News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by donatj on Thursday December 08, 2022 @03:41PM (#33913056)
I have been surprised Waze has stuck around as long as it has. I stopped using it a number of years ago, but my wife still uses it.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by fancyfish on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:10PM (#33913462)
I have used Waze regularly since 2014, and my perception is that it plans more aggressive routes (trickier turns, using side streets, etc) to shave off a few more minutes than Maps, whereas Maps will stick to the major, less complicated routes. But I haven't used Maps for routing lately, so I wouldn't be surprised if Waze/Maps are more similar than I realize.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by gav on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:39PM (#33913877)
I stopped using Waze (I live in Los Angeles) because it would give a slightly faster route with unprotected left turns that was riskier, more stressful, and ultimately not much faster in reality.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by three_seagrass on Thursday December 08, 2022 @05:32PM (#33914678)
>riskier, more stressful, and ultimately not much faster in reality

I used to think the same until we A/B tested it a few times (Maps/Waze) with different cars going to the same destination.

Waze really was faster very time.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by nottorp on Thursday December 08, 2022 @06:18PM (#33915157)
Yep, I use Waze to run around my city at peak traffic because its traffic info is somehow better and it manages to pick a fast ish route every time.

From personal experience, i've regretted ignoring waze because "i live here and know better" every time at rush hour.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by jonny_eh on Thursday December 08, 2022 @05:49PM (#33914874)
I wonder why can't Google Maps use the same routing, even as an option?
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by xyzelement on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:52PM (#33917217)
I had wondered about that before. My guess is that Google considers Waze and Maps users to be different type of "navigators", with Waze being a self-selecting group of folks who want crazy routes to shave a few seconds here and there, while the Maps users are more mainstream and just want a sensible route with options. So they may have hesitated to give the "crazy" option to them.

Another thing, I suspect there's a significant resource cost in constantly re-evaluating these few-second saving opportunities that may not scale well to the size of Map's user base. Could be wrong here.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by sgloutnikov on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:53AM (#33919537)
I am exactly one of those users which you describe and only use Waze for long trips and Maps for the rest. Waze urban navigation drives me crazy with the route it picks sometimes, hoping of shaving off a few seconds.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by Gigachad on Thursday December 08, 2022 @06:17PM (#33915140)
Because city planners would start blocking off side streets if a huge product like google maps was directing people through them.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by WirelessGigabit on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:59PM (#33914224)
Friend of mine lives in South Pasadena. He mentions that since Waze he has a lot more traffic on the road behind his house, just people cutting through to save 30 seconds!
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by carom on Thursday December 08, 2022 @06:52PM (#33915519)
Oh no! The public using a public road!
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by ganbatekudasai on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:54PM (#33917232)
You're right, but I don't think there's any reason for the sarcasm. People are allowed to personally lament actions of others, while fully realizing and even supporting that they are legal. And even hope for circumstances changing, like I'm fully allowed to complain about the rain and wish for sunshine, without someone putting me down with "Oh no! A functioning ecosystem doing its job!".

People would even be allowed to try to effect change. In this case, it would mean weighing saving a likely insignificant amount of time for a subset of people, against residents of the street dealing with constant traffic. What is "fair" depends on the exact circumstances, but taken at face value, I suspect if one were to effect regulation such that speed bumps are added, or through traffic prohibited, or the path being made less convenient, then almost none of the insignificant-time-savers would even notice much. They'd take the new suggested route and be likely just as happy.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by carom on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:11AM (#33918511)
There are a lot of roads in LA that are gated or just dead end. [1,2,3] They drive me insane. It effectively makes a gated community and I doubt the property tax revenue covers the tax dollars that go into these neighborhoods. Roads are a public good and they should be usable by the public. I am fine with the alternative where we privatize them and let the cost of ownership and maintenance fall on the residents, once they're footing the entire bill they can choose who drives on the roads.

The sarcasm will continue until the NIMBYs improve.

1. https://www.google.com/maps/@34.0473537,-118.3282794,78m/dat...

2. https://www.google.com/maps/@34.0448801,-118.3296309,60m/dat...

3. https://www.google.com/maps/@34.0593371,-118.3293991,73m/dat...

