News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by badcppdev on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:16AM (#33829550)
I'm sorry this sounds like a very simplistic and callous question but I'm not from the US. I know there are a lot of guns. Do thieves and robbers get shot on a regular basis and it just doesn't make headline news? Or when a gun is being used in self defence against a robbery is it more likely that the potential thief sees the gun, runs away, and isn't shot (because most people don't actually want to shoot someone).
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by OJFord on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:38AM (#33829724)
For shop robberies, it's at least culturally normal/unsurprising enough that it's common in TV & film for the shopkeeper to pull a shotgun or something from under the counter. (Also not from the US.)

I think it's a really interesting question though - if the point of allowing firearm ownership is self-defence etc., then surely should be looking at the usage metrics for that - when people own them, do they actually use them in such circumstances, is it effective, do non-owners have worse outcomes, etc.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by starkd on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:28AM (#33830153)
I would submit this would not be a very informative metric. Simply because the purpose of owning a gun to defend yourself is that you don't ultimately have to use it. There are many gun owners who never find themselves in that position, but just the knowledge that there are a lot of guns out there is an implicit threat that keeps the peace.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by OJFord on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:19AM (#33831610)
To be clear, by 'using' I meant drawing, not (necessarily) discharging.

> just the knowledge that there are a lot of guns out there is an implicit threat

which makes the comparison against the outcomes of non-owner victims that I suggested valuable right?

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by starkd on Saturday December 03, 2022 @10:12AM (#33844039)
Perhaps, but not sure you can separate gun owners from non-owners for such a study. Criminals do not always know beforehand which of their victims have a gun. The element of surprise creates hesitation to commit a crime.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by roody15 on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:22AM (#33829615)
No. In fact if you shot a person robbing you in San Francisco you would be jailed and likely charged.

This is not the case in all states but in California you cannot shot a thief unless he is threatening you will deadly force.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by CharlesW on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:22AM (#33829610)
> Do thieves and robbers get shot on a regular basis and it just doesn't make headline news?

It depends on your definition of "regularly".

"From 2000 to 2021, fewer than 3% of 433 active attacks in the U.S. ended with a civilian firing back, according to the Advanced Law Enforcement Rapid Response Training Center at Texas State University. The researchers define the attacks as one or more people targeting multiple people." https://www.fox13news.com/news/how-often-does-a-good-guy-wit...

Obviously, we need lots more good guys with guns to fix this. /s

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by tokai on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:27AM (#33829654)
That data is not applicable to gp's question. It's about shooting back at an active shooter, not drawing on a robber.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by badcppdev on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:27AM (#33829648)
I'm just going to sound more callous and clarify that I didn't mean mass shootings just the kind of robberies shown in the article.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by CharlesW on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:32AM (#33829684)
FWIW I don't think you sound callous at all. To clarify my response, the data I shared on mass shootings ("mass" being >3 people) is just meant to illustrate that the "good guy with a gun" scenario is very rare.

As another data point, a Harvard University analysis of a National Crime Victimization Survey concludes that people defended themselves with a gun in nearly 0.9 percent of crimes from 2007–2011: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00917...

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by badcppdev on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:11AM (#33829999)
That survey is almost the answer to my question so thank you for linking to it.

Guns were used in self defence in 0.9% of crimes where the victim of the crime was present. It doesn't state whether the gun was fired or not but given the low percentages of a gun being involved at all I guess there aren't many 'bad guys' being shot (or shot at).

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by lando2319 on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:21AM (#33829606)
for the most part, California does not have concealed carry laws
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by CharlesW on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:27AM (#33829651)
California does have Concealed Carry laws, and residents can get Carry Concealed Weapon (CCW) licenses which has to be renewed yearly.

https://oag.ca.gov/firearms/pubfaqs#4

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by kyleyeats on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:33AM (#33829694)
It's very difficult to get one in SF, which is a city and a county.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by CharlesW on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:45AM (#33829787)
It's very difficult in general compared to "anything goes" states. I found data that shows that California has granted around 121,000 concealed carry licenses as of August 2021, which is 0.31% of the population.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by kyleyeats on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:58AM (#33829883)
San Francisco (the county) issued three between 2010 and 2015.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by actionfromafar on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:39AM (#33829732)
But can you open carry?
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by CharlesW on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:42AM (#33829754)
With few exceptions, my understanding is "no".
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by badcppdev on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:29AM (#33829662)
Not from the US. What is a concealed carry law exactly and what does that mean with respect to robberies? Thieves will be able to see whether the person they are trying to rob is armed before they approach them?

