News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by heresjohnny on Monday December 05, 2022 @04:44PM (#33872330)
Honest question: do you believe that you’ll be able to guarantee the same/better uptime, performance, and security compared to the SaaS version? Hosting your own password manager seems like something you really shouldn’t do, just like hosting your own e-mail. This stuff is critical to your life.
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by Yujf on Monday December 05, 2022 @05:28PM (#33872812)
Better security for sure. Bitwarden is a massive target while I am not. The chance that bitwarden has a databreach is way bigger than the chance that my server gets hacked. No one cares about my server, I am nobody not worth attacking. As long as I don't leave any big holes that can be found by an untargeted attack (which I won't, I run everything behind a personal VPN) it is safer.
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by 542458 on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:31PM (#33874118)
> I am nobody not worth attacking.

You’re probably not worth individually attacking, but a brief look at the failed ssh login logs of any insignificant server shows that you probably are worth automated attacks… so I suppose the question is “Are you more vulnerable due to a) the risk of getting pwnt by an automated attack (due to a misconfiguration or being even a little slow to install a critical patch) or b) due to the risk of bitwarden getting pwnt by a sophisticated targeted actor?”

Further complicating this math is the E2EE nature of it, so it’s not just enough to pwn a server, you’d need to also compromise the client application.

Actually, now that I think about it, if you can compromise the client you don’t even need to compromise the server. I’m not really sure under what scenarios running your own server would protect you in in that case.

Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by dvzk on Monday December 05, 2022 @10:09PM (#33875404)
> Further complicating this math is the E2EE nature of it, so it’s not just enough to pwn a server, you’d need to also compromise the client application.

The webvault is both a server and a client, and you can't not use it. As soon as you sign into it once (which you must, with the official apps) you have allowed unsigned ephemeral javascript code to run against your decrypted vault.

Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by hackerman123469 on Thursday December 08, 2022 @07:46AM (#33907266)
I can contest to this, I am by no mean important and none of my servers that I own have any importance, BUT I have thousands of people trying to remote into the servers every day and also thousands of requests into some of my webservers with things like /admin /phpmyadmin or whatever, you name it.

So yeah even if you aren't a big target then you are still a target for automated attacks as they just pick whatever IPs they can find and try to breach.

Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by phpisthebest on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:51PM (#33874288)
The entire purpose of bitwarden is they do not have your unencrypted data in the first place, so what is the fear there?
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by dvzk on Monday December 05, 2022 @09:48PM (#33875271)
The Bitwarden webvault infrastructure is a doomsday target. If it's compromised, no evidence of a client backdoor will exist except in the server logs. You can't avoid using it, because you need to sign into the webvault to configure 2FA. Want to change the encryption passphrase? Guess what, you need to use the webvault. Bitwarden's vault encryption is essentially reduced to the security model of TLS.
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by jmcnulty on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @04:51AM (#33877593)
And? If you don't trust TLS then I assume you don't trust web banking, or purchasing anything over the internet for that matter. Might as well give up on technology and go find yourself a nice quiet pastoral life.
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by dvzk on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @05:36AM (#33877836)
I trust the cryptography behind TLS. I don’t trust every website using TLS. The difference between end-to-end encryption and transport-layer encryption is the website operator can recover the plaintext. I’m glad that you think E2EE is a waste of effort though.
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by dvzk on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @05:48AM (#33877913)
Following up, I find it funny that this old meme comment thought orders and banking are our most trusted activities, and not our communications and data storage.
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by hackerman123469 on Thursday December 08, 2022 @07:50AM (#33907309)
For me personally, I don't actually trust any of that.

Any purchase I do online is done with a virtual card that links to a bank account that only ever has the amount I need to pay for whatever it is I am currently purchasing. That way it doesn't matter if the information is stolen etc. because there is no more money to use and I can cancel the card as easily as I can create a new.

For banking I also only use my banks official app, I don't know how exactly it works and I assume it does use some form of http and whatnot, but I wouldn't trust using a bank through the browser as you never know what kind of thing an extension or something have in there.

Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by hedora on Monday December 05, 2022 @10:47PM (#33875664)
Well, based on what everyone fears is happening over at lastpass, attackers just download all the encrypted vaults, then brute force the master passwords.

I have a hard-to-guess master password, but it wouldn't surprise me if they could crack it with a 2026 vintage GPU farm.

Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by dvzk on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:07AM (#33876155)
Anyone who doubts you should run zxcvbn and more modern entropy estimators against their passwords. Our intuitions are not good. Offering password-based encryption to normal users is borderline unethical.
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by sam_goody on Monday December 05, 2022 @05:17PM (#33872692)
Sure.

Hosting your own is a twenty minute setup, more or less, and $5/mo on Hetzner. Uptime, in my experience, is 5 nines.

With SaaS, I am losing the main reason that I am using Bitwarden - that I don't want the X agency to force Bitwarden to give them my passwords.

And I know that if said agency (it varies by country and target) could definitely hack the VPS if I was important enough, that is not part of my threat profile. Self hosted is far less likely to get auto vacuumed than SaaS data.

Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by idiotsecant on Monday December 05, 2022 @05:31PM (#33872841)
I think if X agency wants your information the $5 wrench attack will probably bypass your self-hosted server infrastructure.
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by midasuni on Monday December 05, 2022 @06:19PM (#33873366)
If X agency uses the wrench attack then you know you’ve been breached
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by denkmoon on Monday December 05, 2022 @06:37PM (#33873562)
All bets are off if you've got the man taking a wrench to your shins.
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by Dylan16807 on Monday December 05, 2022 @11:00PM (#33875755)
Ok.

There's a very big gap between a warrant and a torture kidnapping. Self-hosting protects a lot of that gap.

Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by phpisthebest on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:54PM (#33874330)
>> I don't want the X agency to force Bitwarden to give them my passwords.

Then you do not understand how bitwarden works,

Bit Warden has the same access to your passwords that Hetzner does, i.e they have only encrypted access to the binary storage.

The only thing agency X could get from bitwarden is an encrypted vault that is useless with out your master key, all encryption and decryption is done client side. THis by the way is the same access Hetzner would have to turn over if Agency X asks for a copy of your VM running vualtwarden

Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by aborsy on Monday December 05, 2022 @10:19PM (#33875465)
This is true, but not enough to protect your vault. See dvzk reply.
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by koevet on Monday December 05, 2022 @05:27PM (#33872801)
I have been running Vaultwarden (formerly known as bitwarden_rs) for years in a docker container and I don't remember a single time that it went down.
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by iso1631 on Monday December 05, 2022 @05:20PM (#33872723)
Yup, it's not rocket science if you already run your own services. An entire generation of techies seem to be completely scared of running their own machine and think it's some kind of massively difficult task.
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by zikduruqe on Monday December 05, 2022 @05:00PM (#33872517)
Just use passwordstore.org and stand up a bare git repo. It really doesn't need to be terribly complicated.
Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by slock83 on Monday December 05, 2022 @06:04PM (#33873199)
Same or better uptime might not be granted, but I've been hosting my instance for quite a bit of time now, and the only downtime I've had were due to my ISP. I'm using vaultwarden too (bitwarden_rs when I first deployed it), and have absolutely no complains whatsoever.

Also, after your device synced with the server at least once, you can still access and export all your passwords, even if the server is down. This is the main selling point for me : even in a disaster scenario, your passwords are "naturally" replicated.

Mine is exposed behind a reverse proxy, with a subdomain != Bitwarden, and a wildcard certificate. Never seen anything weird in the logs since (before, I had a named certificate including subdomain, and I was seeing regular pokes from unknown IPs, so better be on the safe side)

Again, the main bitwarden instance is a huge target. Mine is just a small instance with less than 10 users, which will probably never encounter a targeted attack.

Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by Macha on Monday December 05, 2022 @06:29PM (#33873472)
> Also, after your device synced with the server at least once, you can still access and export all your passwords, even if the server is down. This is the main selling point for me : even in a disaster scenario, your passwords are "naturally" replicated.

Watch out for the browser extension clients though - they're prone to session expiry and insisting you relogin which is a problem if the remote server is down or gone.

Re:Passwordless Authentication – Access Your Bitwarden Web V... by michelllle on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @03:05AM (#33877024)
"Bitwarden has the right to suspend or terminate your access to all or any part of the Website at any time, with or without cause, with or without notice, effective immediately. Bitwarden reserves the right to refuse service to anyone for any reason at any time."

Who would trust their passwords to a service with such a clause?