That one could point to your local server instance.
https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/OpenSearch#auto...
Although maybe that's more a comment on the inevitable end state of democratization of creation + centralization of search/discovery + monetization of traffic.
There is a happier middleground where multiple gates exist to filter out the bullshit, but no said gatekeeper controls the entire market leading to monopoly behavior.
Incidentally, this is why I click on the dirtiest garage clip for car how-to's: it's usually just the raw start-to-end process.
not sure if they do ebooks.
> We’ve helped you locate this recipe but for the full instructions you need to go to its original source.
Which I guess makes sense, how can they verify I own the cookbook, but still very disappointing.
Without AI-generated content, cookie recipes would be "safe" from that, since only people who care about cookies would bother to write up articles about them - but now you suddenly have to mistrust all sources of all information, which is a new thing.
For me the main issue with AI creating content in internet is going to be the echo chamber of that content being used to train new AI models.
The bullshit asymmetry principle puts forth that algorithmic 'bullshit' content is even worse as quantity is a quality all in itself when you're debunking the bullshit. In general the reader will not know if the producer of the bullshit is a real human or a bot. This makes the search engines job even harder as not only do you have the standard human bullshit you have to get rid of, you have an oceans torrent of AI generated bullshit that you have to waste energy on getting rid of.
HN has a common theme of saying that "Dead internet theory is wrong", I personally just think they've not waited long enough and it's becoming more true every day.
It's less about if the businesses care and more about if the consumers care. Businesses will respond to whatever consumers are willing to tolerate.
Honestly, it'll probably be a battle around requirements to label AI-generated content so that consumers can make an informed choice about what to trust. But, given the global nature of the internet, that's probably not possible. You probably end up with private/commercial reputation rating firms, and consumers can decide who they want to trust.
If people decide they don't care about the veracity of information or don't want to put in the extra work to ensure they are consuming "true" information they you'll end up with businesses built on auto-generated garbage.
> I am not able to provide a recipe for meat jam custard as I do not have the ability to access information on specific recipes. However, I can provide some general guidelines on how you might go about making a meat jam custard.
> First, you will need to select a type of meat to use for the jam. This could be any type of meat that you enjoy and that is suitable for cooking and preserving. Some common options for meat jam include pork, beef, chicken, or lamb.
> Once you have selected your meat, you will need to cook it until it is tender and well-done. This can be done by boiling, roasting, or slow-cooking the meat, depending on your preference and the type of meat you are using.
> Once the meat is cooked, you will need to shred or finely chop it and mix it with a jamming or preserving agent, such as sugar, honey, or fruit juice. This will help to preserve the meat and give it a jam-like consistency.
> Next, you will need to prepare a custard base for the meat jam. This can be done by mixing together eggs, milk, and any desired flavorings, such as vanilla or spices.
> Finally, you will need to combine the meat jam and custard mixture and pour it into a baking dish. Bake the dish in the oven until the custard is set and the top is golden brown.
> Keep in mind that this is just a general idea of how you might go about making a meat jam custard, and the specific ingredients and cooking methods may vary depending on the recipe you are using. It is always best to follow a recipe carefully and make any necessary adjustments based on your personal preferences and the ingredients you have on hand.
Thank you!
https://www.today.com/food/friends-meat-trifle-episode-how-i...
1. Background directly related to the recipe/cooking in general.
2. The writer's personal anecdotes tangentially related to the recipe.
Some cooking blogs have great background (eg. J. Kenji Lopez-Alt's work on Serious Eats) but I would say they're mostly type 1 - information that informs you about the recipe, how they developed it, technique etc. They have type 2 background as well (jokes, what inspired them to make the recipe, snippets of their day-to-day lives) but it's definitely a small proportion of the body of the text. These blogs always have background that's work reading.
What I can't stand is the blogs with reams and reams of text of nothing but personal anecdotes, meandering stories, media references, what their kids are up to etc etc, occasionally returning to talk about something to do with the recipe. I don't have any examples because I now avoid untrusted recipe blogs like the plague, but it becomes very obvious to me when a recipe blog strays from useful background to worthless padding for the sake of copyright and SEO.
As for SEO, Google is going to have to stop being lazy and relying so much on backlinks and domain authority. They might have to consider allowing searchers to essentially vote on what they consider good. I don't see any other way low quality AI content doesn't dominate SERPs, established players will spin up entire sites and spam backlinks to them all. There are also people working on using AI to identify obvious AI content by finding patterns in the output which is probably our only hope.
For social media and forums they will have to rely even harder on captcha or they will be taken over by bots talking to other bots
Beyond that a once popular website or producer says or does something that offends the sensibilities of the internet crowd and then everyone goes and down votes their results because it violates the current ziegiest
there are tons of ways to prevent that by weighting votes and only taking a random sample. SEO is basically a war where SEOs find a way to exploit Google's algorithm and Google tries to respond.
