News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by Kiro on Saturday December 17, 2022 @11:33AM (#34029271)
Is Valve the only company in the world that is not universally hated by the HN and reddit crowd?
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by ROTMetro on Saturday December 17, 2022 @11:43AM (#34029415)
No universal but I'm very much anti valve as they are among the few who continue to do business in Russia.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by vlunkr on Saturday December 17, 2022 @12:27PM (#34029935)
What would be the point in cutting regular Russian citizens off from video games? It may actually be a good way to communicate with them.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by ROTMetro on Saturday December 17, 2022 @01:38PM (#34030739)
Video games are the modern 'circus' in 'bread and circuses' it provides an opiate for that masses to escape from confronting their current situation and gives the government an escape valve for young male angst. As to communication, have you seen Russianss on the Steam forums? It's all Zs, Russian flags, and ethnic slurs against Ukrainians.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by vlunkr on Saturday December 17, 2022 @01:52PM (#34030881)
I can see that, but it's a complex situation and I have counterpoints.

- Young male angst has no shortage of outlets. Sports, both extreme and normal, tons of existing media, pirated media, blowing stuff up, etc. Taking away Steam accounts likely isn't going to turn them into revolutionaries.

- In response the existing comments from Russians, that could be selection bias. Many of them could be commenting normally or not at all. After all, most of what you read on the internet is written by insane people.

- Part of the problem in Russia is extreme media bias/propaganda. Further isolating them from foreign contact and influences can only make that worse and reinforce the narrative that everyone else is out to get them.

Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by ROTMetro on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:16PM (#34032326)
So, the users of Steam and what they post on their public pages, is selection bias when judging the usefulness of communicating with... the users of Steam?
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by npteljes on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:21PM (#34032904)
Yes, selection bias. Loud people are easy to spot. Lurkers are hard to spot. A loud minority, therefore, can create the illusion of a larger mass of similar folk. Take, for example, the gamergate situation. There was just SO much toxic communication, it was a complete shitstorm, where many were attacked online in a horrible manner. So, gamers sure are a toxic bunch, right? Well, turns out, there are 1.5 billion gamers on PC alone. I'm sure 95% percent of them never even heard about such a thing as gamergate.

https://gamerant.com/3-billion-gamers-report/

Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by omnimus on Sunday December 18, 2022 @05:30AM (#34036433)
Also dont forget its not best idea to be publically against russia when you are living in it.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by ROTMetro on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:16PM (#34074912)
So what positive discussion comes of the people that aren't involved in discussions on Steam? None, it's still just a circus for Lurkers. If the reason to keep it open to Russia is communication, that is ONLY happening for those that are visible, not for the lurkers.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by npteljes on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:55AM (#34078638)
Communication is not just the forums, I literally meant everything offered by Steam as part of the communication. The selection of games, the content and presentation of the games, the fact that people play together and communicate in game, either explicitly by voice or text, or indirectly by gameplay. It's all a communication not just of words, concepts, but the ways of living, the ways of relating to the everydays and the world. And that's very useful in not leaving people alone in their bubble, it broadens their perspective, makes them more open to new ideas, tolerate more strange things. How do we know that this works? It's everything that an oppressive regime (and abusive people) works against. Their goal is to isolate, so that they can control the narrative, so that they can solidify their power. So, to weaken their hold over people, you need ways in. Culture, like movies, music, novels, internet content. And like Steam.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by LarryMullins on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:20PM (#34032357)
Keeping Russian teens in a sedentary lifestyle with video games is good for Ukraine. It weakens the Russian military. If anything, they should be giving free games to young Russians. Give them lots of pornography, liquor and drugs as well. These things weaken nations.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by zqf11 on Saturday December 17, 2022 @07:41PM (#34033857)
>they should be giving free games to young Russians. Give them lots of pornography, liquor and drugs as well. These things weaken nations.

Wow man cool it with the antisemitic remarks.

Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by npteljes on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:16PM (#34032853)
I'm sure you can spot the nationalists, of which there are many. But how do you differentiate them from the normal folk, who just use a non-descriptive nickname and just play the game? Zooming out a bit, in the group of "gamers" as in people who participate in gaming related discussions, you can find many toxic comments, sentiments and people, of which the ethnic slurs, Zs and everything doesn't even stand out.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by curiousgal on Saturday December 17, 2022 @11:52AM (#34029525)
If Russia is where you draw the line boy do I have news for you! If your standards were universal, you wouldn't be doing business with any company at all.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by npteljes on Saturday December 17, 2022 @12:25PM (#34029911)
Especially with entertainment, I haven't understood the anti-Putin sentiment. Is it really in the West's interest to stop exporting soft power there? Sanctions make sense to me, but this particular industry we should make an exception for, I'd say. Authoritarian regimes try to isolate their populace anyways, it'd be a shame to co-opt that.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by ROTMetro on Saturday December 17, 2022 @01:41PM (#34030766)
Yes, let's ensure we continue to give young Russian males an outlet to escape from thinking about the current realities in their country. Steam is providing the modern circus in 'bread and circuses'. If anything, this is the exact soft power we should leverage to highlight to those your angst filled males that their current reality is isolating them. Or, we could just give an opium of the masses to keep them indifferent to reality in their rooms because 'soft power'.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by npteljes on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:13PM (#34032825)
You can be sure that if we don't give them outlets, China will. Do you think nobody would fill the vacuum? If they'd ban every media import, that'd just be an opportunity for the regime to further solidify their own goals. For examples, look at what happened when McDonalds, Coca Cola left the country - they have the same shit, but now without the influence.

