While I fully agree with you, how do you sync passwords across my 3 laptops and 3 phones without a SaaS offering?
While I don't use this feature, but it is common for ppl to share an account. How can I securely share credentials with family members?
Anything more important than a Netflix account you don't share at all. If they need access, just call them.
Small startups use password sharing tools to share passwords with new employees (think db passwords or other saas accounts). This happens at least a once per month in a 10 person organization.
Maybe the answer is, you can't. Write them down, text each other, call each other and read it over the phone.
Making a spare key for my parents to get in my house isn't "click a button easy," I have to go to the hardware store -- and maybe THAT'S the appropriate level of difficulty.
Again, what many of us are saying is third party password managers are always a bad idea for fundamental reasons. Before, it was just the account owners and the site. Now there's a third party that has some kind of access, and that third party is a juicy target.
Under what guarantee then? Why believe they are safe, especially since time has shown that many are not.
It's dumb, and I will continue to maintain that it's dumb right up until one of these companies offers indemnifcation or some other serious grown-up guarantee.
I will pay for your service if and only if you pay me if/when you mess up.
if you are tech savvy, like to keep up to date on security and are ok with the hassle of setting up a NAS, sync stuff and know how to keep it secure, perhaps. If you had to pay me to do it for you, a few dollars service fee might be much cheaper...
Syncthing. Set up once, runs reliably forever.
> How can I securely share credentials with family members?
I don't do this either (and don't know anyone who does) but I imagine it'd be easy to just create a different shared database for the family for that? With password store, it's also possible to set multiple different gpg keys for a specific directory. I don't think the last option is doable for most people though.
> it's also possible to set multiple different gpg keys for a specific directory. I don't think the last option is doable for most people though.
this seems really complex...
> this seems really complex...
Like I said, it's probably not a solution for many. A second database with shared secret is very straightforward and transparent way that anyone can grasp I think. It would definitely pass the family test for me.
keepassxc + syncthing this is the way
android: keepassdx off f-droid + syncthing
With 1Password 7 I did this with their built-in local syncing feature. I don’t want my passwords in the cloud. I’m happy to manually sync them once a month (or probably less these days). But they removed it in version 8 and forced users into a subscription so I’m not upgrading. Eventually I’ll move to something else, but it’s still working for now.
The only things worth paying for as a subscription are things that require continued human working, or at least a human on-call, period.
In my experience, everything else that's worth it ought to be able to survive on donations (either of labor or money).
A large chunk of the world lives in the cloud, whether its Azure or AWS, there is an enormous amount of infrastructure that is sitting in the cloud as a service.
For many a SaaS password manager is better security for them than what they're doing now by remembering all of their simple passwords. Many people don't know how to use Yubikey's and the sort.
And yes personally I avoid purchasing them (see post title) but it's just another thing to filter out. Especially since sometimes apps actually have useful/novel cloud integrations and other times they just want the subscription money from making you put it in their choice of cloud.
On the Mac at least, some of the alternatives to Adobe are better for the vast majority of users and aren't on a subscription model.
For example, Affinity has a universal license for $99 where you own Publisher, Designer and Photo for macOS, Windows and iPadOS. This is like being able to buy Photoshop, Illustrator and InDesign from Adobe without a subscription [1]:
Experience the full power of Version 2 of Affinity apps with the
Universal License. For just one discounted payment, you can get the
ENTIRE Affinity suite (including Publisher for iPad!) on all your
devices, across macOS, Windows and iPadOS.
If you only need one app and not the entire suite, you can do that.Acorn [2] is a great image editor for macOS that takes much better advantage of the Mac platform than anything Adobe has recently put out. Unlike Adobe, this indie developer doesn't have to make a UI/UX experience that both works on macOS and Windows. It can do much of what other image editors can do, in addition to being programable with AppleScript or JavaScript. The UI is much easier to use than most other mid to high level image editors.
I've been a customer for years because the support is great and the upgrades have always been reasonably priced. A license for Acorn is $40.
OmniGroup provides the best of both worlds with all of its macOS, iOS and iPadOS software: you can purchase a license, pay a monthly subscription or add a web subscription [3].
[1]: https://affinity.serif.com/en-us/
For instance, I see no reason why a password manager should be a SaaS. I don't care how long these companies have been around thusfar; in my opinion, using a password manager as-a-service is asking for trouble and is a waste of money. The closer you approach "perfect" security, the more of your personal security you end up handing off to someone else for their profit. Having a handful of sufficiently complex yet memorable passwords and something like Authenticator or Yubikey might be an appropriate compromise.
Image editor? There's Kirta, GIMP, and Inkscape. No, they're not as good as Adobe software, but maybe that's less important to you than not paying Adobe.
Maybe just using Apple Notes can be good enough for you, if you can get used to it. No subscription necessary. Back it up on occasion. There are of course other note taking apps that aren't SaaS.
Too many streaming services? Consider watching less in general. The less you live vicariously through fictional characters, the less those fictional worlds will matter to you. Spend that extra time learning a skill or spending non-screen time with others. Not watching television only seems abnormal in the context of the last half century.
Tired of "live service" games? There's a million older games that you buy once, probably for way cheaper, and don't have a ton of bugs. Nothing is wrong with older games.
Subscriptions are mostly a problem for those with FOMO. Don't care so much about living in the now. Create some distance between you and the technological machine while still being able to interact with it when you think it's sensible. The only way that companies will back off from everything being a subscription is if enough people who don't appreciate it actually take action in their own lives.