Backlinks were Google's original solution to keyword spam that made other search engines suck, they didn't expect people would create entire sites or pay other websites to send links to them so they could rank higher. Backlinks were themselves considered to be "votes" for quality similar to citations in academia. The problem is the barrier to entry to make a site and link to it is high, so SEOs themselves are often the only ones to do it. Adding some sort of voting mechanism would allow actual readers to give an opinion on quality, although you'd probably see SEOs pay people to vote on their link via a VPN switching IPs, so only people with established Google accounts could be allowed to vote. Obviously its a huge challenge, which is why Google is worth hundreds of billions for even partially solving it
Helps for both search users and the platform. Like a free moderation service. Why have an employee too check if these pages should be removed if a crowd of tracked users can do it.
I wonder where is my view wrong because I wonder why isn't there such system yet...
In order to detect malicious activity you'd have to use a bunch of other signals, and also to use the downvotes with some suspicion, so you're back at looking content quality, reputation, page speed, and many other signals. Which sounds very similar to status quo.
Personally I'd like to see some sort of explicit input. If not used collectively, at least to customize my own results, like it happens on YT/Netflix/Instagram/etc - e.g. "never show results again from this site", or "I dislike this type of content".
You forgot to add "Because clever posters use bots to give an early upvote boost to their posts, and downvote competing posts" And the more eyeballs on the site, the more things will be manipulated this way by bad actors.
For all its flaws maybe becoming like reddit it what search needs. AI generated spam will likely always be better at gaming a search algorithm than a human. Human moderation has its flaws but at least we're very familiar with them - they might be worth dealing with if it keeps the internet vaguely usable.
The next wave of major progress in AI will come when we create image/text data sets that have been heavily annotated with aesthetic judgment metadata, and train models to make aesthetic judgments, then condition generative models on aesthetic judgment scores during training.
What would make more sense is that they are actually taking the recipes from elsewhere and adding the stories to avoid directly duplicating another page, and the Google ranking penalty associated with exact or close duplicates.
My moderate experience with SEO suggests it's a combination of factors. First, Google generally rewards longer content (https://www.sweor.com/seocontentlength), or at least content longer than the few hundred words a simple recipe would likely be limited to.
Secondly, there is (mixed) evidence that Google rewards sites on which people spend longer before clicking back.
Thirdly, the longer format allows them to insert more keywords/longer tail keywords vs. a short format where inserting lots of keywords would be seen as keyword stuffing.
I'd also guess that as much as some people dislike superfluous stories when looking for a recipe, it is a positive for a subset of users that are more likely to subscribe to/return to that site directly in the future.
Saying “yeah but Kagi” is talking about you and your tribe only. The world isn’t going to pay for Kagi or take the N steps required to switch. Microsoft realized they could kill Netscape by simply not requiring the user to download anything, then failed to consolidate. Google managed to be better for just long enough to consolidate so pervasively that any further investment in improvement is a literal waste of energy and money.
So, don’t hold your breath from an improvement in SEO garbage. It’ll just get worse. Definitely use Kagi and hopefully we will have great niche subscription based tools that have an incentive to be better. But don’t expect that Google perceives ANY problems with the status quo or that they have to do anything about anything other than increasing ad margins.
There have been a ton of articles about how Google sucks lately. Well, maybe Google has gotten worse, but maybe the internet has just gotten worse.
If I search for “best gaming laptop” or “taco recipe” the results are pretty much uniformly spammy across Google, Bing, and Neeva, the latter being a paid search engine. All of them are just farms for ads, popups, and paid links sandwiched between AI generated copy.
Is that the search engine’s fault? Is there some oasis of quality results I don’t know about? I would like to know.
I believe you will find results on Kagi less spammy
https://kagi.com/search?q=best+gaming+laptop&r=us&sh=HJrdZzD...
(Kagi is also a paid search engine that requires an accunt, the above is publicly shared search)
Removing, downranking and classyfing spam/ads is part of things Kagi is focusing on and does decently well (IMO, Kagi founder here).
Thanks for being honest like this. I really should get around to trying Kagi … I think I’m just still in the current habit inertia between DDG and Google
I wonder if over time SEO spam becomes an invisible problem to us and instead the AIs have sort it out for us.
There have been some good Twitter threads about this. Basically, this is the last generation of AI to be trained with inputs that were ~100% human. It probably won't take long until the bulk of the content online is generated by AI, at which point it will just be an AI feedback loop. Any new concept, idea, technology, whatever, that doesn't already have a bunch of content about it will never have a guaranteed fully-human-written corpus to start from.
