enthusiastic readers try to follow them only to get "error: max follow limit reached", would be a total and utter failure. A bug, not a feature.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by lapcat on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:46AM (#34068458)
> This isn't about "celebrities" (a word I never used), it's about popular people all around, like authors, journalists, and so on.

I don't want to quibble over terms. Celebrities, popular people, whatever you want to call them.

> And popular figures absolutely interact with and reply to tons of their followers quite frequently, that's the whole point.

And popular people have plenty of places where they can do that. But why does everyplace have to be amenable to people with 10+ million followers?

> But to argue that a place like Mastodon should make it impossible for anybody to be popular, is ludicrous.

That's a straw man. It's simply a question of whether it's technically/financially feasible to scale to that level. And there's no reason why it has to be. I don't see why it needs to be designed around the needs of super popular people.

> The idea that an author with only a few followers could have a best-selling book, and then at some point enthusiastic readers try to follow them

It's possible for a person to outgrow a place. That doesn't mean there was anything wrong with the original place. Popular people have different needs than non-popular people, but that doesn't mean we have to cater to popular people as a prime directive.

I find it ludicrous that every social space on the web would have to make itself accessible to celebrities (my word), as if it were a legal requirement like making it accessible to the disabled. Celebrities are not a protected class. ;-)

The sites that cater to celebrities are supported by advertising. They need all the eyeballs brought by celebrities. Mastodon does not have advertising. It doesn't have the same incentives. That's not a flaw, it's just a different set of choices and priorities.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by crazygringo on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:23PM (#34069967)
> And popular people have plenty of places where they can do that. But why does everyplace have to be amenable to people with 10+ million followers?

This is where you're wrong. Twitter is the only place they can do that right now, where the audience is for that type of content. And people are positioning Mastodon as a better alternative to Twitter. So Mastodon needs to be amenable to people with 10+ million followers. That's just logic. Otherwise, people wouldn't be actively encouraging Twitter users to switch to Mastodon the way they are.

If you want a product that won't support popular accounts then that's fine, but that's clearly something different from Mastodon and the Fediverse then. Really, that's just what regular forums are for, and always have been. But Mastodon is not a forum.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by lapcat on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:36PM (#34070196)
> Twitter is the only place they can do that right now, where the audience is for that type of content.

Facebook? Instagram?

> And people are positioning Mastodon as a better alternative to Twitter.

People are positioning Mastodon as an alternative to Twitter that is not and cannot be controlled by Elon Musk. He is the reason people are leaving. So the last thing that Mastodon needs is to be amenable to people like Elon Musk.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by pwinnski on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:12PM (#34071812)
Twitter gives people who want to micro-publish to many millions of people very easily a place to do that. Of course, since Twitter stopped providing simple reverse-chronological feeds, it's unclear how many people would actually ever see a given post in their timeline as it was posted, rather than quote-tweets or external links directly to the tweet web page, but point taken. It is possible--although by no means certain--that the fediverse is incapable of handling that particular use case.

You asked about email, I'll counter with actual message services. For reasons clear only to the people involved, I have contacts I can only reach via Signal, or via WhatsApp, or via Telegram, or via WeChat, or via Discord, or via Slack, and so on. How do I cope with this? I just do. Similarly, if I had to visit eight different web pages to track my favorite super-popular people, I just would. Or I'd do what I actually do, and follow almost none of them, instead letting people who are terminally online quote and link to the ones worth knowing about.

If ActivityPub filled up, and couldn't take on any more users, then I would first expect technical solutions like a sharp rise in relay servers, which combine the output of many servers into one outbox to be polled. After that, assuming there was some sort of hard limit that couldn't be overcome that way, I would expect that I would need to create a new account on some other ActivityPub-like network, or even a separate unfederated network also running ActivityPub. My chosen client (Mastonaut) can already support multiple ActivityPub accounts on different servers, so my experience would likely remain the same.

You initially suggested that the Fediverse can't scale. It's worth noting that Twitter itself fell apart long before it reached anything like today's mastodon numbers, and the "Fail Whale" was a constant companion in 2008, when Twitter had only one million users, 200k of which were active per week[0]. So already ActivityPub is scaling better across the network than Twitter itself once did all by itself. Maybe Mastodon (Ruby on Rails) will fade over time, replaced by something written in a more efficient language (like Twitter was). Maybe ActivityPub itself will be converted to use thrift or grpc or similar. Maybe ActivityPub can support 100 million users just fine. It seems to have handled going from 300K monthly active users to 2.5 million monthly active users without trouble[1].

The total Fediverse seems to have more than 8 million total users now. I guess we might find out.

0. https://techcrunch.com/2008/04/29/end-of-speculation-the-rea...

1. https://blog.joinmastodon.org/2022/12/twitter-suspends-masto...