Is the situation different in other states that do have concealed carry laws?

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by matwood on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:03AM (#33829933)
> What is a concealed carry law exactly

It means a person can get a license to carry a concealed gun on their person. Typically it requires a bit of training and a test. I live in a more free for all state, and you can get a CCW with a couple Saturdays of class and a hand gun shooting test.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by nszceta on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:19AM (#33830071)
In the "free for all" states judges and juries are also generally more understanding of victims rights in self-defense situations so you are less likely to be branded a murderer in a self-defense situation. In victim-hostile states and counties you have a much higher burden of proof of innocence before the law system as a victim acting in self-defense.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by nszceta on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:07AM (#33829965)
People will rob you and take your gun off you if they see your gun before you notice you're getting robbed. If you draw on someone pointing a gun at you you will get killed.

Some states allow you to protect property with deadly force and others do not. You have to read state law to understand the nuance.

In San Francisco you can generally take anything you want from anybody and the victim will generally get in trouble trying to stop you. You may get arrested for the crime but there is no guarantee. The police will release you soon after you are arrested, often on a signature bond with zero deposit [1]. You can rinse and repeat this process dozens of times per year because it is unlikely you will spend any significant time in jail or prison. You'll have a database record but no problem making ends meet upon release.

[1] https://www.sfdistrictattorney.org/policy/no-cash-bail/

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by ModernMech on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:23AM (#33830111)
> The police will release you soon after you are arrested, often on a signature bond with zero deposit [1]. You can rinse and repeat this process dozens of times per year because it is unlikely you will spend any significant time in jail or prison.

Sounds like what happens to the rich and well connected when they get in trouble with the law. Seems like equal justice to me.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by nszceta on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:35AM (#33831860)
They also aren't following people for 40 miles to bust them up and rob them.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by ModernMech on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:40AM (#33832820)
If you think the rich and well connected are above robbing the poor or even you… I mean, I’d love to live in that world.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by bluedino on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:08AM (#33829979)
'Concealed carry' means that you are allowed to carry a firearm on your person, concealed from view. The typical example of this would be a pistol in a holster, in your waistband, inside of your shirt or jacket.

California doesn't allow 'open carry', which many other states do. This allows you to carry a pistol in a holster outside of your jacket/shirt so that it can be seen.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by yonaguska on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:17AM (#33830063)
Additionally, in some states, it's legal to open carry without a permit, while concealed carry requires a permit. The vast majority of people carrying will choose not to advertise it.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by totalZero on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:44AM (#33829768)
I'm not a lawyer but I've lived in some very gun-friendly places.

Every state has different laws about when/why you are allowed to engage with deadly force against another human being. Generally it is permitted when you face a threat of inescapable, serious bodily harm. Sometimes the law is more permissive than that. Look up "duty to retreat," "stand your ground law," "castle doctrine," and "justifiable homicide."

If an unarmed person is stealing your car in California, it's unlikely that shooting at them would be lawful. However, California law imposes no duty to retreat, this article is about "violent robberies," and it specifically discusses getting held up at gunpoint. Someone under those circumstances would likely be permitted, under law, to kill the robber. That may not be true in states with duty to retreat laws.

The fact that every state has a unique approach to this question means that there really isn't a satisfying and succinct answer to your question.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by starkd on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:24AM (#33830123)
And, depending on the state, if you do use force in self-defense, it may be an open question if you will or will not be prosecuted, and (more importantly), if a jury is willing to convict.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by saiya-jin on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:47AM (#33830344)
Seems to me that when robbery becomes robbery with a gun its too late to be a hero shooting robbers. Not many people want to test if unknown person pointing at them from 1-2m is slower than you getting your own gun from some hidden holster, clicking safety / loading a bullet ie on glocks, pointing and actually hitting back with immediate deadly force.

