Option D seems objectively better to me over Option A based on this bias.
If the research industry were as pure as science itself of course that would never happen...
Resending to tell me I hadn't done it yet was indication enough to me that it wasn't completely anonymous at all.
While the question doesn't mention anonymity specifically, I'm sure it remains a point in some percentages mind.
And you couldn't connect the response to the user. Thats the important part right? not the ability to resend a request
Then we're left with...mostly anonymous. But at that point it's a black box. It could be done how you describe. Or it could be attaching my name to the survey and emailing the CEO directly. I'd never know the difference.
But I disagree with "getting a reminder means its not anonymous" its completely orthogonal.
going to page and submitting will do two things. the table Request will be updated and marked submitted. the table Response will be populated with only the data.
If I write a letter and don't sign it. It's anonymous. Someone could use a corpus of my text and infer I wrote it. That doesn't mean I didn't write anonymously.
I could make 2 updates to 2 tables and then end result would be that having both tables wouldn't let you correlated the data with submitters.
Yes if you control every aspect of the process you can lie to people. Thats not the point. If you think someone is lying to you to harm you why would you interact with them?
So much for unbiased representation.
We have this problem at work. You try to contact customers and they never respond. Sending repeated queries has no effect.
The real answer is: The question is poor and ambiguous, therefore the question is wrong. It reflects poorly on the academic institution asking it. I would be in search of a new school for my child if I saw many test questions like this. They didn't even enumerate the answers correctly.
It is asking for the best plan of action for the University without clearly specing out the goal and all its parameters. The goal may be "Determine if at least half of our first year students had a positive experience." and that can possibly be solved with 90 responses if at least 60 had positive experiences.
It's just like when your boss asks for a time estimate on a task he's barely defined. It depends on the spec he's asking from you. Without clear specification, the question isn't answerable.
Only in so far as it is posed with a multiple choice response and no opportunity to make a comment.
The question itself is about a commonplace occurrence in statistical sampling.
It certainly is, but once again, the question does not specify enough information to choose an answer. Maybe A is correct, if you have a backup/secondary email to try. Maybe, like so many of us who work with email notifications, they can see the email wasn't opened. Or it bounced. Or it was opened and flagged as spam.
Is that all the information you have? You emailed 120 of them and received 90 clickthroughs? Well sir, that is an astounding clickthrough rate! Perhaps that exceeds every expectation of responses and is itself actionable. Perhaps the best plan of action for the University is to discover their magic clickthrough sauce and monetize it.
What is the best plan of action? Impossible to answer when they haven't specified a goal.
It's not a multi choice question (a form I dislike) but a question that requires a reasoned response.
>It's not a multi choice question
But it IS a multiple choice question, and it is ambiguous, which is why it's not a fine question. It's a sloppy, poorly constructed question, which isn't even enumerated correctly, allowing the instructor to select the "correct" answer based on unspecified reasoning, potentially discriminating against the person answering the question (which I suspect is the intention).
You keep saying this, but the screenshot shows that the student has used an elimination tool (the X on the left) to eliminate one of the possible answers (C).
> allowing the instructor to select the "correct" answer based on unspecified reasoning, potentially discriminating against the person answering the question (which I suspect is the intention).
The question looks like it's from albert.io, so the answer is predetermined (and generally provided by the vendor).
1. The non-responders are not responding for similar reasons.
2. Those reasons are somehow related to their opinions.
Both are clearly false. You cannot assume anything about their opinions from the fact that they didn't respond. All you have is their (non)action - which could have been caused by being ill, busy, distracted by personal issues, absent, drunk, or for any other number of reasons.
None of the answers are correct. If you wanted representative data you would have to:
1. Confirm with a different sample but also...
2. Use multiple different channels and methods (phone, in-person survey on campus, maybe an email survey with some kind of benefit to encourage participation, etc) to try to eliminate the non-responders who have personally valid but statistically irrelevant reasons (away, ill, etc).
> ill, busy, distracted by personal issues, absent, drunk
But being ill correlates (lightly) with being older, and being drunk heavily correlates with opinions. Being absent might correlate with wealth (and not even linearly). Personal issues probably correlate with education. Add them together, and you've got a fairly large part of the population missing from your sample.
No, it doesn't. It doesn't get any information from non-responders; it can't, because they don't respond! It only gets information from some people who respond on the second try instead of the first.
Possibly. But it also introduces a potential confounder.
> It's only futile if you conflate as "non-responders" the people who didn't respond on the first opportunity with the smaller number who wouldn't respond even given a second opportunity.
No, the non-responders are the ones who never respond, period. Which, as I said, means you can't sample them to see what they're like.