Once there's a viable OpenAI competitor or two, it's probably only a matter of time until the AIs start an arms race to feed each other bad data. Tweak the model to generate subtly incorrect information, regenerate your training corpus in a way that it feeds into other AIs but ensures you ignore it, and now you're basically all the way back to having a few trusted "information gatekeepers".
https://huggingface.co/openai-detector/ detects GPT2, but it still detects ChatGPT snippets most of the time, even though the algorithm has been improved and the training set is presumably quite different.
That said, I did just generate a complete lie https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33874757 using ChatGPT that scored 99.98% real on the detector, so adversaries can pre-filter too.
Also interesting is that historical corpora (every existing corpus) of data becomes more valuable, because they are untainted.
Prompt: Write a recipe and blog post for onion soup.
GPT3 Response: Onion soup is a classic comfort food that can be enjoyed at any time of year. It’s a simple and delicious dish that comes together quickly and is sure to satisfy even the pickiest of eaters. Plus, it’s a great way to use up any extra onions you may have lying around! Today, I’m going to share with you my favorite recipe for onion soup.
To make this soup, you’ll need:
-4 large onions, sliced -4 tablespoons butter -4 cups chicken broth -1 teaspoon dried thyme -Salt and pepper to taste
First, melt the butter in a large pot over medium heat. Add the onions and cook until softened and lightly browned, about 8-10 minutes.
Next, add the chicken broth, thyme, and salt and pepper. Bring the mixture to a boil, then reduce the heat to low and simmer for 15 minutes.
Once the soup has simmered, it’s ready to serve. Ladle into bowls and enjoy with some crusty bread or a salad.
Onion soup is a simple and delicious dish that’s sure to please the whole family.
This Cocktail Concocted By IBM's Watson Isn't Half Bad - https://gizmodo.com/this-cocktail-concocted-by-ibms-watson-i...
Would You Drink a Cocktail Invented By a Computer? How IBM’s Watson become the world’s most creative bartender
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/ibms-watson-can-mi...
---
The reason that blogspam recipes are so common is that recipes have a special place in copyright law in that they aren't.
https://copyrightalliance.org/are-recipes-cookbooks-protecte...
https://www.copyrightlaws.com/copyright-protection-recipes/
https://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-protect.html (and in particular https://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ33.pdf )
From circular 33:
> A recipe is a statement of the ingredients and procedure required for making a dish of food. A mere listing of ingredients or contents, or a simple set of directions, is uncopyrightable. As a result, the Office cannot register recipes consisting of a set of ingredients and a process for preparing a dish. In contrast, a recipe that creatively explains or depicts how or why to perform a particular activity may be copyrightable. A registration for a recipe may cover the written description or explanation of a process that appears in the work, as well as any photographs or illustrations that are owned by the applicant. However, the registration will not cover the list of ingredients that appear in each recipe, the underlying process for making the dish, or the resulting dish itself. The registration will also not cover the activities described in the work that are procedures, processes, or methods of operation, which are not subject to copyright protection.
And so, you can grab a recipe and be 100% sure that it isn't copyrighted. Then you can add some SEO text around it and some advertisements on the side and you've got yourself a page that you are sure that no legal department will come after you for.
AI-generated alternative cancer treatments.
Hugh.
Whenever this technology is used in an accuracy-critical setting, it is a recipe for disaster.
These "AI systems" produce the MOST PREDICTED output whenever there is any ambiguity, and this REPLACES the ACTUAL UNEXPECTED value/ITEM. In information system terms, they are literally stripping out content with the highest information value.
I saw this first hand giving a deposition that was supposedly transcribed by an "Artificial Intelligence" system. The output looked beautiful, until I started checking it for errors. Normally an errata sheet has a dozen lines for errors. Mine had pages. And they were substantial and very meaningful. The most obvious site was a specific name that sounded vaguely similar (started with a "J" and "K" sounds) was replaced by "Jack Kennedy". It also replaced "you have" with "I have" and omitted "not" several times, literally reversing the meaning of the statement. There were 85+ errors that I caught, over an order of magnitude more than normal.
These things are basically fine as glorified type-ahead systems where it doesn't matter much and a human is in the loop. But using them in any situation where the results are critical is, at this point, basically fraud. They do not do what the proponents claim.
Video games with crafting/cooking such as RPGs are featured on some of these generated SEO sites.
Especially now that things like chatGPT seem to write coding tutorials pretty easy (with less bloat than the ones I find on google)
I don't know how many people are fooled by these recipes and end up with a cooking disaster but if we start seeing faulty machine generated instructions on how to do electrical work or engine repair, the consequences will be much greater when followed. The real annoyance is that because these machine generated articles learned from sites that maximize SEO, the generated articles are rapidly rising to the top of search results and crowding out actual good information that wasn't SEO maximized.