Its either 'redneck' approach when any such encounter is a gun encounter (with its consequences), or just give them wallet/phone and accept the loss&hassle in exchange of much higher chance of surviving.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by slowhand09 on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:08AM (#33832363)
The part you glossed over totally (or just didn't consider) is the ASSUMPTION that the guy robbing or assaulting you or your family will honor the CONTRACT that you imagined he agreed to, that being to just take your stuff and leave you all unharmed.

Many perps aren't completely stupid. They realize you'll call cops if they missed your phone. You'll cancel credit cards immediately. An APB will be issued for your vehicle. You can IDENTIFY them. Everything they took may be rendered useless in minutes.

So instead, they may shoot you, or take your daughter hostage, or ignore your cries that the baby is in the child seat in back.

If you give them complete power maybe they take you to three ATMs, then force you and your family back into your home, and terrorize you, doing or threatening unspeakable things. Think this is made up crap, cherry-picking stuff? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murders_of_Channon_Christian_a...

30 yrs ago a young single woman I know had most of this happen to her. She was held captive, bound, gagged, blindfolded, tased, and raped for 3 days. She escaped by total dumb luck while the perp was paying for a pizza delivery from her purse. Her life is fucked up forever. She moved to the midwest, in with her parents. She's terrified of people.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by AnimalMuppet on Friday December 02, 2022 @02:07PM (#33835213)
All true. But if they've already got the gun pointed at me, and I try to pull a gun in response, are you assuming that they're going to just walk away?
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by slowhand09 on Friday December 02, 2022 @05:37PM (#33837916)
Make your own decision. Your mileage may vary.

I do what I can. I train.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by bombcar on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:46AM (#33829792)
Even most ardently pro-gun people do not recommend killing to protect property; only to protect human life.

It does occur and it isn’t usually terribly newsworthy (here’s a recent one: https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/calumet-heights-shootin... ) unless there is something else around it.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by MengerSponge on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:58AM (#33829884)
There are plenty of pro-gun people who advocate killing to protect their property!

Texas is not the only state with castle doctrine, but it's the least surprising one where it's legal to kill intruders to protect your land.

https://www.dougmurphylaw.com/defense-of-property

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by yonaguska on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:07AM (#33829967)
There's a big difference in protecting property in your domicile vs protecting your property while you're out and about. Most serious gun self defense legal advocates will advocate not protecting your property while out in public, unless your life is truly in danger, simply because you are going to incur immediate legal issues and at least 20k in debt. Whatever you were protecting is not likely going to be worth the legal, or emotional costs of self defense.

When it comes to protecting your property, as in your domicile- you are having your safest place violated. Your life is more likely in danger, and laws are also more likely to favor you, lessening the legal risk.

If I'm carjacked, I have insurance, if someone breaks into my house, where I have several guns and my family- I have much less to lose by killing the intruder.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by pcl on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:37AM (#33830238)
Not in Texas — the Texas castle doctrine extends to your vehicles and workplace.

See section 9.31 here.

https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/PE/htm/PE.9.htm

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by MengerSponge on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:47AM (#33830343)
Again, depends on the state. If you're a white person in Texas? It's vanishingly unlikely that your interaction with the state legal apparatus will extend beyond a hat tip and a thank you sir/ma'am.

Think of it as a "barbarians at the gate" type situation. You're defending civilization from lawlessness. Whether or not your life is in danger doesn't matter in many places. You similarly only have an obligation to deescalate in some states.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by arcbyte on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:20AM (#33830088)
Real property is one thing. Chattel property is another.

OP used the word property responding to comments using it in the sense of chattel property like a car or a wallet or purse. You're bringing up links to real property like someone's home or livelihood. There's a big difference well recognized in the laws of some states as you point out and totally consistent with OPs point that using lethal force to protect chattel property is not something anyone sane recommends for very practical reasons.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by MengerSponge on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:43AM (#33830301)
My point is that a disappointing number of people fully believe it would be good and right to shoot a thief dead. They're sane. Radicalized, maybe, but as sane as they come.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by tolleydbg on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:02AM (#33830504)
In the case of my home, as the user mentioned above, consider me radicalized. If someone breaks in, I'm shooting them. I don't have the time, nor should I be required to carry out this mental calculus about the motivations of the person in my home. If you're in my house uninvited, the onus is on the intruder not to be shot. Luckily, I live in a state that agrees with me.

