News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A homework question in someone’s 11th grade statistics class by silisili on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @06:31PM (#33888597)
I actually vote against A. My work was always sending out 'completely anonymous' surveys that I generally ignored.

Resending to tell me I hadn't done it yet was indication enough to me that it wasn't completely anonymous at all.

While the question doesn't mention anonymity specifically, I'm sure it remains a point in some percentages mind.

Re:A homework question in someone’s 11th grade statistics class by nh23423fefe on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:07PM (#33889433)
But I could make a table Request(email, url, submitted) and a table Response(data)

And you couldn't connect the response to the user. Thats the important part right? not the ability to resend a request

Re:A homework question in someone’s 11th grade statistics class by silisili on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:34PM (#33889659)
I'd argue recording anything at all, including whether I did it, breaks the 'completely anonymous' contract.

Then we're left with...mostly anonymous. But at that point it's a black box. It could be done how you describe. Or it could be attaching my name to the survey and emailing the CEO directly. I'd never know the difference.

Re:A homework question in someone’s 11th grade statistics class by nh23423fefe on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:51PM (#33889791)
I mean sure. If you think someone is lying to you then it doesn't matter.

But I disagree with "getting a reminder means its not anonymous" its completely orthogonal.

Re:A homework question in someone’s 11th grade statistics class by jayd16 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:35PM (#33889666)
Are you assuming the request to respond is broadcast to all recipients regardless of response status?
Re:A homework question in someone’s 11th grade statistics class by nh23423fefe on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:50PM (#33889779)
No implementation is something like email is primary key, url is per user.

going to page and submitting will do two things. the table Request will be updated and marked submitted. the table Response will be populated with only the data.

Re:A homework question in someone’s 11th grade statistics class by jayd16 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:14PM (#33889920)
If you can derive the email at submission time then its not anonymous.
Re:A homework question in someone’s 11th grade statistics class by nh23423fefe on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @12:01PM (#33896868)
It seems like the disagreement is between what makes data anonymous.

If I write a letter and don't sign it. It's anonymous. Someone could use a corpus of my text and infer I wrote it. That doesn't mean I didn't write anonymously.

I could make 2 updates to 2 tables and then end result would be that having both tables wouldn't let you correlated the data with submitters.

Yes if you control every aspect of the process you can lie to people. Thats not the point. If you think someone is lying to you to harm you why would you interact with them?

Re:A homework question in someone’s 11th grade statistics class by jayd16 on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @07:38PM (#33902526)
The point is there's ways to achieve this even assuming bad actors and doing something that's obviously flawed doesn't seem helpful.
Re:A homework question in someone’s 11th grade statistics class by nh23423fefe on Thursday December 08, 2022 @12:10PM (#33910340)
> obviously
Re:A homework question in someone’s 11th grade statistics class by tgv on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @02:55AM (#33891804)
I work for a company that actually runs surveys, and believe me: we don't know who the respondents are. They get a link with a randomly generated id, and that's it. For us, even their email address is hidden, because respondents register to panel at another company, which deletes this information three months after closing the survey, which usually runs for a few days. I can't vouch for the other company, of course, but I do believe them. Sometimes it would be really nice to know who these people are, because not only is non-response a problem, bad responses are an even greater problem, so we'd like to know who to exclude in advance.

So much for unbiased representation.

Re:A homework question in someone’s 11th grade statistics class by HWR_14 on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @01:15AM (#33891220)
The question never says the survey is or claims to be. completely anonymous.