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by kitsune_ on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:34PM (#34058743)
But people do pay for it and set up their own instances, or pool their resources and support larger instances - and maybe that's better than having our attention monetized by opaque algorithms 'for free'.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by nathias on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:45PM (#34058862)
why would they listen if you don't even differentiate between federated and peer to peer solutions? The costs could be made thrivial by sharing in a p2p network.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by yakak on Monday December 19, 2022 @06:31PM (#34059384)
Keybase and IPFS seem to show that a P2P fediverse scales, I don't understand why people are trying to make a fidonet/BBS style fediverse where 10s of thousands rely on one person' altruism instead of every peer caching some encrypted data and responding to some queries a few minutes or hours a day.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by colinsane on Monday December 19, 2022 @06:43PM (#34059496)
> I don't understand why people are trying to make a fidonet/BBS style fediverse where 10s of thousands rely on one person' altruism instead of every peer caching [...]

people are doing things like this too. you hear about Mastodon and ActivityPub because it's the easiest to setup, has the widest network, and works "well enough" for the userbase that's grown on it organically over the last decade.

if you're passionate about a particular experimental/p2p design, go seek it out. Secure Scuttlebutt might be up your alley.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by numpad0 on Monday December 19, 2022 @07:00PM (#34059643)
I don’t know how those protocols work but it seems a major problem is no one skillful enough is planning for a constant high-pressure streams of data. Devs always assume that posting is event based ordeal that happens in probability over time rather than as a constant flow.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by vohzd on Monday December 19, 2022 @07:50PM (#34060046)
When we talk about scale, are we really talking about bottlenecks?

What fascinates me, is that LetsEncrypt has 2 beefy servers and that's it.

Surely, a few million packets of highly compressible text over the pipe isn't that much of an issue? Is it? I've never done it so interested in hearing thoughts.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by TheHappyOddish on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:15AM (#34063919)
> If you're not willing to pay for the services you require... you're going to have a bad time.

Agree. I've been using Kagi for a few months now and have been pleasantly surprised I haven't had to revert back to Google once. I resisted for a long time, but Googles results have been going downhill for a whle, and I realised that if I want to use something, somebody has to pay for it, and that somebody should probably be me, the user.

"Unicorn" companies like social media live off investment dollars then usually ads. The former has dried up, only leaving the latter. I'd never pay $8 a month for Twitter, but I also don't care about it. I'd imagine many daily users would.

I've been a part of many communities where the owners have to beg for money for running costs monthly. It's always a struggle, and I don't see Mastodon being any different without compromising their principles.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by factormeta on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:33PM (#34069197)
We ought to distinguish between Mastodon not scaling with Fediverse doesn't scale. I mean Email seems to be working relatively fine. It seems to all comes down to implementation of the protocol.

While I love writing Ruby (what Mastodon seems to be mostly is build with) it's syntax and cleanliness, it always had an issue with scaling.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by kirbyfan64sos on Monday December 19, 2022 @12:59PM (#34055244)
It's because most of the servers are not nearly on the level of setup that a normal large-scale social network would probably need...which in turn is also because a lot of them have been run by hobbyists and the like, which in turn is also because no one ever needed to scale it this high before.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by ls15 on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:07PM (#34055354)
> What if 100 mil users want to move?

Some of the new users will have to run new servers.

For example if public officials are moving to Mastodon, I expect the state to run their own servers. It was never a good idea to allow Twitter to be a platform for (semi-)official communication.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by fleddr on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:55PM (#34058300)
Which will then need to federate to most other instances, causing an unmanagable load?
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by shapefrog on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:08PM (#34058424)
Is the problem of scale a) broadcasting the one person that millions of people want to see the tweets of or b) millions of people recieving the tweets of one person?
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by fleddr on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:23PM (#34058608)
If my understanding of ActivityPub is correct, it's B.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by ls15 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:08AM (#34063470)
They don't have to federate to everyone.

If the government does not want to put public communication into the hands of tech billionaires again, their second best option after using available software is to build a platform from scratch.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by phoe-krk on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:10PM (#34055403)
It's an error to treat the Fediverse as you would treat Twitter, where there is a singular platform in some way external to its users. Fediverse is a mesh network with single-user instances being feasible. If a single node has problems scaling, split it up. If a whole network has problems scaling, add more nodes. Fediverse is not yet at levels where the whole network is congested, either.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by georgyo on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:18PM (#34055521)
This is a nice thought, but reality is always different.

A really popular person might have many millions of followers on tens or hundreds of thousands of nodes.

That person then boosts a post from another server and they have effectively DDOSed that server. All the other nodes will start querying that server about that post or image.