The other situations are circumstantial, but if I am being accosted by someone in public, I'm drawing on them. As a pizza delivery driver in my younger years, this happened a lot more than I would have liked. No one got shot because they retreated. If they made a motion towards their waist, back, or lunged, they would have been.

In this case, I have issued a warning that this will end badly if you continue, and any further threatening act will get them shot.

If you're talking about witnessing a robbery, even of my own property, and the thief running away, then no, that is insane.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by throwaway27727 on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:03AM (#33830506)
My belongings are not free for anyone to come and take.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by MengerSponge on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @04:10PM (#33887096)
The punishment should suit the crime. Extrajudicial killing, as a rule, is bad policy.

There are plenty of societal sticks that are not homesteaders with a rifle.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by slowhand09 on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:13AM (#33832429)
I don't advocate killing to protect your property. But advertising that to criminals is like putting a sign up that says "take what you want".

For people who say "You value object X over peoples lives", my reply is "Why does that criminal value that object of mine more than his own life?"

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by dtech on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:53AM (#33829836)
If the robber has a gun - like here - isn't it usually easy to argue shooting back was to preserve life? Your comment is also directly contradicted by the numerous Stand-your-ground laws [1], quoting Wikipedia: "Under such a law, people have no duty to retreat before using deadly force in self-defense"

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stand-your-ground_law

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by kkielhofner on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:13AM (#33830021)
I don’t think OP was referring to the letter of the law. My understanding is that “Stand your ground” /can/ at a minimum be applied to any situation where “a reasonable person would be in fear for their life” - which likely (technically) would cover almost any scenario where any kind of violence or even “crime” is targeted towards you.

That said, as OP was saying the overwhelming take (from what I’ve seen) in the gun/conceal carry community has a pretty high standard for deadly force. In reality the standard for “fear for your life” is actually really high for most people. As you say “shooting back” - which implies you were shot at first. I think in that case “fear for your life” is very reasonable and push come to shove anyone with a gun would use it.

This take even stretches into robberies like this. If someone comes up to you on the street and demands your camera (even with a weapon) it’s best just to cooperate and hand it over. All but the most fervent gun people at their core realize that real life isn’t Hollywood. The vast majority of people who say otherwise are keyboard warriors/wanna be tough guys that have never been in such a situation and have some delusional fantasy of themselves channeling John Wick when/if it happens to them. Obviously that’s not reality.

Clearly the US has a ton of guns and there are many millions of people who are armed at all times. Stories in the news of people using a gun to defend themselves are few and far between because 1) violent crime is actually exceedingly rare statistically and 2) even most gun people realize it’s not OK to kill someone over a camera/wallet/etc even though you may have the means to and the law is technically on your side.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by matwood on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:00AM (#33829902)
> isn't it usually easy to argue shooting back was to preserve life?

Depends on the particular laws of where you are. The reality is that even if the laws favor shooting back, if the criminal ends up injured or killed it means years of legal issues for the shooter. This is true for any physical altercation regardless of if weapons are used.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by bombcar on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:57AM (#33829881)
In that case it can be - assuming the victim has a gun, and legally.

Stand your ground laws exist but even then the training literature is quite clear - you run the risk of ruining your life at least financially by pulling the trigger so you better have that as the better option compared to death or serious bodily harm.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by lbayes on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:51AM (#33830378)
I lived (and loved!) in Northern California for nearly 20 years and left in 2017 for personal reasons.

Without a concealed carry permit, any law-abiding citizen who travels with firearms in California must keep them unloaded and in a locked container [0].

It used to be incredibly difficult (nearly impossible [1]) for regular citizens to obtain a concealed carry permit in San Francisco because they had a "Good Cause Requirement" which essentially meant that your cause was not good enough.

Apparently, that changed in June of 2022 with a recent Supreme Court Ruling [2].

There are also [3] many stories of victims who shoot their attackers either being prosecuted criminally or sued for civil damages.

Lastly, while the views on concealed carry vary widely throughout the US, most social environments that I ever encountered in Northern California would find it repugnant.

[0] https://oag.ca.gov/firearms/travel

[1] https://www.desertsun.com/story/news/nation/california/2022/...