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by ganbatekudasai on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @01:56PM (#33973918)
That is a significantly different issue from slowing a residential road down.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by whyenot on Thursday December 08, 2022 @11:55PM (#33917609)
I appreciate your substantive comment.

Many public residential streets are not designed for heavy traffic use. I don't think it's unreasonable for local residents to be upset by the noise and congestion of people taking a shortcut off the highway to cut 30 seconds off their travel time.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by gorgoiler on Thursday December 08, 2022 @11:18PM (#33917375)
It’s antisocial for someone driving across town to use a road that’s sized for local traffic only. If you’re doing a journey shared by thousands of others you should use the 10^3 capacity road, not the 10^1 capacity road.

The place where I work has a fridge full of beers. Every so often I see someone stick a couple in their bag, on their way home. Oh no! An employee taking beers intended for employees to consume!, right?

I blame the parents.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by shapefrog on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:37AM (#33919433)
The place where I work has rolls of toilet paper in the shitter. Every so often I see someone stick a couple in their bag, on their way home ...

I blame the parents.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by mschuster91 on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:42AM (#33919875)
> An employee taking beers intended for employees to consume!, right?

In Germany, that is culturally accepted. It even has, as always in German, its own name: "Wegbier" or the pun version "Fuß-Pils" (a play on "athlete's foot").

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by mschuster91 on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:40AM (#33919864)
"City and traffic planning" is a thing. You see, roads that were planned for the vehicle traffic of a neighborhood (=here in Germany, like one car a minute tops or lower) are usually built to lower standards than a road that is planned as a transit route.

The asphalt layers are thinner, ground support is spec'd for low and moderate traffic... that means that should such a road be subject to unplanned amounts of traffic, the roads will degrade way faster, particularly if heavy goods traffic comes into play.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by caconym_ on Friday December 09, 2022 @12:47AM (#33917983)
Did you know that once upon a time there was no such thing as a speed limit?

Do you think we should return to those good old days? Or is there perhaps an argument to be made that new technologies can lead to suboptimal outcomes when operated within the bounds of regulations that didn't (and couldn't reasonably have been expected to) anticipate their development?

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by crftr on Thursday December 08, 2022 @06:22PM (#33915206)
In L.A., I'll keep Waze open for the speed trap reports but I'll ignore the turn-by-turn directions.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by asdff on Thursday December 08, 2022 @06:34PM (#33915334)
I'm surprised you've seen a speed trap at all in LA county to be honest
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by tcoff91 on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:35PM (#33917118)
Given the amount of drunk drivers i see on the road in LA now i don’t know if they enforce that, let alone the speed limit.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by ryantgtg on Friday December 09, 2022 @12:34AM (#33917894)
They do not seem to. Not for speeding, distracted driving, drunk driving, etc. There’s basically no traffic enforcement here. When was the last time you’ve seen a driver pulled over on a surface street? I think I’ve seen one in the last 10 years.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by acheron on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:34PM (#33913789)
I use Waze but that part of it actually bugs me, because it's hard to tell if it's telling me to go on some side route for a real reason (avoiding a big accident) or just because it's guessing it will be 90 seconds faster.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by whymauri on Thursday December 08, 2022 @05:26PM (#33914607)
Interesting. In Colombia Waze prefers safer roads and highways, whereas Google Maps has sent me down incredibly dangerous mountain paths.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by suzzer99 on Thursday December 08, 2022 @07:11PM (#33915686)
Can confirm. Google maps was more than happy to send me down this "road" in Baja. http://ushuaiaorbust.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IMG_7956...
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by rurp on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:20PM (#33916168)
Google Maps is surprisingly bad at handling dirt roads around my area. It has happily directed me down many awful roads and a couple times through open land without any visible road at all. The estimated travel times can be pretty funny too, like estimating 5 miles down an abysmal dirt road should only take 7 minutes.

I know these sorts of scenarios aren't a priority for them, but I'm surprised they don't even have a roughly accurate estimate given how much location tracking info they collect. If 40 people this year have driven a stretch of road with a range of travel times from 25-40 minutes, an estimate of 7 minutes seems pretty obviously wrong and easy to catch.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by ekidd on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:41PM (#33917150)
I've seen Google Maps try to direct people down "roads" that would cause problems on a horse. And some of these errors have persisted for years, despite many reports to Google.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by AaronM on Friday December 09, 2022 @10:00AM (#33921890)
We have this problem in VT. There is a road here called the notch, which is too narrow for a semi truck to pass, and there is no way to turn around once you get stuck in it. This means that if you drive into it, you have to call someone to help you back down the mountain, and you get a big fine.