You can say that a single user should not have that many followers, however the root of the issue is that mastodon will have some scaling issues.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by phoe-krk on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:27PM (#34055640)
Yes, and we're already seeing it e.g. with https://mas.to getting hugged to death because of pg joining it. If anything, it can be treated as a technological problem, solvable e.g. by (theorizing now) splitting a single instance over a series of machines, or a social problem, by (not theorizing anymore) a famous enough person hosting their own instance as already suggested several times on the Fediverse. The Fediverse will eventually establish a concrete way for handling that sort of matters.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by nerdawson on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:38PM (#34055808)
> The Fediverse will eventually establish a concrete way for handling that sort of matters.

They've had years to get this right. This is their moment to shine and they're blowing it.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by enumjorge on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:55PM (#34056046)
> a famous enough person hosting their own instance

So if the likes Obama or Stephen King want to move over to Mastodon their barrier of entry would be to complete this laundry list [1] or find a service that does this for them? Given that they own the instance, they would also need to provide moderation for it.

I don't disagree that there are solutions to the scale problem. What I have trouble seeing are solutions that are viable. That's the thing about a centralized service--you have a company that handles all of this so your users don't have to.

[1] https://docs.joinmastodon.org/user/run-your-own/#so-you-want...

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by rcarr on Monday December 19, 2022 @02:37PM (#34056587)
I do wonder if the next phase of social media is to encourage people to use a single user instance similar to mastodon.host. It would probably have to offer more than just twitter though e.g peertube, pixelfed etc. Start with a free tier, have it all running on auto scale and then notify people when they start getting popular that they need to scale up and start paying for their instance if they want to grow their audience. Don’t know if it would work or not but it’s an idea.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by georgyo on Monday December 19, 2022 @07:49PM (#34060038)
Most likely not, mostly due to lack of discovery.

When you start off an an empty instance, the only thing you see is yourself. There are no trends, there are no posts, and everywhere you click is just you.

You have to start following people for it start populating, but that requires knowing strings to follow. And then you can you see is stuff in your bubble (maybe a feature?).

But it really missing the dopamine response, as after you read the stuff people you follow posted or boosted; there is nothing.

A dedicated person can push through this initial period. But for mass appeal, people will quickly bounce if they feel like no one else is there.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by rsynnott on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:58PM (#34056091)
> or find a service that does this for them?

Assuming that Mastodon growth continues, such services will probably emerge (there are already a couple of Mastodon hosting services, but there's probably a market for a "so you're a celebrity who wants a single-user Mastodon instance" service which has yet to be filled).

> Given that they own the instance, they would also need to provide moderation for it.

If it was a single-user instance, that would be fairly trivial :)

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by zimpenfish on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:51PM (#34055992)
> That person then boosts a post from another server and they have effectively DDOSed that server. All the other nodes will start querying that server about that post or image.

But that's fixable in several ways - local media cache for an instance, the boost including the preview rather than each client fetching it for themselves, etc.

The problem* with ActivityPub is that it's been designed and developed in a bit of user vacuum and it definitely has issues but they can all be worked on. Much like Twitter going from Rails to Scala, etc., to fix their issues.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by georgyo on Monday December 19, 2022 @02:41PM (#34056636)
There is already a local media cache. My comment doesn't suggest that each follower requests stuff from the home server, but each instance.

The instances cache pretty aggressively, but you still have a thundering herd when a popular person boosts a message.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by zimpenfish on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:06PM (#34056918)
> There is already a local media cache.

I suppose I should have been clearer - apologies. I was talking about a cache for previews (which would presumably be folded into the local media cache since it's already there.)

> you still have a thundering herd when a popular person boosts a message

Not if the boost includes the preview - that -should- cut it down significantly (and indeed it has been proposed but is still being bikeshedded by the Mastodon devs because "what if someone sends a fake preview?!?!?!?!")

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by madrox on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:25PM (#34058625)
Yes, this is a real thing that will happen. However, this is no different than a popular website like, say, HN, linking to someone's hack project and giving it the hug of death. This stuff happens, and if any operational element boils down to someone's hobby then you'll see some issues. That doesn't mean Mastodon is inherently flawed any more than web pages being inherently flawed.

What will happen is the same thing that happened to web servers and email servers. Businesses will pop up to run your instance for you.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by this_user on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:18PM (#34055527)
And who is supposed to do all of that? Without a central organisation doing resource planning, scaling, and paying for all of that, this is never going to run smoothly. 99.99% of users have no interest in running their own instance. Even groups or organisation will eventually get to the point where running and scaling their instance becomes a full-time job. But without any way of monetising that work, or finding sponsors, there is not much incentive to do that.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by phoe-krk on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:28PM (#34055653)
Donating to server admins seems to work for the instances whose growth I'm in/directly observing. And then, running an instance with a few hundred users is not a resource hog.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by qznc on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:06PM (#34056914)
If we take the 99.99% as a hard fact that means 1 admin for 10,000 users. Sounds reasonable. Especially, if we consider that most of those will never even post anything according to Twitter behavior.