Whatever there is, there will be abuses of it, so yeah, many would just use the "opium" part of Steam. But there's another aspect of it that would still get imported, and that's any of the narratives that differ from the propaganda they are subjected to. With Steam specifically, they'd be exposed to titles like This War of Mine, and international communities where they'd experience that nobody gives a fuck about them being Russian, or even find it cool, despite the prevalent anti-Western propaganda in their own media.

And that all, I think, is worth more than sanctioning it.

Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by npteljes on Saturday December 17, 2022 @07:14PM (#34033690)
>Steam is providing the modern circus in 'bread and circuses'

Also, you know what really provides bread and circuses? Populist bullshit such as "Putin banning LGBT propaganda". Nothing better to take the minds off of pressing issues like further harming a marginalized group.

https://news.yahoo.com/vladimir-putin-bans-lgbt-propaganda-1...

Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by rsj_hn on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:52PM (#34033101)
As a whole, Russian nationalists were popping champagne corks when Western media and other influence operations left Russia. It was basically everything they wanted. Given to them for free. By their enemies. Everything that cuts a dependency also cuts an influence vector and increases sovereignty.

The world is moving to regional blocks -- a Western block of North America and Europe, a Eurasian block of Russia/India/Iran/Middle-East/China, and the loyalties of Africa/Latin America are where the wars for influence will be fought, with Africa tilting toward Eurasia and Latin America tilting toward the West. Other battle grounds would be marginal areas like Southeast Asia/Pacific Islands and in Europe the balkans. In that context, it makes no sense for the Eurasian block to allow a business to operate domestically from an enemy block. Why on earth would you let them influence your population? For the same reason, Eurasian influence operations are being banned in the West, from Confucian Institutes to Sputnik News.

The main entrypoints to a block will be those nations that have sufficiently rigid control over their domestic populations to feel free with enemy dependencies -- that would be the US and China, both with impressive soft power and sophisticated information control regimes. That is why US made films that are shown in China often have to have different scenes in them - sometimes shot with different endings -- and there are strict limits. China has their own system of deboosting content and their own troll farms. Same for any kind of internet presence and also video games and other media. Likewise, the US has a sophisticated system of banning and other soft "deboosting" of views that run counter to official regime narratives. There is a whole industry to identify counter-narrative views and brand them as "misinformation" that must be rooted out. Russia has a much less sophisticated information space defense system for this, and much less soft power, so for them outright bans and blocks are the only viable option, and this was given to them by the West on a platter. Amazing self-own.

Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by ROTMetro on Saturday December 17, 2022 @01:35PM (#34030715)
As a hippie that lives in the Rocky mountains, why do you assume I do business with large corporations? And I definitely feel let down by Steam's take to continue to provide entertainment for the masses so that they don't have to contemplate what their country is doing. They are the circus in bread and circuses. But yes you are right, I should just be paralyzed from basing my opinion of any company because 'other companies, other countries'. What a productive take that would be.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by ROTMetro on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:37PM (#34032503)
I just need to point out these 'it's pointless to do anything' people are wrong. My small mountain town's 1Gb fiber ISP is local. Our power company is a co-op. The gas station I use is a co-op. My limited meat consumption comes from an organic Mennonite family farm. Summer months my produce comes from a local CSA and I'm lucky to have a great local flower CSA as well. You can actually live in the modern world in comfort AND choose how you live, even in the USA.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by roflyear on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:00PM (#34032691)
Where do they get their gas?
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by civopsec on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:19PM (#34032885)
Local co-ops are the opiates of the hippie masses. It keeps them plump and happy in their little faux communes and away from the fight against corporations, state and federal government. As someone who lives 5000 “miles” away I feel really strongly about judging these hillbillies/rockabillies that I’ve never met and I for some reason feel that they should be inconvenienced so that they can take up the fight against their government, which after all is the biggest imperial power on the planet.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by kilolima on Saturday December 17, 2022 @02:15PM (#34031112)
The best pirated game scenes are Russian, Valve exiting the market world mean very little. It's also a huge benefit to the rest of the world that Russian/ex Soviet culture has both very little respect for Western intellectual property laws and the technological abilities to make software and digital media easily available.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by jeff_carr on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:34PM (#34031955)
Punishing people living under totalitarian rule might not be a good idea.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by jimbob45 on Saturday December 17, 2022 @11:52AM (#34029532)
JetBrains maybe?
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by pxc on Saturday December 17, 2022 @12:38PM (#34030073)
also probably Tailscale
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by stusmall on Saturday December 17, 2022 @01:23PM (#34030590)
Every now and then I see some brain-dead hand-wringing about them being an agent of the Russian state. I saw a lot soon after the war started. The other time I saw a lot was right after that hack that involved TeamCity.