This results in 5-10 semis getting stuck every year. There is nothing that google is willing to do to help the state out. The state has put up signage telling drivers their GPS is wrong, and they ignore it.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by jsdwarf on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:41AM (#33919870)
In Northern Austria you find a lot of "no gps" signs at the start of agricultural roads. Seems that many lorry drivers rely on google maps for navigation and those small roads are ill-suited for their vehicles, e.g. due to weight limits or sharp turns.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by ilyt on Thursday December 08, 2022 @11:32PM (#33917464)
When I bought my first (used)car and was driving it back it told me to go some farmer's backyard...
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by thesimp on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:58AM (#33919189)
While not on the same level of dangerousness Google Maps will also route me through a nature reserve, with no street lights, cattle grids and no snow plowing in winter. All while the normal highway is 5km to the east and a little bit backed up.

This highlights that routing algorithms do not understand the concept of safe driving and cannot evaluate how dangerous it is to just pick any alternative route.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by paganel on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:47AM (#33919114)
Nice ride! The FJ Cruiser is a hidden gem of the late noughts - early 2010s (otherwise a pretty bland period when it comes to cars).
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by colechristensen on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:43PM (#33917162)
I had this problem often with google maps trying to aggressively optimize routes while i lived on the peninsula. Usually involving taking 7 extra turns and hopping on to 101 for a quarter mile in order to save thirty seconds. It took me a lot of extra time to feel comfortable navigating myself (and gave me the impression that a lot of things were much further way) because of the bad navigation… not to mention rage inducting missed turns because of lag or somewhat ambiguous intersections. Very much in favor of a “no crazy uncle secret shortcut mode”. I don’t need to drive through a residential neighborhood or take the exit immediately after the highway entrance or take the next seven lefts, thank you. I moved back to the Midwest where such shortcuts rarely exists and that problem is just one less.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by Cthulhu_ on Thursday December 08, 2022 @05:17PM (#33914499)
I've started using Waze again because its UI allows me to control music at the same time as navigation is on. But it does aggressively reroute me during heavy traffic. I've started to ignore those though; going off the highway through small side- and country roads might save a minute but it's a lot of extra effort.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by aSockPuppeteer on Friday December 09, 2022 @11:10AM (#33922889)
The advertisements are getting more intrusive for Waze. You can’t tap the directions area to see the rest of the set of directions until you tap out of the advertisement.

Waze routes have started to look more like maps routes though with the environmental gas saving trip focus instead of the most direct or fastest route.

I may try Apple Maps or something else. The waze directions don’t account for traffic and the capability to follow the directions.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by genocidicbunny on Friday December 09, 2022 @01:32AM (#33918259)
I have had the exact opposite experience, and maps also generally seems to have trouble accurately determining location compared to waze. Last few years, maps tends to suggest routes that might shave a few seconds if you never needed to stop to make turns, but otherwise end up being much slower, not to mention have many more traffic flow changes to manouver through. Maps also frequently places me on adjacent or cross streets to where I'm driving, whereas waze actually seems to realize that no, I did not just jump my car up a 20 foot berm and over a sound barrier to drive down a parallel road.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by ceejayoz on Friday December 09, 2022 @10:01AM (#33921907)
> maps tends to suggest routes that might shave a few seconds if you never needed to stop to make turns

I've definitely noticed this getting worse; it likes to suggest I do a zig-zag route across rural areas. If I didn't have to decelerate for a 90 degree turn it'd probably be much faster, but I do. Maybe the Maps devs are all in fast-cornering supercars.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by squidgyhead on Friday December 09, 2022 @12:46AM (#33917970)
Side streets really shouldn't be used as major thoroughfares. That's sort of an anti-feature for me - I don't like ruining a neighbourhood by using it as a shortcut all the time.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by Rapzid on Friday December 09, 2022 @01:03AM (#33918086)
I've had that issue with maps TBH driving up and down 35 in Texas(among other things). Taking me off the interstate on a detour through the hood with a dozen turns, stop signs, speed bumps, unprotected street crossings... To save 2 minutes on a 4+ hour trip.