With respect to monetisation, I hope the fediverse will provide a live sandbox to try all kinds of experiments at eye level: Free, ad-supported, fees, one-time fees, pay-per-toot, pay-per-followed-instance, whatever. Multiply by private, non-profit, and for-profit approaches.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by viraptor on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:16PM (#34057058)
I think many people are too used to the centralised model and having one org responsible to blame for issues.

You know how we use websites right now? Who's responsible for planning, scaling, and paying for all of that? Users have no interest in running their own "website instance". Right?

And we're already at the point where for big groups running your own requires multiple full time jobs.

Even if things don't work smoothly, it's fine. Most breakage is instance local and temporary. I've been on Twitter with a weekly failwhale and it's been fine too.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by hejaodbsidndbd on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:15PM (#34055471)
This makes the network congestion exponentially worse. It’s not scalable.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by phoe-krk on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:30PM (#34055681)
Email mailing groups figured out a way of scaling despite the same sort of exponential congestion. If anything, Fediverse traffic between larger clusters may eventually ossify around some larger pipes, not unlike the Internet traffic being handled by backbone operators.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by jancsika on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:14PM (#34055456)
Have you submitted a bug report? :)
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by jshen on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:30PM (#34055682)
Twitter didn’t scale for many years. Remember the fail whale?
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by mempko on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:48PM (#34055933)
Really? Email scaled. Internet scaled. Decentralization is scalable.

Why doesn't anyone remember how shitty Twitter was when it was growing. Slow and constantly breaking.

Mastodon is working fine even after millions moved to it. Yes, Admins had to scale up, but they did it.

I like that I pay my admin. No ads. No bullshit.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by rvz on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:19PM (#34058559)
> Really? Email scaled. Internet scaled. Decentralization is scalable.

I don’t see any normal person self-hosting their own email service. Even if they did, good luck with handling spam. It can only viably scale to hundreds of millions with centralization; hence Gmail, Outlook, etc to reduce / limit the spam issue.

Mastodon has the same mistakes as the other federated alternatives and has already proven to be unable to scale more efficiently than Twitter, let alone the ridiculous hurdles to begin using it.

We are talking about scaling to hundreds of millions, not ten thousand or a shy hundred thousand and it falls over on a single moderator’s instance.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by radley on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:53PM (#34058955)
> I don’t see any normal person self-hosting their own email service.

But email didn't fail as a result. Just as you said, email services popped up.

Just give it a little time.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by rvz on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:26PM (#34070020)
> But email didn't fail as a result. Just as you said, email services popped up.

With centralization; hence the spyware, bans and spam prevention which only benefits the big centralized email services like Gmail, Outlook, etc.

Email was meant to be used as a decentralized protocol such that one can operate their own email service; but despite many here claiming to run their own, they gave up and many still won't. Even sending an email to a Gmail and Outlook addresses will just fail their spam filter test.

So it has been a failure for email without centralizated providers.

> Just give it a little time.

A 6 year federated experiment is not early days to see that a worse version of Twitter has already failed.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by numpad0 on Monday December 19, 2022 @06:00PM (#34059034)
My primary email addresses are @gmail.com.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by postalrat on Monday December 19, 2022 @09:19PM (#34060732)
Thats your mistake. You can use gmail with your own domain.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by guerrilla on Monday December 19, 2022 @02:44PM (#34056676)
New instances will be (are being) created. Supply will fill demand.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by rglullis on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:53PM (#34058282)
> What if 100 mil users want to move?

Then supply and demand will dictate that people will start paying for accounts, and that will be a good thing.

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by radley on Monday December 19, 2022 @06:01PM (#34059056)
This is like saying email can't scale. Of course Mastodon can scale, especially for those businesses willing to do it as a service. It's an entirely new, legitimate territory.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by sangnoir on Monday December 19, 2022 @09:29PM (#34060795)
> What if 100 mil users want to move?

Tumblr will be happy to host them! Matt[1] from Automattic has stated that Tumblr will be joining the Fediverse soon.

1. https://twitter.com/photomatt/status/1594577983028740096

Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by wfaler on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:26AM (#34063992)
A couple of things: * It's mostly hobbyists running their instances, some literally in their basement. * Most scaling glitches have usually been addressed within a few days. The comparison to early-day Twitter is fair, maybe people have literally not expected such a fast scaling route. * I don't think anyone in their wildest fever-dreams expected Elon Musk to burn down Twitter this fast, thus causing a mass-migration.
Re:Server stats say movetodon.org reached a new record of 49... by vlugorilla on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:01AM (#34065256)
This is why Nostr is the way