What you're doing, instead, is creating two different subsamples of responders: those who responded on the first try, and those who responded on the second try. Which might make things worse, since now you have an additional variable that you created by sending a second email to those who didn't respond the first time.
This is a better statement than any of mine of the point I've been trying to make.
Of course not. But making second, third, or nth requests is not "sampling from non-responders". It's just creating more and more different groups of responders. Which doesn't improve anything statistically that I can see; in fact it might make things worse, because you are introducing more and more potential confounders.
If this analysis tells you there is no significant difference between the subgroups, that's nice, because you can then just lump them into one and not worry about it any more. (This also tells you you didn't actually need to send out the second email, but what's done is done.)
But if this analysis tells you there is a significant difference between the subgroups, you don't know if it's something that was there already or something that you created by sending out a second email to people who had not responded to the first. So you're not actually better off than if you hadn't sent the second email; you're worse off, because you now have a confounding variable present and you don't know what to do about it.
> otherwise we knowingly have a biased sample
You have a biased sample regardless of whether you send out a second email or not.
For example, you must sample the mall-goer population. Some people "seem approachable"/etc. ("respond to your first email"), and you approach them. You are worried that others will be annoyed if you approach. If this assumption is true (which it may not be), their responses could be biased and confounding.
Should you still survey them? I believe the stats textbooks would say yes, since it will result in a more representative sample.
I assume it would be a detriment to the survey if you exclude some groups merely because they aren't compatible with your survey-taking techniques. All surveys have some inherent measurement error, and there are some techniques to detect biases/inconsistencies without excluding entire groups.
No, just any subgroup that, by construction, is not reachable with whatever technique you are using. The key point is that there will always be such subgroups. See further comments below.
> Should you still survey them?
If you mean, should you still send out surveys the first time even though you don't know how people will respond? If you're going to do a survey at all, you have no choice, so this question is pointless.
If you mean, should you continue to pester people who didn't respond the first time, on the grounds that "it will result in a more representative sample", I would question whether that is really the case. See further comments below.
> I assume it would be a detriment to the survey if you exclude some groups merely because they aren't compatible with your survey-taking techniques.
It's a "detriment" if you fail to realize that there is no way to avoid it. Taking a survey inherently means you get responses from people who respond to surveys and not from people who don't. Going back and asking a second time for a response from people who didn't respond the first time inherently means you get responses from people who will respond the second time and not from people who won't. And so on. There is no way to avoid the fact that any survey-taking technique will inherently exclude some proportion of the population.
Once you realize this, you realize that the idea of "getting a more representive sample" is based on a false premise, that you can somehow "include" everyone if you just go about it the right way. You can't.
Using language such as "pester" is making assumptions about the group. In fact, many likely were busy or have just forgotten to reply. As I mentioned above, there are techniques for assessing biased/inconsistent responses.
But representative of what? You can't get a sample that is "representative" of non-responders--because they don't respond.
If you ask once and include whoever responds in your sample, your sample is representative (you hope) of people who respond.
If you ask non-responders again, your sample now includes people who responded when asked once, and people who responded when asked twice. But the "asked twice" part introduces an extra variable: did the fact that you asked them twice change something that you would rather had not been changed? Given that, it's not clear that the second sample is any more "representative" of anything useful than the first.
In practice, "extra variables" are naturally present in every study. For example, surveying mall-goers in the morning vs evening. Or surveying people at one end of the mall vs the other. These variables are likely far more confounding than "must send a followup email".
People asked in the evening might be more annoyed, but you shouldn't assume this a priori and decide to skip surveying them. Just as "busy people" in the studied population might forget to initially respond to an email and need a reminder.
Just as a personal anecdote, I've dealt with this issue quite a lot. In my surveys, the people who respond initially are almost always eager to give glowing reviews. If we didn't send follow-ups, we would have extremely positively biased results. Maybe it is true that sending reminders makes respondents slightly more negative than they normally would be. However, we'd completely exclude "unsatisfied people" otherwise and the survey results would be worthless.
That's true, but it doesn't change the fact that if you ask people a second time to respond, that's an extra variable you created, not one that was naturally there already. It's not a good idea to create extra variables in the course of doing the study.
It's true that the people who respond to the survey without any further prompting are not necessarily going to be representative of the entire population. But that doesn't mean you can "fix" that by further prompting. What it actually means is that surveys are a tool with only limited usefulness. That's just an inherent, inconvenient truth about surveys.
People here are drastically overthinking it. Yes, it's true that the problem didn't state those assumptions, but you are supposed to make them, not to say "the university didn't give us its criteria for 'best plan' so all the answers are equally good". Given the way that problems like this work, it's obviously meant to test knowledge of the specific idea that the people who respond may be nonrepresentative of all the opinions. Only response A shows knowledge of this idea.