HN and Reddit aren't hive minds and both hold a lot of diverse opinions. Nothing is universally loved on either. Today's society can longer agree on agree on fundamentals like if the earth is round or if democracy is good. So it isn't a huge surprise that not everyone has accepted The Infallible Glory that is the Jetbrains product roster (A little joking in that last bit.... but just a little. All praise CLion)

Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by sgjohnson on Saturday December 17, 2022 @12:16PM (#34029793)
Cloudflare?
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by ParetoOptimal on Saturday December 17, 2022 @12:46PM (#34030172)
I personally dislike cloudflare for not dropping KF, not sure if that's a majority opinion.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by smoldesu on Saturday December 17, 2022 @12:58PM (#34030319)
Yeah, even though I'd agree that KF is detestable, the way Cloudflare cracked under pressure was a public embarrassment. It's hard to give them the benefit of the doubt these days.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by heywhatupboys on Saturday December 17, 2022 @01:17PM (#34030525)
> Yeah, even though I'd agree that KF is detestable

I am very curious about this tbh. Has anyone here gone to that site? I read that they just report publicly available info that people have voluenteered online. While I understand that doxxing is terrible and so is targeted harassment, are they that much worse than the daily mail or any other gossip magazine?

Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by ever1337 on Saturday December 17, 2022 @01:46PM (#34030827)
the difference between KF and a tabloid is that KF members go out of their way to interfere in their targets' lives
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by smoldesu on Saturday December 17, 2022 @02:00PM (#34030946)
The larger difference is that KiwiFarms members don't get paid for their work. That being said, you can be disgusted by something while still accepting it as a valid form of self-expression. Real-life crimes deserve prosecution to the fullest extent of the law, but people being mean online is a shitty justification for deciding to void an entire website. It's entirely Cloudflare's choice to make, but it's value as a virtue signal is vastly outweighed by how many CF customers are wringing their hands now.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by ThrowawayTestr on Saturday December 17, 2022 @02:56PM (#34031546)
Anyone that brags about harrassing people gets banned immediately.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by HereIGoAgain on Saturday December 24, 2022 @01:03AM (#34114436)
No, they actually don't. That is against the rules to even talk about. You're thinking about /b/ or something from back in the day, or the people attacking the site.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by Faark on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:10PM (#34032796)
Not an expert, only checked a few threads shortly before its very end. From what i can tell...

- gossip magazines usually target "public figures". many jurisdictions have relaxed privacy rules around those. KF targeted whom they found... "interesting"

- haven't really read gossip magazines, but i assume they have a higher bar. for example, did any of those print the hunter biden dick pics requested to be deleted in the "twitter files"? cause you could be sure of them to have been on KF, if they had thread on him

- "publicly available info" is stretching it quite a bit. In the case of @elonjet, we that is info required by law/court to be public. KF, on the other side, is more like "stuff that was ever published somewhere" (as opposed to getting new stuff), so again your nudes are fair game for them, no matter any distribution rights

Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by jl6 on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:00PM (#34031597)
It’s the difference between awful and systemically-awful.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by ParetoOptimal on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:18AM (#34035473)
Funnily enough, it sounds like we have opposite opinions.

I'm glad they "cracked" and wish they'd initially dropped KF.

Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by sgjohnson on Saturday December 17, 2022 @08:19PM (#34034111)
I dislike them for dropping them a week after saying that they won't drop websites that are simply detestable.

Personally I don't care, they are free to have whatever policy they want, but doing exactly what they did one week after writing up a blog post and explicitly stating that they most likely won't drop any websites like that anymore was a bit disappointing.

Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by jeff_carr on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:32PM (#34031936)
+1 for Cloudflare
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by Semaphor on Saturday December 17, 2022 @12:45PM (#34030147)
Another company is Fastmail. Usually loved on HN, not really talked about on Reddit (at least where I see it)
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by christophilus on Saturday December 17, 2022 @02:04PM (#34030995)
There are many. Mozilla isn’t universally hated. Apple is another.

I’d say Valve comes close to being universally loved here, though, and that is pretty unique.

Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by zach_garwood on Saturday December 17, 2022 @02:44PM (#34031418)
Apple is a weird one from my perspective. I dislike Safari, but overall I'm pretty ambivalent about Apple in general. But most devs I've met IRL seem to despise them, while HN seems to mostly have a positive view.
Re:Valve Is Paying Open-Source Developers to Work on Proton,... by yurishimo on Sunday December 18, 2022 @08:00AM (#34037292)
Most devs don't develop on/for Apple platforms. HN has a huge amount of SV developers though and FAANG which lean Apple anyway. If you work at Google, you need to make sure your products work on Apple devices, so you probably use a Mac since the dev environment is locked to the platform.

If you work for a shop in Omaha Nebraska making software for surrounding businesses, you probably use Windows.