[2] https://www.sanfranciscopolice.org/get-service/carrying-conc...

[3] Oregon, not CA https://www.gilmanbedigian.com/man-who-shot-intruder-in-his-...

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by rayiner on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:11AM (#33830003)
In the places where most robberies happen, cities like San Francisco, only the criminals have guns. In the parts of the country with lots of gun-owning households, like Idaho, robberies are rare. I’m not saying it’s a cause-effect relationship, it’s just that the issue doesn’t come up that often.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by asveikau on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:37AM (#33830247)
Are you failing to take per capita measurements in that assessment? I think per capita violent crime, gun violence in particular, is high in rural areas. Seems to me what you're saying is "a lot of people live in cities".
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by xyzzyz on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:48AM (#33831124)
> I think per capita violent crime, gun violence in particular, is high in rural areas.

This is very much false. Rural areas have very little violent crime, in both absolute and per-capita terms. I encourage you to spend some time looking into this, with the focus on “why did I ever think this could be true”.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by asveikau on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:56AM (#33831263)
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by rayiner on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:43AM (#33831980)
Those articles both conflate murders with auto accidents and gun suicides, which is bizarre.

It’s true that New York City was exceptionally safe from 2000 to 2018 or so. But the same data shows big cities have double the homicide rate of no metro areas.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by badcppdev on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:12AM (#33832425)
Why does America not have clear statistics on this?
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by xyzzyz on Friday December 02, 2022 @02:21PM (#33835416)
It has, but the activists are deliberately trying to confuse people. You can look at NCVS, for example:

> The NCVS involves about a quarter of a million interviews each year with a nationally representative sample of U.S. residents. The federal government’s field agents ask respondents whether they were the victim of a crime within the past six months. According to the NCVS, violent crime in urban areas rose 29 percent from 2020 to 2021, from 19.0 to 24.5 victimizations per 1,000 persons aged 12 or older. From 2018 through 2020, the NCVS found that the violent-crime rate in urban areas was between 29 percent and 42 percent higher than the rate in rural areas. In 2021, however, the violent-crime rate in urban areas was 121 percent higher, more than doubling the rate in rural areas (24.5 victimizations in urban areas, versus 11.1 in rural areas, per 1,000 persons). In addition, the violent-crime rate in urban areas was 48 percent higher in 2021 than in suburban areas, more than tripling any difference in urban and suburban rates registered from 2018 to 2020. The property-crime rate in urban areas was nearly twice as high in 2021 as in suburban areas (157.5 to 86.8 victimizations per 1,000 households) and nearly three times as high as in rural areas (157.5 to 57.7 victimizations per 1,000 households).

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by slowhand09 on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:22AM (#33832586)
When choosing your sources, you might consider that Bloomberg is owned by Micheal Bloomberg. He is the person funding Everytown for Gun Safty (which has nothing to do with gun safety), Moms Demand Action, Mayors Against illegal Guns, and Americans for Responsible Solutions, all with one purpose - to eliminate guns in society.

Bloomberg travels with a contingent of bodyguards armed with FULLY automatic weapons. He caused quite a stir after landing in Bermuda for a stay. Bermuda is so anti-gun that even its own police force isn’t armed, but Blooomberg's guards were.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by onetimeusename on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:44PM (#33833861)
The American Progress article is interesting. Does the image they used for that article have a certain implication about who is committing the homicide in those rural counties? Some of the items in Figure 1 are not even rural, they appear to be actual cities, despite the labeling.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by brk on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:12AM (#33830016)
"On a regular basis" may not be quite the level occurrence, but yes, it does happen, and it often will not become a news story when it does.

As others have pointed out, some states like California have laws and enforcement policies that at times appear to favor criminals over self defense. Other states, like Florida or Texas, tend to better enable self defense with lethal force.

The whole thing is an equation you really do not want to find yourself in. Even with justifiable/legal use of deadly force in a defensive situation you are likely to wind up embroiled in a lot of hassles, law suits, and associated costs.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by galangalalgol on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:17AM (#33830059)
And I have been told that no matter how precious the lives you were protecting were to you, killing someone isn't a memory you want in your head. Either it will bother you forever, or worse, you'll find you liked it, and that changes you.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by tolleydbg on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:48AM (#33830351)
I don't know who this is true for, but I am proud of the fact that I was armed and able to protect my pregnant wife. I feel absolutely no remorse for it. I didn't enjoy it and the entire situation was unpleasant at the time.