Bad Google!

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by samanator on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:09PM (#33913442)
In Israel, Waze is the only real choice. Maps is not up to date on construction and changing roads, nor is its real-time traffic system accurate.

In the US I solely use maps

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by EdwardDiego on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:31PM (#33913739)
I like it because I drive a lot on unsealed roads, and Google Maps doesn't want to help me find a fast route that involves gravel, whereas Waze has an option to allow that.

Waze doesn't seem to be aware of fords, but then, I wouldn't expect it to be.

I also like that I can tell Waze "I ain't afraid of tricky intersections", and that it's happy to take side-roads if it'll get you there slightly faster, which Google Maps prefers not to do.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by Zigurd on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:01PM (#33913344)
My main use case is to "warn me of problems ahead" when I don't need navigation help. For example, it saved my butt when the road ahead iced-over suddenly. I saw numerous accidents ahead and pulled off before I was in trouble or stuck on the road behind a wreck. I passed several scary big truck accident scenes a couple hours later once the road had been sanded.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by vforvendettador on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:36PM (#33913831)
I still use Waze. It has better incident reporting than Google. Also it reports where the cops are.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by suzzer99 on Thursday December 08, 2022 @07:09PM (#33915677)
My girlfriend was completely obsessed with getting the Waze badges for keeping it on while driving.

And then she hit the final badge and that was it. She was crushed. Why can't they just keep making more badges?

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by aceazzameen on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:19PM (#33917001)
Tell her to make a new account and see how many accounts she can complete.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by robertlagrant on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:54AM (#33920684)
NG++
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by bitshiftfaced on Thursday December 08, 2022 @03:48PM (#33913155)
I only go back to Waze when I need the "plan a drive" feature, where you tell it what time you want to arrive, and it tells you when to leave.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by richiebful1 on Thursday December 08, 2022 @03:52PM (#33913224)
That feature exists in Google Maps, by clicking through the "depart at/arrive by" button
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by capableweb on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:01PM (#33913352)
Can you also just put a destination and it'll show some sort of histogram of when the traffic is the busiest? Basically that + community warnings is the reason I'm 100% using Waze for driving directions.

Here is a screenshot of the feature I'm talking about: https://techcrunch.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/waze-plann...

Basically, I know I want to go to A, but I'm not sure when to leave, I just know I want to avoid as much traffic as possible, so when should I leave? The feature kind of answers that.

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by r00fus on Thursday December 08, 2022 @05:21PM (#33914548)
Not on mobile (iOS) unless they hid it very effectively. Only on web.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by _rs on Thursday December 08, 2022 @05:41PM (#33914773)
It’s on mobile and hidden very well behind the 3 dot menu to the top-right of the start/end location fields. Tap the 3 dots and then you can choose “set depart or arrive time” in the menu that opens

With that said, I do prefer waze’s graph showing traffic changing over time to help decide when to leave

Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by mfcl on Thursday December 08, 2022 @03:51PM (#33913198)
Can't you do that in Google Maps?
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by yrgulation on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:31PM (#33913741)
Extremely popular in europe. Shows locations of speed cameras and police checks.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by unixhero on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:51AM (#33919144)
Extremely popular everywhere
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by bsagdiyev on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:15AM (#33920425)
I've used Waze since first getting a smart phone and continue using it. It got us from California to North Carolina, and does a great job when driving up north or down to Florida. Hopefully this doesn't get affected by this change. I prefer it over Apple Maps or Google Maps.
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by unixhero on Thursday December 08, 2022 @11:10PM (#33917329)
Why did you stop using it? It is superior
Re:Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move by fbernier on Friday December 09, 2022 @12:38AM (#33917920)
I am stumped by that person's comment. Waze is superior in every single way for navigation:

Faster adjusting to real-time traffic, better navigation UI, more importantly tells you where polices are but also other various things that are good to know beforehand.

Google maps is still useful to pre-plan a route, get information about businesses, restaurants, opening hours and just better overall building information with street view and such, but I'd never go back to using maps for navigation unless they do exactly as waze does.