Had the situation had been different, say I was alone and it was merely a robbery by some kid or something, sure, I would feel differently if I killed them (and I wouldn't). I just don't accept the initial premise of your statement for my experience and those I have spoken to in similar situations.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by galangalalgol on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:22AM (#33830721)
Yeah, I have met a couple people like that, I shouldn't have tried to lump the mindset of all humanity into two lumps. I was merely pointing out that using lethal force to protect property that isn't critical to your family's well-being could have emotional as well as monetary costs. Because it can have those costs even if you are protecting loved ones, and you won't know until it happens.

Edit: also why is the other post expressing the same sentiment dead? Along with all the other posts by that person? The part about banning healthy violence resonates with me. Young people fight, young animals fight, if it doesn't cause permanent damage it is a healthy part of learning how to relate to each other. And if non lethal violence was less taboo I suspect letha violence would be less common.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by tablespoon on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:49AM (#33832965)
> Edit: also why is the other post expressing the same sentiment dead? Along with all the other posts by that person?

He got banned somewhere around here: https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=iwillbenice&next=334.... The account name (and the fact there was no mod warning post) makes me think that wasn't the first time.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by tablespoon on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:46AM (#33832916)
> And I have been told that no matter how precious the lives you were protecting were to you, killing someone isn't a memory you want in your head. Either it will bother you forever, or worse, you'll find you liked it, and that changes you.

Though I suppose seeing the people you care about getting killed or injured also "isn't a memory you want in your head," either. Seems like a damned if you do, damned if you don't kind of situation.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by imperialdrive on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:14AM (#33830030)
It really varies by state. In Texas it's more like the old days, shoot on sight more or less. Not so much in California, where one would likely be jailed/sued for protecting liberties. You can sort of tell by interacting with the police. In one state they're rather kind/respectful, in the other they are burnt out by all the bs. All in all, America is still so wonderful though. As long as the average citizen retains the right to bear arms I think we'll make it out alive in the long run.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by ihatepython on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:27AM (#33830140)
> and it just doesn't make headline news?

It would only make headline news if the perpetrator was white. In the event that the perpetrator was black, the story would be quickly buried.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by tolleydbg on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:52AM (#33830387)
This is exactly how most confrontations end, especially if the assailant is not armed with a firearm as well - this is their most effective use. The armed victim shows the gun and they run away. It never turns into the Hollywood bloodbath opponents of firearms think that it will.
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by badcppdev on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:10AM (#33832390)
Surely majority of opponents just point to school shootings as good reason to ban guns
Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by jt2190 on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:57AM (#33830449)
The other replies are correct, but I’ll just add that you’re mixing two things here: - self defense - robbery

For self defense (including cases where the defendant is being personally robbed) there is definitely a deterrent effect of guns.

For robbery where the owner isn’t present (the case you replied to, and also the vast majority, obviously) there doesn’t seem to be much of a deterrent.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by kryogen1c on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:10AM (#33830566)
> headline news?

this is really the crux of your question. gun violence in America is a multifaceted problem, but if your source of information is headline news, you will get 0 meaningful information.

> Do thieves and robbers get shot on a regular basis

this depends drastically on the local/state laws. San Francisco, for example, does not issue permits to carry concealed firearms and openly carrying firearms is illegal. California is simply a very gun unfriendly state, so you will almost never see a citizen defend themselves from a robber with a gun there. Even if you can carry a gun somewhere else, as a sibling goes into more detail, there are various laws with wildly different requirements to be able to employ lethal force. They range from requiring you to attempt to run away first to allowing lethal violence in defense of your property (like a vehicle with cameras in it).

for what its worth, gun violence in america has little to do with so-called mass shootings that make the headlines or the hated "assault rifles". the story of gun violence in america is something like 90% pistol shootings in economically damaged, inner city slums.

Re:After violent robberies, some photographers opt to stay a... by jopython on Saturday December 03, 2022 @01:39PM (#33846041)
Its not easy to get a concealed carry permit in CA.